Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / White Sand

Go To

  • Broken Base: While the 17th Shard fan forum is extremely serene and rational, especially compared to many others, White Sand is still a point of contention among them. Some say that it's far worse than the book it's based on (which is available from Sanderson by asking for it), while others call it So Okay, It's Average and yet others praise it highly, calling it a great introduction to graphic novels and a good story in its own right. The problem likely lies in the fact that the format doesn't really play to Sanderson's strenghts - worldbuilding and dialogue - and the adaptation omits a lot of both.
  • One-Scene Wonder: He only appears on a handful of panels, but Trell's presence sure sparked some discussion.


Top