Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ArtisticLicenseMedicine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* For a series with a doctor as a protagonist, ''Series/Forever2014'' is a repeat offender.
** Zigzagged in regards to a certain poison. In the pilot, Henry mentions that if he were to have poisoned the subway conductor, he would have used polonium, as it would take weeks to work and allow for the creation of a better alibi. This is much closer to real-life than how it is depicted in "The King of Columbus Circle," where a victim of polonium poisoning shows symptoms soon after being dosed and is treated by pumping her stomach. In reality, it takes some time before the adverse effects become noticeable and by the time they do, it's too late to do anything besides making sure the victim's comfortable.
** In "New York Kids," when Henry finds a suspect unconscious and barely breathing, suspecting an overdose, he mixes sour milk and baking soda, then pours it into the man's mouth to induce vomiting. Trouble is, a person who is unconscious is generally unable to swallow, or even to protect their airway by coughing. Sitting an unconscious person up and pouring ''any'' liquid into their mouth is a good way to ''drown'' them, and even if they survive, foreign substances getting in their lungs is a recipe for severe aspiration pneumonia. This is why it's recommended to put an unconscious person in the "recovery position" lying on their side, so that if they vomit or regurgitate, the fluids can drain out of their mouth instead of pooling inside and being inhaled as they would propped upright or lying on their back.
*** Even better, there's a length of rubber hose around his upper arm when they find him, of the sort that would be used to make the veins stand up for ''injecting'' drugs. If the overdose was an intravenous injection, there would be absolutely no point in making the patient vomit, and it would ''only'' create a risk of aspiration pneumonia or drowning.
** In "The Frustrating Thing About Psychopaths," the killer tells Henry that he's punctured his lung and "vena cava artery" and he'll bleed to death in minutes. The ''vena'' cava, as the name indicates, is a ''vein'', not an artery. Arteries are under much higher pressure, so damaging the equivalent artery, the aorta, would have led to bleeding out much more quickly. The medicine is correct that a large vein would fulfill the killer's goal of making his victim suffer longer, but the terminology should have been used correctly.
** Two thousand year old Adam's blood found at a crime scene, and assistant M.E. Lucas reveals that it has antibodies to diseases that haven't even existed for centuries. So, why would a forensic lab be testing for them? How would they even have a test for a disease that hasn't existed since long before such testing was invented? Sure, it's ''possible'' some kind of anthropological researcher might develop a test for a disease found in ancient mummies or bog-men, but why would a forensic lab run such a test on a modern-day suspect's sample, even assuming they knew the test existed?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/November9'', Fallon's burn injuries aren't really described or dealt with realistically. It's stated that she suffered fourth-degree burns to 30 per cent of her body, with her left side being covered in scars. Fourth-degree burns are some of the severest burn injuries you can receive, extending down to muscle and bone. In many cases, body parts such as limbs that have been burnt this severely need to be amputated and there's usually permanent damage to the affected areas (provided the person even survives). Fallon is extremely lucky that she didn't lose an arm or leg, or go blind in her left eye; it's also more likely that her left breast would've removed as opposed to just being scarred. At the start of the book, it's only been two years since the fire and yet Fallon is completely physically recovered besides her scars, without so much as a limp. In real life, if she was that seriously burnt she'd likely still be in and out of hospital getting skin grafts and reconstructive surgeries, would probably be in physical therapy to regain use of her body and may not be fully able to eat, drink or speak on her own yet. She'd likely also be wearing protective gear to prevent her burns getting infected during the healing process and be taking pain medication.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/AfterLife'': There's an InUniverse example in an excerpt from a hack medical romance novel in which the doctor injects an unspecified medicine into the patient's "main artery". Besides the obvious issue here, medicine is injected into veins, not arteries. Injection into an artery could work, but it carries risks that using a vein doesn't, and is usually only done accidentally by drug addicts.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* An episode of ''Series/HermansHead'' played into the myth that sugar is 100% fatal to diabetics. Part of the story involved Herman giving a bear a donut and then finding out later that the bear was diabetic and died a short time later. Note that even if the myth were true, an animal as large as a bear would need a ''lot'' more sugar than one donut could contain to affect its glucose level significantly.

to:

