Follow TV Tropes

Following

Misused: Catharsis Factor

Go To

To-do list:

    Original post 
Note: This thread was proposed by Shooting Star 7 X.

Catharsis Factor is supposed to be a YMMV trope about actions to relieve stress with—typically violent ones in video games. However, it's seen common misuse as an Audience Reaction for the satisfaction of an unsympathetic character (usually a Jerkass, Hate Sink, or Complete Monster) getting killed, arrested, or punished in some way for their transgressions.

Wick check: Link here. Of the 56 wicks checked:

  • 5/56 (8.92%) are correct according to the trope description;
  • 9/56 (16.07%) are semi-correct—an unsympathetic character in a video game getting their comeuppance;
  • 22/56 (39.28%) are for an unsympathetic character being punished in a non-video game work;
  • 3/56 (5.35%) are for a character not intended to be unsympathetic getting punished, or otherwise Take That, Scrappy!;
  • 14/56 (25.0%) are combinations of the above, Zero-Context Examples, unclear usage, or other misuse;
  • 3/56 (5.35%) are unsorted.

Solution: The solution here is easy. I propose redefining Catharsis Factor to an Audience Reaction for tension-relieving moments, which would broaden the trope to fit the common misuse. Catharsis Factor's Laconic page was even rewritten to my proposed definition at one point, so I'm thinking this is the best option. But what do you think?

Wick check:

Catharsis Factor is supposed to be a YMMV trope about actions to relieve stress with—typically violent ones in video games. However, it's seen common misuse as an Audience Reaction for the satisfaction of an unsympathetic character (usually a Jerkass, Hate Sink, or Complete Monster) getting killed, arrested, or punished in some way for their transgressions.

Wicks checked: 56/56

    Correct use (5/56, 8.92%) 
  • YMMV.Ace Combat 7 Skies Unknown:
    • The first half of Pipeline Destruction (Mission 8) has you launching an assault on an enemy oil field. As you destroy one oil tank, the explosion will cause a chain reaction to other nearby targets as well. The sight of enemy oil fields exploding in a massive inferno one after another is pretty cathartic. This also doubles as In-Universe Catharsis for Spare Squadron; coming right after the encounter with Mister X in the Yinshi Valley, Tabloid appreciates the simplicity of the operation, another Spare declares "This beats being stuck at the penal base!", and most of the radio chatter consists of various Spares enthusiastically commenting on the ensuing carnage—including one unnamed member cheering on Trigger if the player's dealt significant damage to the enemy facilities before Megastorm Inessa II rolls in.
      Spare Squadron: Yeah! That's the stuff, Trigger! Go ape on 'em!
    • The first half of Faceless Soldier (Mission 9) involves doing a "corridor flight" through mountain valleys with limited visibility due to cloud cover, special rules that cause players who rise above the clouds to get one-shotted if they don't go back under them within a few seconds, and an unclear path of traversal through the level resulting in some frustrating Trial-and-Error Gameplay. However, the second half of the mission is a glorious turn around involving a pleasantly challenging furball of a battle set to awesome music where the fractious 444th Squadron starts pulling together and kicking ass, and is extremely morale-boosting moment after several missions spent being degraded as disposable.
    • In Transfer Orders (Mission 10), you can shoot down Hate Sink Colonel D. McKinsey's plane Roper One despite it failing the mission if you do this. Here's the kicker though, not only the game itself awards you with 1,000 points, AWACS Bandog of all people sounds like he doesn't even care as he gives a rather deadpan reaction, making it all the more satisfying.
      AWACS Bandog: Roper One lost, along with the mission. Not that it was a load worth protecting.
    • In Fleet Destruction (Mission 11), there's nothing quite as satisfying as blowing out the support columns and watching the platforms topple over and fall into the sea, AND destroy any ships docked underneath them moments later. Even your allies comment on how wonderful it feels. One example is about killing a Hate Sink in an optional scenario that fails you the mission, but the rest seem fine.
  • ThatOneBoss.AtlusShin Megami Tensei III: Nocturne has several, and not because of the Nintendo Hard difficulty of the game. In order of appearances:
    • Dante (or Raidou Kuzunoha XIV in the Chronicle Edition and the HD Remaster if the "Chronicle" version was chosen at the start. They're functionally identical.) is faced at the entrance to Mantra HQ, and he's a very well-rounded combatant who cannot be easily cheesed. He responds to your debuffs with a Dekunda of his own, he has party-wide attacks of the phys, elec and force variety, and his signature attack has a very high crit rate. He also uses his own version of Taunt that makes you more vulnerable to everything he has. He resists all forms of damage with no weakness and has the usual Contractual Boss Immunity. No gimmicks or tricks, just a straightforward battle a la Devil May Cry, which makes preparing for him all the more difficult. He becomes tediously nightmarish during his game at the Third Kalpa. The Player is forced to navigate a labyrinth with a series of switches that must be activated to proceed, all while avoiding encountering him. The problem is Dante will pursue you across the whole Kalpa while constantly shooting at you if you are in his line of sight and within a certain range. Each shot staggers you, and he fires at a high rate and with minimal breaks, so getting too close essentially means you are already caught. When he tags you, Dante will score a free hit on you, kicking you back to the beginning, and he will reset all the switches. Fitting, considering he basically went through some similar puzzle levels in his own game, but still unpleasant. It's a big Catharsis Factor when you finally get around to recruiting him at the bottom of the Labyrinth of Amala, and you get to use his exact powerful skill set to sweep enemy mobs. Recruiting That One Boss and using him against enemies. Seems valid.
  • Awesome.Video Game Levels T To Z
    • The final level is two very different types of Catharsis Factor. After BT's Heroic Sacrifice, you get your hands on the Smart Pistol for the only time in the campaign, letting you tear through the IMC facility at top speed without bothering to aim. Then you get to call in your Titan, reinstall BT's core, and rip through the IMC forces with a gigantic Gatling gun, thanks to the Legion loadout being unlocked.
    • Special mention goes to the level near the end: Before you stands a climb up a tower with hundreds of demons and their ilk guarding the Final Boss you know how much of a pain you're in for as you wait for the loading screen to finish. When it finally finishes, Titus stands there, Jump Pack equipped, Thunderhammer in hand and doesn't say a word - because there's nothing left to say. There's the goal, enemies inbetween and all you have a Jump Pack and a Thunderhammer. It's all you need. Feel free to scream "FOR THE EMPEROR!" as you Ground Pound for the first time and revel in the Catharsis of righteous slaughter Both seem correct.
  • Main.Finishing Move: The Dishwasher, an XBLA Hack and Slash game, has finishing moves ("Clean Kills" and "Messy Kills") as a key part of its gameplay flow. When an enemy's cybernetics start sparking, one or both of the grab or heavy attack buttons will appear over their head. Using the indicated attack will reward you with restored health or a skull magic...Though the player would probably do them anyways, as the finishers are both very violent and very cathartic. Seems valid.
  • YMMV.Red Faction: Guerilla offers this in spades. There's no feeling quite like bringing down an EDF base with only your trusty sledgehammer- and gratuitous amounts of explosives. Armageddon offers up a bit more, though not nearly as much due to its linear storyline. You can't fault it for trying though, especially when it gives you the option of reassembling what you just blew up with the Nano Forge... so you can destroy it again. Seems valid.

