Okay, here goes: The Joker is the ONLY outlier in the three movies where the antagonist wasn’t clearly stated to be a member of the League of Shadows. For some reason, he sets up shop in the only city to both have a strong mobster presence, and the world’s (Nolanverse) only vigilante with military grade hardware.
As pointed out on multiple occaisions, he really couldn't care less about money, and he does EXACTLY what Ra's Al Ghul did before, and what Bane / Talia would do later: try to destabilize Gotham.
The problem with the military theory is, even for personnel in top secret positions, their civilian identity doesn’t usually get scrubbed. Instead, it's their relationship with the branch of the military that’s kept secret. With this in mind, the Joker’s civilian identity would still come up in identity checks.
The only way to truly stay outside the system, is to never be part of it in the first place. Taking into account the Joker’s skill set, overall education, etc., the more effective explanation for all of his character attributes is that he was born outside the US within the League of Shadows.
They gave him the training for what he does in The Dark Knight.
Now, Ra's Al Ghul’s death doesn’t mean that much as far as the League of Shadows as an institution is concerned, but the destruction of their headquarters means a lot. That put the guy who would become the Joker without any governing body to report to. The infighting starts, and the proto-Joker stays loyal to Ra's Al Ghul’s faction, and as a result, gets captured by a splinter cell and tortured.
The movie even implies that the reason why someone like the Joker could come to power is because Batman messed with the status quo. And again, with Talia / Bane, their motivations are directly tied to Ra's’ death. Ras wouldn’t even allow Bane to stay in the League while he was alive.
The torture that Joker endured led to his injuries, and combined with his life of destabilizing countries, eventually he took this perspective to its extremes because it's all he knew. After he escaped, or the infighting allowed him to go free, he travels to Gotham. Becoming progressively more unhinged, on some level he planned on picking up where Ras left off.
...because the League of Shadows members are nothing if not ‘loyal to the cause...’
For an explanation as to why the Joker doesn’t say he was a League member:
- In the first and third movies, the only people who come out and say it are Ra's, Talia, and Bane. Their underlings won’t admit to it, even under interrogation.
- Since the Joker operates much like a lone wolf, only he would seriously know the answer to that question, so unless he opts to say it, all we have to go on are his tactics and goals.
It’s important to note: this movie is also the only installment to feature attack dogs. Specifically, “dogs off their leash,” which is an apt metaphor for what the Joker is quickly becoming. Losing his sense of self, and bearing, he develops an obsession with “The Batman” who sparked all the experiences that led the Joker to this new identity. He even goes so far as to explicitly say: “I’m a dog chasing cars.” ...which is usually what dogs do when their owner isn’t present.
After a string of “war fund collection” (bank robberies), he strong-arms the mobsters into cooperation. They fund his initial startup operations, while he builds a wildly corrupted League cell of psychos.
He figures out that Batman is Bruce Wayne as early as the fundraiser, because it's a Wayne-owned building without a Wayne present. However, upon realizing this, and seeing Batman’s reaction to Rachel falling out the window, he’s confronted with an idealist who doesn’t fit his world view. This causes a villainous BSOD, and causes him to leave the fundraiser immediately. Between this and realizing Batman is Bruce Wayne, he learned everything he needs to know. Disturbed by Bruce Wayne’s idealism, the Joker stops trying to kill him, and instead goes about trying to torture him into becoming another Joker-like killer.
It kind of creates a bit of irony here: the Joker does have rules, and those rules are “Chaos and pure self interest are the only things that make sense.” His obsession with Batman gets kicked into overdrive because he’s the antithesis of Joker’s sense of order.
He then sets about killing Bruce Wayne’s relationships. He never attacks Bruce Wayne directly, because he wants to change him, not kill him.
Bane alludes to this in the subsequent movie where he tells Wayne something along the lines of “only after you are utterly broken, will you have my permission to die.”
The Joker at this stage only really understands chaos, and his tactics reflect that. Instead of planning for everything to just work, he probably has piles of contingency plans. The issue here is all of his plans are purely destructive because the League of Shadows doesn’t actually do nation building.
When the Harvey prisoner transfer takes place, the Joker knows it's a trap, so he goes about using terror tactics, because that’s all he knows. His tactics, though, like taking down the helicopter... insurgents don’t usually have access to helicopters. The same thing goes for his rocket launcher. That type is a Warsaw Pact weapon. Again, something insurgents would use.
His captivity scenes are super important because he begins commenting on Batman’s amateurish approach to aggressive interrogations. Then, afterwards, his discussion with the lone guard about using cutting to a person’s real personality. This not only gruesomely highlights his own expertise, but is also a more likely reference to his scars at the hands of his torturers. It’s important to note here: he emphasizes this is when a person’s ‘real’ personality comes out. This implies the link between both his scars and his personality.
How the ‘Glasgow Smile’ actually became a thing in the real world, the victim usually has their face ‘cut enough,’ but not all the way through, so they can actually tear their own flesh by simply opening their mouth far enough (I bet you thought this theory would be lame). The victim is then tortured until they do a wide-mouth scream, causing the actual ‘smile.’
Once again, it reiterates: he definitely went through enough torture to go insane.
The medical horror doesn’t stop there. When he implants the bomb in the one prisoner, that’s also been done in the real world. This is usually an insurgent tactic, and not really a military tactic. Hence, he wasn’t ‘fighting for the good guys’ when learning how to do what he does. He even knows the blast won’t be big enough to do more than distract. ...much like similar real world attempts.
It’s important to note: he makes it clear that all the cops with mob ties are taking HIS orders. Once again: an expert on infiltrating governments, not insurgent cells.
Fast forward to the ‘soldier’ lecture with Harvey: the Joker isn’t talking about feeling abandoned getting ‘blown up.’ He’s talking about blowing up soldiers and realizing after the fact that it's a weak terror tactic. This matches the “Don't start with the head” advice he gives to Batman, and the “Knives show a person’s true personality” lecture to the cop.
Fast forward to the hostage scene at the end: the Joker knows the good guys are looking for weapons in hands, so he switches the appearances of the hostages and hostage takers.
By the time of the third movie, the reason we don’t hear mention of him in the third movie is Bane and Talia quietly take him out, because he would be too unreliable to include in their plans, and too dangerous to leave alive.
The Joker isn’t a “(maybe) good guy turned bad,” he’s the physical manifestation of the League of Shadows’ world view, and all the horrors it brings with it.
- Ra's Al Ghul could also be a codename.
- In the comics, the Lazarus Pit is synonymous with the League of Shadows. It's only fitting that Nolan and co. would rework it for the movies, which he did. In The Dark Knight Rises, the pit prison, located somewhere in, er, Morocco? Somewhere. In the second act, Bruce goes into the pit broken, and after his months-long physical and spiritual recovery, emerges restored, just like the mystical pool from the DC universe, minus the mysticism. There are references to Ra's al Ghul's metaphorical resurrection from the pit as well, in the form of Talia and Bane carrying on his legacy after climbing to freedom and Bruce's hallucinogenic meeting with Ra's himself.
- It explains Bane being older than he looks. If Bane was Talia's protector in the pit when Talia was a child, he had to be at least in his late teens, more likely his 20s, when she was born. Talia, meanwhile, looked only around 8 to 12 when she got out. This means that Bane likely had to be at least 30 before the League of Shadows got him out. This movie likely takes place 20 to 30 years after that, while Talia is in her 30s... Bane is probably between 50 and 60, but he's still capable of kicking huge amounts of ass. It's not impossible in real life, but it would have been seriously helped along by the Lazarus Pit, especially with that physique. As for the rest of the prisoners in the pit... Um... Maybe you specifically have to rise out of the pit to get its effects? To get the immortality offered by the pit, at least in the movie-verse, you may need to be strong enough in mind and body to rise.note
The reason he wears makeup is that he wants to mimic his REAL face on the face of the man he stole.
- This was either his real name, and he saw that it resembled "Joker", or he decided to change his original name to it (like Eddie Nashton -> Edward Nigma -> E.Nigma -> The Riddler). If he were caught, having a fake "real name" could cover for his actual name! Also, the J could stand for Jack, in reference to the last set of films.
And last but not least, the movie's trailers have a serious Occupy Gotham vibe. What was Ra's al Ghul's initial plan for destroying Gotham? Economics.
- Sort of. He's the new leader of the League of Shadows, and he's introduced as Ra's al Ghul's son. It turns out to be a Red Herring, though.
- Jossed
- Loosely confirmed. The Dark Knight Rises is an amalgam of The Dark Knight Returns with Knightfall and No Man's Land.
- I would like this far better than what happened to him in the comics.
- Jossed. We briefly learn that Gordon's wife left him and moved to Cleveland with their children after the events of The Dark Knight. Beyond this, Jimmy and the other Gordon children are never mentioned. It's implied that John "Robin" Blake will become Batman's successor.
- Though most of this remains to be seen, the part about the League of Shadows having leaders based in the Middle East is starting to seem very likely. Remember that Ominous Latin Chanting in the trailers that caught everyone's attention? That's not Latin— it's Moroccan Arabic.
