Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / InnocentInaccurate

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Inverted in ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/48229834/chapters/121627141 My Brother, the Devil]]''. Shortly after defending Zeref to his fellow guild orphans, seven-year-old Natsu tells Makarov about his wonderful big brother [[spoiler:Zeref]] who says it's okay to kill people. Makarov thinks that Natsu and his brother were indoctrinated into a Zeref cult that [[spoiler:hailed his brother as the reincarnation as Zeref]], and that Natsu was too young to understand; while Natsu does childishly believe whatever his brother says, his version of events is accurate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Advertising/TransportAccidentCommission'': In the "12 Days of Christmas" [=PSA=], neither of Alan's children show awareness that he died [[DrunkDriver in a drunk driving accident]]. One of them asks "Mummy, is Santa gonna find Daddy?" even after attending his funeral the preceding Christmas Eve.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In issue 61 of ''ComicBook/AnimalMan'', Buddy Baker's young daughter Maxine mistakes discarded condoms on the beach for "wiggly balloons".

Added: 360

Changed: 19

Removed: 320

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[folder:Fanfics]]

to:

[[folder:Fanfics]][[folder:Fan Works]]



[[folder:Film]]

to:

[[folder:Film]][[folder:Film - Animated]]
* The opening of ''Anime/FinalFantasyVIIAdventChildren'' is narrated by the young Marlene, who simplifies things quite a bit. For example, when describing Sephiroth, the BigBad who tried to summon Meteor to strike the planet so he could become a god, she says "he hated the planet so much, he wanted to make it go away."
[[/folder]]

[[folder:Film - Live-Action]]



* The opening of ''Anime/FinalFantasyVIIAdventChildren'' is narrated by the young Marlene, who simplifies things quite a bit. For example, when describing Sephiroth, the BigBad who tried to summon Meteor to strike the planet so he could become a god, she says "he hated the planet so much, he wanted to make it go away."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/{{Threads}}'', Michael Kemp, the youngest member of the Kemp family, believes that creating a makeshift shelter to survive an incoming nuclear strike will be like going camping.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"He [Jenny's father] was a very loving man. He was always kissin' and touchin' her and her sisters. (...) God is mysterious. He didn't turn Jenny into a bird that day [as she had requested]. Instead, he had the police say that Jenny didn't have to stay in that house no more. She went to live with her grandma.(...) Some nights, Jenny sneaked out and come on over to my house, just 'cause she said she was scared. Scared of what? I don't know, but I think it was her grandma's dog. He was a mean dog."''
-->-- '''Film/ForrestGump''', describing what he understood about Jenny's molester father.

to:

->''"He [Jenny's father] was a very loving man. He was always kissin' and touchin' her and her sisters. (...) [...] God is mysterious. He didn't turn Jenny into a bird that day [as she had requested]. Instead, he had the police say that Jenny didn't have to stay in that house no more. She went to live with her grandma.(...) [...] Some nights, Jenny sneaked out and come on over to my house, just 'cause she said she was scared. Scared of what? I don't know, but I think it was her grandma's dog. He was a mean dog."''
-->-- '''Film/ForrestGump''', describing what he understood about Jenny's molester father.
father



* In ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'', the episode "The Offspring" has Data's "daughter" Lal get laughed at by her classmates. She concludes that this means she's mastered the art of humor.

to:

* In ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'', the The ''Series/StarTrekTheNextGeneration'' episode "The Offspring" "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS3E16TheOffspring The Offspring]]" has Data's "daughter" Lal get laughed at by her classmates. She concludes that this means she's mastered the art of humor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
True Art Is Incomprehensible is now an in-universe trope as per TRS.


* Creator/WilliamFaulkner does this with the sections written from the perspective of Vardaman, a nine year old boy, in ''Literature/AsILayDying'' and by Benjy, an autistic man, in ''Literature/TheSoundAndTheFury''. Five words: [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible "My mother is a fish."]]

to:

* Creator/WilliamFaulkner does this with the sections written from the perspective of Vardaman, a nine year old boy, in ''Literature/AsILayDying'' and by Benjy, an autistic man, in ''Literature/TheSoundAndTheFury''. Five words: [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible "My mother is a fish."]] "
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ''Anime/{{Pokemon}}'' fanfic ''Fanfic/{{Symbiosis}}'', due to being [[RaisedByWolves raised by Pokémon]], Ash is initially horrified by the concept of catching Pokémon until his adoptive father, Poison Lance, explained that most Pokémon encounters are by Pokémon who know the risk or want to be captured. He also doesn't understand why [[ThePeepingTom men would peek]] on [[BathingBeauty women bathing]]. He believes that men do it because women hide their secret to good hygiene, which is why women smell cleaner. He [[AccidentalPervert vows to assist these men if he ever gets the chance]] because he wants to smell cleaner.