* An episode of ''Series/HermansHead'' played into the myth that sugar is 100% fatal to diabetics. Part of the story involved had Herman giving give a bear a donut and then finding find out later that the bear was diabetic and died a short time later. Note that even if the myth were true, an Bears don't get diabetes, nor would one sugar hit kill any diabetic animal as large as unless it was already on the verge of death, besides which any creature the size of a bear would need a ''lot'' lot more sugar than one a single donut could contain to significantly affect its blood glucose level significantly.level, diabetic or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/DonkeyHodie'': In the episode "Cheesy Con", Donkey is told to rest and stay off her hoof after spraining her hoof on a toy truck. In real life, you can still walk on a sprained foot, or if it's a really bad sprain, perform activities with the assistance of a wheelchair.

to:

* ''Series/DonkeyHodie'': In the episode "Cheesy Con", Donkey is told to rest and stay off her hoof after spraining her hoof it on a toy truck. In real life, you can still walk on a sprained foot, or if it's a really bad sprain, perform activities with the assistance of a wheelchair.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Puppet Shows]]
* ''Series/DonkeyHodie'': In the episode "Cheesy Con", Donkey is told to rest and stay off her hoof after spraining her hoof on a toy truck. In real life, you can still walk on a sprained foot, or if it's a really bad sprain, perform activities with the assistance of a wheelchair.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WesternAnimation/HowToTrainYourDragon: [[spoiler: Hiccup's loss of his leg]] at the end is simplified and streamlined in several ways:

to:

* WesternAnimation/HowToTrainYourDragon: ''WesternAnimation/HowToTrainYourDragon2010'': [[spoiler: Hiccup's loss of his leg]] at the end is simplified and streamlined in several ways:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Turns up in the backstory of Tyranno Kenzan in ''Anime/YuGiOhGX''. While on an archaeological expedition when he was younger, Tyranno fell and broke his leg. Rather than do something completely unreasonable like getting him to a hospital, they performed an on-site surgery to replace his broken bone with that of a dinosaur that they had dug up. Not even getting into how they just [[ContrivedCoincidence happened to find a dinosaur bone the exact size and shape of the shin-bone of a maybe ten-year-old boy]], or how fossils of bones don't actually contain any bone (it's converted to rock in the fossilisation process).

to:

* Turns up in the backstory of Tyranno Kenzan in ''Anime/YuGiOhGX''. While on an archaeological expedition when he was younger, Tyranno Kenzan fell and broke his leg. Rather than do something completely unreasonable like getting him to a hospital, they performed an on-site surgery to replace his broken bone with that of a dinosaur that they had dug up. Not even getting into how they just [[ContrivedCoincidence happened to find a dinosaur bone the exact size and shape of the shin-bone of a maybe ten-year-old boy]], or how fossils of bones don't actually contain any bone (it's converted to rock in the fossilisation process).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* Medical dramas or medical scenarios on non-medical shows often have scenes that in RealLife would violate patient confidentiality --loved ones being present when the doctor asks questions or delivers news, etc.
* {{Police Procedural}}s are especially fond of having cops barging into a doctor's office, exam room, or even an operating room to arrest the physician in question, something that would not only violate the patient's privacy but contaminate the area.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''FanFic/TravelsOfTheTrifecta'' when Paul faints after the Canalave Gym battle, he stays unconscious for at least a few hours, which would be an abnormally long time in real life and would be a sign of something much more severe than exhaustion and influenza/severe cold. [[spoiler: Possibly justified by his terminal chronic illness that is revealed later on in the story, although this instance still stands out as unusual when compared to the other times in the story when he is rendered unconscious. In Chapter 10, for example, he wakes up from Mars knocking him out in a much quicker amount of time.]]

to:

* In ''FanFic/TravelsOfTheTrifecta'' when Paul faints after the Canalave Gym battle, he stays unconscious for at least a few hours, which would be an abnormally long time in real life and would be a sign of something much more severe than exhaustion and influenza/severe cold. [[spoiler: Possibly justified {{justified|trope}} by his terminal chronic illness that is revealed later on in the story, although this instance still stands out as unusual when compared to the other times in the story when he is rendered unconscious. In Chapter 10, for example, he wakes up from Mars knocking him out in a much quicker amount of time.]]