- Confirmed. Ra's Al-Ghul was the leader, but his daughter took over after his death.
- His appearance in Part 3 would be a great way to bookend the series, and would probably occur just prior to the endgame, likely with something like "How many times do I have to tell you that Ra's al-Ghul is immortal?" and The Reveal that he's been manipulating things from behind the scenes throughout "The Dark Knight" and afterward, including the entire plot of the third movie which would come with its own false reveal.
- Confirmed?
- Not exactly, but close. His daughter took over the League of Shadows after he died. Also, Ra's did say something like the above statement to Bruce Wayne in a hallucination.
- Well, Ra's DID say "...if you make yourself more than just a man, if you devote yourself to an ideal, and if they can’t stop you, then you become something else entirely. (...) A legend, Mr. Wayne.". So in a sense, he is immortal simply because the League of Shadows exists, as it will always serve Ra's al Ghul's will.
- Yeah, but, he likes Maggie Gyllenhaal, so he can't be a troll.
- He held a knife against her cheek and blew her up. He was like "Hello, beautiful (lol jk chipmunkface)"
- This Troper is a geek, her sister refuses to read comics but will see the odd comic film. Coming out of the film, Troper and Troper's Sister were discussing Joker's makeup. Troper's Sister responded "He hasn't perfected putting it on yet." Then it hit me. There was no chemical spill, no tragic backstory... or we'd have seen one. This Joker is just a guy who decided to put on makeup and be a dick to Batman because he found it amusing.
- After he is crippled, the Batman mantle will be taken up by Jean-Paul Valley a.k.a. Azrael.
- And the movie will be titled Knightfall.
- Well, the third movie, The Dark Knight Rises, now stars Bane. And we all know what that means...
- This article makes a very good case as to why Nolan would do this.
- Half-right. Bane does break his back, but Bruce gets better.
- That's not WMG. That's just canon.
- I don't believe Harvey's dead. Just because of Rule Of He's Still Alive In The Comics.
- Then you should get used to Rule of Nolan's Movies Are Set On Their Own Free Continuity With Beginning Middle And End— Which Is TDKR.
Before you start to kill me, I've already run this by a friend who is cuckoo for comic puffs, and he agrees with it!
- Have you seen Mark Hamill do a live Joker laugh? Youtube it, it's frightening. It would WORK.
- I seriously think Mark Hamill could play him physically, just much older. Hell, if Heath Ledger could be made scary...
- We don't need Mark. Youtube. Joker Blogs. Search it NOW!
- Just get Cere Proc to replicate the voice like they did for Roger Ebert. Pouring a few million into perfecting a voice that doesn't have actually to be generated on the fly should do nicely. After that, it's all mo-cap.
- Two words: Harley Quinn.
- One problem: Nolan has said he "wouldn't be comfortable" with having the Joker in the next Batman film.
- Which he wasn't.
- There's even photographic evidence!
- Reconstructive Magic Plastic Surgery could account for the change of actor, and smoke damage could account for the change in voice. (Hey, if Futurama could do it...)
- This WMG would certainly explain Joker's absence in Rises. A standard asylum is nowhere near sufficient to hold a domestic terrorist.
- You have never read a comic book in your entire life, have you? The Joker ALWAYS pleads Insanity, and he ALWAYS gets it. Also, he did in-fact plead Not Guilty once, because he honestly didn't kill the person they said he did. This is how Batman knew he was telling the truth, and he begrudgingly set out to find who was trying to frame the Joker.
- I have read more comic books than it took to push the Flaming Carrot over the edge, and this is not about comics, this is about the realism the movies are trying to establish, and there is simply no way the Joker is making it to a third movie alive, he will either be executed or killed in prison. He's pissed off way too many people in that city to realistically be allowed to live.
- Actually (speaking as a psychologist) the Joker could, potentially, plead insanity; all he'd have to do is convince people that he legitimately did not know that what he was doing was wrong, OR that he was compelled to do it by his mental illness and had no way of resisting. It has been demonstrated in the films that Gotham is the type of town where "convincing" a jury is easy enough if you have enough money to go around... though in the Joker's case, that would probably be a lot of money. (Let's hope he didn't burn all of those millions of dollars, hm?)
- The thing is, though, the Joker wouldn't do that because he honestly doesn't think he's insane, he'd either plead guilty (because he's proud he did it) or not guilty (just for the fun of screwing with people during the proceedings).
- The Joker could be declared mentally incompetent and be slung in Arkham until he is found competent again. That's unlikely, though.
- He wouldn't be. He's legally a terrorist, and would be considered a federal-level criminal. Any evidence of bribery (and this trial would a case under national scrutiny) would get the case kicked up to a higher circuit court. In any realistic case he'd be in solitary for life, disappeared by Homeland Security, tortured in some Eastern European country, and detained somewhere, or put to death.
- Also, pleading insanity is actually very difficult.
- Joker from the comics always pleads insanity, but Ledger's Joker is different and more likely to plead guilty. His whole philosophy is based on the fact that he is willing to admit being a complete monster, unlike others who deny it.
- I have read more comic books than it took to push the Flaming Carrot over the edge, and this is not about comics, this is about the realism the movies are trying to establish, and there is simply no way the Joker is making it to a third movie alive, he will either be executed or killed in prison. He's pissed off way too many people in that city to realistically be allowed to live.
- Or they'll pull the whole "he's gone but we won't say why" option.
- Oh but he does act on this. Forcing Batman to kill the man who stole his gal, which would of course lead to him questioning his morals, and then the dilemma of "Am I killing Two-Face for being an evil bitch, or am I killing Harvey Dent for stealing my bitch?"
- Except that the Joker went out of his way to prevent the blackmailer from revealing who Batman is because he didn't want the secret spoiled. But that didn't mean he mightn't have suspected it. Yet as Lois Lane said as regards the Clark Kent/Superman thing when Supes revealed himself to her, "Suspecting something and believing it aren't necessarily the same thing."
- It's not about Batman the person, it's about Batman the symbol; if it got out that Bruce was Batman, the police would move in, and he'd be arrested. That would destroy the person, and leave the symbol intact. Also, it would shift the public's attention off the symbol and onto the person. Joker wanted to destroy the whole concept of Batman, not the person. He needed Batman as, for all intents and purposes, a separate entity from Bruce.
- Alternatively, there were no explosives on any of the boats. He expected both sets of passengers to use the detonators, and letting everyone live with that guilt probably seemed funnier to him than killing them.
- Alternatively, each detonator would blow up both boats. This would fit the Joker's personality even more.
- Or even the Joker didn't know which detonator did what.
- I do like the idea that the Joker intentionally stopped paying attention while constructing the detonators and setting the channels on the receivers.
- The best thing about all three detonators blowing up both boats is that the Joker's entire explanation would still have been true: Each captain's detonator would blow up the other boat (along with his own), and his own boat would not blow up at midnight (because it already would have blown up when his detonator was used). Sure, some information was left out, but nothing he said would actually have been false.
- His Exact Words were "If... one of you presses the button, I'll let that boat live". So it's not just an "at midnight" thing, it would be another technicality in the vein of "I didn't rig those charges".
- Or even the Joker didn't know which detonator did what.
- The detonators blow up something entirely random. They push the button, and the camera does a fast cut to something random exploding.
- Possibly the hospital.
- Or the yellow van.
- Maybe the detonators blow up THE JOKER!
- As I said on the Fridge Brilliance page or somewhere, the great thing about the situation is that there's no telling what would have happened. The Joker's extreme unpredictability is what makes him the bogeyman of even the most vastly superpowered fellow DCU supervillains.
- All three detonators only blow up the prisoners' boat. The Joker would get to tell the public that the civilians resorted to murder, no matter what the actual outcome was.
- The detonators were designed to just blow themselves up when activated. The batteries were just small batteries inside the cases of larger batteries, the rest of the cases' insides being some sort of blasting material. It would have the benefit of both Classic Joker's lethal pranks (in this case, an upgraded palm buzzer), and it would have the mark of (fandom's perception of) the TDK Joker by permanently branding those who made the morally wrong choice but letting them survive no matter what choice the other made. This also means it would have been obvious once the boats docked that it was the prison warden or officer or whatever who pressed the button, and not some sort of little uprising among the cuffed and shackled prisoners against the armed man surrounded by guards who got the detonator in the first place.
- Related to above. What reason does the Joker have to lie? The outcome as he's planned it is perfect one way or the other as he sees it. Either a whole bunch of civilians get blown up, in which case the prisoners or the boat staff would be blamed, or the boat full of civilians have just blown up an entire boat of other people, and the social experiment has proven that ordinary people are able to kill people if pushed too far, which is what the Joker already tried to prove with Two-Face and Batman himself. He has absolutely no reason for lying.
- He had no reason to lie about the respective locations of Rachel and Harvey Dent, and he also had no reason to lie about where his scars came from. He's a liar. The reason is that it amuses him. If it did exactly what he said it would do, it would be terrible, but everybody would have known what to expect. But if he was lying, then the thesis statement of the social experiment is still valid, but now, in addition, he has wrought even more chaos.