to:

* In the ''Anime/{{Pokemon}}'' ''Anime/PokemonTheSeries'' fanfic ''Fanfic/{{Symbiosis}}'', due to being [[RaisedByWolves raised by Pokémon]], Ash is initially horrified by the concept of catching Pokémon until his adoptive father, Poison Lance, explained that most Pokémon encounters are by Pokémon who know the risk or want to be captured. He also doesn't understand why [[ThePeepingTom men would peek]] on [[BathingBeauty women bathing]]. He believes that men do it because women hide their secret to good hygiene, which is why women smell cleaner. He [[AccidentalPervert vows to assist these men if he ever gets the chance]] because he wants to smell cleaner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PlayedForDrama on ''Series/CriminalMinds,'' when this trope manages to save the life of Hotch's four-year-old after the season's BigBad takes Hotch's wife and son hostage and plans to kill them. Jack asks Hotch if George is a "bad guy," but doesn't grasp the gravity of the situation. When Hotch tells him to "work the case," Jack excitedly runs out of the room, happy to be given the job. We find out later that this is a reference to Jack's misunderstanding of Hotch's work, as he thinks it means hiding in the blanket chest in Hotch's office. Hotch knows the unsub won't think to look there, and sure enough, that's where Jack is hiding when Hotch is finally able to get to the house. Jack's proud "I worked the case, Daddy, just like you said" is a heartwrenching reminder that Jack is ''four,'' and he has no idea his mother [[spoiler: has just been murdered, and he very nearly was, too.]]

Added: 289

Changed: 3

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Used in ''Film/MyNameIsKhan'', in which the main character has Asperger's. [[spoiler:He is mistaken for a terrorist and ends up in the equivalent of Guantanamo bay, where the guards change the temperature in his cell from extreme cold to extreme heat as a form of torture. His internal monologue: "This is a strange place. Sometimes it's too cold, sometimes it's too hot. Maybe they're having problems with the air conditioning."]]

to:

* Used in ''Film/MyNameIsKhan'', in which the main character has Asperger's. [[spoiler:He is mistaken for a terrorist and ends up in the equivalent of Guantanamo bay, Bay, where the guards change the temperature in his cell from extreme cold to extreme heat as a form of torture. His internal monologue: "This is a strange place. Sometimes it's too cold, sometimes it's too hot. Maybe they're having problems with the air conditioning."]]



* Used in OctoberDaye with April O'Leary, who has been fused to a computer system and thus perceives life through that lens. [[spoiler:Unfortunately, that includes interpreting death as a system shutdown which the person can return from, and leads to her exploitation as a murder weapon.]]



-->'''Annie''': They let me acompany them on their visits to patients in the hospital. [...] It was like a game to me. And for the longest time I never understood why these people were gone the next day.

to:

-->'''Annie''': They let me acompany accompany them on their visits to patients in the hospital. [...] It was like a game to me. And for the longest time I never understood why these people were gone the next day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* This trope becomes an important plot point in ''LightNovel/ListenToMeGirlsIAmYourFather''. After 3 year old Hina's parents go missing after a plane crash (and most likely died), her uncle and 2 older sisters try to avoid the subject of why her parents have been gone so long. She doesn't think about it too much until episode 12, when she starts asking why they haven't come back home yet, and upon being told the truth, she doesn't take it very well [[spoiler:until the very end, when everyone she's met comes to watch her classmate sing, showing she still has people who care deeply about her.]]

to:

* This trope becomes an important plot point in ''LightNovel/ListenToMeGirlsIAmYourFather''.''Literature/ListenToMeGirlsIAmYourFather''. After 3 year old Hina's parents go missing after a plane crash (and most likely died), her uncle and 2 older sisters try to avoid the subject of why her parents have been gone so long. She doesn't think about it too much until episode 12, when she starts asking why they haven't come back home yet, and upon being told the truth, she doesn't take it very well [[spoiler:until the very end, when everyone she's met comes to watch her classmate sing, showing she still has people who care deeply about her.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The crutch of the joke is that the main character of the song is a proud brat who lets in the burglar for a cut of the profits. I don't think it counts as an example.


