Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / BlackfaceStyleCaricature

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Cartoons made in the mid-20th century would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look and sometimes perform other acts reminiscent of MinstrelShows, such as dancing a cakewalk and generally engaging in UncleTomfoolery. This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were more familiar with minstrel show tropes.

to:

Cartoons made in the [[The20thCentury mid-20th century century]] would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look and sometimes perform other acts reminiscent of MinstrelShows, such as dancing a cakewalk and generally engaging in UncleTomfoolery. This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were more familiar with minstrel show tropes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Cartoons made in the mid-twentieth century would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look and sometimes perform other acts reminiscent of MinstrelShows, such as dancing a cakewalk and generally engaging in UncleTomfoolery. This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were more familiar with minstrel show tropes.

to:

Cartoons made in the mid-twentieth mid-20th century would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look and sometimes perform other acts reminiscent of MinstrelShows, such as dancing a cakewalk and generally engaging in UncleTomfoolery. This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were more familiar with minstrel show tropes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope due to racism, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance especially in media from places where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].

to:

A caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope due to racism, its racist origins, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance especially in media from places where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].



* One of these illustrations is a plot point in ''Film/GhostWorld''. Enid borrows a poster from Seymour depicting Cook's Chicken's OldShame mascot, a monkey-like dark-skinned child with huge red lips and eyes, eating chicken, and presents it as art to one-up her pretentious art teacher. This backfires as the art teacher loves it and features it at an art exhibition. The blatantly racist poster attracts a lot of brouhaha, and all the criticism involved get [[spoiler: Seymour fired from his job and Enid forced to fail the art class]].

to:

* One of these illustrations is a plot point in ''Film/GhostWorld''. Enid borrows a poster from Seymour depicting Cook's Chicken's OldShame mascot, a monkey-like dark-skinned child with huge red lips and eyes, eating chicken, and presents it as art to one-up her pretentious art teacher. This backfires as the art teacher loves it and features it at an art exhibition. The blatantly racist poster attracts a lot of brouhaha, and all the criticism involved get [[spoiler: Seymour [[spoiler:Seymour fired from his job and Enid forced to fail the art class]].



* The children's book ''Literature/LittleBlackSambo'' did not originally have illustrations- early publications often illustrated the title character with black skin and exaggerated red lips, although it has been reprinted with more realistic illustrations in modern times.

to:

* The While the children's book ''Literature/LittleBlackSambo'' did not originally have illustrations- illustrations, early publications often illustrated the title character with black skin and exaggerated red lips, although it has been reprinted with more realistic illustrations in modern times.



* The obscure Dreamcast launch title, ''VideoGame/PenPenTricelon'', has Unga Pogo: a ''jarringly'' racist -- almost bestial -- depiction of an African native.

to:

* The obscure Dreamcast launch title, ''VideoGame/PenPenTricelon'', has Unga Pogo: Pogo, a ''jarringly'' racist -- almost bestial -- depiction of an African native.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Theodore Geisel (Creator/DrSeuss) sometimes depicted black characters in racist ways in cartoons intended for magazines. One featured a store selling various things are which are puns on familiar sayings. Under a sign urging people to buy "a high-class nigger for your woodpile" are depictions of several black men waiting to be purchased.

to:

* Theodore Geisel (Creator/DrSeuss) sometimes depicted black characters in racist ways in cartoons intended for magazines. One featured a store selling various things are which are puns on familiar sayings. Under a sign urging people to buy "a high-class nigger for your woodpile" are depictions of several black men waiting to be purchased. Seuss would later go on to denounce these early works as being outdated and offensive.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/Animal Crossing'':

to:

* ''VideoGame/Animal Crossing'':''VideoGame/AnimalCrossing'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Animal Crossing:

to:

* Animal Crossing:''VideoGame/Animal Crossing'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Animal Crossing:
** Jane in the Japanese version of the first game had this, but was altered in the western release.
** Kiki's face truly qualifies as this, and yet it never caused any major controversy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Its very first star, WesternAnimation/BoskoTheTalkInkKid, isn't seen much nowadays because he is visually a blackface caricature. He was generally depicted as the hero of the shorts and an admirable character, and the blackface elements of his design were gradually toned down, but the origin was still obvious.

to:

** Its very first star, WesternAnimation/BoskoTheTalkInkKid, isn't seen much nowadays because he is visually a blackface caricature. He was AmbiguouslyHuman enough to the point where he looked [[SonOfAnApe like a monkey]]. He was generally depicted as the hero of the shorts and an admirable character, and the blackface elements of his design were gradually toned down, but the origin was still obvious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Boogie from the ''VideoGame/RhythmStar'' franchise resembled one until he was redesigned for international release.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/CoalBlackAndDeSebbenDwarfs'', one of WB's WesternAnimation/CensoredEleven shorts, was a parody of ''Literature/SnowWhite'' whose entire cast consisted of various black stereotypes. The dwarfs were all blackface caricatures. The Prince wore a Zoot suit and had straightened hair and gold teeth. "So White", was a hypersexual, big-bottomed younger black woman, with perky breasts and revealing clothing. The mother and child at the beginning were a stereotypical Mammy character and a literal pickaninny.

to:

* ** ''WesternAnimation/CoalBlackAndDeSebbenDwarfs'', one of WB's WesternAnimation/CensoredEleven shorts, the Censored Eleven, was a parody of ''Literature/SnowWhite'' whose entire cast consisted of various black stereotypes. The dwarfs were all blackface caricatures. The Prince wore a Zoot suit and had straightened hair and gold teeth. "So White", was a hypersexual, big-bottomed younger black woman, with perky breasts and revealing clothing. The mother and child at the beginning were a stereotypical Mammy character and a literal pickaninny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A good chunk of the ''WesternAnimation/CensoredEleven'' are called like this mainly for this reason and other negative stereotypes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Black characters in ''ComicBook/{{Asterix}}'' tend to be drawn like this. One story in ''Uderzo croqué par ses amis'' parodies the fact by depicting a [[StylisticSuck ridiculously bad strip]] supposedly drawn by a young Uderzo. It features a Roman optio and his 'politically-incorrect Romans', soldiers who are drawn in a blackface style even more extreme than the style in the original comics.

to:

* Black characters in ''ComicBook/{{Asterix}}'' tend to be drawn like this. this, with the most recurring being the lookout of Captain Redbeard's {{pirate}} crew. One story in ''Uderzo croqué par ses amis'' parodies the fact by depicting a [[StylisticSuck ridiculously bad strip]] supposedly drawn by a young Uderzo.Creator/AlbertUderzo. It features a Roman optio and his 'politically-incorrect Romans', soldiers who are drawn in a blackface style even more extreme than the style in the original comics.



* One of Cleopatra's servants in ''WesternAnimation/AsterixAndCleopatra'' falls squarely into this trope.

to:

* One of Cleopatra's servants in ''WesternAnimation/AsterixAndCleopatra'' (specifically, the ServileSnarker bringing Cleopatra's lion) falls squarely into this trope.trope. Earlier, there's the lookout of the {{pirate}} ship, who's much thinner than his comic book counterpart and whose skin (in a quite uncomfortable moment to watch that often ends up a [[invoked]]DeletedScene) ''whitens'' out of fear whenever OhCrap situations occur for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance especially in media from places where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].

to:

A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, DiscreditedTrope due to racism, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance especially in media from places where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/{{Coonskin}}'' uses this as part of the film's ''vicious'' satire on racism in America. While the film caused ''tremendous'' controversy, the blow was softened by both its [[ShownTheirWork stunningly accurate depiction]] of race relations and the film's Largely African American cast and crew. Pictures and footage of actual blackface and "Darkie iconography" are sometimes used in the background to hammer the point home.

to:

* Ralph Bakshi's ''WesternAnimation/{{Coonskin}}'' uses this as part of the film's ''vicious'' satire on racism in America. While the film caused ''tremendous'' controversy, the blow was softened by both its [[ShownTheirWork stunningly accurate depiction]] of race relations and the film's Largely African American largely African-American cast and crew. Pictures and footage of actual blackface and "Darkie iconography" are sometimes used in the background to hammer the point home.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


See also FacialProfiling, a broader trope about how cartoons indicate race.

to:

See also FacialProfiling, a broader trope about how cartoons indicate race. May also overlap with UnfortunateCharacterDesign.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Wham Bam Rock in ''VideoGame/KirbySuperStar'' is a BackgroundBoss that appears as a floating face against a pitch-black background, with his only visible features being his eyes and bulbous orange lips. This was changed in the ''Ultra'' remake, where he was [[CulturallySensitiveAdaptation redesigned]] into a {{Mayincatec}} stone-face (meanwhile, Wham Bam Jewel, a harder version of Rock exclusive to the remake, looks organic like the original Rock, but has much thinner lips and more bestial traits like fangs and a third eye to look less humanlike).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A 1938 Nazi exhibition for [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Degenerate_music "degenerate music"]] (i.e. any and all music associated with Black and Jewish communities) was advertised with [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Entartete_musik_poster.jpg a poster]] depicting a big-lipped Black jazz performer with a Star of David lapel pin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/OsamuTezuka's original ''Anime/{{Metropolis}}'' manga had blackface caricatures in one page, seen standing in front of a store called "Hottentotto travel". Note that "Hottentot" is a racial slur that comes from the mockery of the language of the Khoekhoen tribe of southwest Africa.

to:

* Creator/OsamuTezuka's original ''Anime/{{Metropolis}}'' ''Anime/Metropolis2001'' manga had blackface caricatures in one page, seen standing in front of a store called "Hottentotto travel". Note that "Hottentot" is a racial slur that comes from the mockery of the language of the Khoekhoen tribe of southwest Africa.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the ComicBook/DisneyDucksComicUniverse, [[VoodooZombie Bombie the Zombie]] has the blackish-brown skin, exaggerated lips and golden ear and nose rings. Ironically, this makes him one of the more human-looking characters among a cast of {{Dogfaces}} and {{Funny Animal}}s. Notably, his first animated appearance in ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales2017'' changes him into a dogface as well, with gray rather than black complexion, to push his design away from this trope.

to:

* In the ComicBook/DisneyDucksComicUniverse, [[VoodooZombie Bombie the Zombie]] has the blackish-brown skin, white eyes, exaggerated lips and golden ear and nose rings. Ironically, this makes him one of the more human-looking characters among a cast of {{Dogfaces}} and {{Funny Animal}}s. Notably, his first animated appearance in ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales2017'' changes him into a dogface as well, with gray rather than black complexion, to push his design away from this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In the ComicBook/DisneyDucksComicUniverse, [[VoodooZombie Bombie the Zombie]] has the blackish-brown skin, exaggerated lips and golden ear and nose rings. Ironically, this makes him one of the more human-looking characters among a cast of {{Dogfaces}} and {{Funny Animal}}s. Notably, his first animated appearance in ''WesternAnimation/DuckTales2017'' changes him into a dogface as well, with gray rather than black complexion, to push his design away from this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].

Cartoons made in the mid 20th century would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look, and sometimes engage in other MinstrelShow-related acts (e.g. dancing a cakewalk). This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were familiar with Minstrel Show tropes.

to:

A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance especially in media from places where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].