- He did have a reason to lie about where Rachel and Harvey were: namely, to fuck Batman's shit up. Imagine how Batman felt when he saw it was Harvey? Now imagine, he's up fighting the Joker, suddenly one of the boats explodes. The Joker leers at Batman, his twisted grin splitting his pale face. "You see, Bats, each boat had a detonator, and each group was told it would blow up the other boat. But really it blew up their own boat!" Batman: "..."
- This troper disagrees, the boat experiment really was about the people on the boat, not Batman. If he was successful, an entire boatful of people would have killed another boatful of people. That would have been a wonderful validation of the Joker's beliefs and ethos, and showed to a boatload of people how monstrous they really were. That's his philosophy as presented in the movie, to show how people really are when they're pressed. Allowing one boat to kill the other will show that sticking by "nobility" will get you killed by those who are more "honest." But having a boat's passengers blow themselves up would allow the surviving boat's crew to appear noble, uncorrupted, and rewarded for taking the high moral ground, just what the Joker despises. He lets those who have been corrupted and become raw and pure in his eyes to go, while killing those who resist baser instincts.
- This is one reason why he doesn't kill Harvey Dent in the hospital, because as Two-Face, Harvey is a pure expression of the true violent self we try to hide under a veneer of nobility. Releasing Dent will show the people in the city that even the noblest will turn to murder and hatred.
- New possibility. He did have a valid reason to lie. Because it's funny.
- He had no reason to lie about the respective locations of Rachel and Harvey Dent, and he also had no reason to lie about where his scars came from. He's a liar. The reason is that it amuses him. If it did exactly what he said it would do, it would be terrible, but everybody would have known what to expect. But if he was lying, then the thesis statement of the social experiment is still valid, but now, in addition, he has wrought even more chaos.
- After he was "saved" by Bruce Wayne from being killed, Reese decided to back off for awhile until the Joker situation is resolved or contained. Then he comes back to stalk Batman/Bruce Wayne. As we see in the film, Reese is interested in making money and is not happy when Bruce disagrees with Lau's proposal. He may or may not be aware that Lau was a criminal. In the second sequel, not only will he try to blackmail Bruce for money or he'll reveal his secret identity, but he'll also figure out what really happened to Harvey Dent. He'll learn that Batman, Gordon and the few cops are hiding the truth that Harvey killed people, thus threatening people's faith and hopes. Reese may also find out that Rachel chose Harvey and emotionally defeat Batman (temporarily). If Harvey DOES come back, then Reese will probably tell Harvey that Bruce is Batman and trick him into thinking he let Rachel die because if Bruce can't have her then no one can.
- The Nolanverse has stayed faithful to the comics as far as names go. Origins, not so much, but Riddler wouldn't be the same without the E. Nigma.
- If that were true, John Robin Blake would have been named Dick Grayson. This WMG is still valid until Jossed.
- The Nolanverse has stayed faithful to the comics as far as names go. Origins, not so much, but Riddler wouldn't be the same without the E. Nigma.
- It also makes sense because, in the story that part of the movie is based on, Harvey's wife survives, and she goes on a Roaring Rampage of Revenge because of what happened to him.
- Jossed; Selina Kyle is played by Anne Hathaway and is a separate character.
- And, at any rate, if Rachel Dawes survived, she'd probably be called Phantasm. "Bruce Wayne...your angel of death awaits."
- Yo, Elvis Bigfoot, son of Diana. :P
- The films with Nolan are going to end with three. Warner will almost certainly make more with someone else, hopefully not resulting in another Schumacher debacle.
- Schumacle?
- There are several directors that could make a good Batman film.
- If I recall correctly, back in the 90's Alex Proyas was considered because of his work on The Crow.
- Imagine giving the reigns to Joss Wheedon.
- Or someone like Tarsem Singh, especially after his work on The Cell, and The Fall.
- So when is New Line going to make Lord of the Rings 4?
- It comes out this Xmas, it's called the Hobbit. Same cast, crew, FX team, director.....
- Well, that's a limited literary adaptation, while Batman has over 60 years of comics and dozens of villains to draw on. And on a technical note to that claim, Observe!
- They're making a new movie for him in the new DCCU. Not canon with TDKS, though.
- To go even further, he made them specifically so he could tell people bull about how he got his scars.
- A theory flying about in Batman boards before the film came out was that the one scar was part of an accident or an attack and the other is self-inflicted, to even it up.
- This, plus the bullet theory from just below, is the most likely. Here are some high detail images of some "Heath Ledger as The Joker" action figures. The scar on the right cheek is clearly a carved smile, while the left cheek looks considerably messier. It actually looks like a hole instead of a cut.
- I'm thinking his origin will be based on The Killing Joke.
- I had a thought that Jack Napier had his face shot by a sniper, the bullet only hit the side of his face and blew up the cheeks. Think about it, why is it always a knife? A bullet can do the same thing.
- Well, you see, it's because it's organized crime.
- Nope, he goes after the mob because Batman is going after the mob.
- Vic Sage (The Question's secret identity) is a news anchor, that's what inspired this Wild Mass Guess. And Mike Engel was the news anchor who starred in the Gotham Tonight featurettes and appeared several times in the movie. Was hung upside down and read the Joker's threat? Played by Anthony Michael Hall? Any of this ringin' a bell?
- And, in the novel, both his cheeks are torn to pieces by the end. Hmmm...
- "You wanna know how I got these scars? I had a split personality, you see..."
- "And my alter ego looked like Brad Pitt and he was insane— he wanted to destroy the world. So I took a gun to my mouth to try to stop him. Instead, I became him. But I don't look like Brad Pitt— why can't I look like Brad Pitt? If I am him, then I should look like him, right? Then why do I look like this?"
- "You wanna know how I got these scars? I had a split personality, you see..."
- Would the logical conclusion be that Joker is the way older Calvin?
- NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! NO! NONONONONO! *whimper* ...
- Considering The Joker's M.O. and Calvinball, this seems quite likely...
- NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! NO! NONONONONO! *whimper* ...
- He and Joker also share a taste for being hit, and laughing manically while this is happening.
- Also, the Narrator is sometimes referred to as "Jack". It's unclear how canonical this is, but the Tim Burton films do have that as the Joker's real name...
- This means that every scene in which the Joker and Batman are together it is within Batman's mind. When he beats the shit out of the Joker in the interrogation, it is in fact the Joker beating himself up. He's the only one that doesn't understand that he has a split personality. Batman never goes to find Rachel in the warehouse, he understands what will happen and imagines it because he is the Joker.
- The fight scene at the end is his internal conflict being resolved.
- The scars? Make up. Prosthetics. Heath Ledger pulled it off, why not Bruce Wayne?
- Bruce kills Rachel because he has come to despise her.
- He kills the innocents of Gotham because he realizes that they resent him and he's returning the favor.
- He drives Harvey insane because he stole Rachel.
- He can never get his story right because he's making it up as he goes along.
- Did you see I'm Not There? Batman and The Joker are the same man, and his name is Bob Dylan!
- A new, unrepentantly evil and extremely dangerous criminal appears, who only Batman can deal with. He tortures and kills the people who impersonate Batman, the people of Gotham (who no longer need Batman), and the legal system that is replacing Batman.
- Lucius, Bruce's only close companion and parent substitute, is close to perfect— competent at everything, very wise and incorruptible.
- Rachel dies for choosing a relationship with another man over waiting for him.
- Harvey, who stole both Rachel and Batman's reason for existing, loses Rachel, suffers horribly, proves not to have the moral fortitude to deal with her death without turning evil (unlike Bruce), and is killed by Batman.
- Tellingly, by the end of the film, nearly every single protagonist in the film who's not entirely a Red Shirt has been forced to choose between their loved ones and doing the right thing, just as Bruce is being forced to choose between honouring his parents' memory by continuing to be Batman and doing the right thing and gracefully retiring as the now unnecessary Batman.
I know it's part of the mystery of the character, but Two-Face and Batman and Scarecrow got histories, so why not the Joker? Even he can't get his own history straight with his "Why So Serious?" tales that change every time he tells it. Either he is that much of a psychopath or he doesn't have a history at all.
- For a similar idea, one could say that Randall Flagg of The Stand and The Dark Tower series is the Joker— both are surprisingly charismatic for being violently insane, scarily competent with evil, ambiguous in history, and both are servants of chaos and destruction.
- Maybe the thief in Alfred's story was the same demon?
- Joker is one of the Masks of Nyarlathotep. He even calls himself an avatar of chaos— not far from that to the Crawling Chaos.
- The Joker really is an agent of Chaos, specifically Tzeenetch. Sure, he says he's not a schemer, but that's exactly what a real schemer would want you to think.
- Demonic Possession has become nearly a Dead Horse Trope. Its modern equivalent is Alien Abduction. The Joker is...really an alien!