    Video game examples of an unsympathetic character getting punished (9/56, 16.07%) 
  • YMMV.Final Fantasy Brave Exvius: A particular mission in Grandore Central Block is to finish Vlad's second form with Bahamut's Megaflare. If you are fully aware of the lore, you know that Bahamut was one of the Eight Sages of Hess which Vlad banished to Lapis. Having a fully maxed 3* Bahamut, with tons of Evoke damage geared, spitting Vlad, who is responsible for seven hundred years of misery, death and destruction in Paladia, out of commission by himself? Epic satisfaction.
  • YMMV.Blaz Blue Central Fiction: Finally finding a way around Terumi's Joker Immunity and giving him the death he so richly deserves but has avoided for years? Delicious. Yuuki Terumi is a Complete Monster.
  • Funny.Spyro Year Of The Dragon: Perhaps the funniest moment is getting your sweet revenge on Moneybags, chasing the greedy bear down and ramming/flaming the gems right out of him- repeatedly, no less. By the end, he's reduced to a panting wreck.
  • YMMV.Berserk And The Band Of The Hawk: For those who had been waiting for the Schedule Slip-prone manga to come to a conclusion, this game offered some therapy by letting them beat the crap out of Griffith/Femto for everything he did. And oh yeah: Casca's playable. Griffith/Femto is a Complete Monster.
  • YMMV.The Clue Finders Reading Adventures Ages 912 Mystery Of The Missing Amulet: After being completely fooled the entire game, it's nothing but cathartic when it's Owen who stops Malicia's attack on the Cluefinders through LapTrap and his shiny reflective surface. Malicia is listed under Complete Monster.
  • WMG.Dissidia Final Fantasy 2015:
    • I do not know if this would extent to being playable, because no one would want to, but if NPC-only boss exist, adding Argath might serve as a good Catharsis Factor, because come on, was FFXIV enough?
    • Aerith Gainsborough (FFVII): Might be interesting to see a White Mage style character go, and she's… not exactly demure as many flanderized her as, could work as some sort of 'support' (works well because it's team game). Plus, the Catharsis Factor of manually having her beat the crap outta Sephiroth instead of last time being programmed to always be shish-kebab'd by him.
  • YMMV.Fire Emblem Mystery Of The Emblem: This is more or less the purpose of the first three chapters of the game, where Marth is forced to follow Lang's orders. At every turn, Lang displays his nature as cruel, craven, and unlikable, and on top of that, the situations he forces you into are seemingly designed to be annoying to play (particularly the infamous third chapter). When Jagen realizes the truth and hands Lang a "The Reason You Suck" Speech, and Lang flees like the coward he is, you're immediately aware: this guy has screwed you over, and now it's your job to hunt him down. The next few chapters are much more open and hand you some very powerful characters, freeing you up for a satisfying-as-hell asswhooping. Lang is a Dirty Coward, Jerkass, and Viler New Villain.
  • YMMV.Tales Of Xillia 2Breather Boss:
  • YMMV.Kingdom Hearts II:
    • For many fans, that would be the boss battle with Scar. Given he murdered Mufasa, lied to Simba and forced him into exile, and tried to force the lionesses into cannibalism by attacking and eating Sora, being able to fight Scar for all his crimes is a huge catharsis for fans of the film after waiting for eleven years.
    • Ever wanted to give Shan Yu his just desserts for ambushing the village and slaughtering tons of innocent people, including children? Well this game gives you the satisfaction to give him the beating he deserves.
    • Just in case you didn't get your fill of beating up the Disney villans that terrified you throughout childhood in I, this game gives you the opportunity to beat up Hades, Jafar, Oogie Boogie, and Ursula (sort of) again.
Scar and Shan Yu are Complete Monsters.

