Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / ArtisticLicenseMedicine

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/MidsomerMurders'':
** "[[Recap/MidsomerMurdersS19E4 Red in Tooth & Claw]]": It is rare for pet allergies to cause anaphylactic shock, so triggering someone's allergies to rabbits is not a good murder weapon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/TheImmortals'', a pregnant dragon who's already at the point of having contractions miscarries and the contractions stop. Daine, who's only just learned how to heal mundane animals, has a bout of PowerIncontinence and heals her - the dragon's fetus returns to life and the contractions start again, and she flies off to give birth. In live bearing animals, contractions happen regardless of whether a fetus is alive - it still has to leave the womb. Admittedly, this is a dragon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/TheImmortals'', a pregnant dragon who's already at the point of having contractions miscarries and the contractions stop. Daine, who's only just learned how to heal mundane animals, has a bout of PowerIncontinence and heals her - the dragon's fetus returns to life and the contractions start again, and she flies off to give birth. In live bearing animals, contractions happen regardless of whether a fetus is alive - it still has to leave the womb. Admittedly, this is a dragon.

Added: 392

Changed: 255

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Jaws Wired Shut", Homer gets his jaw wired shut and can't speak. Speaking with one's jaw wired shut is harder, but not impossible.

to:

** In "Jaws Wired Shut", Homer gets his jaw wired shut and can't speak. Speaking with one's jaw wired shut is harder, but not impossible. Writer Matt Selman did not know this at the time he wrote the episode, but later found out from fellow ''Simpsons'' writer Brian Kelley, who had undergone the procedure himself, but didn't bring it up because he didn't want to blow a hole in the premise.


Added DiffLines:

** In "Ice Cream of Margie (with the Light Blue Hair)", a boy who says he's lactose-intolerant suffers a severe allergic reaction and falls unconscious after Homer, who doesn't understand what "intolerant" means in this context, forces some ice cream onto him. Lactose intolerance and dairy allergies are two separate conditions; in real life, the boy would suffer digestive problems instead.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/TraumaCenter'' operations are completed within a few minutes each; the time limit for most operations is 5 minutes, and 10 minutes for FinalBoss-type illnesses. In real life, a patient is highly, highly unlikely to be in and out of the O.R. in recovering condition in just 10 minutes. After all, [[RuleOfFun this is a game, not medical school]]. It's quite possible that in-universe, the procedures take much longer than the 5-10 minutes that serve as an out-of-universe mechanism in favor of the player.

to:

* ''VideoGame/TraumaCenter'' ''VideoGame/TraumaCenterAtlus'' operations are completed within a few minutes each; the time limit for most operations is 5 minutes, and 10 minutes for FinalBoss-type illnesses. In real life, a patient is highly, highly unlikely to be in and out of the O.R. in recovering condition in just 10 minutes. After all, [[RuleOfFun this is a game, not medical school]]. It's quite possible that in-universe, the procedures take much longer than the 5-10 minutes that serve as an out-of-universe mechanism in favor of the player.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Film/{{Madame Web|2024}}'', a woman is told that her unborn baby has [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myasthenia_gravis myasthenia gravis]]. There is no way to diagnose it before birth ''now'', let alone in 1973 when the scene in question is set. Myasthenia gravis is not a genetic condition but an autoimmune disorder.

to:

* In ''Film/{{Madame Web|2024}}'', a woman ''Film/MadameWeb2024'', Constance Webb is told that her unborn baby has [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myasthenia_gravis myasthenia gravis]]. There is no way to diagnose it before birth ''now'', let alone in 1973 when the scene in question is set. Myasthenia gravis is not a genetic condition but an autoimmune disorder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I had noticed this part about Sims 3 Seasons for some time.

Added DiffLines:

** ''VideoGame/TheSims3'''': Seasons'' lets Sims take a seasonal flu vaccine at hospitals during fall and autumn, including while the Sim is currently sick with the same flu that the vaccine is aimed to cure, and taking the vaccine will instantly cure the Sim either way. In most real-life situations, such a combination would make the patient feel more ill, not less, and would usually not make the person more immune.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/{{Madame Web|2024}}'', a woman is told that her unborn baby has [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myasthenia_gravis myasthenia gravis]]. There is no way to diagnose it before birth ''now'', let alone in 1973 when the scene in question is set. Myasthenia gravis is not a genetic condition but an autoimmune disorder.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Series/DarkWinds'', the hospital has an MRI machine. Those existed in 1973, but most hospitals didn't have them yet, so it's unlikely that a small hospital in rural Arizona would have had one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Music/PaulaCole's iconic "I Don't Want To Wait" (best known as the theme song to ''Series/DawsonsCreek'') contains the lyrics "She had two babies; one was six months, one was three." Barring the very rare condition of [[https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/conditions/uterine-didelphys uterine didelphys]], that's impossible-- births have to happen at least nine months apart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Music/PaulaCole's iconic "I Don't Want To Wait" (best known as the theme song to ''Series/DawsonsCreek'') contains the lyrics "She had two babies; one was six months, one was three." Barring the very rare condition of [[https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/conditions/uterine-didelphys uterine didelphys]], that's impossible-- births have to happen at least nine months apart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Literature/StationEleven features a mutated superflu with no incubation period and a near 100% mortality rate that kills off 99.99% of humanity. In reality, such a virus would kill all its hosts long before it could spread globally.

to:

* Literature/StationEleven features a mutated superflu with no incubation period and a near 100% near-100% mortality rate that kills off destroys 99.99% of humanity. In reality, such a virus would kill all its hosts long before it could spread globally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* “Literature/StationEleven” features a mutated superflu with no incubation period and a near 100% mortality rate that kills off 99.99% of humanity. In reality, such a virus would kill all its hosts long before it could spread globally.

to:

* “Literature/StationEleven” Literature/StationEleven features a mutated superflu with no incubation period and a near 100% mortality rate that kills off 99.99% of humanity. In reality, such a virus would kill all its hosts long before it could spread globally.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* “Literature/StationEleven” features a mutated superflu with no incubation period and a near 100% mortality rate that kills off 99.99% of humanity. In reality, such a virus would kill all its hosts long before it could spread globally.

Added: 340

Changed: 422

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/MelaniesMarvelousMeasles'' has Melanie allegedly suffering from the titular disease, but she's still active and her rash doesn't even itch, however, her doctor claims it's the worst case he's seen. In reality, the rash nearly always itches, the disease nearly always makes you sleepy, and in the worst cases, it can kill you.



* ''Literature/MelaniesMarvelousMeasles'' has Melanie allegedly suffering from the titular disease, but she's still active and her rash doesn't even itch, however, her doctor claims it's the worst case he's seen. In reality, the rash nearly always itches, the disease nearly always makes you sleepy, and in the worst cases, it can kill you.

to:

* ''Literature/MelaniesMarvelousMeasles'' has Melanie allegedly suffering from the titular disease, but ''Literature/PostmanPatsDayInBed'': Mrs Goggins says she's still active okay to visit Pat because she's had the flu before and her rash doesn't therefore won't catch it from him. You ''absolutely'' can have the flu twice, maybe even itch, however, her doctor claims it's within the worst case he's seen. In reality, the rash nearly always itches, the disease nearly always makes you sleepy, and in the worst cases, it can kill you.same flu season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BaldnessMeansSickness: When having a terminal illness automatically causes you to lose [only] the hair on your scalp, when in real-life it's the chemotherapy used to treat many forms of cancer that actually causes hair loss, and causes the patient to lose ''all'' the hair on their body.

to:

* BaldnessMeansSickness: When having a terminal illness automatically causes you to lose [only] the hair on your scalp, when in real-life it's the chemotherapy used to treat many forms of cancer that actually causes hair loss, and it causes the patient to lose ''all'' the hair on their body.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BaldnessMeansSickness: When having a terminal illness automatically causes you to lose [only] the hair on your scalp, when in real-life it's the chemotherapy used to treat many forms of cancer that actually causes hair loss, and causes the patient to lose ''all'' the hair on their body.

Added: 5244

Changed: 883

Removed: 813

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s), removing complaining and contradiction.


* ElectroconvulsiveTherapyIsTorture: Electroconvulsive Therapy has been performed safely for decades. It's also been shown to be a positive treatment for several mental illnesses. Also, unlike the fictional depictions, the patient is unconscious while it happens, thanks to muscle relaxants and short-term anesthetics. That said, it's ''because'' the treatment used to be so torturous and synonymous with punishment that advancements were made, leading to the milder modern version.

to:

* ElectroconvulsiveTherapyIsTorture: Electroconvulsive Therapy has been performed safely for decades. It's also been shown to be a positive treatment for several mental illnesses. Also, unlike the fictional depictions, the patient is unconscious while it happens, thanks to muscle relaxants and short-term anesthetics. That said, it's ''because'' the treatment used ''used'' to be so torturous and synonymous with punishment that advancements were made, leading to the milder modern version. As such, the ArtisticLicense might be mitigated if the work is set in the past.