- He's not just a demon, but Satan. Think about it: traditionally, Christians consider Satan to be a force of pure evil, and the Joker is all about chaos. Much of what Satan does seems less "Screw you YHWH!" and more being evil for its own sake. Satan is often considered to be a Card-Carrying Villain, much like the Joker. Being God's former's prosecutor, Satan believes we'll abandon our morals when hardship hits-the logic behind the "social experiment" of the Joker.
- If God really did send down the Joker just to butcher massive amounts of people purely as a test of faith, then he's an asshole.
- "Wanna know how I got these scars? Well, there was this time I wagered my head to a bunch of dwarves..."
- It makes so much sense! D: He went Crazy after he was impregnated by the horse and his brother used his eight legged demon horse son as a steed!
- ...He likes dragons, and tattoos?
- Gordon says that the Joker has no fingerprints. Yakuza members burn their fingertips to achieve this.
- He's that guy from Ichi the Killer?
- That guy DOES have vibrant hair and a purple longcoat...
- "Greetings and Salutations Commissioner..."
- !!!!! This awesome theory wins 150 Internet Points!
- He accidentally killed J.D in a prank gone wrong. Instead of admitting his guilt, he convinced himself it was part of the joke.
- (Summons army of squirrels)"Why so serious?"
- So does this mean Squirrel Girl is the Joker's daughter? (5th and 7th entries)
- Heath Ledger's Joker appears to have pain when Batman interrogates him, but continues to act all-powerful, anyway. That pause before he says "see?' is telling.
- That could easily have been the Joker checking to see if his jaw or teeth were broken, or his lips had split. And remember, Batman went for the head first, so Joker was "all fuzzy."
- Oooor maybe he's a run of the mill sadomasochist? I always assumed he got pleasure out of the pain or some such.
- That could easily have been the Joker checking to see if his jaw or teeth were broken, or his lips had split. And remember, Batman went for the head first, so Joker was "all fuzzy."
- Maybe he had some mooks with medical training? But that's actually a really cool idea. Explains why he's so damn good at finding inventive ways to hurt people. Though the Joker as a funeral home director would just scare the crap out of me.
- If you combine this WMG with the WMG that the Joker is a doctor of some sort, it can only mean one thing. The Joker is really House!
- Nolanverse Bane has had his Venom replaced with aerosol painkillers, so this looks more likely now...
- Lau was his last name. Note how Lucius calls him "Mr. Lau."
- Hmmm... a gangster with a daughter, who's murdered by another gangster? In a Demythified Batman setting that could always use a non-Batgirl-or-Robin sidekick? Huntress.
- Daughter named Sandra? Possibly short for...Cassandra?
- Moreover, he will program it into attack drones and set it to monitor his own actions, to destroy him if he goes too far.
- He'll rebuilt it in the cave(WITH A BUNCH OF SCRAPS) under his still-being-rebuild mansion. Can anyone say, Batcomputer?
- When this troper saw TDK for the first time, exposure to the 60's cartoon series from a young age made me sure the sonar rig would be the Batcomputer. Hoping for future rights to say I Knew It!!
- Some people figure that similar motivations were behind Michael Jackson's recent death.
- He did appear in one more movie, but was unable to finish filming due to, well, dying. I believe it's called the Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus, though I might be wrong.
- Knowing what the last "magic trick" he did as The Joker was like, I think we can feel grateful we were spared another one.
- That's probably one of his reasons, yes.
- The Corinthian would be all over that. Admit it. Like the Corinthian, who presumably doesn't leave fingerprints or physical evidence besides his victims (mutilated in his calling-card fashion), the Joker can only be tracked by the trail of damage he leaves. They would
so get it onget along like a house on fire.
- Hmmm, it does sometimes sound like he's hiding SOME kind of accent.
- Like maybe an antiquated Connecticut or colonial Westchester accent?
- And scarecrows aren't exactly used in cities.
- In this troper's personal continuity, Crane is so a former country boy. Something about his demeanor...
- Anyone who likes this idea may enjoy the Year One: Scarecrow comic.
- Maybe the toxin really only works on human brain chemistry, and the whole "effects all living things" was just a lie or mistake?
- Still wouldn't change the fact that all the chaos in the streets would spook a horse. Gunfire, screams... I mean the sheer would set a horse off. trust me, I know. Horses a jumpy little bitches.
- Maybe the toxin really only works on human brain chemistry, and the whole "effects all living things" was just a lie or mistake?
- Or in a little different possibility she resigns/is expelled from the police force after the events and still will try to atone for what she did. Becoming eventually the Question. (Being the successor of this universe version Vic is a possibility...)
- What about introducing Montoya herself? The villain(s) in the third movie will have to be incredibly hardcore, so Batman could use some more allies. Montoya is such a complex character in her own right that the movie wouldn't even need to show her becoming the Question (another masked hero might take the focus off Batman, and the poor dear needs his franchise back after the Joker took over...) but a few suble in-jokes that reference her future and appease the comic fans couldn't hurt.
- Interesting as this idea would be, it's possible that Ramirez died off-screen. At the end of The Dark Knight, Gordon mentions that Two-Face killed five people, two of whom were cops. The only cops Two-Face was shown interacting with were Gordon, who he obviously didn't kill; Wuerzt, who he killed; and Ramirez, who he decided to spare, but knocked out with a Tap on the Head before he left. Apparently, in spite of what Harvey intended, the blow was fatal.
- Gordon doesn't say Two-Face killed five people; he said "5 dead, 2 of 'em cops, you can't sweep this up." Wuertz, Moroni, Moroni's driver, the cop that was killed in the hospital (Gordon wouldn't be able to pin it on the Joker because as far as the GPD is concerned, the Hannibal Lecture never happened) and Harvey himself (though as some would say, not necessarily Two-Face).
- Ramirez was clearly just an Expy of Montoya to begin with anyway, so who knows?
- The problem from a fandom point of view that Montoya is incredibly upstanding, so Ramirez could never be a true Expy beyond the fact that she's a hispanic cop who Gordon likes. Montoya had the opportunity to kill someone who she knew absolutely, with incontrivertable proof and a practica confession, had killed her partner, but she still couldn't do it because it was wrong. Montoya isn't someone who could sell out like Ramirez did. If Ramirez really did become explictly a Montoya clone then the fans of Montoya and the Question would go nuts (I might not be a traditional fanboy, but for me this would be the one step too far over the line for the Nolanverse.)
- Maybe the very same Lambourghini he raced to the scene in during that very same sequence?
Admittedly, this is mostly wishful thinking cuz I love the classic Batmobile look, but a Troper can hope, can't he?
- Yes he can. Imagine how great the trailer for the 3rd movie could be with a straight-up honest-to-God Batmobile.
- That means, he'll have to find a mechanic who can build a new stylistic Batmobile. Maybe an old friend of Lucius Fox.
- Yeah! A mute, hunchbacked, homeless friend of Lucius Fox. Named Ed.
- ...What.
- It's a reference to a rather unknown (by the public) character from the Bat-comics by the name of Harold, who was a mute, hunchbacked social outcast that happened to be very good with electronics and engineering. He worked on several upgrades for the Batmobile and outfitted the Bat-cave with various security devices. The average Bat-comic reader that didn't grow up in the nineties will most likely remember him as the C-List Fodder guy that got shot near the end of the "Hush" arc.
- That means, he'll have to find a mechanic who can build a new stylistic Batmobile. Maybe an old friend of Lucius Fox.
- Jossed. He uses the tumbler again in the third movie.
- Not to mention all the mob bosses that were killed in the cross-fire: Sal Maroni, Gamble, and the Chechen with the dogs. And, half of the mob's funds went up in flames thanks to the Joker, and Mr. Lau, the mob's last resort for laundering their money, is dead.
- Essentially confirmed. Gotham's streets are fairly safe at the beginning of DKR.
- Remember, also, that comics canon states that Barbara is actually Gordon's niece and that she is adopted. Can we say "abandonment complex driving her to seek approval"? Yes, we can.
- That's who'll show up in the later movie(s). It may or may not be a different person each time.
- Joker is Gotham's Anonymous.
- So the Joker is yet another Stand Alone Complex.
- Copycats? Maybe we'll get Jokerz in the next film.
- On a Meta level, this has turned into Harsher in Hindsight after what happened in Aurora.
- But how does that explain the visible white makeup residue on his hands during the hospital scene?
- I got news for you. This ain't make-up!
- Of course!
- And his first victim was the Kite-Eating-Tree.
- Either that, or a bad line drive.
- Barbara (his wife) finds out and thinks James is having an affair. So she leaves him, taking her son with her while their daughter stays. Maybe the real reason is the stress of keeping the truth about Two-Face a secret and believes Gotham City isn't safe for anyone anymore.
- Or, Ramirez is Gordon's daughter. Hence the look about her mother. Leaves some interesting possibilities open, doesn't it?
- Did you read my story?
- Confirmed.
- And what if Hannibal Lecter had an older brother?
- The Fireflys?
- Maybe Wednesday had a child.