* In some versions of the song "Nuttin' for Christmas", the singer (a little boy) sees an elderly, fat burglar in a red and white suit and assumes he's SantaClaus. Even when the burglar starts stealing the silverware, the boy still thinks he's Santa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Invoked in ''Anime/FullmetalAlchemist'' fanfic ''Fanfic/BuildYourWingsOnTheWayDown'' by Edward and Hughes. Nina thought her time [[spoiler:spent as a chimera]] was a bad dream. They let her think that to spare her the pain of what happened until she's old enough to handle it.

to:

* Invoked in ''Anime/FullmetalAlchemist'' fanfic ''Fanfic/BuildYourWingsOnTheWayDown'' by Edward and Hughes. Nina thought her time [[spoiler:spent as a chimera]] was a bad dream. They let her think that to spare her the pain of what happened until she's old enough to handle it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/WithPearlAndRubyGlowing'': some characters learned the hard way that just because the person taking naked pictures of you is dressed like a doctor doesn't mean it's okay. Another comes to the rape support group to ask how she can be safe around men, every one of whom she thinks is going to assault her, but fails to grasp that the other group members count her mother persuading her of this fact as a form of sexual abuse in itself.

to:

* ''Fanfic/WithPearlAndRubyGlowing'': some characters learned the hard way that just because the person taking naked pictures of you is dressed like a doctor doesn't mean it's okay. Another comes to the rape support group to ask how she can be safe around men, every one of whom she thinks is going to assault her, but fails to grasp that the other group members count her mother persuading her of this fact as a form of sexual abuse in itself. There's also the time a child brings a handful of human teeth to show-and-tell and explains how her great-uncle got them when he killed a communist, because he didn't tell her what a communist was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''[[https://archiveofourown.org/works/33189970 Imposter]]'', Adrien in his childhood believes that his mother Emille normally shifts between a serious persona with green eyes and a doting persona with blue eyes. When he is ten, her blue-eyes self asks him to pack for a trip away from their home, but when he is ready to go, his mother has green eyes and tells him to forget what he told her before, and never shows her sweet side again. Between his age and lack of knowledge, it never occurred to Adrien [[spoiler:that the kinder side of his mother was actually a Sentimonster created to care for him, then permanently erased by the real Emilie when she tried to escape with him]].

Added: 673

Changed: 40

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%%
%%
%% This list of examples has been alphabetized. Please add your example in the proper place. Thanks!
%%
%%%



* [[Manga/SayonaraZetsubouSensei Kafuka Fura]], though whether she's naive or delusional is up for debate.

to:

* [[Manga/SayonaraZetsubouSensei ''Manga/SayonaraZetsubouSensei'': Kafuka Fura]], Fura, though whether she's naive or delusional is up for debate.



* ''[[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RgkrBTryVCfmAARA5ZCMTY4nTa2ta2-mhmdpxvipEoA/edit?hl=en&pli=1#%20 Bubbles,]]'' a ''[[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic My Little Pony]]'' fanfic about how Derpy Hooves [[TearJerker got her cutie mark.]] It's a DarkFic, because Derpy's mother is [[AbusiveParents abusive]], calling her a "retard", yelling at her, and hitting her sometimes, and Derpy's [[TheKlutz clumsiness]] is [[AdaptationalExplanation explained]] as her having some sort of birth defect that makes her move, see, and talk badly. Her mother is implied to also have something wrong with the wiring upstairs, as she takes medicine "so she doesn't cry". Derpy, however, thinks her mother is just loud and that "retard" is a strange new word. Also, at one point, Derpy goes to the hospital but doesn't understand, and thinks it's just a cool new place.

to:

* ''[[https://docs.google.com/document/d/1RgkrBTryVCfmAARA5ZCMTY4nTa2ta2-mhmdpxvipEoA/edit?hl=en&pli=1#%20 Bubbles,]]'' Bubbles]]'', a ''[[WesternAnimation/MyLittlePonyFriendshipIsMagic My Little Pony]]'' fanfic about how Derpy Hooves [[TearJerker got her cutie mark.]] mark]]. It's a DarkFic, because Derpy's mother is [[AbusiveParents abusive]], calling her a "retard", yelling at her, and hitting her sometimes, and Derpy's [[TheKlutz clumsiness]] is [[AdaptationalExplanation explained]] as her having some sort of birth defect that makes her move, see, and talk badly. Her mother is implied to also have something wrong with the wiring upstairs, as she takes medicine "so she doesn't cry". Derpy, however, thinks her mother is just loud and that "retard" is a strange new word. Also, at one point, Derpy goes to the hospital but doesn't understand, and thinks it's just a cool new place.



