This is a CLOSED page for wild mass guesses from the series One Piece which have been Jossed by the series or Word of God. This page includes theories that were Jossed during the Dressrosa Arc and the Zou Arc, and is for viewing purposes only. If a WMG on one of the open pages is Jossed, please move it to Jossed Theories: Part Three.
Do NOT post newly Jossed theories here. Please add newly Jossed entries to "Jossed Theories, Part Three".
- Jossed - Luffy doesn't want someone else to have the fruit, going so far as to enter a tournament with the fruit as a prize, so no one else can have it.
- Think of it this way. Brook said Kine'mon died in the gas. However, Caesar said that the gas paralyzes its victims and then traps them in their weird-stoney-bodycasts. Chopper will find a way to reverse the bodycast bit, but will be unable to reverse the paralysis. Kine'mon will threaten sepukku as usual when he learns he can't walk, but Momonosuke will offer to take him back to Wano, and learn the way of the samurai and Foxfire sword style to continue his father's legacy.
- Partially Jossed, but not entirely yet: When the gas clears out, people stuck in the shells break out on their own. Kinemon required no help from Chopper.
- No, it's fully Jossed. He's not paralyzed.
- No, what I mean by "not entirely yet" is that it's still uncertain whether Kinemon and Momonosuke will join the Straw Hats or not. If they do, it's fully Jossed. If they don't, it's partially Jossed and partially Confirmed.
- I think he showed up in the Z movie though...? I'm not sure, I'm watching a terribly bootlegged (and unsubbed) version. Although, at the very least, I support this as an AU.
- No, the blind man is Issho aka Fujitora the new Admiral.
- Jossed. The blind man's name is Issho, and his alias is Fujitora. Neither have to do with 'low-ranking blind person Ichi' which is what Zatoichi means (His name is Ichi, his title is Zato-no-Ichi, or Zatoichi for short)
- Jossed-there was nobody like this on the island.
- Doesn`t Giolla`s devil fruit turn people into art not toys though?
- Yes, Giolla turns people into her own demented form of art, not toys. The manga made it clear that there was a separate - and as of yet, unknown - Devil Fruit user from Giolla that was responsible for turning people into toys.
- Jossed. It's Sugar.
- Jossed. He does fix his problem, after a fashion... but the end of the fight was anything but diplomatic.
- Jossed. It was all about a treasure, after all.
- Jossed. He first learns about Luffy when he was nearly executed by Buggy in Logue Town. Bartolomeo immediately became Luffy's fanboy. He wanted to get the devilfruit to Luffy because of that, plus Sabo comes back later to get the fruit himself.
- Jossed. He first learns about Luffy when he was nearly executed by Buggy in Logue Town. Bartolomeo became immediately Luffy's fanboy and then he started his pirate career.
- Jossed. He is just a pirate who looks up to Luffy(-senpai) since the Logue Town arc.
- Lalala~ Can't hear you T___T Although, I have to chokingly admit, that a part of her feels that anything except for death would feel like a cop-out, and she is furiously trying to smother that part.
- Ah, but it was revealed later on that * probably* the Blackbeards beat the crap out of Magellan, so who knows about ol' Mr. 2 now?
- Then that means that Bon-chan is stuck on an island with no escape (he can't open the gate for himself) trapped with hundreds of marines. Best case scenario is he's disguised as a guard until he gets some (pretty unlikely) help, Or escapes while disguised as a guard.
- I would love to see some sort of filler episode where Bon Kurei escapes Impel Down with the captured New-Kama disguised as Magellan and Impel Down guards.
- Ah, but it was revealed later on that * probably* the Blackbeards beat the crap out of Magellan, so who knows about ol' Mr. 2 now?
- Jossed in one of the From the Decks of the World manga covers, he's still alive and has apparently become the new queen of New-Kama land.
- Firstly, high bounties can come from being Axe-Crazy, which Doflamingo definately is. Secondly, this is One Piece. There are no weak powers. The guy with the power to push things is one of the more dangerous people around.
- So Doflamingo used King's Haki to slice off Oars Jr.'s leg?