- That's actually a good idea. It could be a symptom of the Joker's insanity. After all, the also insane Deadpool knows that he is in a comic book
- (1) That's not what "ironic" means. (2) It was never established that Carmine Falcone was responsible for creating Batman. Chill was operating on his own. Falcone just happened to share a cell with him afterward.
- Actually, Carmine gave a rather stirring speech ("You always fear what you don't understand") to Bruce just moments before he took off on his seven year journey, so it's hard to argue that he didn't have a major role in creating Batman (and thus causing his own eventual downfall).
- Only she didn't know. That's precisely the point of the dialog between her and Harvey before Batman arrives: we see that she's really convinced that Bruce will come for her (like he would have if the Joker didn't lie to him) and she's trying to help by asking him if he can somehow save himself because she thinks it's the only chance he has. She says she accepts to marry him because she thinks it's the last chance she has to do so before HE dies (in a way it would have been cruel if she knew she was going to blow up and leave him behind). And the expression on her face when she hears Harvey yell at Batman on the other side of the line is sheer surprise. That's why this scene is so poignant, we really believe that Batman will save Rachel and so does she.
- Loosely confirmed. The city used Harvey's death to pass the "Dent Act" which gave more power to the police against organized crime, and they were all but gone by the beginning of TDKR
- "Why couldn't you save me?"
- Jossed
- Probably to try something different from the established comic book mythos, Robin will not be Dick Grayson. Instead, it will be either Jason Todd (a street orphan whose circus acrobat parents were killed by the main villain) or Tim Drake (Batman fan who needs his help to find his kidnapped parents).
- Confirmed! It borrows directly and frequently from 'Returns and Knightfall.
~Most of Batman Begins, all the way up until Ras Al' Ghul meets his demise on the train.~The beginning of Batman (1989 film), up until the Jack Naiper becomes the Joker.
~The final scenes of Batman Begins.
~The rest of Batman (1989) stop just before Joker kidnaps Vicki Vale
~The Dark Knight
~The end of Batman (1989), with the Joker kidnapping Vicki and eventually falling to his death.
~The rest of the Batman films (from Batman Returns to Batman and Robin)
~Birds of Prey the TV series would take place next, in the future.
As for the Catwoman film, I haven't seen it, but I know that it doesn't star Selina Kyle like Batman Returns does, so who knows. I guess it could fit in at some point before Birds of Prey TV series. So yeah...
- And the burned-out part of the Narrows is rebuilt and nicknamed "New Gotham", thus fitting the BOP continuity.
- It actually doesn't make sense. In the Nolanverse, Bruce KNEW and SAW that Joe Chill killed his parents. There's no such "Jack Napier" in the scene. Plus, we all know that Bruce's one true love is Rachel. So...he is swinging to Vicki Vale all along? And why would he downgrade his suit from that in Batman Begins to that in Batman (considering the armor didn't take tangible damage)? Try to explain how Napier's boss will fill in when you realize that the underground crime of Gotham is run by Falcone (even before Bruce's parents died) THEN Maroni. This WMG is the least plausible among the list.
- This troper thinks this idea is still cool and could work. You just have to remove Harvey Dent's presence at the end of Batman and change the news report about Harvey Dent early in Batman Forever. In fact, an early script of the 1989 film included Bruce being trained by Henri Drucard and Gordon consoling young Bruce. For more ideas for your timeline, check out this site, it includes profiles on characters from the Tim Burton/Schumacher films and notes from scripts. This troper is also doing something similar, like having Harvey Dent in Batman Returns as in the original script and changing Batman Forever, Batman and Robin, and Catwoman to fit the style of the first two movies, and the canceled Batman Triumphant would follow.
- With the latest film out, this idea is 100% jossed.
- It actually doesn't make sense. In the Nolanverse, Bruce KNEW and SAW that Joe Chill killed his parents. There's no such "Jack Napier" in the scene. Plus, we all know that Bruce's one true love is Rachel. So...he is swinging to Vicki Vale all along? And why would he downgrade his suit from that in Batman Begins to that in Batman (considering the armor didn't take tangible damage)? Try to explain how Napier's boss will fill in when you realize that the underground crime of Gotham is run by Falcone (even before Bruce's parents died) THEN Maroni. This WMG is the least plausible among the list.
Super Villains.
Think of it a as sort of non super power Meta Origin to batman's growing Rogues Gallery. when someone stress in Gotham there's a very real chance they flip out put on a absurd outfit and blow up a bank because their brain are chemically wired that way. A Crime Related Mental Disorder if you will.
Now this is speculation admittedly but it helps explain the rather odd actions of many characters in The Dark Knight. Such as why Harvey Dent (an upstanding DA, vowed to protect and serve) after a tragedy and injury quickly becomes little better (or gimmicky) than the psychos he puts away. why the Batman inspired vigilantes think they can fight crime wearing Hockey pads. As well as How the joker can easily recruit people for his anarchy. The man's violently insane and offers nothing buta war with the police. However In the mind of the average Gotham street gangster this doesn't seem like a bad idea because basically they're high with him around him.hell the Joker suggest this with his last lines.
Insanity is a lot like gravity, all it takes is a little push.
The Riddler vs. The Penguin in a gang war. Call them something a little less Batman-camp but make it fairly thinly veiled. Batman has to clean up the streets with his growly voice of doom.
Ferris hasn't learned anything, though, and continues to fuck around and cause trouble, and his father takes to the bottle to cope, and as the problem continues to fester unchecked, he becomes abusive, while the "maturing" Ferris starts to become a juvenile criminal of a much stickier kind than he was in the past (gets into fights and starts ransacking people's homes, in other words worse stuff than abusing his friends' trust and wasting their time). This culminates in the "Why so serious" scene which Joker relates to Gambol how he got those scars. Ferris' life goes downhill from there pretty fast.
- Let's just hope Sloane wasn't his "beautiful wife"
- And she takes up the mantle of The Phantasm.
- Jossed. It's Bane time.
- Also explains why he doesn't have fingerprints or any other form of identification.
- Iron Man 2 wasn't as good as the first one. Not by a long shot.
- Captain America ended up being the one to break the curse.
- Jossed
Alfred aproches Bruce, who is talking to Daniel Craig in a tuxDo you need something Master Wayne
No Alfred, Thank you.
And you Mr...
James Bond, good to see that the boys are getting original, Mr Craig.
Or add a reveal that M was Alfred's Bond Girl.
- Which would make Lucius Q. Suddenly it all adds up....
- Funny, because Michael Caine was actually considered for the role of Bond after Connery left the franchise, though he turned it down.
- But wasn't the Butler family tradition specifically relating to the Fowls?
- Nope, it's just as dark or DARKER than the second film.
- Not necessarily. That's up to the viewer to decide. The Dark Knight has a real Downer Ending. In TDK, the Joker technically wins (Batman breaks his rule, albeit, accidentally), Commissioner Gordon has to perpetuate a lie to keep his city safe, the main love interest is brutally murdered, Gotham's white knight is broken and killed and the dark knight is forced into hiding. 'Rises ends on a much more optimistic note.
- In any case, The Dark Knight Rises was lighter as far as photography was concerned.
- All of Batman's confrontations with the Joker in The Dark Knight take place at night or a dimly-lit room, except for part of the interrogation. The final fight with Bane occurs outdoors in bright sunshine.
- Jossed. The love interest is Catwoman.
Clearly, sometime after the end of Following, Cobb manages to tick off the wrong mobster and gets a permanent smile put on his face. He flees to the US, but the damage is already done. Cobb gains a thorough hatred of organized crime, and changes his personal philosophy from sociopathic hedonism to something worse. Finally, a combination of Batman's example and exposure to Crane's fear toxin inspires him to be reborn as Batman's opposite, a clown and an avatar of chaos.
- Also, the Mystery Man from David Lynch's Lost Highway is an aged Joker, probably twenty years or so after the Batman continuity.
On the inmate's boat, the guy with the detonator let the prisoner take it fully expecting that he was going to blow up the other boat. He wanted to, but he couldn't stand the thought of having to face judgement for doing it himself. Again, it was dumb luck that the prisoner was a good enough person to throw it overboard- or perhaps he wasn't, maybe he was a sadist who was intentionally trying to get them all killed.
In either case, the Joker was right about the ugly face of humanity. He just overestimated their survival instinct.
- I agree. The problem with the Joker's last experiment is that being in a crowd defused everyone's sense of responsibility. ("Somebody else can detonate the other boat.") If they had to take action to stop the other boat from blowing up, but passivity would have saved them, the Joker's plan might have worked!
- Then again, the choices were "let one boat full of people die, or let two boats full of people die", the difference being that choosing to destroy the other boat and doing so before the other boat could destroy them would have guaranteed their lives, but letting the other boat make the choice would have made it a gamble of unknown odds (a more complex version of the Prisoner's Dilemma) on whether the other boat would have killed them or two boats full of good/cowardy people would have died.
- I see it possible that some people on the boat were like the ones at the beginning of this page and thought the explosions wouldn't necessarily blow up the other ship but themselves, or maybe something different like an orphanage.