* In an in-Verse example, Dean on ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' once explained away his having fired a gun in his girlfriend's garage by claiming he'd seen a possum and knew they carried rabies. Due to their low body temperature, opossums are the ''least'' likely North American backyard mammals to harbor the rabies virus, something any doctor who knows about rabies ''or'' exterminator who knows possums would be aware of. {{Justified}} because Dean ''was'' an "exterminator", but [[HunterOfMonsters of the paranormal variety]] rather than the vermin variety.
* ''Series/ViennaBlood'': {{Justified}} due to the show being a PeriodDrama set in mid-1900s Austria. Max, part of the main {{Buddy Cop|Show}} duo, is portrayed as thoughtful and enlightened for his belief in and use of Freudian psychology and the "talking cure". His supervising physician Gruner is portrayed as a brutal torturer for his use of electric shock therapy. In the show, it's ambiguous whether Max or Gruner was more effective at treating Amelia's dissociative disorder (though the framing supports Max since it's his story). Modern medical science has shown ECT to be really useful for quite a few mental conditions when properly performed (i.e. with muscle relaxants and anesthesia, as opposed to just hooking the patient's head up to a voltage source the way Gruner does it), while Freudian psychology, though the forerunner of modern cognitive behavioral therapy, is now dismissed as mostly nonsense.

to:

* In an in-Verse example, Dean on ''Series/{{Supernatural}}'' once explained away his having fired a gun in his girlfriend's garage by claiming he'd seen a possum and knew they carried rabies. Due to their low body temperature, opossums are the ''least'' likely North American backyard mammals to harbor the rabies virus, something any doctor who knows about rabies ''or'' exterminator who knows possums would be aware of. {{Justified}} {{Justified|Trope}} because Dean ''was'' an "exterminator", but [[HunterOfMonsters of the paranormal variety]] rather than the vermin variety.
* ''Series/ViennaBlood'': {{Justified}} {{Justified|Trope}} due to the show being a PeriodDrama set in mid-1900s Austria. Max, part of the main {{Buddy Cop|Show}} duo, is portrayed as thoughtful and enlightened for his belief in and use of Freudian psychology and the "talking cure". His supervising physician Gruner is portrayed as a brutal torturer for his use of electric shock therapy. In the show, it's ambiguous whether Max or Gruner was more effective at treating Amelia's dissociative disorder (though the framing supports Max since it's his story). Modern medical science has shown ECT to be really useful for quite a few mental conditions when properly performed (i.e. with muscle relaxants and anesthesia, as opposed to just hooking the patient's head up to a voltage source the way Gruner does it), while Freudian psychology, though the forerunner of modern cognitive behavioral therapy, is now dismissed as mostly nonsense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May be related to ArtisticLicenseBiology or ArtisticLicenceAnatomy. See also ArtisticLicensePharmacology, and MedicalTreatmentTropes.

to:

May be related to ArtisticLicenseBiology or ArtisticLicenceAnatomy.ArtisticLicenseBiology, ArtisticLicenceAnatomy and ArtisticLicenseBotany. See also ArtisticLicensePharmacology, and MedicalTreatmentTropes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Fanfic/ApprenticeAndPregnant'': [[spoiler:Applefur]] is a cat who suffers from delusions. To help with the hallucinations, her [[TheMedic medicinecat]] tells her to eat a mixture of poppy seeds and yew leaves every day. This wouldn't do anything in real life and is more likely to make a cat ill than anything.

to:

* ''Fanfic/ApprenticeAndPregnant'': [[spoiler:Applefur]] is a cat who suffers from delusions. To help with the hallucinations, her [[TheMedic medicinecat]] tells her to eat a mixture of poppy seeds and yew leaves every day. This wouldn't do anything in In real life and life, this would probably kill her. Yew is more likely toxic to make a cat ill than anything.most animals.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''LightNovel/SwordArtOnline'': The "Mother's Rosario" arc (volume 7 of the book series, last third of season 2 of the anime) deals with Asuna befriending Konno Yuuki, a sick girl who contracted HIV through a blood transfusion given to her mother during a C-section. While it is medically possible to get HIV from a transfusion, it's anachronistic enough to be extremely unlikely: this would have happened in 2010 given the in-universe dates. Blood centers began testing donations for HIV-1 in 1985 and the rarer HIV-2 strain in 1992, and the practice has only been intensified in the years since. [[https://www.redcrossblood.org/biomedical-services/blood-diagnostic-testing/blood-testing.html According to the Red Cross]], at time of writing your chance of getting even the commoner strain this way is about 1 in 2 million.