* PerfectHealth: In reality, sneezing, coughing, burping, etc. doesn't ''necessarily'' mean someone is sick, and when someone ''does'' get sick, it doesn't usually lead to drama.



* In two now-deleted fan videos of ''WesternAnimation/TheIncredibles'', Mr. Incredible and Elastigirl break all of their bones, yet they're able to sit up straight and talk, neither of which would be possible with every bone broken.



* In ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12825040/4/Love-Sick Love Sick]]'' (based on ''Film/Ghostbusters1984''):
** Egon is said to not have [[TheFoodPoisoningIncident food poisoning]], because he got sick on the same day as he ate the relevant food, not the next day. Food poisoning takes anywhere between thirty minutes and eight hours to show itself, not a whole day.
** Later, there's some CringeComedy when Janine [[JokeOfTheButt sees Egon's butt]] as he's [[NakedPeopleAreFunny stripped for surgery]], but surgeons wouldn't let someone, much less a non-family member, be present for the surgery prep.
** After Egon has his [[RupturedAppendix appendix removed]], and while he's still in the hospital, he bends down to tie his shoes, and then later Janine wants to tickle him. Both would realistically cause pain at best and ripped stitches at worse.



* ''WesternAnimation/FrozenFever'': Elsa's disease is said to be a cold, but at one point, she gets delirious. Colds aren't serious enough to cause delirium.
* ''WesternAnimation/HowToCatchACold'': This short has a few myths, like being cold can lower your resistance (which is only true if there's a rapid ''change'' in temperature or if you're already fighting an infection), and that viruses can survive for weeks on surfaces (they generally only survive about ''a'' week on surfaces). The live-action version was made to counter these myths.



* ''Film/CoolCatFightsCoronavirus'' is so unbelievably inaccurate that it would seem like a parody, were its [[Creator/DerekSavage creator]] not deadly serious about the whole thing. The film starts off dubiously with Cool Cat punching away some tennis ball-sized coronavirus molecules, complete with pinball sound effects. That could possibly be justified as a stylised depiction of Cool Cat fighting COVID, but then Dirty Dog comes along, trying to spread COVID to kids by coughing on them. This is despite the fact that he's a dog and therefore can't catch COVID, and that children are the age group least at risk from COVID. But the pinnacle is when Dirty Dog literally grabs a coronavirus molecule out of the air, adds his "magic sauce" to make it grow, then thanks the "witch-dogs" for the magic powers. And then Cool Cat comes along and punches the coronavirus, making it explode and ending the entire pandemic. Reminder, this is in a supposedly educational PSA for children.
** Dogs definitely ''can'' catch COVID-19, and even die from it, as can cats. However, there has never been a documented case of a person catching Covid from a dog; it's always the other way 'round. (There is also a completely different coronavirus that causes diarrhea in young puppies that's been in puppy Distemper Combo vaccines for ages, hence specifying "COVID-19" above, but humans can't catch that coronavirus at all.)

to:

* ''Film/CoolCatFightsCoronavirus'' is so unbelievably inaccurate that it would seem like a parody, were its [[Creator/DerekSavage creator]] not deadly serious about very inaccurate, which is quite unfortunate since the whole thing. PSA is meant to be educational. The film starts off dubiously with Cool Cat punching away some [[MonstrousGerms tennis ball-sized coronavirus molecules, molecules]], complete with pinball sound effects. That could possibly be justified as a stylised depiction of Cool Cat fighting COVID, but then Dirty Dog comes along, trying to spread COVID to kids by coughing on them. This is despite the fact that he's a dog and therefore can't catch spread COVID to humans[[note]]Dogs can ''catch'' COVID, but they can't spread it to humans.[[/note]], and that children are the age group least at risk from COVID. But the pinnacle is when Dirty Dog literally grabs a coronavirus molecule out of the air, adds his "magic sauce" to make it grow, then thanks the "witch-dogs" for the magic powers. And then Cool Cat comes along and punches the coronavirus, making it explode and ending the entire pandemic. Reminder, this is in a supposedly educational PSA for children.\n** Dogs definitely ''can'' catch COVID-19, and even die from it, as can cats. However, there has never been a documented case of a person catching Covid from a dog; it's always the other way 'round. (There is also a completely different coronavirus that causes diarrhea in young puppies that's been in puppy Distemper Combo vaccines for ages, hence specifying "COVID-19" above, but humans can't catch that coronavirus at all.)