- I think Joker really was pissed at Batman for slamming his head into the table in the interrogation room. Not for the pain, but because he thinks Batman is above being that crude and unsubtle. In other words if the Goddamn Batman is going to go bad cop on you, you expect something a little more then just a bang on the head.
- I think he meant it when he told Batman that he thought Batman letting Dent take the fall as the Batman was cold, even for him.
- I think he was honestly impressed at Dent's plan to let him live or die based on the flip of a coin. For a guy as far our as the Joker, it probably does impress him to be put into a situation that is out there even for him.
- I think he was being purely matter of factual when he response to an outraged mobster asking "Do you think you can steal from us!" with a simple, direct, deadpan "Yeah."
- Harvey was much more insane than the Joker. The Joker knows he is messed up, that itself is lucidity manifested, while harvey just left everything to a coin.
- Lau is The Calculator.
- The Scary Black Man on the boat is Killer Croc.
- The boat prisoner certainly resembles the alternative version of Croc seen in Azrello's "Joker" comic.
- The Jumpy Thug at the dock is an obscure one-off thug named Bigger Melvin.
- The Gotham Bank Manager is the Penny Plunderer.
- The mental patient that Harvey Dent intimidates (Thomas Schiff) is the Mad Hatter.
- Rachel Dawes is Julie Madison.
- Mr. Earle is an expy of Max Shrek.
- As said above, the blonde boy in Begins is Jason Todd.
- Gambol is Carlton Duquesne.
- Alternatively, Gambol is King of the Royal Flush Gang
- Or Rupert Thorne
- The fat prisoner with the cell phone in his chest is Humpty-Dumpty.
- The news anchor Mike Engel is Jack Ryder, minus the Creeper alter-ego.
- Or as suggested above, he's Vic Sage, the original Question.
- As suggested above, Mr. Reese (Mysteries) is the Riddler.
- John Daggett is Roland Daggett.
- Phillip Stryver is Germs.
- Bane, with his nifty life support system, is a semi-expy of Mr. Freeze
- Bane's unnamed Dragon could be seen as Deadshot, since he manages to hold the police off with nothing but a Sniper gun and a damn good aim.
- It was THE JOKER who carved his mother with a knife, and "put a smile on that face" for his father.
- Likewise, it was the Joker who got in deep with the Sharks and gets his trademark grin from them (or maybe one half, and the other was self-inflicted). His wife's "leaving" may have been literal, figurative, or both on separate occasions.
- Had he been able to tell Batman another story, we would have had another wrinkle in the tale.
- Because his name is Leonard and he thinks Batman is his new "John G".
- More or less jossed, as he isn't in the third movie.
- Interestingly, he was going to be the main villain before Nolan decided to go with Bane.
- No Name Given
- The bullet wound Norton's character self-inflicts at the end of Fight Club is consistent with the Joker's scar.
- After leading a revolution and blowing up those buildings, the character got a taste for anarchy maybe after running from law enforcement.
- A tragedy involving Marla could send him totally over the deep end.
- He already has problems with sanity. Maybe Tyler came back with a vengeance and obliterated everything else in his head.
- The Joker's and Tyler's knowledge of chemistry and tendencies toward being Crazy-Prepared are consistent.
- Jossed. It ends with Bruce "dying" and retiring form Batman. Robin is introduced to be the detective Batman worked with during the movie and takes up the role of Gotham's vigilante
- If it's not bad enough, the dream will end with Rachel screaming that she doesn't love Bruce anymore, that she chose to marry Harvey Dent. This will linger on his mind, and will tell Alfred if Rachel ever said anything to him the night of her death. He'll noticed Alfred seem hesitant at first before he said no. Later he'll tell him to come clean about the letter he burned. Bruce will understandably be upset at not only Rachel's decision, but for Alfred breaking his trust. Eventually, Bruce forgives him.
- Jossed
- It would be a nice way to bookend the series. And besides, Scarecrow is actually just as scary as the Joker when you sit there and think about it. Fear toxin in the air vents of City Hall or the police department could wreak havoc in seconds, assuming people aren't already innoculated after the events of Batman Begins. And Nolan obviously loves the idea of foils, and Scarecrow wasn't fully explored as a character, and therefore his role as a foil wasn't fully realized. (Batman uses fear as a means to an end, for Scarecrow fear is the end, Batman chose bats because they scare him, Scarecrow chose a scarecrow because it scares what scares him, etc ...)
- Jossed. It's Bane time.
- He does appear though.
- "Ever danced with the devil in the pale moon light?"
- This fits in with the first one, which had many allusions to the story of [[Faust]]. Just like Dr. Faust, Bruce Wayne is a dissatisfied intellectual who yearns for more than his social standing can give him. It's at this critical time that Ra's Al Ghul comes in and offers Bruce the chance to become a legend, just like Mephistopheles. Another parallel includes Bruce's relationship with Rachel, whose innocence stands as potential collateral damage for Bruce's vigilantism. And like later interpretations of the Faustian legend, Bruce ultimately rejects Rha's deceptions and strives for the greater good. And to top it all off? The play that the Waynes go to see on the night of their murder is Arrigo Boito's ''Mefistofele'', a retelling of Faust. This just leaves the question: which gothic pseudo-Christian myth involving the devil will The Dark Knight Rises be based on? Dante's Inferno?
- Confirmed.
- He sort of is, although Talia turns out to be the mastermind.
- Jossed. She wasn't in TDKR
- If you're going after the man who killed your father and destroyed everything he built, the first thing you want to do (as a Criminal Mastermind) is destroy everything his father built. What better way to begin than by getting yourself on the board of his father's company? It's all a cunning scheme to destroy the Wayne Foundation (or its movie universe equivalent). "Tate" could even be a deliberate misspelling of "Tete", the French for "head" (Talia's alias when she went corporate in the comics).
- Think about the name Miranda for a second. The most famous Miranda is the one from Shakespeare's the Tempest, the daughter of the aging wizard Prospero, who lived in sheltered isolation under her father's care, growing dependent on him even as he plots against a world that wrong him. Sounds a lot like Talia and her dad. The only other people Miranda encountered before the shipwreck that kicks off the story are the brutish yet cunning Caliban, who grew up in isolation on this prison island, and the graceful spirit Ariel. Caliban sounds ALOT like Bane, and Aerial's grace and femininity (though originally male, Ariel is usually depicted as female in modern stagings) recalls Catwoman. Ariel even comes from the Hebrew words for "Lion of the Lord." What are three of the major themes of the Tempest? Theatricality ("all the world's a stage"), change, and knowing when it's time to step down.
- Actually, "All the world's a stage..." was from As You Like It. But other than that...wow. That's one of the best theories about Miranda I've seen so far.
- Confirmed. Miranda is Talia, who is Bane's lover and co-conspirator.
- Think about the name Miranda for a second. The most famous Miranda is the one from Shakespeare's the Tempest, the daughter of the aging wizard Prospero, who lived in sheltered isolation under her father's care, growing dependent on him even as he plots against a world that wrong him. Sounds a lot like Talia and her dad. The only other people Miranda encountered before the shipwreck that kicks off the story are the brutish yet cunning Caliban, who grew up in isolation on this prison island, and the graceful spirit Ariel. Caliban sounds ALOT like Bane, and Aerial's grace and femininity (though originally male, Ariel is usually depicted as female in modern stagings) recalls Catwoman. Ariel even comes from the Hebrew words for "Lion of the Lord." What are three of the major themes of the Tempest? Theatricality ("all the world's a stage"), change, and knowing when it's time to step down.
- Not to mention Harvey refused to take painkillers. He was literally in a lot of pain only being able to move thanks to his insanity.
- So little baby Jamie Wilkerson grows up to be The Joker then, since Malcolm in the Middle ended it's run before Jamie was given a real personality.
- Alan Moore wrote The Killing Joke, and breaking legs won't really cripple you for life, unless you really destroy them. It's spinal cord injuries that cause that kind of damage - that's what Barbara Gordon and Batman both suffered.
- My points still stand.
- Unlike Barbara.
- Zing!
- Nope. It's an amalgam of Knightfall, The Dark Knight Returns, and No Man's Land.
- Except he's inhumanly strong in the film. He's able to absorb blow after blow from Batman without much to show for it. Most likely it's just to make him more realistic.
- Maybe the Joker just didn't get around to using his Joker gas yet....
- For the most part, confirmed - Bane has Charles Atlas Superstrength, and the gas is instead a painkiller.
- Jossed by The Dark Knight Rises Talia is the daughter of Ra's Al-Ghul. Zig zagged in that while they're still different characters, both Bane and her desire to "fullfill his destiny".
- Not necessarily Jossed, just not acted upon. If Ra's Al-Ghul is a male name, Talia had adequate reason not to adopt it like her father did. Her own successor might still opt to do so, assuming the League of Shadows wasn't completely wiped out in Rises.
- Possibly Jossed. The other cop might have been then one Joker shot outside of Harvey's hospital room.
- Also, Harvey was a lawyer, not a cop.
- Suggested at least by the trailer, which features Gordon in the hospital. Hmm....