Cartoons made in the mid 20th mid-twentieth century would sometimes combine this with AshFace, in which characters would briefly adopt a blackface look, look and sometimes engage in perform other MinstrelShow-related acts (e.g. reminiscent of MinstrelShows, such as dancing a cakewalk). cakewalk and generally engaging in UncleTomfoolery. This served as a ParentalBonus for parents who were more familiar with Minstrel Show minstrel show tropes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The title character from ''ComicBook/MeminPinguin'' looks like this. It also gives him a NonStandardCharacterDesign, as all the other human characters, including his [[{{Mammy}} mammy]]-looking mother Doña Eufrosina, look much more realistic than him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-western works.

to:

A racist caricature usually seen in very old cartoons, with a design that resembles {{Blackface}}. Characters drawn in this style have solid black skin, exaggerated red or white lips, and round white eyes. This is very much a DiscreditedTrope, and most examples are either an OldShame that franchises try to cover up, or going for DeliberateValuesDissonance in order to provide commentary on racism. Straight examples may still occasionally be found in non-western works.
non-American works, [[ValuesDissonance where it's not considered a cultural taboo]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** An infamous cartoon has WesternAnimation/BugsBunny donning blackface while imitating Al Jolson.

to:

** An "WesternAnimation/AnyBondsToday" features an infamous cartoon has scene where WesternAnimation/BugsBunny donning dons blackface while imitating Al Jolson. Creator/AlJolson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Reverting to the old caption because 1) letting the reader know what they see in the image is more important than snark for the sake of snark. 2) The fact that racial caricatures have fallen out of favour is not the inevitable consequence of a natural process, but the result of a long political struggle. Racial stereotypes in advertizing have been the subject of controversy in the recent past, and may continue to do so in the future. The sentiment that "today's society has advanced so far beyond racial caricatures!" is not shared by everyone.


[[caption-width-right:350: [[SarcasmMode Hard to believe these aren't sold anymore.]]]]

to:

[[caption-width-right:350: [[SarcasmMode Hard to believe these aren't sold anymore.]]]]
[[caption-width-right:350:1922 ad for Picaninny Freeze Ice cream]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The early ComicBook/CaptainMarvel comics had Billy Batson’s friend Steamboat an African American with a simian like appearance and very large red lips.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Even with an offensive trope, we should use neutral language.


* Cyborg 008 (a.k.a. Pyunma) in ''Manga/Cyborg009'' originally had a blackface-like design despite being one of the heroes and not a source of comic relief, but he was thankfully changed from ''[[Anime/Cyborg009TheMovieLegendOfTheSuperGalaxy Super Vortex]]'' onwards.

to:

* Cyborg 008 (a.k.a. Pyunma) in ''Manga/Cyborg009'' originally had a blackface-like design despite being one of the heroes and not a source of comic relief, but he was thankfully changed from ''[[Anime/Cyborg009TheMovieLegendOfTheSuperGalaxy Super Vortex]]'' onwards.



* Osamu Tezuka's original ''[[{{Anime/Metropolis}} Metropolis]]'' manga had blackface caricatures in one page, seen standing in front of a store called "Hottentotto travel". Note that "Hottentot" is a racial slur that comes from the mockery of the language of the Khoekhoen tribe of southwest Africa.

to:

* Osamu Tezuka's Creator/OsamuTezuka's original ''[[{{Anime/Metropolis}} Metropolis]]'' ''Anime/{{Metropolis}}'' manga had blackface caricatures in one page, seen standing in front of a store called "Hottentotto travel". Note that "Hottentot" is a racial slur that comes from the mockery of the language of the Khoekhoen tribe of southwest Africa.



* ''Anime/PokemonTheSeries'': The Pokémon Jynx drew considerable controversy with its official introduction in the episode "Holiday Hi-Jinx", as the decidedly female Pokémon initially sported a black face with prominent lips which drew accusations from Western viewers of it being potentially offensive for its uncanny resemblance to blackface; one critic even labeled it among the most "Politically Incorrect Pokémon" of the series. In response to these criticisms, Nintendo eventually recolored Jynx with purple skin to offset the resemblance to blackface, and the character has been altered several times in Pokémon media to avoid further offense.
* ''Anime/ShamanKing'': Chocolove was originally drawn with large lips resembling a blackface caricature, though they were colored darker than his skin (rather than brighter, as typical with blackface). The 2021 series fixed his design so that his lips are not much larger than that of the Asian and white characters and are colored the same tone as his skin.