to:

* ''LightNovel/SwordArtOnline'': ''Literature/SwordArtOnline'': The "Mother's Rosario" arc (volume 7 of the book series, last third of season 2 of the anime) deals with Asuna befriending Konno Yuuki, a sick girl who contracted HIV through a blood transfusion given to her mother during a C-section. While it is medically possible to get HIV from a transfusion, it's anachronistic enough to be extremely unlikely: this would have happened in 2010 given the in-universe dates. Blood centers began testing donations for HIV-1 in 1985 and the rarer HIV-2 strain in 1992, and the practice has only been intensified in the years since. [[https://www.redcrossblood.org/biomedical-services/blood-diagnostic-testing/blood-testing.html According to the Red Cross]], at time of writing your chance of getting even the commoner strain this way is about 1 in 2 million.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheColoredCross: An enforced artistic license; The Red Cross logo is recolored to another color or changed to another logo per request from the International Red Cross organization.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Franchise/EvilDead'': Ash is never shown at any point doing much more to his stump initially than wrapping it up, unless he treated it properly and kept it clean he would have died a pretty quickly.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Webcomic/VampireGirl'', Laura, a Certified Nursing Assistant provides the titular vampire girl Levana with sangria as a placebo whenever she has relapses from blood withdrawals to avoid having to take actual pints of blood from the hospital's blood bank. In actuality, stored blood can only last for about six months before much of it "dies", becoming useless for people, and it therefore goes to waste; unless vampires are picky as far as drinking live blood or dead blood goes, Laura could have secretly saved the wasted blood for Levana.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': During the invasion of the Southlands, Bronwyn gets hit with an arrow from behind, getting pierced through the chest, on the left side. First, a bow-and-arrow setup can't adequately penetrate the heavy bone like the scapula, and even less the head of the arrow to come out on the other side, it can only puncture the lungs. Anyway, Bronwyn loses a lot of blood, and asks her son to take the arrow out of her chest, because otherwise, she will die. Remember that she is a healer with supposed medicine knowledge. Anyone with basic medicine knowledge would know that taking out the object piercing your body would only speed up the hemorrhage, but this can be an AcceptableBreakFromReality, because Bronwyn's wound is sealed immediately with elfirine seeds, known to have magical healing properties. She also recovers fast for a human, only a few hours later, she is back on her feet, celebrating, and suffering no repercussions like septicemia, breathing problems, lungs flooded with blood, or at least a crippling pain that should keep her in bed for days until she recovers.

to:

* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': During the invasion of the Southlands, Bronwyn gets hit with an arrow from behind, getting pierced through the chest, on the left side. First, a bow-and-arrow setup can't adequately penetrate the a heavy bone like the scapula, and even less the head of the arrow to come out on the other side, it can only puncture the lungs. Anyway, Bronwyn loses a lot of blood, and asks her son to take the arrow out of her chest, because otherwise, she will die. Remember that she is a healer with supposed medicine knowledge. Anyone with basic medicine knowledge would know that taking out the object piercing your body would only speed up the hemorrhage, but this can be an AcceptableBreakFromReality, because Bronwyn's wound is sealed immediately with elfirine seeds, known to have magical healing properties. She also recovers fast for a human, only a few hours later, she is back on her feet, celebrating, and suffering no repercussions like septicemia, breathing problems, lungs flooded with blood, or at least a crippling pain that should keep her in bed for days until she recovers.

Added: 1530

Changed: 723

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* An episode of ''Series/HermansHead'' played into the myth that sugar is 100% fatal to diabetics. Part of the story involved Herman giving a bear a donut and then finding out later that the bear was diabetic and died a short time later. Note that even if the myth were true, an animal as large as a bear would need a ''lot'' more sugar than one donut could contain to affect its glucose level significantly.