- Jossed. There's a direct recreation of the back break from Knightfall
- Nope, he succeeds.
- Jossed. It was one of Bane's henchmen.
- 1. Jack Napier lives a pathetic life in the Narrows. You can have a small look at it in Batman Begins, where you can hear a woman screaming at a man to get a job. That is because Napier just got
- 2. He decides to join the mob as a small-time gangster in order to feed his pregnant wife. Their target for a robbing is going to be the plant he worked at, as such, he will go there as the "Red Hood.".
- 3. He learns that his wife has been killed in a household accident involving an oven fire. This is what happens to Rachel in the Dark Knight. He tries to weasel out, but the mob forces his hand.
- 4. The heist at the plant goes awry - in an act of revenge, one of the criminals take out a knife and sticks the blade in his mouth, creating the smile the Joker is famous for.
- 5. The police arrives - The Joker, the last man of the team, is scared out of his mind and makes a run for it. He escapes by jumping in a polluted river, which turns his hair a sickly shade of brown/green.
- 6. Once he comes out of the water, he runs to a nearby bar and goes for the bathrooms. There, he looks at himself in the mirror. The pollution has changed the color of his hair; over his face is some sort of white substance, similar to the one found inside lightbulbs, his eyesockets are dark because he has not slept in days, and finally, his mouth and lips are bright red due to the blood still coming out from his fresh wounds. Mr. J hides in a corner and starts chuckling.
- The owners of the bar find him there, and, unable to get any info out of him, decide to have him placed in Arkham. He does not stay there for long, though, and is out in the open in the finale of Batman Begins.
- There's been theories floating around that Dick may very well be in the movie, just not at Robin yet. The big idea is that Bruce adopts him after his parents are killed in one of Bane's attacks.
- ...The whole point of custom made clothes is that you can ask a tailor for whatever you want and as long as you have enough money they'll make it without asking questions.
- But Alfred said he was in Burma, not Borneo.
Harry was probably friends of someone in the Wayne family (either Bruce s grandfather or one of his uncles) due to Wayne Corps military interests (which have included British special ops or MI5). At some unseen point Harry was named as infant Bruce's godfather. And at some other point Harry took the job as the Wayne butler simply because he was starting to get bored with his retired life.
After the death of Bruce's parents however Harry's role as godparent and caregiver became more serious. So throughout Bruce's bodyguard as well as Manny (Man Nanny).
- Confirmed.
- Ra's al-Ghul who turns out to be either somehow alive or immortal, maybe?
- Alternatively, Bane was Ra's dragon, but was Dragon His Feet in Begins and has since become a Dragon Ascendant. In the comics, Bane was Ras' second choice for heir to the League of Shadows after Bats turned him down. Maybe the same thing happened here, only off screen.
- Talia is a strong candidate for being revealed as The Man Behind the Man.
- Confirmed.
- Jossed. She's actually Talia al-Ghul using an alias.
- It also makes sense, because those three themes are also aspects of Batman: a self-appointed vigilante who terrorizes criminals has to walk a fine line if he doesn't want to give into madness (the chaos of DK), to overcome his own fears (as in Begins), or become a self-righteous, solipsistic tool(in this hypothetical version of DKR).
- Confirmed, possibly, by this new trailer. At the beginning of their underground/Batcave brawl, Bane addresses "Mr Wayne".
- I was almost right, Bane does know Batman's identity but doesn't go after him, Batman goes after Bane and gets the ever living crap out of him but just in his own base.
- It is Marion Cotillard. Looks just like her, because it is her.
- It looks vaguely like Marion.
- Same highly distinctive sleepy eyes and prominent chin and facial structure, same everything else. It's Cotillard. Gyllenhaal is also really easy to pick out of a police line-up, and it isn't her.
- Oh hey, it was Marion Cotillard.
- That seems kinda clichéd. I was thinking it would be cool if, during a scene with Bane releasing prisoners, one of his men would find a locked cell, open it to free the guy inside, only to find it completely empty...save for red and black graffiti all over the walls, and a few notes of Joker's theme from the previous movie's soundtrack playing. Confused, he backs out and continues his job. This would imply that Joker had already escaped from Arkham by himself, as he always does, but just like his origin story we wouldn't have any idea how he did it or where he is by the end of the story. It would also be a fitting send off to Heath Ledger. It probably won't happen, but it's just what I would do if I were Christopher Nolan.
- There's bound to be something, even if it's simple. They threw one into Begins, and I think it would be appropriate to throw one in here. His impact in Dark Knight was too strong to just pretend he doesn't have a presence in Gotham anymore, even if behind bars.
- Got a source on that? It's been stated that he won't be in the movie, but I hadn't heard there won't be any kind of Callback.
- Then again a few months ago Ridley Scott was telling us there would be no Xenmomorphs in Prometheus.
- Nope, no mention of the Joker at all.
- Jossed by her whispering in Bruce's ear that, "You don't owe these people anything." If she were a Marxist she wouldn't tell the richest man in the country, if not the world, that he didn't owe anything to anyone.
- We don't know the context of the line, and Batman is a such an unusual man and so incredibly self-sacrificing that she may simply be making an exception. For all we know, she could be talking about figures of power and authority who want Batman back once Bane goes on a rampage.
- Or maybe, if any, she's talking to Batman (the legend/symbol which is about as close to an ideology in this fictional setup) and not to the Bruce Wayne (the man who's part of the bourgeois) she knows: if any, we aren't even sure that she knows (yet) that they are one and the same. This ain't Batman Returns after all.
- By that time, Bruce Wayne was broke.
- Jossed in Gotham Tonight. He personally hadpicked Gordon to lead the Major Crimes Unit and publically acusses Maroni of corruption.
For a lighter view of this title interpretation: Batman gets the civilian equivalent of a canonization, and the legend of the Dark Knight returning after his disappearance hovers over Gotham like an eternal bat signal, proving that while amateur vigilantes are more trouble than they're worth, good vigilantes carry out the spirit of Batman, even after the man behind the one and only cowl has died.
Either way, my guess is that "rises" is in the euphemistic sense, one way or another.
- The theory about Joker's death has been Jossed for now. Word of God is that he was put on trial and swiftly executed for his crimes after the events of The Dark Knight, though no one will mention this during Rises. Granted, this was done more to handwave his absence than for any other reason, but it still stands.
- Apparently not everyone got that memo; while the Joker isn't mentioned in the film proper, the novelization says that he's alive and is currently the sole inmate at Arkham.
- Actually, there was no such Word of God on the issue, just fanon. Nolan simply said that the Joker would not be mentioned in DKR.
- It seems more like that he's a weathervane who will turn to wherever the wind blows. He used to be in cahoots with R'as al Ghul, so joining Bane would have been a natural move.
We know he's going to be in this movie, and thus he will be the only main villain appearing in all three movies. Sick of being pushed to the sidelines, Crane orchestrated a plan over the last eight years to completely decimate both Batman and Gotham City. He's got the brains to do it, and this plan will strike fear into the hearts of Gotham's elite as well as the Bat. He's a dark reflection of Batman (using fear on his enemies as Batman does to criminals), and it would be nice to see him get a little recognition.
The Adam West show had Riddler as Batman's archenemy instead of Joker, likely because of the incredible Frank Gorshin's performance, so why can't Nolan's trilogy make Scarecrow the archvillain?
- He does appear, but jossed since Talia Al'Ghul was behind Bane.
A stabbing carries little visual detail and the focus is on the treachery of the character using the knife rather than on any sense of relish in violence.
Of course this raises the question of who is the traitor they reffer to.
- Catwoman: We know Selina's ethics will be ambigous and there have been reffrences to Catwoman using a knife. Then again it might be predictable and while unscrupulous it seems out of place for her to stoop to outright murder.
- Miranda Tate: If she turns out to be Talia all the more likely.
- Confirmed
- John Blake: As an orignal character Nolan has more freedom to take his character to places the audience wouldn't expect. It could be a great bit of misdirection, build him up as an idealistic Audience Surrogate only for him to be Evil All Along.
- One of Gordon's Men: They have a bad record for loyalty.
- The Joker: I know it's been jossed by Word of God... But can't a man dream? (Cries manly tears into the keyboard). Perhaps he'll be in disguise, like in the Bank Robbery, plus a knife is mentioned in the advice.
- The Traitor in question actually betrays Bane to help out Batman
- After five months, she'd be showing, and there'd be little chance of the child surviving that impact.
- Not necessarily. Some women can go their whole pregnancy without showing much more than a little weight gain. Besides, people have survived worse in the Nolan-verse...
- Yeah, but typically not women with figures like Marion Cotillard. In any case, Talia and Batman's relationship in the film is very different than the comic book version, and unlikely to produce someone like Damian.
- Calm down, it IS WMG here
- I like this theory almost purely for the literary (cinematic?) symmetry.
- After five months, she'd be showing, and there'd be little chance of the child surviving that impact.