    Non-video game examples of an unsympathetic character getting punished (22/56, 39.28%) 
  • YMMV.Tyranny Of DragonsBroken Base: There's some contention online over how good this campaign truly is, with very little middle ground. Those who like the campaign say that it appropriately builds up Tiamat as a threat and the Final Boss, making her into The Dreaded and a credible threat to the entire world. Also, Rise of Tiamat has the players taking on full-grown dragons and winning, making the campaign have a nice Catharsis Factor at watching the Cult of the Dragon fail. Those who dislike the campaign say that there's either too many characters or too many dangling plot hooks, and that the game balance isn't polished enough to make the difficulty consistent, especially because the module was written for the early release of Fifth Edition, causing many frustrating encounters. Regardless of whether one likes or dislikes Tyranny of Dragons, it really doesn't help that it came after Lost Mine of Phandelver, which is widely considered one of the best campaigns in all of Fifth Edition, and maybe one of the best in all of D&D, giving this campaign a tough reputation to try and live up to. The very few people who sit in the middle feel that the ideas and outline are good, but that it needs a lot of tweaking to make the module work as intended. They're a group rather than a character, but the Cult of the Dragon looks to be an Apocalypse Cult.
  • YMMV.Norbit: Seeing Norbit finally stand up to Rasputia at the end in front of the entire town, and utterly destroying the Lattimores and Deion’s plot after looking like he failed, is very satisfying. Rasputia, the Latimore Brothers, and Deion are all listed under Jerkass.
  • YMMV.Alessas Fantasies:
    • After everything Cynthia has done, watching them beg for mercy before Alessa tosses them to their doom feels pretty good.
    • Alessa avenging her family by killing Satan himself. Cynthia and Satan (the latter known as Nicholas here) are both listed under Complete Monster.
  • YMMV.House Of Cards US: Season 3 has quite a bit of it, as Frank finds out being the President is no easy task when all the people you screwed over to get there are still working with you. It then continues on in season 4 when Hammerschmidt uncovers the tracks in Underwood's plot against Walker in seasons 1 and 2, publishing it, leaving Frank's power grip in serious jeopardy. Frank Underwood is a Complete Monster.
  • YMMV.The LodgeMoral Event Horizon: A huge chunk of the audience believed the children crossed it when it's revealed that they were gaslighting Grace throughout their entire stay in the lodge, while stealing her medication and possibly drugging her, and then letting her dog outside to freeze to death (albeit unintentionally). Many audience goers have come away believing the children to be more evil than Damien Thorn and that their fates in the end was a case of Catharsis Factor at work.
  • Funny.The Boys 2019: Homelander is dealt with by The Boys in the stormdrain, with Billy unbinding Kenji's hands to bring the tunnel, the road above and a bus down on his head. Right after Homelander's taunting of Billy's wife. Doubles as an Awesome Moment. Homelander is listed under Jerkass on his character page.
  • YMMV.Family Guy S 9 E 6 Brian Writes A Bestseller: While on Real Time with Bill Maher, Brian is all smug and confident about his book, but he is chewed out and criticized by Maher and his guests (comedian Dana Gould and journalist Arianna Huffington) and ends up peeing himself. Brian Griffin picks up the Jerkass Ball in this episode.
  • YMMV.Platinum End: There's something tremendously satisfying about Metropoliman getting brutally shot to death by Mukaido. Metropoli Man falls under Bad Boss and Politically Incorrect Villain; subtropes of Hate Sink.
  • YMMV.The Super Mario Bros Movie: Bowser launches an attack on the Mushroom Kingdom and tortures Toad in an attempt to force Princess Peach to marry him, and explicitly states he's going to sacrifice Luigi and all the other prisoners into the lava pool at the wedding. Thus, it is immensely satisfying when Mario and Luigi team up to beat the shit out of him, then Peach shrinks him with a Mini Mushroom, and he is imprisoned in a glass bottle.
  • YMMV.Ghostbusters 2016: After the mayor pretending not to know about the ghosts and harassing the Ghostbusters into silence, it's a bit of Rooting for the Empire that Rowan through Kevin turns his government agent friends and the army into People Puppets, making them dance around 'cause it's cool. The Mayor is listed under Jerkass.
  • YMMV.Pokemon Harmony And Chaos: Given how much of an unbearable Jerkass he is, it is extremely satisfying when Lightning Blitz gets hit with Laser-Guided Karma.
    • His first on-screen defeat in the series is when he loses to Doc in the Semi-Finals of the Grand Hoof Cup. After trash talking all his opponents, his arrogance costs him the battle when his Guardroid loses to its pre-evolved form Higear. Lightning angrily storms out of the stadium, not even bothering to stay for the rest of the tournament.
    • He goes through a Humiliation Conga for almost the entire Camp Everfree arc. He is forced to attend camp by his grandfather, despite him making it clear he doesn't want to be there at all. He misses out on every opportunity he tries to catch a powerful Pokémon, and is constantly being told off by everyone else and actually punished for his bad attitude, at one point even getting blasted by a Gyarados he bullied as a Magikarp.
    • When he challenges his grandfather, the previous Equestrian Champion Grand Hoof, to a full six-on-six battle to test his skills, he is subjected to a Curb-Stomp Battle. Even when his goal is just to knock out a single one of Grand's Pokémon, he still fails to reach that goal.
    • He loses in the finals to the Balance Battle Tournament to Flash. This is especially satisfying since not only is it the first time they face off since their battle at the Hoofington Battle Tournament, it is the first time Flash has beaten Lightning at something and shows that his Pokémon have way better teamwork than Lightning's.
    • Finally, perhaps the biggest moment yet, during the finals of the Equestria League between him and Flash, Flash finally tells him to shut up after hearing him badmouth his Pokémon one too many times, Lightning ends up having a Villainous Breakdown when Flash won't lose already and the entire stadium starts cheering him on, Flash proceeds to mockingly taunt Lightning by calling him boring for using the same Breaking Speech over and over, and finally Lightning ends up losing the battle and having his entire worldview shattered.
  • YMMV.Let The Darkness Bring Us Into The Light: Both readers and the author, genuinely enjoyed getting to see Jounouchi casually beat up Bakugou for terrorizing his friends in Chapter 10. And it gets "better" when Yami awakens after Bakugou explodes Izuku's leg resulting in the other self finishing off the bully with a "Mind Crush" attack. Bakugou looks to be a bigoted bully.
  • YMMV.Rumble In The Bronx: After having spent nearly the entire film being harassed, battered, bloodied and nearly killed, Keung finally beating the crap out of the gang at their own hideout is immensely satisfying. The gang members are "brutal thugs", according to the Token Evil Teammate entry on the main page.
  • YMMV.Sponge Bob Square Pants S 2 E 6 Grandmas Kisses Squidville: While Squidward getting his house destroyed by SpongeBob and Patrick is just another act of Squidward suffering from their well-intentioned buffoonery, the fact that this episode comes right after one where he actually does something wrong makes it feel all the more deserving. Squidward Tentacles picks up the Jerkass Ball and is a Karma Houdini in "Grandma's Kisses".
  • YMMV.Enter The Arena As Your Avatar: After all the crap he's put everyone through, including forcing friends and family to fight each other AND turning the Arena into a warzone, Galeem gets quite a satisfying beatdown from the assembled cast.
    • Katre and Troa are two of Bolded1's most notorious villains. Even after their plot-mandated defeats, they were being used in attempts to get them killed off or utilized as pawns to dispose of other villains. But when Thor and Loki's plan went awry, and Set freed them from their power-restraining shackles, who's the first person they picked a fight with? Saitama. Seeing one man stand his ground against two (three!) characters who could send whole teams of opposing characters flying in their own times simultaneously and very nearly turn the tables on them can certainly be satisfying.
    • Glitchtrap's demise in their boss fight can be seen as this, considering who they're the Virtual Ghost of, and in their game they never truly face any comeuppance for their actions. Here, they get physically AND verbally torn to shreds by the assembled cast, one of whom is even the first soul he ever murdered, loses their power to the ghosts of all their victims, and just like before, they're Dragged Off to Hell. All this means that, aside from timeline shenanigans, they're Deader than Dead.
    • Hazama, who's easily one of the vilest villains to ever terrorize the Arena, finally gets his long-overdue and incredibly satisfying comeuppance by way of Fu's timeline shenanigans.
  • Awesome.Way Of The Tiger: Grinding Manse's skinny neck into the ground until it snaps like a twig under your heel is incredibly gratifying after the comrades he's slain and the numerous times he can kill you in some horrific fashion in both this book and the prequel.
  • YMMV.As Told By Ginger S 3 E 02 Wicked Game: Courtney exposing Miranda and Mipsy is quite cathartic for how their mean girl antics often went unpunished in the series. Miranda's "that was Ginger?" is a true Break the Haughty moment if there ever was one. Miranda and Mipsy are both Jerkasses and the former is also a Hate Sink.
  • Awesome.Spectacular Seven: At the end of Volume III, Twilight gives her Racist Grandma Golden Light a "The Reason You Suck" Speech about how Golden Light is automatically assuming the worst about people. And considering that Twilight just fought against both Moondancer and Tempest, nearly getting burned to death as a result, and still managed to save the wedding, it comes with a Catharsis Factor, since it's also a "No More Holding Back" Speech.
    Twilight: Just because you can't see the real value in people doesn't mean we all have to stoop to your level!
    Golden Light: Excuse you?
    Twilight: No, excuse you! You've demeaned and made assumptions about everyone since you got here! Yes, this is a sword! I've been learning how to defend myself for situations like this! These 'hooligans' are not only my best friends, they're some of the best people in the world who accept me for who I am! Cadence is wise, caring, funny, loving and an all-around incredible person! She was the best babysitter and she's going to be an even better wife and sister-in-law! We just risked our lives to save this wedding and everyone here, so now, we're going to go have a beautiful ceremony, Shining and Cadence are finally going to get married, I'm going to dance with my girlfriend, and we're all going to have a good time after this horrible morning! Either stop your nagging and enjoy the wedding, or leave!
  • YMMV.Hush: After all the horrible things he does and what a vile, sadistic monster he is, it's enormously gratifying to see Maddie kill The Man by stabbing him in the throat and to see his hubris and sadism give way to genuine fear. The Man is listed under Complete Monster.
  • YMMV.Fargo:
    • Marge shooting Grimsrud in the leg. After all the people he's killed, it is a damn relief.
    • Jerry's arrest, while somewhat pitiable, is still what he deserves for his selfish and cowardly behavior.
Grimsrud is a Complete Monster, while Jerry is listed under Bitch in Sheep's Clothing; a subtrope of Hate Sink.
  • YMMV.Star Craft II Wings Of Liberty: Anyone can agree that hearing Mengsk spout out the words, “I will rule this sector or see it burnt to ashes around me!” on UNN is always enjoyable to hear considering the backlash that comes after it. Mengsk is listed under Dirty Coward and Smug Snake; subtropes of Hate Sink.
  • YMMV.Transformers Animated: Anytime Sentinel Prime gets his skid plate tossed around is immensely satisfying, seeing how big of a Jerkass he is. The worse he suffers, the better.