* ''WesternAnimation/HowToCatchACold'': This short has a few myths, like being cold can lower your resistance (which is only true if there's a rapid ''change'' in temperature or if you're already fighting an infection), and that viruses can survive for weeks on surfaces (they generally only survive about ''a'' week on surfaces). The live-action version was made to counter these myths.



* ''Literature/AngelaNicely'': In “Matchmaker!”, Miss Darling says that she has hay fever and needs a day off. However, hay fever isn’t contagious and unless the sufferer is immunocompromised, it isn’t serious enough to incapacitate someone, so it wouldn’t generally necessitate a day off.

to:

* ''Literature/AngelaNicely'': In “Matchmaker!”, Miss Darling says that she has [[PlotAllergy hay fever fever]] and needs a day off. However, hay fever isn’t contagious and unless the sufferer is immunocompromised, it isn’t serious enough to incapacitate someone, so it wouldn’t generally necessitate a day off.






** Absence of libido (which ''can'' be a symptom of a medical issue such as a tumor) is equated with asexuality, a lack of sexual attraction, which is not a medical disorder.

to:

** Absence of libido (which ''can'' be a symptom of a medical issue such as a tumor) is equated with asexuality, a lack of sexual attraction, which is not a medical disorder. Libido is basically a desire to do something sexual, and while sexual attraction often triggers it, it's not the same thing (an asexual with a libido usually feels compelled to masturbate). In addition, since the man afflicted had apparently ''never'' been attracted to anyone before, this implies the tumour formed during puberty. In reality, someone who'd had a brain tumour for that long would have had other, worse symptoms, or even died, long ago.



** In "Samaritan Snare", Wesley calls Picard's mechanical heart "parthenogenetic", which would actually suggest a biological heart that was artificially created.
** In "Metamorphosis", when O'Brien's dislocated shoulder is healed with an alien's supernatural abilities, no bones are seen moving back into place.
** In "Clues", Dr. Crusher's medkit is meant to depict a Rod of Asclepius (a snake wrapped around a staff, which is a symbol of healing), but actually depicts a caduceus (two winged snakes depicted around a staff, which is a symbol of messengers). Admittedly, this is a common mistake made in real life, but it's an odd mistake for Starfleet to make.



* ''WebAnimation/TheOdd1sOut'': In "A Book I Made as a Kid", the doctor diagnoses the young James with kidney failure by putting his hand on James's face and confirming that it hurts.

to:

* ''WebAnimation/TheOdd1sOut'': In "A Book I Made as a Kid", the doctor in said book diagnoses the young James with kidney failure by putting his hand on James's face and confirming that it hurts.



* ''Webcomic/ThePetriDish'':
** In one strip, Thaddeus fears that the lab is infected with COVID due to a scan revealing the presence of bacteria on all the surfaces. COVID is not a bacterium; it's a virus.
** A RunningGag is Thaddeus getting paranoid every flu season, and it often involves scientists [[WorkingThroughTheCold going into the lab with the flu]]. This is illegal in real life.



* ''WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'': In ''[[Recap/ArthurS1E18ArthursChickenPoxSickAsADog Arthur's Chickenpox]]'', the chickenpox causes Arthur to hallucinate, which is not a symptom in real life.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Arthur}}'': In ''[[Recap/ArthurS1E18ArthursChickenPoxSickAsADog "[[Recap/ArthurS1E18ArthursChickenPoxSickAsADog Arthur's Chickenpox]]'', Chickenpox]]", the chickenpox causes Arthur to hallucinate, which is not a symptom in real life.
* ''WesternAnimation/TheCasagrandes'': In "Mexican Makeover", Lupe starts having a heart attack from shock, but when the shock goes away, this cancels out the heart attack. That cannot happen in real
life.