- I think the original poster means Doflamingo has a Razor Wire fruit still.
- Firstly, high bounties can come from being Axe-Crazy, which Doflamingo definately is. Secondly, this is One Piece. There are no weak powers. The guy with the power to push things is one of the more dangerous people around.
- Jossed. His Devil Fruit is proven to be completely responsible for his body manipulation.
- Jossed concerning the name, but the powers are right. It's the String-String fruit.
- Which is how he can control other people: he's manipulating the blood in their veins to control their movements like puppets, a la bloodbending from Avatar: The Last Airbender.
- This does not explain how he can run in midair...unless he's controlling his own blood.
- Jossed. His fruit is the string string fruit and he flies by using his fruit to hang from the cloulds.
- It could be possible he could be converted to a Pacifista via their turn-regular-people-into-a-tree-sized-man thing, but not the face of a new model as he doesn't have the reputation or fear-inducing appearence like Kuma does.
- Neither did Robert Patrick. if anything, Bon Clays would be a far more stealthy version after some modifications from Vegapunk; he had two years to create more powerful versions of the Pacifista, who knows what he's capable of doing to Bon Clay? maybe take his power and further it along his shape shifting abilities, maybe be able to change his voice, etc. Vegapunk IS this universes version of Tony Stark, after all.
- Jossed. Bon Kurei still has all of his free will intact and no apparent machine powers. He's in hiding in Impel Down 5.5, rebuilt and back into secrecy.
- Oh yes. Oh for the love of God please yes. Bon-chan can NOT die T_T
- If anyone it'd be Avalo Pizarro, because, if you notice, he's the only one of the Level 6 Blackbeard Pirates not mentioned by Iva when he was explaining Level 6.
- Not likely. Blackbeard recruited all four directly from their cells after killing their cellmates.
- But what if Bon-Chan killed one of the members and took their image when they got up to where he and Magellan were fighting. Maybe Magellan redirected his attack on Blackberad and in the midst of the battle and Bon-Chan knew his only way of getting out was to kill a member. Total BS I know, but this IS WMG
- Possible, if we're following the speculation that Blackbeard Pirates vs Straw Hat pirates as an even factor, the Straw Hats either need one more or Blackbeards need one less.
- Jossed sadly. Bon Kurei is still in Impel Down.
- If anyone it'd be Avalo Pizarro, because, if you notice, he's the only one of the Level 6 Blackbeard Pirates not mentioned by Iva when he was explaining Level 6.
- Maybe, maybe...
- A Pacifishta then?
- They already have the Kuma Model Pacifista; would they go to the extra effort of taking months or even years to modify someone completely new, who probably isn't even as strong as Kuma originally was?
- Jossed: the new warlords were Law, Buggy, and Weevil.
- 1: It's never been established what happened to him after he was beaten by Luffy
- 2: He fits with the Animal Motifs of the other Shichibukai
- 3: His main motivation is to not get chased by the Marines, which could easily be accomplished by becoming a Shichibukai.
- 4: He's a likely candidate for Magikarp Power due to not yet having a Devil Fruit. Unlike Alvida, he actually possesses some legitimate fighting skills to build off of (having developed his own rudimentary form of Soru without any prior knowledge of Rokushiki) as well as the intellect necessary to make the most of a Devil Fruit Power. With enough practice and/or a complementary Devil Fruit Power he could conceivably evolve into a Fragile Speedster-type fighter.
- Well, the thing is, Kuro is unlikely to be the next Warlord because he has no drive to be a pirate. Remember, he wanted to escape piracy and be rid of his bounty. The last thing he would probably want is to have to endure the difficulty of becoming one of the world's strongest pirates, be hunted down by Marines, and then have to earn his right to be a Warlord (and then have other pirates coming for his head rather than Marines).
- jossed: see theory above.
- Why exactly would you hire someone who had her entire crew utterly defeated by him into your elite unit?
- Moria got his [bottom] kicked by Kaidou before he became a warlord, so being beaten by the best clearly does not disqualify you.
- Plus Crocodile ended up getting his butt kicked by Whitebeard after becoming a Warlord but didn't lose his title.