** In ''The Edgy House'', covered in After Dark 4, the Leni in the story [[spoiler:until it's revealed to be a joke all along]] thinks that Lynn Sr.'s [[VillainousIncest raping her]] is just "kissies".

to:

** In ''The Edgy House'', covered in After "After Dark 4, 4", the Leni in the story [[spoiler:until it's revealed to be a joke all along]] thinks that Lynn Sr.'s [[VillainousIncest raping her]] is just "kissies".



* ''Fanfic/YourMoveInstigatorDrawYourWeaponAndHoldYourTongue'': Sakura, Kiba and Tenten fall into this; between their youth (ranging from ages six to eight) and how they're ChildSoldiers that have been ConditionedToAcceptHorror, they often misinterpret things. For instance, Sakura and Kiba remember their instructor's hands constantly shaking, and assume that was from age; it's heavily implied Clanless Bekko-sensei was actually overwhelmed by how he was teaching kindergarten-aged students how to kill, knowing they'd be shipped out to the frontlines shortly.



-->'''Linda:''' Butters, where did Daddy go after the movie?
-->'''Butters:''' To the gym.
-->'''Linda:''' To the gym?
-->'''Butters:''' Yeah, the White Swallow Spa.
-->'''Linda:''' ''Aah!!''
-->'''Butters:''' Yep, he went in there and he wrestled with all kinds of guys. He wasn't too good, though. This one black guy had him pinned down for fifteen minutes straight.

to:

-->'''Linda:''' Butters, where did Daddy go after the movie?
-->'''Butters:'''
movie?\\
'''Butters:'''
To the gym.
-->'''Linda:'''
gym.\\
'''Linda:'''
To the gym?
-->'''Butters:'''
gym?\\
'''Butters:'''
Yeah, the White Swallow Spa.
-->'''Linda:''' ''Aah!!''
-->'''Butters:'''
Spa.\\
'''Linda:''' ''Aah!!''\\
'''Butters:'''
Yep, he went in there and he wrestled with all kinds of guys. He wasn't too good, though. This one black guy had him pinned down for fifteen minutes straight.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* From ''Magazine/TheOnion'': [[https://www.theonion.com/daddy-put-in-bye-bye-box-1819569708 "Daddy Put In Bye-Bye Box."]] Widely regarded as one of the [[TearJerker saddest articles on the site]]. A man named Howard Lewis dies of a terminal disease (probably [[TheTopicOfCancer stomach cancer]] since he lost his hair and there was mention of him needing "a new tummy") and is buried, but his little son Ryan thinks he's just going on vacation and his even-younger daughter Rebecca thinks he's just asleep like Snow White, so both think Howard will be back. Ryan doesn't even understand that Howard was sick, thinking he just went to the hospital to play. The Lewis kids also have a dead cat Muffin, grandma Sarah, and uncle Brian, yet don't understand that those three are dead either.

to:

* From ''Magazine/TheOnion'': [[https://www.theonion.com/daddy-put-in-bye-bye-box-1819569708 "Daddy Put In Bye-Bye Box."]] Widely regarded as one of the [[TearJerker saddest articles on the site]]. A man named Howard Lewis dies of a terminal disease (probably [[TheTopicOfCancer stomach cancer]] since he lost his hair and there was mention of him needing "a new tummy") and is buried, but his little son Ryan thinks he's just going on vacation and his even-younger daughter Rebecca thinks he's just asleep like Snow White, so both think Howard will be back. Ryan doesn't even understand that Howard was sick, thinking he just went to the hospital to play. The Lewis kids also have a dead cat Muffin, grandma Sarah, and uncle Brian, yet don't understand that those three are dead either. The article ends with their mother about to talk to them about what they think is eating their vegetables and cleaning their rooms, but is really about their father’s death.

Added: 1700

Changed: 21

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also PleaseWakeUp. A TearfulSmile may attempt to prevent a child's realizing another character's grief. Related to UnreliableNarrator.

to:

See also PleaseWakeUp.PleaseWakeUp and InnocentSwearing. A TearfulSmile may attempt to prevent a child's realizing another character's grief. Related to UnreliableNarrator.


Added DiffLines:

** In Episode 36, seven-year-old Lana reads a story in which her older sister Lori [[OrgasmicallyDelicious moans while eating a hamburger]]. Lana believes that the hamburger in the story must've been so good it hurt.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Jokes]]
* A little girl [[PrimalScene walks in on her parents having sex]]. The mother claims that she's letting the air out of the father's belly, but the girl tells her not to bother because the maid blows him back up every day.
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

* In some versions of the song "Nuttin' for Christmas", the singer (a little boy) sees an elderly, fat burglar in a red and white suit and assumes he's SantaClaus. Even when the burglar starts stealing the silverware, the boy still thinks he's Santa.


