In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Shrek, God of Ogres (Love, Life), as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Giants and Smallfolk (House of Otherness)
- Donkey, God of Second-Rate Equines as a Demigod in the Hall of Ungulates (House of Beasts and Fauna)
- Lord Farquaad, The God Who's Compensating for Something as a Quasideity in the Hall of Body Images (House of Personal Appearance)
- Princess Fiona, The Goddess Who Proves That True Love is Exceptional as a Lesser Goddess in the Hall of Romance (House of Love and Affection)
- Dragon, Goddess of The Female Monster Surprise (Elizabeth the Dragoness) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Female Appearances (House of Gender)
- Puss in Boots, God of Beguiling Stares (Diablo Gato, the Furry Lover, the Chupacabra, Frisky Two-Times, Your Favorite Fearless Hero, Gatito/Gato [by The Wolf], Pickles) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Eye Abilities (House of Personal Appearance)
- The Fairy Godmother, Goddess of Evil Fairy Godmothers (Dama Fortuna) as an Intermediate Goddess in the Hall of Fairies (House of Otherness)
- Jack Horner, God of Surprisingly Normal Backstories ("Big" Jack Horner, Little Jack Horner, "Big Roarin" Jack Horner, "Robbin' Big" Jack Horner) as a Lesser God in the Hall of Character Reveals (House of Characterization)
- Death, God of Sinister Whistling (The Wolf, Lobo, Bounty Hunter, Big Bad Wolf, Death Wolf) as an Overdeity in the Hall of Voices (House of Quirks)