- Jossed-the new warlords are Buggy, Law and Weevil.
- Bon being alive is also strongly hinted at in the latest chapter, when Luffy himself exclaims to a disinterested Buggy that he could be okay.
- Alternatively, he'll become the next Ivankov, spending his days merrily partying away with other inmates in Level 5.5.
- I highly doubt that, cause Mallegan said he'll kill him, as there's no way he'll back down from that, after everything that has happened, unless Bon Kurei escaped. Though there's a possibility that Impel Down will search for how the prisoners where vanishing and reappearing from. So the only way Bon Kurei would survive, if somebody saves him, namely a guy who can disable Devil Fruit powers, and a person who knows Mallegan very close.
- In the most recent chapter, Magellen was found beaten to near death, his assailant missing. It sounds like Bon Clay (Kurei, whatever) might show back up again. His assailant was the former head-jailer Shilliew "of the Rain"
- Alternatively, he'll become the next Ivankov, spending his days merrily partying away with other inmates in Level 5.5.
- The Blackbeard Pirates showed up at the war site, minus Bon Clay, so...
- Confirmed. It wasn't elaborated on how he escaped, but in one of the From the Decks of the World manga covers, he's still alive and has apparently become the new queen of New-Kama land.
- JOSSED. Chapter 666's cover shows that Bon Kurei is the new queen of Newkama Land: Impel Down 5.5.
- Jossed: Sugar is the one with the Hobby Fruit that turns people into toys.
- Jossed. Rebecca was the last one left standing, thus winning the block division.
- Seconded, because that would also neatly tie up two loose threads.
- It's become highly unlikely—with the blind man revealed as Admiral Fujitora, the only way this could work is if he competed in the Colosseum many years ago under the pseudonym of Kyros.
- Jossed, Kyros is someone completely different.
- Jossed: "Lucy" grabbed and ate the Mera-Mera no mi, making him the victor.
- Plus the Lucy who won was actually Sabo.
- I thought so, too! Buggy faked one, didn't he?
- Jossed. Lucy/Sabo ate the fruit and started to show off fire powers, showing the fruit was the real thing.
- Plus Bentham already ate a devil fruit so eating another would be suicide (with one exception).
- Jossed. It is.
All this troper will say: The last thing a person does when they die.
- No. Jossed.
- Taking in consideration that both are inspired by the most famous Spanish-speaking characters to ever exist...
- Or maybe SANJI is somehow related to Doflamingo...
- Doflamingo appeared to be in his late teens or early twenties at the time of Roger's execution. He could be Zoro's father. Zoro could be so protective over Chopper because he sees himself in Chopper, a person without a father figure. So he wants to fulfill that role.
- Jossed. Doflamingo's family is quite well documented as of the latest flashback. Zoro's nowhere in it.
- Akainu. Luffy will shove it down his throat at the last minute of their fight giving him a gloriously Karmic Death.
- Coby
- None of the Strawhats will eat it, but it will be eaten by an ally which Sabo is.
- A random child just like when Luffy eat Gomu-gomu fruit which was kept by Shanks.
- Jossed: Sabo ate it.
- Jossed: Law's family was shown in a flashback, and they all died. But Gin was nowhere to be seen or mentioned.
- That would have been impossible even if they survived since the Amberlead toxin would have killed them long ago. Only reason Law's alive is his devil-fruit powers.
- Jossed, she already has a devil fruit power.
- You could also consider this pre double-jossed, as with the latest revelation about the condition of their family, it's unlikely any of the royal family would leave Dressrosa after the arc is over. Like Vivi and Alabasta.
- Jossed, probably. Considering who he turns out to be, there is no way he's ever leaving Dressrosa again, especially just to become a pirate.
- If this happens, I could see a reason why, and three possibilities regarding the outcome.
- would eat the fruit right after Luffy had beaten him, as a sort of desperate effort to keep Luffy from gaining the fruit or as a sort of Take That! trying to prove a last point to Luffy that Dreams and Determination don't always win (since one of Doflamingo's things seems to be the idea that dreams are for wussies). Then this would result in one of three possible scenarios:
- First, Doflamingo already seems to have a Devilfruit power, and people with a power can't consume a second fruit or it kills them. Thus consuming the fruit would be suicide for him (Blackbeard is the exception).