- Or possibly not even in prison. I mean, who can prove she was actually a bad guy, rather than a hostage who cooperated to keep people alive? The aftermath of the League's rule over Gotham is going to be confusing as hell, and if any of her minions are captured they're probably not going to sell her out. A decent lawyer could keep her out of jail, and she'd probably even be able to keep her place on the Wayne board. Bruce Wayne would have to return to rescue his father's legacy.
"You ain't for us, therefore you're against us." In pace requiescat.
- I would like to imagine that he was put to a lower security prison with a shortened sentence as a reward for his actions. A guy who does that is unlikely to return to a life of crime.
- Assuming, of course, he also gets enough money as a reward so that he'll never have to return to a life of crime...
- For the Bat's autopilot to be fixed, we have to believe that Bruce Wayne is a better software than Lucius Fox, the guy he goes to for everything technology related. We have no confirmation that the patch actually works, merely that it's there.
- Lucius implies that Bruce is as smart as he is, it's just that Bruce is too busy being Batman to do all the things he has Lucius do.
- Alfred is emotionally distraught, and the cafe scene almost exactly matches a fantasy he admits to having had for years. He is not a reliable observer.
- If Alfred is imagining the scene, why is Selina there? He only met her while she was working as a maid, then learns she's really a thief, and leaves before any sort of romance begins. It's more likely he would have imagined Rachel.
- He's the goddamn Batman. Five seconds is all he needs.
- No, five seconds is all Superman needs. Batman would have barely hit the water in five seconds, let alone had time to swim six miles.
- Theoretically, he could have jetisoned and glided. If The Bat was travelling at top speed it could have gotten far enough away, with him gliding in the opposite direction, for him to escape the blast (if the blast wave didn't help the glide). Still highly unlikely in real life, but this isn't real life.
- Correction: we see Batman in a cockpit sometime before the last five seconds. Thanks to cunning editing, we don't know when exactly he's last in the cockpit and there's nothing to confirm he was in the plane carting the bomb. Most likely he punched under the cover of the explosion that broke through the buildings/wall/whatever and flew off in a second Batwing.
- He's the goddamn Batman. Five seconds is all he needs.
- The last shot we see of Batman is him sitting in his seat. The shot is too close to show the interior of the Bat. He could have ejected at any point and was just resting due to his knife wound.
The only way I can imagine Crane becoming rising to the position of People's Judge is with the help of his connections to the League of Shadows. He buys the hype and still thinks the plan in anarchy.
- The criminals of Gotham might have a long memory and remember that a decade earlier he bailed a lot of them out that night in the Narrows. Making him a judge probably seemed fitting to them (since he also kept them out of prison and in the asylums instead).
- He'll be too indignant to restart his magnum opus, but will not openly sabotage the 2015 film. Instead, he will act as a Literal Genie whenever anyone asks him to do anything, will never volunteer advice of his own free will, and will get himself fired/ ruin the movie completely. Or he could ask any of his villain actors to become Clayface. Or do it himself.
- Nolan had no involvement with Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice outside of producing. The film is a Zack Snyder work, which if anything, is more of a Superman movie that starred Batman for a good amount of it.
- He's lost his fortune, and is pretending to be dead. He has no documentation, no verifiable work history, and no references. All he has left are his thief girlfriend and a set of skills that would be very useful for a thief to have. How else would he fund his new life?
- There's an issue of MAD magazine that has a cartoon that shows Batman pulling off Bane's mask only to show the Joker. It would explain where the Joker is and why Bane never takes off his mask and why his voice is distorted. True, we did briefly see an unmasked Bane in a Flashback, but maybe that was the real Bane who was killed and the Joker took on his identity.
Think about it. We never learn the Joker's real name, and his character is only in action for about six months (a year if you count The Joker Blogs) and then his actions are completely off the books. Who's to say he didn't escape and resume his old identity, perhaps even getting some corrective surgery on his face. He becomes a cop, deduces Batman's identity because... he's the Joker, and prepares to gain the trust of Bruce Wayne so he can get access to his equipment and bring Gotham to it's knees. And once he has done that, he could pop in to see Bruce Wayne and shove his failure right in his face.
- It is hinted at in some comics that before his accident, the man known today as the Joker was a terrible stand-up comedian.
- If he was really there he would probably correct Bruce's statement that Bane was his child.
- if this is true, it raises the possibility that Ra's could resurrect both Talia and Bane. He could even resurrect Two-Face at a stretch (Dent may have been cremated but this is Ra's we're dealing with.) Of course none of this couldn't and shouldn't apply to the Nolanverse, but it could be an awesome way to keep all the villains alive.
The Penguin becomes the mayor of Gotham and turns it back into a crime ridden city.
Wayne Enterprises creates a product that messes with DNA and creates Man-Bat, Killer Croc, Posion Ivy, and/or Clayface.
Catwoman steals from Black Mask who then goes after her for revenge.
Lady Shiva regroups the League of Shadows and continues the assault on the Bat Family.
The Justice League asks him to join them.
- In The Dark Knight Rises, when Bane's bombs are destroying the bridges, we have an aerial shot that is clearly Manhattan (albeit with a few bridges digitally inserted on the Hudson River - you know they're CGI because the first bridge to cross the Hudson is the George Washington Bridge at 175th Street).
- You might need to do comparison shots, but the paint scheme on the GCPD's patrol cars is identical to the paint scheme that was used on the NYPD's fleet in the early 1990s (the obvious differences being that the GCPD cars have a darker shade of blue than the 1990s NYPD cars.
- Really? You couldn't have paraphrased that Cracked article? You just had to copy it directly onto the wiki? I mean, don't get me wrong, I it makes perfect sense and I agree completely, but couldn't you at least have tried to put it into your own words?
- The Joker does show a great deal of familiarity with urban warfare, between taking down helicopters, ambushing convoys, staging multi-pronged attacks on hard targets like the police precinct and the mob bank, and his comfort with "insurgent tactics". However, his lack of registered fingerprints and DNA records most likely excludes him from any possible military service. He could have been a private military contractor ("If you're good at something, never do it for free!") who took a completely private path to the career, or he could have somehow removed his fingerprints from the records... or his fingers. That still leaves his DNA up in the air. If he could alter the records (perhaps with some of that money he stole from the bank?) he'd essentially be The Spook he became.
- Been awhile since I've watched the movie, but did they ever mention checking his DNA? Doesn't that usually take a couple days, if not, weeks? They only had him for a few hours, it's possible that they just didn't have time to swab him and check it. Also, he could have burned off his fingerprints.
- Or, whatever happened to him in the military was something the government wanted to hide, so they removed all records of him and his death from the books to maintain "plausible deniability". He was perfectly capable of driving a semi truck, so he may have been a military convoy driver who was tasked with transporting something illegal and who ran into an accident along the way.
- This Insane Fan Theory video concludes that the Joker is a soldier who was disavowed by his government and erased from official records, captured and tortured, and came back to the States with a grudge. It takes into account his proficiency with military-grade weapons (never misses when shooting, hits a moving target with an RPG from a moving platform), vehicles (he drives an eighteen-wheeler for a while), and hand-to-hand (takes down an active-duty cop who has the size advantage), resistance to pain (interrogation scene), and his planning (lots of contingencies). He'd experienced the sort of urban warfare he carries out during his tour of duty.
- None other than Patton Oswalt adds his own spin to this theory: "What if he’s not only ex-military, but ex-military intelligence? Specifically — interrogation?"
The Joker may have experience with weaponry, precision timing, and scarring that corresponds to an explosion, but that doesn't explain his ability to make the most of the terror he creates, not to mention what must have been a perfect disappearance, with the ability to now have 'no name given' for an identity. Military training also isn't the best explanation for his apparent first-hand experience with enhanced interrogation. As such, I'd argue that instead of a military background, Nolan's Joker used to work for an intelligence agency (and not necessarily American. After all, the way he talks appears to mask a much deeper voice, and the Gotham accent might be faked as well.). His work brought him in contact with the worst aspects of intelligence though, possibly leading to his experience with terror, torture, and capture at the hands of an enemy, explaining his injuries. With his previous identity believed dead, and his survival leaving him with a mix of intense physical and emotional scarring, the Joker set out to make a mockery of what he saw as a society whose plans appeared as impersonal as they were calculating.
- No, I don't think he forgot. He knew the two addresses off the back of his hand. He clearly knew all along, unless you want Obfuscating Stupidity to be what's really happening.
Look at the unit registration printed on the rear side panel of John Blake's marked Ford Crown Victoria when he's at Wayne Manor in TDKR: 66 PCT 98821. Since the GCPD's paint job is based on the NYPD, it's clear they use precincts. The unit number on Blake's car can be broken down as follows: 66 PCT means that his car is assigned to the GCPD 66th Precinct, and 98821 is the unit's shop number (used to identify a city-owned vehicle).
I thought it was odd that he acts so serious compared to other incarnations. Then I thought about his Fountain of Memes status, which made me wonder: What if he was acting Narmy on purpose? What if he intentionally said all those silly things with a straight face, knowing that the audience members who weren't terrified of him would get a kick out of it?