Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion History Main / RidiculousCounterRequest

Go To

Changed line(s) 1 from:
n
I would like to add an example but I\'m not sure if it completely fits the trope\'s definition.
to:
I would like to add an example but it deviates quite a bit from the original formula, so I\\\'m not sure if it completely fits the trope\\\'s definition.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
* The phrase consists in the \"counter-request\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \"Milky Way\" there[[/labelnote]]?\" (\"\'\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\'\'\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \"a blowjob and a Mars bar\" (\"\'\'une pipe et un mars\'\'\").
to:
* The phrase consists in the \\\"counter-request\\\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. This is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \\\"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \\\"Milky Way\\\" there[[/labelnote]]?\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\\\'\\\'\\\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\\\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \\\"a blowjob and a Mars bar\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'une pipe et un mars\\\'\\\'\\\").
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
* The phrase consists in the \"counter-request\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \"Milky Way\" there[[/labelnote]]?\" (\"\'\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\'\'\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \"a blowjob and a Mars bar\".
to:
* The phrase consists in the \\\"counter-request\\\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \\\"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \\\"Milky Way\\\" there[[/labelnote]]?\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\\\'\\\'\\\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\\\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \\\"a blowjob and a Mars bar\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'une pipe et un mars\\\'\\\'\\\").
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
The phrase consists in the \"counter-request\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \"Milky Way\" there[[/labelnote]]?\" (\"\'\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\'\'\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \"a blowjob and a Mars bar\".
to:
* The phrase consists in the \\\"counter-request\\\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \\\"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \\\"Milky Way\\\" there[[/labelnote]]?\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\\\'\\\'\\\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\\\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \\\"a blowjob and a Mars bar\\\".
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
This is not an example from a specific work, but a real life stock phrase. I\'m asking to make sure \"In real life, [language X] has a stock phrase which is an example of the trope: [translation of said stock phrase]\" is considered as a valid example instead of something too generic.
to:
* This is not an example from a specific work, but a real life stock phrase. I\\\'m also asking to make sure \\\"In real life, [language X] has a stock phrase which is an example of the trope: [translation of said stock phrase]\\\" is considered as a valid example instead of something too generic.
Changed line(s) 3 from:
n
1) The phrase consists in the \"counter-request\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want something else along the first request.
to:
The phrase consists in the \\\"counter-request\\\" not being an absurd request by the second person, but is actually a snarky suggestion asking the first person if they want to up their request. this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \\\"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \\\"Milky Way\\\" there[[/labelnote]]?\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\\\'\\\'\\\"). This is also a sort of inversion, as the mock suggestion (some money and a candy bar) is relatively mundane. There\\\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \\\"a blowjob and a Mars bar\\\".
Changed line(s) 5 from:
n
2) This is not an example from a specific work, but a real life stock phrase. I\'m asking to make sure \"In real life, [language X] has a stock phrase which is an example of the trope: [translation of said stock phrase]\" is considered as a valid example instead of something too generic.

In case you\'re wondering, this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \"Milky Way\" there[[/labelnote]]?\" (\"\'\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\'\'\"). There\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \"a blowjob and a Mars bar\".
to:
This is not an example from a specific work, but a real life stock phrase. I\\\'m asking to make sure \\\"In real life, [language X] has a stock phrase which is an example of the trope: [translation of said stock phrase]\\\" is considered as a valid example instead of something too generic.
Changed line(s) 7 from:
n
In case you\'re wondering, this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar?\" (\"\'\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\'\'\"). There\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \"a blowjob and a Mars bar\".
to:
In case you\\\'re wondering, this is a French stock phrase which consists in answering an unreasonable demand by retorting \\\"do you also want 100 bucks and a Mars bar[[labelnote:For American readers]]Not the candy sold in the US under this name, but a similar treat renamed \\\"Milky Way\\\" there[[/labelnote]]?\\\" (\\\"\\\'\\\'tu veux pas non plus cent balles et un Mars?\\\'\\\'\\\"). There\\\'s a cruder variation which literally translates as \\\"a blowjob and a Mars bar\\\".
Top