- Second, Doflamingo eats the fruit...and somehow gains its powers in addition to the ones he already has, a la Blackbeard. This would also reveal how Blackbeard was able to consume a second fruit. Unlikely? Sure, but this is One Piece, and the series has a history of doing what we'd least expect.
- Third, sort of similar to the second one, is that Doflamingo's previously displayed powers are somehow NOT the result of a Devilfruit, thus he simply eats the fruit and gains Ace's former powers in addition to the Razor Floss powers he's used before.
- Jossed he ate the Ito Ito No Mi so he can't eat another fruit.
- Very improbable, if you recall just what happened to Sabo in Luffy's flashback. And him being alive would nullify Luffy's whole motivation, which I doubt Oda would do.
- If you recall, there was very strong hinting in both the manga and anime that he survived, and Dragon and co. saved him.
- I think it's confirmed in some data book that Sabo is definitely dead.
- "Sabo" may be dead, but that still leaves multiple other possibilities, like amnesia, or mind control, or like they did with Kuma
- As of chapter 731, Luffy meets up with someone who is heavily implied to be Sabo and freaks out about how he thought he was dead. So if Robin met Sabo, she didn't know about his connection to Luffy and he didn't tell her, considering she's one of the crew most likely to not forget something like that.
- Jossed (for the letter) and seems that Robin did know who Sabo was.
- Jossed. Turns out, HE was rotten one from the start and his family were all good people. He cares for his underlings so much because he has no one left seeing as how he indirectly led to his mother's death and murdered his father and brother.
- Jossed. He never wanted to leave the nobility.
- Ironically, his father was a Defector from Decadence.
- I thought that about Haki too when those two guys on Big Mom's crew had it. But then I thought, this is the unfathomably stronger part of the most dangerous sea in the One Piece world; it only makes sense that more Ds would show up here, after all it's probably where they are destined to be.
- Jossed: Because of Trafelagar D. Water Law. Better luck next time.
- The assassin part is jossed, the other is partly confirmed. She leads them into a trap, but she doesn't know it herself.
- Even better, Doflamingo could force Luffy into a situation where attacking him could mean serious trouble (such as Doflamingo holding people hostage with his powers), and the only way Luffy can safely resolve the situation is to get through to Doflamingo at an ideological level.
- Nope. As of chapter 745 the fists are flying, no Bellamy required.
- Jossed. Koala is Koala.
- To clarify, something about his speech makes me think of him as a D somewhere even further down the sliding scale of morality from Blackbeard. Also, his habit of smiling and laughing at all times, even in the middle of a vicious war, make me think of a truly warped and depraved D.
- While Blackbeard was a bastard, he was a bastard that believed wholeheartedly in the power of dreams. Belief in the power of dreams seems to be a characteristic of the Ds. A nihlist like Doflamingo doesn't really fit all that well.
- Makes sense. Besides, every character that is a D. has had that fact revealed from the first moment their full names were revealed, and that's not the case with Doflamingo.
- Not with Roger it didn't.
- Because we didn't know about the will of D then.
- While Blackbeard was a bastard, he was a bastard that believed wholeheartedly in the power of dreams. Belief in the power of dreams seems to be a characteristic of the Ds. A nihlist like Doflamingo doesn't really fit all that well.
- Eh, I'd rather know first what enabled Blackbeard to eat a second fruit, or - to be more contextual - to tap into Whitebeard's power. It's been established that eating a second fruit will make you die, and Blackbeard's case is special, but we haven't seen what's "special" about him.
- Jossed: Sabo did.
- Jossed. Not only does she join him for real, but she's not even a Heel to begin with. She's the princess of Dressrosa, and was coerced into working with Doflamingo under the threat that if she didn't, her father would be killed.
- Rebecca and Cavendish are in the same block of fighters (D) so one one of them can make it to the finals. your theory still holds up however as long as Cavendish defeats Rebecca. My guess for the finalists are Jesus, Lucy, Bellamy, and Cavendish.