* An episode of ''Series/HermansHead'' played into the myth that sugar is 100% fatal to diabetics. Part of the story involved Herman giving a bear a donut and then finding out later that the bear was diabetic and died a short time later. Note that even if the myth were true, an animal as large as a bear would need a ''lot'' more sugar than one donut could contain to affect its glucose level significantly.

to:

* An episode of ''Series/HermansHead'' played into ''Series/HouseOfTheDragon'': Unless he has an incredibly high pain tolerance, Aemond Targaryen takes getting his [[EyeScream eye slashed out]] surprisingly well. Even getting a scratch on the myth eye is incredibly painful, so much so that sugar people often become delirious or pass out, and Aemond's was basically ''sliced open''. Aemond is 100% fatal to diabetics. Part of also wide awake as the story involved Herman giving a bear a donut and then finding out later that the bear was diabetic and died a short time later. Note that even if the myth were true, an animal as large as a bear physician sews up his wound, which in reality would need a ''lot'' more sugar than one donut could contain to affect its glucose level significantly.induce profuse sweating, uncontrollable shaking, and screaming, before eventually making him pass out again.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheLordOfTheRingsTheRingsOfPower'': During the invasion of the Southlands, Bronwyn gets hit with an arrow from behind, getting pierced through the chest, on the left side. First, a bow-and-arrow setup can't adequately penetrate the heavy bone like the scapula, and even less the head of the arrow to come out on the other side, it can only puncture the lungs. Anyway, Bronwyn loses a lot of blood, and asks her son to take the arrow out of her chest, because otherwise, she will die. Remember that she is a healer with supposed medicine knowledge. Anyone with basic medicine knowledge would know that taking out the object piercing your body would only speed up the hemorrhage, but this can be an AcceptableBreakFromReality, because Bronwyn's wound is sealed immediately with elfirine seeds, known to have magical healing properties. She also recovers fast for a human, only a few hours later, she is back on her feet, celebrating, and suffering no repercussions like septicemia, breathing problems, lungs flooded with blood, or at least a crippling pain that should keep her in bed for days until she recovers.

Added: 318

Changed: 144

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/PeppaPig'': In "Not Very Well", Dr. Brown Bear makes a house call just for a skin rash. Real life doctors only make house calls if the situation is serious.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/PeppaPig'': ''WesternAnimation/PeppaPig'':
**
In "Not Very Well", Dr. Brown Bear makes a house call just for a skin rash. Real life doctors only make house calls if the situation is serious.serious.
** In one episode, when Mummy Rabbit gave birth to the twins, Peppa and her friends were allowed to watch her do so. In real life, kids aren't allowed to watch childbirth.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/AngelaNicely'': In “Matchmaker!”, Miss Darling says that she has hay fever and needs a day off. However, hay fever isn’t contagious and unless the sufferer is immunocompromised, it isn’t serious enough to incapacitate someone, so it wouldn’t generally necessitate a day off.

Added: 702

Changed: 735

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/BeforeTheDevilKnowsYoureDead'', when [[spoiler: Andy]] is on a hospital bed, the leads to the EKG unit are completely misplaced. They're not a bit off - they look like they were slapped on by someone just trying to make things look medic-... Oh, yeah. When they are moved to another person, they are similarly slapped on incorrectly. This kind of thing normally triggers an alarm if the machine thinks the leads are misplaced or the rhythm detected by the machine is way off. Nothing sensible would come out from simply putting the leads in the wrong places, likely triggering an alarm, though [[TruthInTelevision hospital staff don't always react to an alarm with the urgency you'd hope]].