    A character not intended to be unsympathetic gets punished/Take That, Scrappy! (3/56, 5.35%) 
  • YMMV.Fable I: You can completely humiliate Thunder, if you so choose. Namely: you can kill his sister (who has the same condescending attitude), steal his wife, humiliate him in a fight, and then in the Lost Chapters, you have the choice between killing him for good measure or letting him live with his failures. I have no clue whether Thunder was intended be unsympathetic or not — I see him listed under Asshole Victim, but also Jerk with a Heart of Gold and The Scrappy.
  • MythologyGag.Super Smash Bros Ultimate Spirits: Slippy Toadnote  is a green Greninja who is constantly running away while Fox does most of the fighting (but only Greninja needs to be beaten to win). The match is also timed. That's right, you are reenacting "Fox, get this guy off me!" — except this time, YOU are "this guy". Alternatively, Slippy can be summoned with the cores of Lin (a mechanic) and Winky (a frog). In World of Light, he can fix and pilot the broken Great Fox to traverse the space area. Slippy Toad is a heroic character; albeit a Base-Breaking Character and a case of Americans Hate Tingle.
  • YMMV.Miraculous Ladybug: After years of them dancing around it, people were happy when the love square swap finally happened. Ladybug gaining a crush on Cat Noir and him losing his crush on her has been particularly well-received due to Cat's fans not liking how rude Ladybug used to be to him and were glad to see Cat Noir actually be done with her antics. Both are heroes and this is fan contention as opposed to anything deliberate.