- You're right. Somehow, I thought Lucy was in Block D, with Cavendish in C and Rebecca in B for some reason. Everyone in Luffy's group has split off to do his own thing, however, so it'd also require meeting up with his pals again later on. Looking at the lineup, Block B will most likely come down to Bellamy and Bartolomeo though.
- The finalists are Lucy, Rebecca, Bartolomeo, Burgess, and Diamante.
- "Lucy" gets the fruit. Jossed.
- Jossed. Sabo ate it.
- She's wearing a crown and Trebol is in chains. Perhaps she did something to his mind to put herself in control with her memory manipulation. It would be a classic Oda twist to have the little girl be the real nasty instead of the blob man.
- Jossed. They're both equally nasty, for one thing, and Trebol just has an eccentric fashion sense. If you meant the SMILE factory, it's leader is actually a lesser minion named Kyuin. Trebol and Sugar are just patrolling there due to the invasion.
- Jossed, everyone memories returned as soon as Sugar knocked out.
- Um, jossed?
- A theory that would leave M.Night Shyamalan proud. But yeah, way jossed.
- Jossed. He's one tough bastard.
- Just to add to this: Luffy was effectively getting his ass kicked for most of the initial fight while barely being able to hurt Doffy with Gear 2nd Haki imbued hits. It took until chapter 784 when he unleashed Gear 4th that Doffy was on the receiving end of a Kong gun, Rhino Schneider, and Culverin that Luffy gained the upper hand.
- Jossed as of chapter 764. Corazon used the Nagi Nagi no Mi, so it is impossible for him to have eaten the Ope Ope no Mi.
- The first part of Law's past had a similarity to Robin's, but the part where he went along with Corazon is rather similar with Chopper. Chopper's called monster and Hiluluk was as silly as Corazon. We know eating two DF would destroy someone. It's Dofla's original plan, and seeing how Hiluluk actually died... My guess is Corazon was in a situation where he can't refuse Doffy's order to eat the fruit. Without any choice, he ate the fruit knowing well it would meant his death, but not before asking Law to prepare another fruit. With his death as a distraction, Ope-ope's transferred to another fruit and Law ate it right away.
- He's already got a devil fruit power, but as things are, it doesn't look like he'll be able to deliver it to Law. That, and the fact that Law is in no condition to cure himself, means that Rocinante will have to eat it, live just long enough to use the eternal life thing, and then explode.
- No. Doflamingo will force him to eat it. He doesn't know about Nagi Nagi.
- Jossed.
- Seeing how Doflamingo actually valued his family, jossed. Unless he didn't know Sanji's actually his son or something.
- Double Jossed, since it was recently revealed that Sanji is part of a DIFFERENT Royal family called the Vinsmokes.
- He might have rather been his son because that would mean that at least a couple of his relatives were decent
- Jossed. Corazon is Corazon.
- Wouldn't the others have forgotten all about him, then?
- Perhaps it only applies to Dressrosa, or perhaps the memory-wiping is a separate process.
- Wouldn't the others have forgotten all about him, then?
- Jossed
- Jossed, Corazon is killed by Doflamingo.
- That doesn't explain why they have different last names (Monkey and Gol). Maybe they're cousins.
- Plus, Garp would surely have known if his nemesis Roger was his son.
- Another possiblity is that Roger is Garp's brother. As for the difference in surnames, they could easily be half-brothers (same mother, different fathers), or one of them could have chosen to use there mother's surname instead of their father's, (as Ace did).
- Probably jossed from overwhelming evidence. It's been stated many times in canon that Luffy is not related to Ace by blood in any fashion. If they were cousins, it would have been mentioned by now, certainly before Ace's death. Also, Dragon being Roger's brother would make Garp Roger's father, and we've seen that they were clearly around the same age during their fighting days 20 years ago, both appearing as middle aged men. Unless Garp was actually really older than he looked and Roger was really younger than he looked, it's highly unlikely that Roger could be Garp's son, and by extension, Dragon's brother.