Added DiffLines:

* Parodied in "[[https://www.parents.com/holiday/christmas/reasons-santa-is-totally-real-duh/ 7 Reasons Santa is Totally Real, Duh]]". The narrator is a woman who thinks like a kid, so she StillBelievesInSanta. She doesn't catch on that her dog was the one who ate Santa's cookies and that the letters are actually written by her grandma (even when the handwriting changes right as Grandma gets arthritis), thinks Santa is the one keeping his wrapping paper in other people's houses, mistakes ''WesternAnimation/ThePolarExpress'' for a true story, thinks a creepy man calling her "naughty" was actually the Elves on a Shelf speaking, mistakes the barcodes on the gifts for a tracking device from Santa, and doesn't realise that it's actually her husband giving her presents.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/DanielTigersNeighborhood'': In "Daniel's Fish Dies", four-year-old Daniel doesn't understand that his fish is dead. He thinks that the fish is just staying by the castle because he loves it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/TheSandMan'' includes a {{Flashback}} where a much younger Sophie explains to a friend why her mother's no longer around, referencing a "Ban Crobber".

to:

* ''VideoGame/TheSandMan'' ''VideoGame/TheSandman2014'' includes a {{Flashback}} where a much younger Sophie explains to a friend why her mother's no longer around, referencing a "Ban Crobber".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheBoyInTheStripedPyjamas'', an eight year old named Bruno has a father who is very high up and important. His father works for the Fury [[spoiler:(Fuhrer)]], and is forced to leave his old home in Berlin with the rest of the family. They move to a place named Out-With [[spoiler:(Auschwitz)]] wherein he isn't really happy. He never understands why his mother starts taking so many medicinal sherries and long naps, and why the young but cruel Lt. Kotler seems to be around so much. [[spoiler:(She's having an affair with him.)]] He retains his naiveté even after meeting and speaking regularly with someone from the other side of the fence, "Shmuel".

to:

* In ''Literature/TheBoyInTheStripedPyjamas'', an eight year old named Bruno has a father who is very high up and important. His father works for the Fury [[spoiler:(Fuhrer)]], and is forced to leave his old home in Berlin with the rest of the family. They move to a place named Out-With [[spoiler:(Auschwitz)]] wherein he isn't really happy. He never understands why his mother starts taking so many medicinal sherries and long naps, and why the young but cruel Lt. Kotler seems to be around so much. [[spoiler:(She's having an affair with him.)]] He retains his naiveté even after meeting and speaking regularly with someone from the other side of the fence, "Shmuel"."Shmuel", who wears the titular striped pajamas ([[spoiler:his concentration camp uniform, as he's a Jewish boy held there with his family]]). Naturally, it [[DownerEnding leads to tragedy]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After ''Film/{{Babe}}'' stops a pack of dogs from attacking a flock of sheep, he gets blood on his snout when he's mourning over Maa's corpse. Farmer Hogget assumes that Babe was the one who killed Maa and gets ready to put him down with his shotgun. Babe's thoughts are narrated to the audience:

to:

* After ''Film/{{Babe}}'' stops a pack of dogs from attacking a flock of sheep, he gets blood on his snout when he's mourning over Maa's corpse. Farmer Hogget assumes that Babe was the one who killed Maa and gets ready to put him down with his shotgun. He can't bring himself to after Babe innocently mouths the barrels, thus realizing that he'd never kill her. Babe's thoughts are narrated to the audience:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A flashback in ''28 Days'' shows the main character and her sister as children discovering that her mother has passed away. As they're being taken away by their aunt, one of the girls tells her, "Just slap her ''real'' hard, she'll wake up."

to:

* A flashback in ''28 Days'' ''Film/TwentyEightDays'' shows the main character and her sister as children discovering that her mother has passed away. As they're being taken away by their aunt, one of the girls tells her, "Just slap her ''real'' hard, she'll wake up."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


'''Bart:''' It looks like he's trying to jump ''over'' her, but can't quite make it. C'mon boy! You can do it!\\

to:

'''Bart:''' It looks like he's trying to jump ''over'' her, but he can't quite make it. C'mon boy! You can do it!\\
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Marge:''' Uh-oh...\\

to:

--->'''Marge:''' '''Marge:''' [[OhCrap Uh-oh...\\]]\\

Top