    ZCE/unclear use/other (14/56, 25.0%) 
The first is a Hate Sink getting punished; the second is either correct or Video Game Cruelty Potential; and the third is defeating a Complete Monster. Lucy's classmates seem to be unsympathetic, but Bando may have likable traits—at least after his Character Development.
  • YMMV.Final Fantasy XIV:
    • The end of 2.5 is a Wham Episode of the first order, but it does feature some genuine catharsis in-between the Player Punches. Watching Raubahn literally slice Teledji Adeleji in half for all of his scheming and backstabbing — including at an attempt on the sultana's life — is karmic justice for all of the trouble that Teledji has caused the Scions.
    • After watching Valens get away with a lot of vile things in the Sorrow of Werlyt storyline, seeing him get one-uped by Gaius then crushed to death by his own machinations makes for a satisfyingly karmic punishment.
    • The Melee DPS role quests in Endwalker require you to recruit the Company of Heroes once again to slay a powerful monster, just like when you consulted them to help fight Titan... and the Warrior of Light gets the option to tell them that they will not be throwing them a banquet in order to get their help like the last time. For those who disliked the Titan Arc due to its long series of fetch quests, it was very tempting to not automatically press that dialogue option.
    • For those who disliked the "Waking Sands" due to being a few minute walk away from the nearest warp point and the constant going back and forth between it and other zones, the quest when it gets invaded and the scions captured was this instead of the intended reaction.
Teledji Adeleji and Valens are both Hate Sinks, the third entry seems correct, and the last is Take That, Scrappy! ...on a Scrappy Mechanic instead of a character.
  • NinetiesAntiHero.Anime And MangaTexhnolyze: Ichise is a coolheaded prize fighter who becomes one of these, granted a more subdued example along the lines of the aforementioned Killy, through the course of the show's twenty-two episodes. He becomes increasingly violent and psychotic after acquiring his cybernetic limbs, the eponymous Texhnolyze, both as he becomes more corrupted by the power he has to take out his pent up rage and also in response the increasingly dire circumstances as he and others become apathetic. In-universe example.
  • YMMV.Pokemon Journeys The Series:
    • After decades of Ash being underestimated in and out of universe and his achievements downplayed, there is a genuine feeling of satisfaction listening to a stadium cheering Ash on with the call CHAMPION!, CHAMPION!, CHAMPION!.
    • While many fans still bitter about the Kalos League would have preferred to see Ash defeat him, Alain's first round defeat at the hands of Leon drew some catharsis from some segments of fans who never forgave Alain for defeating Ash in the Kalos League finals and his general undefeated streak and took a specific level of joy at seeing him defeated in a way similar to Trevor.
      • In another way, for the same fans who were bitter about the Kalos League finals, Ash's match versus Steven Stone ending with Ash's victory, could be seen as this since Steven is one of the only people that Alain could not defeat in the Mega Evolution specials.
    • Ash defeating Cynthia in the next round. Not only does this more than make up for Ash infamously losing the Sinnoh League to Tobias (as Cynthia is still likely much stronger than Tobias, even with his legendaries), but due to Cynthia being infamously seen by everyone as the single, hardest Champion fight from the main games, this really cements just how far Ash has come over the years. While this victory would quickly be overshadowed by Ash then going on to win the final match against Leon, this one win alone has officially redeemed every failure and black mark in his history as a trainer.
    • 25 years ago, Ash swore he would be the very best, like no one ever was. 25 years later, he managed to take down Leon in the most difficult battle of his career which will no doubt go down in history as his single-greatest crowning achievement. But with his trusted Pikachu by his side, he finally brought down the undefeatable, and his goal To Be a Master has been achieved. He is no longer Ash Ketchum, a kid from Pallet Town; he is Ash Ketchum: World Coronation Series Monarch!
Ash's achievements are Moments of Awesome and/or And the Fandom Rejoiced, and the Base-Breaking Character Alain's defeat is Take That, Scrappy!
  • YMMV.Resident Evil 7 Biohazard: The Not A Hero DLC provides this for players who have been waiting for Lucas Baker to get their just desserts for a long time.
    • The End of Zoe DLC, rather than have the slow and careful inventory management style of the rest of the game, has you play as an Awesome Boxing Battler hillbilly that punches the monsters to death and shows absolutely no fear through the entire story.
Improper indentation aside; the first is punishing a Complete Monster, but the second seems correct.

