Heartwarming / Annabelle's Wish

• Annabelle thoughtlessly reveals that she can talk on Christmas Day (which was supposed to be a secret) by saying "Bless you" to Billy after he sneezes. This causes him to react with surprise at first, and the other animals with dismay, but eventually Billy loves that the animals can talk.
• Annabelle's loyalty and friendship with Billy. When Billy gets picked by two bullies due to losing his ability to speak. After telling him saying "So much for a silent night". Annabelle angrily charges towards them to stop bullying him.
• Annabelle performing a selfless act by giving up her ability to speak to humans just for Billy to speak again. The next morning, after Billy opens up a Christmas present that makes him speak again. He talks to Annabelle before discovering she gave up her voice for him. Billy is saddened but touched to know she was that dedicated to hear him speaking again.
• How reasonable the Sheriff was when Gus took possession of Annabelle. Willing to give Charlie reasonable time to come up with the money to pay off the debt. He also shown to be a good friend, saying that if he had the money, he'd give it to him, something Charlie is appreciative of.
• The Odd Friendship turned relationship between Gus and Agnes.
• The ending, after Annabelle is on the verge of death as an old aged cow. Santa encounters her and turns Annabelle into an actual reindeer due to her loyalty and love with Billy. She is overjoyed to know her dreams of flying has finally come true. An adult Billy is pleasantly surprised to discover that not only has Annabelle became a reindeer. But her dreams of flying became a reality, with Annabelle wishing him a "Merry Christmas" before taking off with Santa and his reindeer.

---