* In ''Film/BeforeTheDevilKnowsYoureDead'', when [[spoiler: Andy]] is on a hospital bed, the leads to the EKG unit are completely misplaced. They're not a bit off - they look like they were slapped on by someone just trying to make things look medic-... Oh, yeah. When they are moved to another person, they are similarly slapped on incorrectly. This kind of thing normally triggers an alarm if the machine thinks the leads are misplaced or the rhythm detected by the machine is way off. Nothing sensible would come out from simply putting the leads in the wrong places, likely triggering an alarm, though [[TruthInTelevision hospital staff don't always react to an alarm with the urgency you'd hope]].

to:

* In ''Film/BeforeTheDevilKnowsYoureDead'', when [[spoiler: Andy]] is on a hospital bed, ''Film/BoilingPoint2021'', the leads to ambulance workers that arrive at the EKG unit are restaurant use an oxygen mask that has a reservoir bag with the bag completely misplaced. They're not a bit off - they look like they were slapped on by someone just trying to make things look medic-... Oh, yeah. When they are moved to another person, they are similarly slapped on incorrectly. This kind of thing normally triggers an alarm if deflated, which negates the machine thinks function of the leads are misplaced or the rhythm detected by the machine is way off. Nothing sensible would come out from simply putting the leads in the wrong places, likely triggering an alarm, though [[TruthInTelevision hospital staff don't always react to an alarm with the urgency you'd hope]].mask.

Added: 408

Changed: 167

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasySexChange: Transitioning takes years of therapy, including hormone treatments; it simply isn't possible for Alice to have a single operation and wake up as Bob (or vice versa). Also, unless someone was born with a working uterus and ovaries, they cannot become pregnant or have periods.

to:

* EasySexChange: Transitioning takes years of therapy, including hormone treatments; it treatments, and every body part (face, chest, genitals, etc.) that the person wishes to alter will require a separate surgical procedure, each necessitating months of recovery. It simply isn't possible for Alice to have a single operation and wake up as Bob (or vice versa). Also, unless someone was born with a working uterus and ovaries, they cannot become pregnant or have periods.


Added DiffLines:

* ImprobablyQuickComaRecovery: After waking up from a lengthy coma, your muscles will have atrophied, making you extremely weak and unable to move without assistance. Regaining full autonomy will require a long and difficult physical therapy regimen. Yet in fiction, characters will be shown getting up after spending years in a hospital bed, and almost immediately being up and about as if nothing happened.

Added: 2415

Changed: 240

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12573127/1/Under-the-weather Under the Weather]]'' (based on ''Film/Ghostbusterrs1984''), not only does it play CatchYourDeathOfCold straight, but Egon has a fever of 104 despite only having a cold (in real life, colds only cause a fever of 102 at the highest) and when [[HereWeGoAgain Janine catches his cold]], she has watery eyes, which are more a symptom of allergies than a cold.

to:

* In ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12573127/1/Under-the-weather Under the Weather]]'' (based on ''Film/Ghostbusterrs1984''), ''Film/Ghostbusters1984''), not only does it play CatchYourDeathOfCold straight, but but:
**
Egon has a fever of 104 despite only having a cold (in real life, colds only cause a fever of 102 at the highest) and when highest).
** When
[[HereWeGoAgain Janine catches his cold]], she has watery eyes, which are more a symptom of allergies than a cold.cold.
** Janine rubs vapour rub on Egon's ''feet'' to help with his congestion. Actually, since vapor rub is meant to be inhaled, it shouldn't be placed on the body part that's furthest from the nose and mouth. People have tried to rub it on their feet to stimulate their spinal cords, which they believe would stop a cough, but there's no evidence this actually works.
** In one scene, Egon accidentally takes the entirety of a little medicine cup, which was apparently four times the needed dose, and it puts him to sleep but doesn't otherwise harm him. In actuality, those medicine cups are designed to hold the ideal dose for an otherwise-healthy adult and no more (providing an easy way to accidentally take four times the recommended dose is asking to be sued), and the medicine he took was Robitussin, which would cause a lot more, worse side effects than drowsiness if overdosed.
** Egon tries to prevent getting germs on the equipment by wearing gloves. While this would help to an extent, it wouldn't do anything about any air or saliva coming out of his mouth.