- Very much jossed since Oda has released both the ages of Garp and Roger which shows that Roger is only a year younger than Garp.
- Jossed. It's explicitly stated that Usopp started telling lies, specifically about Yasopp returning, to try and cheer his mother up and encourage her to get better. It's very likely that after she died, he continued lying in the same vein as a coping mechanism.
- Personally I'd like to see Brook become Zoro, purely to see Zoro act like Brook does and have Zoro get pissed at Brook for using his swords the "wrong way".
- Fair enough. My reasoning is Luffy freaking out with happiness at the fact he's now the "awesome singing afro skeleton," Brook regaining his lost youth through Usopp, Usopp gets to feel real strength for once, Zoro being put in a woman's body and the fights it results in with Nami!Sanji, and Robin gets the only body left.
- The hilarity of Robin -> Luffy would be Luffy acting smart.
- Good point, also Luffy being incredibly calm and full of morbid comments.
- Well he swapped Smoker and Tashigi? as of chapter 663. He had an opportunity to swap the other straw hats, but for whatever reason he hasn't done so. ...Yet, at least.
- Jossed, he never did, not on Punk Hazard at least.
- When did Rebecca ever receive any type of love letter?? Besides, Jossed because Bellamy is clearly older than Rebecca, who's only 16.
- Jossed. They landed on Dressrosa, an inhabited island, but there wasn't any panic or celebration going on because of it.
- Funnily enough though, there was both a mass panic and a mass celebration when they left Dressrosa, with the Marines panicking and the citizens celebrating. You were really close.
- Pluton was built in Water 7 hundreds of years ago, way before Dr Vegapunk's time. And it has been confirmed to be some sort of a warship.
- Jossed, Dragon was present at Gold Roger's execution as shown in the special Chapter 0. They're two separate people.
- I think you just countered your own argument there. Don Krieg fled after not getting very far in. Where was Brook's crew wiped out? The Florian Triangle. A stone's throw away from the Red Line. If they had made it that far, I doubt Don Krieg would have turned around and fled all the way back to the East Blue.
- Not to mention that Brook's Crew was wiped out some 50 years Before the series happens, Krieg probably wasn't even born then.
- I'd say we can count this Jossed. Too much evidence against it for it to ever be true.
- Jossed, he's been shown with his shirt off on Punk Hazard, no tattoos. The 3D2Y was likely just temporary or possibly just a marker.
- Jossed. She's passed away now, and there's nothing really to support that she saw the kids as anything but "toys" (she seems to get a genuine kick out of suffering). Furthermore, she personally refers to the children as "the master's precious experiments", states that her "mission" is to protect Caesar and his "experiments", and goes on to mockingly refer to them as her and Caesar's "treasure" with a very obviously insincere smirk on her face. As for her seemingly concerned face on the next page, it's also arguable that her despair comes from knowing that Doflamingo will kill her if she fails her mission- hence the reason her last line of the chapter is reiterating the importance of her mission.
- You can count this effectively Jossed. The Thunder Soldier, who we now know is actually the legendary gladiator Kyros, is an original inhabitant of Dressrosa who would have no way to have learned the government's signature martial art. Furthermore, we saw a fairly detailed chronicle of his life from 15 years old up until he was transformed into a toy at 34; no mention of Rokushiki at all, and he fights with a longsword even in present day.
- Jossed. She was shown in the past clearly depicted as a girl at 10 years old and a young woman at 19. It's doubtful Ivankov would have had any reason to be in Dressrosa and turn the King's son into a girl.
- Jossed. Luffy's Gum Gum Fruit has been confirmed as a Paramecia many times. There are several things that make it not a Logia. He can't generate limitless amounts of rubber nor move it by itself without force like all Logias have shown the ability to do. His body can also be hurt by plain blunt attacks (Lucci, anyone?), which is major evidence against him being Logia; even solid Logias like Aokiji's ice and Crocodile's sand aren't hurt by plain blunt attacks, they don't even feel them. Also, there are other Paramecias that are permanently "on" at all times, like Buggy's Chop Chop fruit (after all, he can't "turn off" his body splitting up when it gets cut, as shown when Mihawk cut him by surprise).