* ''WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}}'': Even ignoring CatchYourDeathOfCold, "Cold Warriors" has a flashback to the past where Fry is said to be running a fever of 109°F (42.8°C). Given that the brain begins to liquify at about 105°F, it is all but certain that Fry would be dead long before he could reach that point. However, it's possible that the thermometer was defective.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Futurama}}'': Even ignoring CatchYourDeathOfCold, "Cold Warriors" has a flashback {{flashback}} to the past where Fry is said to be running a fever of 109°F (42.8°C). Given that the brain begins to liquify at about 105°F, it is all but certain that Fry would be dead long before he could reach that point. However, it's possible that the thermometer was defective.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/JaneAndTheDragon'': In "Dragonphobia", Jane eats some poisonous berries and they give her a fever and amnesia. Seeing as a fever is the body's way of killing pathogens, it isn't usually a result of poisoning -- eating poisonous berries usually results in stomach cramps and possibly diarrhea and/or vomiting instead.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/LittlePrincess'':
** Justified in that it's only make-believe and the person doing it is only four, but in "I Want Baked Beans", the Princess is pretending her toys are sick from too many beans and bandages their bellies. Bandages can't treat nausea, and may even worsen it if the abdomen is bandaged.
** Subverted in "I Don't Want a Cold", where Puss seems to have caught the Princess's cold despite being a cat, but it turns out to just be {{Hypochondria}}.
** In "What's Wrong with Gilbert?", an ambulance is called regarding Gilbert the teddy bear's detached leg (and Gilbert isn't a LivingToy either; he's truly non-sentient) and actually arrives. If anyone in real life did this, they'd be brushed off if they were a child, and fined for wasting time if they were an adult.


Added DiffLines:

** Paula Price is allowed to play sports, despite her leg being broken. This wouldn't happen in reality.
* In the ''WesternAnimation/MarthaSpeaks'' episode "Martha in Charge", Truman's medical book lists lycanthropy (being a werewolf) as an actual disease.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/TheSimpsons'':
** In "The Bart Wants What it Wants", Homer thinks he will not have to pay for deliberately injuring himself in Canada due to the free healthcare. In reality, Canadian healthcare is only free to other Canadians, so he'd still have to pay. That said, [[TheDitz Homer is stupid]] so it's plausible he just didn't know.
** In "Jaws Wired Shut", Homer gets his jaw wired shut and can't speak. Speaking with one's jaw wired shut is harder, but not impossible.
** In "Blood Feud", Mr. Burns gets a kidney transplant from Smithers, despite them having different blood types. Kidneys can only be donated between people with the same blood type.
** In "Round Springfield", Bart gets appendicitis from eating jagged metal. This would cause internal bleeding, not appendicitis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/ProjectHospital'', patients strip down to their underwear when undergoing a chest X-ray, including women. In real life, women are required to remove their bra and accessories and change to a hospital gown since they interfere with the X-ray. This departure from the proper procedure was likely done for [[VideoGamePerversityPrevention modesty reasons.]]

to:

* In ''VideoGame/ProjectHospital'', patients strip down to their underwear when undergoing a chest X-ray, x-ray, including women. In real life, women are required to remove their bra and accessories and change to a hospital gown since they interfere with the X-ray.x-ray. This departure from the proper procedure was likely done for [[VideoGamePerversityPrevention modesty reasons.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''VideoGame/ProjectHospital'', patients strip down to their underwear when undergoing an X-ray. In real life, you are required to remove all underwear and accessories and change to a hospital gown since they interfere with the X-ray. This departure from the proper procedure was likely done for [[VideoGamePerversityPrevention modesty reasons.]]

to:

* In ''VideoGame/ProjectHospital'', patients strip down to their underwear when undergoing an X-ray. a chest X-ray, including women. In real life, you women are required to remove all underwear their bra and accessories and change to a hospital gown since they interfere with the X-ray. This departure from the proper procedure was likely done for [[VideoGamePerversityPrevention modesty reasons.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
I know it doesn't have a page yet, but still

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/ProjectHospital'', patients strip down to their underwear when undergoing an X-ray. In real life, you are required to remove all underwear and accessories and change to a hospital gown since they interfere with the X-ray. This departure from the proper procedure was likely done for [[VideoGamePerversityPrevention modesty reasons.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added new example

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/FamilyGuy'': In "[[Recap/FamilyGuyS16E19TheUnkindestCut The Unkindest Cut]]", after a GroinAttack from a shark results in Quagmire's penis being ripped off, Ida gives him the latter's penis from before she transitioned. Thing is, her penis wouldn't have been removed in the first place, just reshaped and tucked into her body to simulate a vagina. This one overlaps with SeriesContinuityError since her first appearance had her point out that this process is what happened during the surgery.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Film/Awake}}''. Oh boy, ''Awake''. Along with making the same mistake as the below-mentioned ''Seven Pounds'' (only with medication instead of jellyfish venom), there are a few. For instance, how the anesthesiologist is allowed to just step out of the operating theater to make a phone call when it's his job to stay there to make sure the patient isn't starting to wake up before the surgery is complete. Or how the donated heart for the surgery shows up AFTER they have already opened up the patient. Although, according to [[WebVideo/BadMovieBeatdown Film Brain]] at least, this helps makes the movie a so-bad-its-good experience for both non-experts and medical professionals alike.