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Music]]
* The song "I've Got a Cold in My Nose" has a lyric "What a funny feeling in my eyes and ears and throat". While colds can cause throat pain and ear congestion, they don't generally affect the eyes.
* In the children's song "Found a Peanut", the singer [[TheFoodPoisoningIncident eats a rotten peanut]], takes penicillin, gets surgery, and dies. While people have died from food poisoning, that's ''extremely'' rare, and it usually won't kill you or require surgery, especially from something as small as a peanut.
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Poetry]]
* The jump rope song "Cinderella (Dressed in Yella)" sees Cinderella needing multiple doctors as the result of accidentally kissing a snake. There's no such species of snake that could spread venom via mouth-to-skin contact, and even if it was meant to imply that the snake responded to the kiss by biting her, treatment for a snake bite usually only takes one doctor.
[[/folder]]


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/PeppaPig'': In "Not Very Well", Dr. Brown Bear makes a house call just for a skin rash. Real life doctors only make house calls if the situation is serious.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CasualCrucifixtion: Being crucified is far easier to recover from than it should be.

to:

* CasualCrucifixtion: CasualCrucifixion: Being crucified is far easier to recover from than it should be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CasualCrucifixtion: Being crucified is far easier to recover from than it should be.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


May be related to ArtisticLicenseBiology. See also ArtisticLicensePharmacology, and MedicalTreatmentTropes.

to:

May be related to ArtisticLicenseBiology.ArtisticLicenseBiology or ArtisticLicenceAnatomy. See also ArtisticLicensePharmacology, and MedicalTreatmentTropes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Fargo}}'': A gunshot Hanzee steals hydrogen peroxide to disinfect his wounds. It's a common misconception that hydrogen peroxide should be used for wound disinfection, probably because it ''is'' used for sterilization, but it actually slows down wound healing.

to:

* ''Series/{{Fargo}}'': A gunshot Hanzee steals hydrogen peroxide to disinfect his wounds. It's a common misconception that hydrogen peroxide should be used for wound disinfection, probably disinfection. In reality, it's used to sterilize medical tools but not applied to wounds directly because it ''is'' used for sterilization, but it actually slows down wound healing.healing.



* ''Series/{{House}}'' often features chemotherapeutic drugs as a single "chemo" chemical that you just give a patient to kill any cancer that might be anywhere in the body. In reality, chemo can use alkylating agents, antimetabolites, anthracyclines, plant alkaloids, topoisomerase inhibitors, or any number of other chemicals, and it all depends on the specific type of tumor.
** Interestingly enough, there are often multiple treatments for the same type of tumor, depending on allergic reactions and bodily tolerance. (read: some are more toxic than others, and God help you if you turn out to be allergic.)
** In one episode of ''Series/{{House}}'', we see a patient ripping out his cochlear implant -- cue spurting blood and frantic attempts to save his life. In real life, the external parts of the device (the microphone and speech processor) are held on magnetically, with the actual implant itself safely under the skin. Deaf people and hearing itinerants remove them all the time. It's the equivalent of someone tearing their eyes out by removing their glasses. [[note]]Some of the earliest experimental implants did have the external components physically connected. As this requires leaving a gaping hole in the patient's flesh, they don't do that anymore. Chances are that any of the recipients of those early prototypes are either dead of old age, or have upgraded to a newer model.[[/note]]
** The series has repeatedly shown the OR with dark, dramatic lighting. While there are some cases [[note]]When a surgeon is using a camera attached to a scope, the lights in the room are usually dimmed to prevent glare on the monitor so that the surgeon can see the images.[[/note]] where this would happen, the truth is that OR rooms are brightly lit in the majority of cases.

to:

* ''Series/{{House}}'' ''Series/{{House}}''
** The show
often features chemotherapeutic drugs as a single "chemo" chemical that you just give a patient to kill any cancer that might be anywhere in the body. In reality, chemo can use alkylating agents, antimetabolites, anthracyclines, plant alkaloids, topoisomerase inhibitors, or any number of other chemicals, and it all depends on the specific type of tumor.
** Interestingly enough, there are often multiple treatments for the same type of tumor, depending on allergic reactions and bodily tolerance. (read: some are more toxic than others, and God help you if you turn out to be allergic.)
tumor.
** In one episode of ''Series/{{House}}'', episode, we see a patient ripping out his cochlear implant -- cue spurting blood and frantic attempts to save his life. In real life, the external parts of the device (the microphone and speech processor) are held on magnetically, with the actual implant itself safely under the skin. Deaf people and hearing itinerants remove them all the time. It's the equivalent of someone tearing their eyes out by removing their glasses. [[note]]Some of the earliest experimental implants did have the external components physically connected. As this requires leaving a gaping hole in the patient's flesh, they don't do that anymore. Chances are that any of the recipients of those early prototypes are either dead of old age, or have upgraded to a newer model.[[/note]]
** The series has repeatedly shown the OR with dark, dramatic lighting. While there are some cases [[note]]When a surgeon is using a camera attached to a scope, the lights in the room are usually dimmed to prevent glare on the monitor so that the surgeon can see the images.[[/note]] where this would happen, the truth is that OR rooms are brightly lit in the majority of cases.



