This is based on opinion. Please don't list it on a work's trope example list.
We are talking about a webcomic made by
the same person who eventually made
Alastor, The Radio Demon, so there's bound to be some
Nightmare Fuel in something as fluffy as this.
- Damian, as pictured, on his Establishing Character Moment and introduction to Cameron.
- Let us also mention that Cameron has a terrible case of Zoophobia and this very well qualified for her as a hearty-helping of Nightmare Fuel and ultimately cause her to have a Heroic BSoD.
- Hell, in general. While it has its quirky characters, the place is crawling with freakish monstrosities and foreboding landscapes. And then, there's SATAN himself...guh!
- The mere concept of being mysteriously transported to a world full of bizarre and dangerous beasts that you only thought to be true in myth and legend; suddenly existing unbeknownst to the rest of the human world is a pretty And I Must Scream fate to say the least. Now imagine having an overactive case of zoophobia and having to work at a school FILLED with animals and strange creatures who view humans as a lesser species. It certainly is a nightmare come true at this point.
- Also the fact that entities capable of incredible power and providence are surrounding you at all times is endless Paranoia Fuel.
- Kaycee could qualify. That demented Cheshire Cat Grin can be quite unsettling.
- Jack's curse. The guy can't die and is constantly in great pain. Word of God is that he can feel hunger and starvation and yet not die of malnourishment, and also suffers constantly from the pain from scabs and wounds. Ouch.
- Hello, Brutis.
Nice to meet you. - Venganza. From the blood dripping from her mouth to her sidekick to the creepy vibes she gives off while attacking Zill, she makes sure she makes a lasting impression.
- Adina from the cancelled Angels & Demons arc is quite terrifying. Her being an angel doesn't diminish her creepiness factor. If anything, her calmly torturing or ordering the deaths of others with a serene, motherly smile on her face while espousing that it's the Lord's will makes her more frightening.
