Sole Survivor
A smart and strong store worker, who plays dumb to shrink the target on his back.
First Suikoden fan character.
- The Ace
- The Big Guy
- Bully Hunter
- Flawless Victory
- The Hero
- Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: With Chaona.
- Nice Guy
- Obfuscating Stupidity: He does this so he'd be seen as less of a threat, although he's forced to drop this tactic when Lilly exposes him later on.
- Sole Survivor: The fourth, and is the first one to win unanimously.
- Standardized Leader: After he drops his Obfuscating Stupidity tactic.
- Super Drowning Skills: It's been proven that, while he is strong, Barney is NOT a swimmer.
- Teeth-Clenched Teamwork: With Lilly against Minerva.
- Verbal Tic: Has a tendency to split his sentences into fragments when agitated.
Runner-Up
A young apprentice who constantly seeks a master to replace his own, Cecil Harvey, during the game.
Second Final Fantasy fan character.
- Blind Obedience: Will just work unquestioningly for whoever he deems to be his current master.
- No-Damage Run
- Undying Loyalty: When Luke chooses a master, he remains loyal to that person, no matter what even though his first master is blindsided early because of this.
- Satellite Character: What he ultimately ends up being. His only purpose in the game is to help whoever is his master at the given time, first it was with Jez, then Mac, and by merge time to Barney for the rest of the season, however we learned next to nothing about him as a person despite lasting the whole game and his blind loyalty to his master led to him losing with zero votes cast onto him; had he drop his Undying Loyalty with Barney and taken Lilly to FTC instead he would had most likely won due to Lilly's Jerkass and Manipulative Bitch status make a lot of the jury members either turn off from her or just hate her plainly.
The Jury
A selfish girl who nonetheless knows how to play the game well.
Canon character from Suikoden.
- Anti-Hero:
- Berserk Button: When she finds out there's a final two, not a final three, facing the jury.
- The Chessmaster
- Jerkass
- Last of Her Kind: The last Canon character left in the game.
- Manipulative Bitch
- Sitcom Arch-Nemesis: With Minerva and Barney.
- Teeth-Clenched Teamwork: With Barney against Minerva.
A hedgehog girl with a rather pessimistic outlook, who is friends with Knuckles.
Third Sonic the Hedgehog fan character.
A common enemy from Ice Climbers, this particular Polar Bear talks in the third person and has a huge crush on Minerva. Came first in an all-season popularity poll.
Canon character (sort of) from Ice Climber.
- Accidental Misnaming: P. Bear is incapable of spelling anyone's name right when he votes.
- Acrofatic: Won 4 individual challenges, the most out of anyone this season. One of which while sleeping.
- Bears Are Bad News: Subverted, since P. Bear is actually well-liked by the characters and audience.
- Big Fun
- The Cameo: In All-Stars, having gotten a job as the "Security Bear". He isn't able to stop Mo from attacking Vinnie, unfortunately.
- Insistent Terminology: P. Bear doesn't like to be called "Polar Bear".
- Shout-Out: To Greg Buis in his final words, using some of the lines from Greg's own uncut final words.
- Wins by Doing Absolutely Nothing: At one point he sleeps through an immunity challenge, but winds up winning because everyone else eliminated each other.
The main villainess of the season, responsible for manipulating almost every man into doing her bidding.
Canon character from Animaniacs.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars and Season 10: Battle of the Tribes.
- Attention Whore
- Big Bad
- The Chessmaster: Uses her looks to sway a lot of people her way.
- Manipulative Bitch
- Ms. Fanservice
- Odd Friendship: With P. Bear.
- Screw the Rules, I'm Beautiful!
- Sitcom Arch-Nemesis: For Lilly, Riku, Barney, Bulma, Shiki...
- The Vamp
A crazy wolfgirl who continually makes friends with inanimate objects.
Second Kingdom Hearts fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Characterization Marches On: Originally an idiot who thought she was a strategic genius. Then her more ditzy traits started to show...
- Cloud Cuckoolander
- The Ditz
- Genki Girl
- Sanity Slippage
- Small Name, Big Ego: Her initial characterization.
- Smug Snake
A friendly but dumb echidna.
Canon character from Sonic the Hedgehog.
- Shout-Out: His first attempt at making a fake immunity idol is a stick with a smiley face on it.
- Too Dumb to Live: Minerva somehow convinces him not to play the hidden immunity idol when he knows he's being voted for.
Marc's goofy teen sidekick, yet he also has a good understanding of the game.
First The World Ends with You fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Ascended Fanboy
- Enemy Mine: The only reason why he allied with Minerva, other than Marc did.
- Fanboy
- Hyper-Competent Sidekick: Often shows more insight than Marc about the game.
- In the Hood: Wears a cool purple hoodie.
- Keet
- Kid-Appeal Character
- Nice Guy: To counter Marc being a major tool.
- The Pollyanna
Eliminated
A woman that cannot function without any kind of technology.
Canon character from Dragon Ball.
A teenager that tries to keep Minerva Mink in the game despite thinking that she is evil.
Canon character from Kingdom Hearts.
- Only Sane Man: The only one who sees Minerva for the threat she is.
Rebecca's twin sister, who has a strange habit of grabbing butts.
Second Resident Evil fan character.
- Flat Character
- Palette Swap: Of Rebecca. Justified, considering they're twins.
A black cat who is constantly plagued by her own bad luck.
First Animaniacs fan character.
Came back for Season 6: All Stars.
- Born Unlucky: She has a weird connection with the number 7, which leads her to be the seventh voted out in her season.
- Break the Cutie: Has a rough time pretty much all season, and her elimination is especially rough.
- Ironic Name
A very social person who knows how the game works because of his past experience in reality TV.
Canon character from Total Drama.
- Amusing Injuries: Just like on his original show, until he actually gets eliminated due to an injury.
- I Coulda Been a Contender!
- No-Damage Run: Ironic, considering he got eliminated because of bodily damage.
- Non-Gameplay Elimination: Is abruptly medically evacuated shortly after Rebecca is voted out.
A medic.
Canon character from Resident Evil.
- The Medic: Looks at all of Trent's Amusing Injuries, which happens a lot.
A nice, quiet girl who, much like she was during the Reapers' Game, didn't want to leave as a nobody.
Canon character from The World Ends with You.
- A Death in the Limelight
- My Death Is Just the Beginning: She manages to alter the course of the game by swapping the tribes herself after getting voted out.
A red-headed Saiyan who ended up stuck in between the conflict taking place in the Fans tribe.
First Dragon Ball fan character.
- Playing with Fire
- Wild Card: Became the swing vote for a crucial Tribal Council, and tried to take advantage of that fact. It ended poorly for him.
First Ice Climber fan character.
A young girl in a parka who tries to play the ultimate "under the radar" game.
- Out of Focus: A side effect of trying to stay under the radar.
- Poor Communication Kills: Her strategy alienated herself from the tribe, and caused her to be voted off.
- The Quiet One
The villain that unwittingly tries to form an alliance with everyone on his tribe, which horribly backfires.
Canon character from Final Fantasy VII.
- Asshole Victim: The first of Minerva's many victims.
- Disc-One Final Boss: BIG TIME.
- The Dreaded: Everyone was afraid that he would kill someone on the island.
- Humiliation Conga: The ultra-powerful and ultra-cool antagonist of Final Fantasy VII... is voted out first.
- Starter Villain: He stirs up a lot of trouble, but is shown the door immediately.
