In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Maka Albarn and Soul Evans, Divine Duo of Scythes (Maka: Tiny-Tits [by Soul] | Soul: Soul Eater, Death's Last Weapon) as a Lesser Gods in the Hall of Bladed Weapons (House of Weapons)
- Black☆Star, God of Massive Egotism (Center of Self-Thought, Master of All Egocentricism) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Prideful Archetypes (House of Pride and Egotism)
- Death the Kid, God of Absolute (Symmetric) Order Obsession (Kid) as a Greater God in the Hall of Order and Chaos (House of Philosophy)
- Spirit Albarn, God of Fathers who Seek Their Child's Respect (Death Scythe) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Familial Perspective (House of Family and Relatives)
- Dr. Franken Stein, God of Frankenstein Homages as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Fictional Expies (House of Derivatives)
- Blair, Goddess of Pretty Freeloaders (Cat Witch Blair, Monster Cat) as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Character Archetypes (House of Characterization)
- Medusa Gorgon, Goddess of Sinister Yellow Eyes as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Eye Colors (House of Colours)
- Crona, Deity of Ambiguous Gender (The Demon Sword Meister) as a Lesser Deity in the Hall of Gender/Sex: Miscellaneous (House of Gender)
- Excalibur, God of Annoyance and Irritation (Holy Sword, Seiken) as a Greater God in the Hall of Anger (House of Emotion)