    Unsorted (3/56, 5.35%) 
  • YMMV.Avengers Infinity War:
    • Thor making a Dynamic Entry and driving Stormbreaker right into Thanos's chest at the climax of the film can feel wholly deserved after watching the Mad Titan lay waste to every hero in his way up until that point. Unfortunately, the attack doesn't prevent Thanos from carrying out his Badass Fingersnap, bringing on the Downer Ending, and getting away a Karma Houdini.
    • Just seeing Iron Man's team fighting alongside the Guardians is worth the price of admission all by itself. Then there's the fact that they come the closest to actually beating Thanos, even though they fail at the last minute. The fact that Iron Man then goes one-on-one with Thanos, holds his own for more than a few minutes, and actually makes him bleed is equally satisfying to watch.
    • The Children of Thanos are all such bastards that it's extremely satisfying whenever one of them is given a gruesome death scene.
    • As it turns out, The Red Skull suffered a fate worse than death. Seeing him so broken and a shell of his former self is very deeply satisfying after all the atrocities he committed in World War II.
    • Wanda jumping onto the battlefield and effortlessly wiping out half of Thanos's forces, as well as Okoye's fantastic Leaning on the Fourth Wall line:
      "Why was she up there all this time?"
Seems to be a mix of non-video game heroes showing their might and villains getting punished — I can't make out how unsympathetic these villains are supposed to be at a cursory glance.
  • YMMV.Amphibia S 3 E 30 All In: Andrias' breakdown and the revelations about how he actually saved Marcy's life are so brutal to watch, it's almost impossible to derive any joy from his defeat. Darcy on the other hand... After all the sheer sadistic cruelty and smug gloating from Darcy, it is incredibly satisfying when Sasha finally manages to cut her connection to the Core. Darcy reacts with a glorious Villainous Breakdown before she passes out. The happy reunion between Sasha, Anne, and Marcy only makes it better. Conveys reaction that's more complex than can fit under existing YMMV items.
  • YMMV.Tangerine:
    • Tino and Victor take no nonsense from Arthur or Erik. To avenge Luis, they storm the commemoration center and proceed to give Erik a black eye. For the first time in the book, someone actually got the jump on him. Tino and Victor are only angry that Paul tried to help him by jumping on a coach for trying to break up the fight, saying that he has more to lose than they do. He says that he couldn't let them take on Erik alone.
    • The neighbors find out what kind of monster Erik is, and learning he and Arthur were stealing their heirlooms. They go You Have GOT to Be Kidding Me! when the Fisher parents — Paul has opted to talk with Joey on the phone— try to convince them to not call the police. One man gives them a "The Reason You Suck" Speech and that this wasn't just "Boys will be boys."
    • Just as the Fisher parents convince everyone to not press charges for the burglaries, a police car comes roaring up to the curb. Two cops come out and swiftly arrest Arthur, reading the kid his rights. Arthur's father tries to defend him, but Paul shuts him up and says that he saw Arthur kill Luis, and that Erik gave the order. Erik is forced to admit this is true when Mr. Fisher asks, and the cop orders him to not leave his house.
    • When we learn why Paul's grandparents are estranged. They reveal they were furious on his behalf that the parents covered up that Erik poured paint in his eyes, and had wanted Erik to face some sort of punishment. When Mr. Fisher says it's fine for them to say I Told You So, the grandparents point out that this is an "I told you so" situation. Mrs. Fisher is forced to admit they're right on this.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Oct 29th 2023 at 11:38:45 AM

PhiSat Planeswalker from Everywhere and Nowhere Since: Jan, 2011
Planeswalker
#26: Jul 19th 2023 at 12:44:28 PM

[tup]to expanding to satisfying karmic moments in any setting. I don't think it needs to be intentional from the creators, that's why it's an Audience Reaction. We have In-Universe Catharsis for when characters are relieved from tension.

Edited by PhiSat on Jul 19th 2023 at 1:45:42 PM

Oissu!
Nen_desharu Nintendo Fanatic Extraordinaire from Greater Smash Bros. Universe or Toronto Since: Aug, 2020 Relationship Status: Who needs love when you have waffles?
Nintendo Fanatic Extraordinaire
#27: Jul 19th 2023 at 12:49:01 PM

Expand and create a new trope for video game catharsis factors

Speaking of the new trope, I recommend the addition of a video from video game creator Masahiro Sakurai:

https://youtu.be/TYh5SJb5gWk

He calls Carthasis Factor "Squeeze and Release."

Perhaps we could call the new trope Tension Squeeze And Release?

Edited by Nen_desharu on Jul 19th 2023 at 3:49:52 PM

Kirby is awesome.
ShootingStar7X Just call me Solemn. Since: Dec, 2017
Just call me Solemn.
#28: Jul 19th 2023 at 12:49:17 PM

Huh, you guys are noticing a lot of flaws with Catharsis Factor I missed when I made the proposal! I guess that means I'll have to be more diligent if I ever want to take a trope to TRS again...

I'm still settled on Tabs' suggestion (regardless of whether we make the supertrope no-examples or not), but Ferot_Dreadnaught did raise some good points.

Edited by ShootingStar7X on Jul 19th 2023 at 12:50:26 PM

Otherwise known as SolemnStormcloud.
MasterN Berserk Button: misusing Berserk Button from Florida- I mean Unova Since: Aug, 2016 Relationship Status: Shipping fictional characters
#29: Jul 19th 2023 at 1:00:08 PM

I agree with it being so common as to be too broad.

