The nice tree was a kind old lady who died of old age.
Otto was an eight year old child. One day, he went out for a boat ride in a wooden boat when it tipped over. Otto, unable to swim, died. That's why he thinks wood sinks.
King died in a coal mine explosion where he suffocated/starved to death. His "rust on the tracks" meant he was unable to get out.
Carrot was an activist who was assassinated.
Pencil was a child accidentally left behind in the park where he got hit by a car.
The toaster died from an eating disorder. He used to play with his food and not eat it, that's why the cheese has to stay in the park.
The wishing well worked itself to death.
The grandfather clock died at the age of two many years ago from an unknown disease. It was likely before modern medicine. This explains why he has to enjoy "every minute."
The pieces of kitchen equipment were restaurant workers killed in a kitchen fire at lunchtime. This explains why it was always lunchtime.
The living room furniture: A family killed when someone broke in and killed them. They think Sam is the one who kills them.
Wink and Blink were a gay couple who got murdered. More specifically, Wink was murdered and Blink survived. That explains why Blink wants all of Wink's power. It's survivor's guilt.
The three trees guarding the garden: victims of a hate crime. The last thing they saw were trees, so now they think that all trees are good and everyone else is evil.
The chair: Murdered in her home. She was shot in the leg and bled out. It explains why she says phrases from the game Clue, and why it's her leg that breaks.
The bridge: Committed suicide by jumping off a bridge after suffering a major financial blow.
The instruments: Musicians who died in a car accident.1. The head was the driver and decapitated in the accident.2. The organ was in the passenger's seat. He kept telling the head to be careful, but he wasn't.3. The trombone survived the accident, but suffered a brain injury making him unable to speak. This is why he does not speak. He died years later of natural causes.
- It could also be an in-universe Continuity Reboot.
However, she still retains the power— and she uses her connections with dimensional deities to help her out with parenting. Kid's freaking out over sleeping in the dark? Well, hey, you slept in that guy's guest room for a month in college. Kid won't eat his veggies? Seeing the effects of political imbalance amongst the food groups will teach him to have a balanced diet! Thunder and Lightning? Oh, they're just the nicest couple! Of course they'll put him up in the weather machine for a night— hopefully, he doesn't break anything.
Anyway. This would explain why the characters in the "pretend" worlds make pop culture references and jokes that go over Sam's head, and why everything always works out fine in the end. And as a bonus? That carrot that's in every game is an interdimensional traveler as well. And, though it's going out on quite a limb, he's Sam's biological father. It was a fling back when his mom was younger, okay? He's clearly a child of the 60s, so it sounds about right, age-wise. She'd been meaning to have a little explorer of her own, anyway.Sam's mom sends Sam off on interdimensional travels to raise him correctly, and Sam's dad watches over him on these adventures.
No Need to Hide When It's Dark Outside takes place at his house and surroundings, Thunder and Lightening is his hometown, You Are What You Eat is at the grocery store.
- Considering how... Infamous Life Is Rough When You Lose Your Stuff! is, along with the fact that it is technically an unnumbered installment, I can see them doing what Crash 4 did.
- Pajama Sam 4: It's About Time For Fun When In Competition.