to:

* ''{{Film/Awake}}''.''Film/Awake2007''. Oh boy, ''Awake''. Along with making the same mistake as the below-mentioned ''Seven Pounds'' (only with medication instead of jellyfish venom), there are a few. For instance, how the anesthesiologist is allowed to just step out of the operating theater to make a phone call when it's his job to stay there to make sure the patient isn't starting to wake up before the surgery is complete. Or how the donated heart for the surgery shows up AFTER they have already opened up the patient. Although, according to [[WebVideo/BadMovieBeatdown Film Brain]] at least, this helps makes the movie a so-bad-its-good experience for both non-experts and medical professionals alike.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheOrville'', episode "[[Recap/TheOrvilleS2E5AllTheWorldIsABirthdayCake All the World Is a Birthday Cake]]". Doctor Finn and Lieutenant Talla are touring a Regorian hospital and are brought into a surgical suite where a C-section on a premature child is taking place. There's two pieces of artistic license here, one {{justified|Trope}}, the other not so much.

to:

* ''Series/TheOrville'', ''Series/TheOrville'': In the episode "[[Recap/TheOrvilleS2E5AllTheWorldIsABirthdayCake All the World Is a Birthday Cake]]". Cake]]", Doctor Finn and Lieutenant Talla are touring a Regorian hospital and are brought into a surgical suite where a C-section on a premature child is taking place. There's two pieces of artistic license here, one {{justified|Trope}}, the other not so much.



** In "Time's Arrow", Data mistakes two men who are coughing as victims of a cholera outbreak. Cholera is an intestinal disease, not a throat or lung infection.
** In "Genesis," it's claimed that it's traditional to name a new disease after the first patient discovered with it. In reality, the names of diseases can come from a wide variety of sources, including a simple description of its effects, the name of the most prominent researcher, the name of the most prominent patient, the location of the first known outbreak, and even literary references.

to:

** In "Time's Arrow", "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS5E26S6E1TimesArrow Time's Arrow]]", Data mistakes two men who are coughing as victims of a cholera outbreak. Cholera is an intestinal disease, not a throat or lung infection.
** In "Genesis," "[[Recap/StarTrekTheNextGenerationS7E18Genesis Genesis]]", it's claimed that it's traditional to name a new disease after the first patient discovered with it. In reality, the names of diseases can come from a wide variety of sources, including a simple description of its effects, the name of the most prominent researcher, the name of the most prominent patient, the location of the first known outbreak, and even literary references.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/ViennaBlood'': {{Justified|Trope}} due to the show being a PeriodDrama set in mid-1900s Austria. Max, part of the main {{Buddy Cop|Show}} duo, is portrayed as thoughtful and enlightened for his belief in and use of Freudian psychology and the "talking cure". His supervising physician Gruner is portrayed as a brutal torturer for his use of electric shock therapy. In the show, it's ambiguous whether Max or Gruner was more effective at treating Amelia's dissociative disorder (though the framing supports Max since it's his story). Modern medical science has shown ECT to be really useful for quite a few mental conditions when properly performed (i.e. with muscle relaxants and anesthesia, as opposed to just hooking the patient's head up to a voltage source the way Gruner does it), while Freudian psychology, though the forerunner of modern cognitive behavioral therapy, is now dismissed as mostly nonsense.

to:

* ''Series/ViennaBlood'': {{Justified|Trope}} due to the show being a PeriodDrama set in mid-1900s Austria. Max, part of the main {{Buddy Cop|Show}} duo, is portrayed as thoughtful and enlightened for his belief in and use of Freudian psychology and the "talking cure". His supervising physician Gruner is portrayed as a brutal torturer for his use of electric shock therapy. In the show, it's ambiguous whether Max or Gruner was more effective at treating Amelia's dissociative disorder (though the framing supports Max since it's his story). Modern medical science has shown ECT to be really useful for quite a few mental conditions when properly performed (i.e. with muscle relaxants and anesthesia, as opposed to just hooking the patient's head up to a voltage source the way Gruner does it), while Freudian psychology, though the forerunner of modern cognitive behavioral therapy, is now dismissed as mostly nonsense. On the other hand, Max is completely correct to have taken the eponymous "Melancholy Countess" of the season 2 premiere off of Gruner's prescription of opium: besides the obvious dangers of addiction, opiates tend to make depression ("melancholy") symptoms ''worse'' after the high wears off.

Top