One of these days, all of you will accept me as your supreme overlord.
Ferot_Dreadnaught Since: Mar, 2015
#30: Jul 19th 2023 at 1:16:36 PM

With that, I'd say make Catharsis Factor an exampleless super trope (too broad/omnipresent to warrant listing separately from the tropes/YMMV that cause it intentionally or otherwise, but still a big thing to note), the current definition renamed "Interactive Catharsis Factor" and made a sub-trope.

Edited by Ferot_Dreadnaught on Jul 19th 2023 at 1:17:00 AM

ShootingStar7X Just call me Solemn. Since: Dec, 2017
Just call me Solemn.
#31: Jul 19th 2023 at 1:32:14 PM

[up]I can live with that. If anyone has another definition we could use, I'm also open for it.

Otherwise known as SolemnStormcloud.
RandomTroper123 She / Her from I'll let you guess... (Not-So-Newbie) Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
She / Her
#32: Jul 19th 2023 at 2:22:41 PM

I guess I'm leaning on Tabs' suggestion. EDIT: Though[up][up] also sounds good.

Edited by RandomTroper123 on Jul 19th 2023 at 2:23:05 AM

Unicorndance Logic Girl from Thames, N.Z. Since: Jul, 2015 Relationship Status: Above such petty unnecessities
Logic Girl
#33: Jul 19th 2023 at 3:52:37 PM

I'm a little concerned that if we expand it, people will use it to complain (e.g. "I hate that character, so I liked it when something bad happened to them.")

For every low there is a high.
RandomTroper123 She / Her from I'll let you guess... (Not-So-Newbie) Relationship Status: [TOP SECRET]
She / Her
#34: Jul 19th 2023 at 4:03:24 PM

[up]I agree and I have seen complaining in misused CF examples too. I also think expanded examples could fall under Take That, Scrappy!, SugarWiki.Moment Of Awesome, or maybe something in the index Karma (depending on the character/what happened).

ShootingStar7X Just call me Solemn. Since: Dec, 2017
Just call me Solemn.
#35: Jul 19th 2023 at 4:07:24 PM

[up]Uh-huh. Definitely learning more towards a no-examples supertrope now, with the original definition spun off into a subtrope.

Otherwise known as SolemnStormcloud.
ImperialMajestyXO Since: Nov, 2015
#36: Jul 19th 2023 at 5:59:54 PM

Personally, I support splitting this into a trope and a subtrope for video games ("Interactive Catharsis" might be a good title), but I'd be fine with expanding the definition.

GastonRabbit Sounds good on paper (he/him) from Robinson, Illinois, USA (General of TV Troops) Relationship Status: I'm just a poor boy, nobody loves me
Sounds good on paper (he/him)
#37: Jul 19th 2023 at 6:54:11 PM

So, what would the definition for the broader supertrope be? The video game subtrope (if we split it off) would be where we'd move the current definition to, but it seems like there's been disagreement on the broader Audience Reaction's definition.

We could still add it to No On-Page Examples due to how broad it would be, but I'm not sure how broad it would be now that there's been more discussion.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 19th 2023 at 8:55:18 AM

Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
Ferot_Dreadnaught Since: Mar, 2015
#38: Jul 19th 2023 at 7:06:38 PM

[up][up][up][up]This misuse/complaining is why, before voting on expanding or not, we should decide on some limits/rules for the expanded use.

MorganWick (Elder Troper)
#39: Jul 19th 2023 at 11:37:53 PM

From The Other Wiki:

It is most commonly used today to refer to the purification and purgation of thoughts and emotions, and to a resulting emotional state that results in renewal and restoration.

In dramaturgy, the term usually refers to arousing negative emotion in an audience, which then expels it, making them feel happier.

Based on the second quoted sentence, my initial thought was that it was more appropriate to use "catharsis" to refer to the non-interactive definition, possibly for an objective trope and Intended Audience Reaction. But looking at the first quoted sentence again, as well as how Webster's defines it...
1a: purification or purgation of the emotions (such as pity and fear) primarily through art
b: a purification or purgation that brings about spiritual renewal or release from tension
...there definitely is a case for using the word for the interactive definition as well. Or perhaps for works that allow for a release of catharsis for reasons not brought up in the work itself.

Edited by MorganWick on Jul 19th 2023 at 11:38:44 AM

Ferot_Dreadnaught Since: Mar, 2015
#40: Jul 20th 2023 at 8:32:07 AM

[up]This seems like an argument for making a no examples allowed super-trope if Catharsis Factor is so broad there isn't even a singular definition for what it is.

ShootingStar7X Just call me Solemn. Since: Dec, 2017
Just call me Solemn.
#41: Jul 20th 2023 at 9:29:36 AM

[up]Yeah, and leaving it as "unsympathetic characters gets comeuppance" would just result in gushing and—for unintentional examples—overlap with Take That, Scrappy!

Otherwise known as SolemnStormcloud.
GastonRabbit Sounds good on paper (he/him) from Robinson, Illinois, USA (General of TV Troops) Relationship Status: I'm just a poor boy, nobody loves me
Sounds good on paper (he/him)
#42: Jul 20th 2023 at 10:00:04 AM

[up]Then maybe we should rename this while keeping the video game-related definition, without splitting off non-video game examples (though we could move them to other Audience Reactions), and disambiguating the old name between the new name and Take That, Scrappy!, and possibly other pages.

I think that's what I'm now in favor of since I never got an answer regarding what the proposed redefinition/supertrope would entail, as opposed to how the current definition already exists and is simply misused because the name doesn't indicate that it's video game-related.