** The series usually offers up a real howler at least once per episode, of the kind you don't even need medical education to notice. Toxoplasmosis? A fungus (in reality, a disease caused by parasitic protozoa). ALS? Affects sensory neurons (there's a reason it's also known as "'''motor''' neuron disease"). Unnoticed tumors 30 ''centimeters'' in diameter (larger than a basketball). Etc.

to:

** The series usually offers up a real howler at least once per episode, of the kind you don't even need medical education to notice. Toxoplasmosis? A fungus (in reality, a disease caused by parasitic protozoa). ALS? Affects sensory neurons (there's a reason it's also known as "'''motor''' "''motor'' neuron disease"). Unnoticed tumors 30 ''centimeters'' in diameter (larger than a basketball). Etc.



** Apparently, [[UnfortunateImplications asexuality doesn't exist in healthy people]] [[note]]despite an estimated seventy ''million'' people being asexual in RealLife[[/note]], is the same thing as absent libido[[note]]it's not--it's the absence of sexual ''attraction'', not the inability to get horny. However, the absence of libido ''can'' be a sign of other medical problems[[/note]] and can be caused by tumors.

to:

** Apparently, [[UnfortunateImplications asexuality doesn't exist in healthy people]] [[note]]despite an estimated seventy ''million'' people being asexual in RealLife[[/note]], is the same thing as absent libido[[note]]it's not--it's the absence of sexual ''attraction'', not the inability to get horny. However, the absence Absence of libido (which ''can'' be a sign symptom of other a medical problems[[/note]] and can be caused by tumors.issue such as a tumor) is equated with asexuality, a lack of sexual attraction, which is not a medical disorder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


** In [[Recap/ColumboS02E07 one episode]], the hospital requests that the patient's assistant go to his hotel room to retrieve his usual medications. In reality, no hospital would do this as it would be a monumental waste of time- they'd either likely have the drugs on hand or would be able to get them from a nearby pharmacy.
*** They ''might'', however, make such a request if they didn't have a patient's records and no one was sure what medications they were taking. That's one reason it's a good idea to keep your prescriptions in their original bottles, all in one place, and bring them along to any appointment involving a new doctor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Genesis," it's claimed that it's traditional to name a new disease after the first patient discovered with it. In reality, the names of diseases can come from a wide variety of sources, including a simple description of its effects, the name of the most prominent researcher, the name of the most prominent patient, the location of the first known outbreak, and even literary references.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EasySexChange: Transitioning takes months of therapy, including hormone treatments; it simply isn't possible for Alice to have a single operation and wake up as Bob (or vice versa). Also, unless someone was born with a working uterus and ovaries, they cannot become pregnant or have periods.
* ElectroconvulsiveTherapyIsTorture: Electroconvulsive Therapy has been performed safely for decades. It's also been shown to be a positive treatment for several mental illnesses. Also, unlike the fictional depictions, the patient is quietly asleep while it happens, thanks to muscle relaxants and short-term anesthetics.

to:

* EasySexChange: Transitioning takes months years of therapy, including hormone treatments; it simply isn't possible for Alice to have a single operation and wake up as Bob (or vice versa). Also, unless someone was born with a working uterus and ovaries, they cannot become pregnant or have periods.
* ElectroconvulsiveTherapyIsTorture: Electroconvulsive Therapy has been performed safely for decades. It's also been shown to be a positive treatment for several mental illnesses. Also, unlike the fictional depictions, the patient is quietly asleep unconscious while it happens, thanks to muscle relaxants and short-term anesthetics.anesthetics. That said, it's ''because'' the treatment used to be so torturous and synonymous with punishment that advancements were made, leading to the milder modern version.

Top