to:

* ''Anime/PokemonTheSeries'': The Pokémon Jynx drew considerable controversy with its official introduction in the episode "Holiday Hi-Jinx", as the decidedly female Pokémon initially sported a black face with prominent lips which drew accusations from Western viewers of it being potentially offensive for its uncanny resemblance to blackface; one critic even labeled it among the most "Politically Incorrect Pokémon" of the series. In response to these criticisms, Nintendo eventually recolored Jynx with purple skin to offset the resemblance to blackface, and the character has been altered several times in Pokémon ''Franchise/{{Pokemon}}'' media to avoid further offense.
* ''Anime/ShamanKing'': Chocolove was originally drawn with large lips resembling a blackface caricature, though they were colored darker than his skin (rather than brighter, as typical with blackface). The 2021 series fixed changed his design so that his lips are not much larger than that of the Asian and white characters and are colored the same tone as his skin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Unnecessary cruft per Expy cleanup thread


* ''WesternAnimation/CoalBlackAndDeSebbenDwarfs'', one of WB's WesternAnimation/CensoredEleven shorts, was a parody of ''Literature/SnowWhite'' whose entire cast consisted of various black stereotypes. The dwarfs were all blackface caricatures. The Prince wore a Zoot suit and had straightened hair and gold teeth. The Snow White {{Expy}}, "So White", was a hypersexual, big-bottomed younger black woman, with perky breasts and revealing clothing. The mother and child at the beginning were a stereotypical Mammy character and a literal pickaninny.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/CoalBlackAndDeSebbenDwarfs'', one of WB's WesternAnimation/CensoredEleven shorts, was a parody of ''Literature/SnowWhite'' whose entire cast consisted of various black stereotypes. The dwarfs were all blackface caricatures. The Prince wore a Zoot suit and had straightened hair and gold teeth. The Snow White {{Expy}}, "So White", was a hypersexual, big-bottomed younger black woman, with perky breasts and revealing clothing. The mother and child at the beginning were a stereotypical Mammy character and a literal pickaninny.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Creator/PhoenixGames title ''VideoGame/SnowWhiteAndTheSevenCleverBoys'' gives us Sonny, one of the titular boys and a walking blackface caricature. He's also dressed in an outfit somewhere between Uncle Sam's outfit and a Harlem Globetrotters uniform, and he plays sax during Snow White's song.

to:

* The Polish EdutainmentGame ''[[VideoGame/FamilijnyCDRomek Królewna Śnieżka i Siedmiu Wspaniałych]]'' (localized by Creator/PhoenixGames title ''VideoGame/SnowWhiteAndTheSevenCleverBoys'' as ''Snow White and the Seven Clever Boys'') gives us Sonny, one of the titular boys and a walking blackface caricature. He's also dressed in an outfit somewhere between Uncle Sam's outfit and a Harlem Globetrotters uniform, and he plays sax during Snow White's song.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Manga/DragonBall'': Mister Popo, Staff Officer Black and other black characters have a blackface appearance, which has been a long-standing nightmare when it comes to trying to export the shows. This, combined with his status as a "servant" character, has long made Mister Popo a target of criticism, to the point that Creator/FourKidsEntertainment changed his skin color to blue when ''Anime/DragonBallZKai'' aired on Creator/{{Toonzai}}.

to:

* ''Manga/DragonBall'': ''Franchise/DragonBall'': Mister Popo, Staff Officer Black and other black characters have a blackface appearance, which has been a long-standing nightmare when it comes to trying to export the shows. This, combined with his status as a "servant" character, has long made Mister Popo a target of criticism, to the point that Creator/FourKidsEntertainment changed his skin color to blue when ''Anime/DragonBallZKai'' aired on Creator/{{Toonzai}}.

Top