Edit: The description could stand to be clarified as well, because it takes a while for it to say that it's for video game players, since it starts out by discussing catharsis in general.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 20th 2023 at 12:13:03 PM

Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
WarJay77 Big Catch, Sparkle Edition from The Void (Troper Knight) Relationship Status: Armed with the Power of Love
Big Catch, Sparkle Edition
#43: Jul 20th 2023 at 10:27:17 AM

My personal supertrope idea was for the broadest possible definition of narrative catharsis, whether interactive or not — similar to the definitions pulled out a few posts ago. Admittedly, IDK if making this really requires TRS approval since ultimately the definition is so radically different and it would need a new name.

Edited by WarJay77 on Jul 20th 2023 at 1:27:41 PM

Current Project: Incorruptible Pure Pureness
ShootingStar7X Just call me Solemn. Since: Dec, 2017
Just call me Solemn.
#44: Jul 20th 2023 at 10:36:16 AM

[up][up]I'm not saying that such a definition will always devolve into gushing—especially if we give strict, objective criteria, but it's a big concern if it's the route we're going down.

And either way, I think renaming the trope and clarifying its description is the best option so far.

EDIT: I forgot to mention, how would this affect video game examples of unsympathetic characters receiving karma?

Edited by ShootingStar7X on Jul 20th 2023 at 10:38:17 AM

Otherwise known as SolemnStormcloud.
GastonRabbit Sounds good on paper (he/him) from Robinson, Illinois, USA (General of TV Troops) Relationship Status: I'm just a poor boy, nobody loves me
Sounds good on paper (he/him)
#45: Jul 20th 2023 at 11:20:25 AM

What are the specifics of a non-video game definition? I tried asking that last night and still haven't gotten an answer.

If the definition being referred to was the one in Morgan's post, he was discussing the definitions of the word "catharsis" in general and how it could potentially relate to a definition of an Audience Reaction, rather than referring specifically to the context of the audience of a work of fiction.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 20th 2023 at 1:22:11 PM

Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
WarJay77 Big Catch, Sparkle Edition from The Void (Troper Knight) Relationship Status: Armed with the Power of Love
Big Catch, Sparkle Edition
#46: Jul 20th 2023 at 11:22:58 AM

Essentially, the idea of the emotional release audience members get from events in the work. I've explained sort of what I was thinking here, it simply boils down to the way works can provide the type of catharsis Morgan's posts were discussing — by offering the audience a safe way to relieve themselves of emotions (the "arousing negative emotion in an audience, which then expels it, making them feel happier" part of the definition).

The reason I didn't answer beforehand was because once again there were different definitions being discussed and I didn't want my idea for the supertrope to be presented as the idea for the supertrope.

Edited by WarJay77 on Jul 20th 2023 at 2:24:28 PM

Current Project: Incorruptible Pure Pureness
GastonRabbit Sounds good on paper (he/him) from Robinson, Illinois, USA (General of TV Troops) Relationship Status: I'm just a poor boy, nobody loves me
Sounds good on paper (he/him)
#47: Jul 20th 2023 at 11:24:33 AM

Perhaps that definition would be workable, though it's broad enough that making it No On-Page Examples would probably be the way to go.

Due to how broad it is, I was wondering if expanding it to that without renaming would mean not having to clean up wicks, due to what's currently misuse (or at least some of it) being covered.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 20th 2023 at 1:26:30 PM

Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
WarJay77 Big Catch, Sparkle Edition from The Void (Troper Knight) Relationship Status: Armed with the Power of Love
Big Catch, Sparkle Edition
#48: Jul 20th 2023 at 11:25:36 AM

Yeah, that was my idea basically: A universal no-examples supertrope. Which... really doesn't fix any of the current issues with Catharsis Factor but would give us a place to discuss the non-interactive version.

My assumption was that, if this happened, the interactive version would still exist but as a subtrope. We'd still need to clean wicks if the supertrope is made because it would be so omnipresent as to essentially be the status quo. That's part of why I thought maybe it wouldn't require TRS at all, since it's such a radically different and broader concept.

Edited by WarJay77 on Jul 20th 2023 at 2:27:01 PM

Current Project: Incorruptible Pure Pureness
GastonRabbit Sounds good on paper (he/him) from Robinson, Illinois, USA (General of TV Troops) Relationship Status: I'm just a poor boy, nobody loves me
Sounds good on paper (he/him)
#49: Jul 20th 2023 at 11:28:11 AM

We'd definitely need to clean up wicks if the supertrope ends up being a Definition-Only Page, but I was referring to if we only made it No On-Page Examples, and I was referring to if we expanded it without splitting off a video game-based subtrope.

Maybe making the supertrope a Definition-Only Page and splitting off video game examples under a new name (I'm against retaining the current name for something specific to video game examples, since that got us into this mess to begin with, or at least part of why that happened) wouldn't be a bad idea due to differing definitions of the word "catharsis", though, since forbidding examples would solve the problem of having to decide what goes in an example.

Edited by GastonRabbit on Jul 20th 2023 at 1:37:44 PM

Patiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
MasterN Berserk Button: misusing Berserk Button from Florida- I mean Unova Since: Aug, 2016 Relationship Status: Shipping fictional characters
#50: Jul 20th 2023 at 2:56:39 PM

[tup] Example-less supertrope + split.

One of these days, all of you will accept me as your supreme overlord.

Trope Repair Shop: Catharsis Factor
3rd Aug '23 9:46:03 PM

Crown Description:

It was decided to do a Trope Transplant and move the current video game-specific definition of Catharsis Factor to a new name and split off a new Audience Reaction with the original name about moments that relieve tension. The new Audience Reaction is reusing the Catharsis Factor name, but the video game-specific Audience Reaction is receiving a new name. What should the video game Audience Reaction's name be?

Total posts: 145
Top