- Uh, isn't plant and animal are different?
- Jossed. He hasn't shown the "3 forms" typical of a Zoan, it's been claimed many times he's made literally out of just plain ol' rubber, and there's so far been no Zoan fruits based on plants.
- Judging by how Law reacted, I think he's got something to do with what was going on.
- Law has just as much to do with Doflamingo's decapitation as Helmeppo had to do with the Marineford War: they were both there, but couldn't do crap. And even if Law could have done something, he wouldn't have let Doffy live. Plus, what's so strange about being surprised at a random guy suddenly busting into the room and cutting your arch-enemy's head?
- Jossed. It's a puppet made of string that he uses. He's still a Paramecia. Though he does have some Logia like qualities, being able to generate limitless amount of string and all, keep in mind that Magellan can do the same with poison and he's also confirmed a Paramecia.
- HIGHLY unlikely, if not outright Jossed. Kuina is the sensei's daughter, and it's very unlikely that he'd do something like that.
- Jossed. Dragon and Roger aren't related at all, it's been confirmed in canon many times that there is no relation between the Monkey's and the Gol's. Also, I doubt Oda would make his main hero inbred. Or include incest as a major plot point. That's just... weird. And not funny weird, but nasty weird.
- Buggy D. Clown: He's gotta be hanging around for some reason.
- Edwar D. Newgate: His name ends with a D, the same as "Gold Roger." And he's the closest one to One Piece.
- Moot point now what with him being dead and all.
- Fisher D. Tiger: The Men of D have shown to have an impact where ever they go. Fisher's one-man raid on Mariejois and the freeing of all the slaves there including one (maybe two) future Shichibukai counts as an impact to me.
- It's not stated that Tiger is still alive, so it's pretty improbable at this point.
- Chapter 623 confirms that he's dead.
- It's not stated that Tiger is still alive, so it's pretty improbable at this point.
- Jossed. Well, technically Jossed. Yes, at least one person (Traflagar D. Water Law) has been revealed as a D. way after their introduction. But, none of these guys listed are D's. Whitebeard and Tiger died without the trademark smile for one thing, and it would be silly to reveal that they were D's now that their story is done. As for Buggy, he hasn't shown a single trait that could point to him being a D. And "Clown" isn't his last name, it's his pirate epithet.
- Ummm... Luffy has made the World Government look like complete idiots on numerous occasions, and was largely responsible for two of their three most important bases being wrecked to total hell. Granted, the WG's actions tend to be well below genius-level, but that would be a seriously sloppy and self-defeating gambit even for them.
- Jossed. We've seen the Gorosei talk about Luffy in an antagonistic manner even in complete private. Also, Akainu tried to drive a magma fist through his brain. I don't think the Gorosei would authorize that if Luffy was their secret weapon to capture Dragon.
- Er, Jossed? A "dud" is when a bomb fails to go off. We saw the bomb explode in Pell's face. There was nothing dudly about it.
- Or its simply humor since saying someone who has been throwing axes at you because you refuse to marry them and as a result have forced you to live in a tower for ten year is not your type is a tiny bit of an understatement.
- I'd say Jossed. The Arc is over and no greater significance was ever given to it.
- Well, pretty much Jossed. His views on the world aren't really from having a dream crushed. Rather, they're from his being kicked out of Mariejois and being hunted down and tortured by common folk for no less than two years straight as a child. His twisted world views are a product of seeing the worst humanity had to offer, along with his own insanity. Also, his Slasher Smile is definitely genuine.
- Well, his DF is specically described as a Daibatsu then Buddha, as they were made out of bronze, gold, what have you. No clue on the palm blasts
- Jossed. His fruit's powers are specifically the Daibutsu. The only "plain" Hito Hito fruit in the world belongs to Chopper.
- Nope. They still grew after the Timeskip, as seen is his Walk Point.
- Jossed. None of that happened.
- Jossed. Sugar is Monet's sister.
- Jossed.
- While I can't say that this is Jossed, it doesn't seem likely that Oda would recycle that kind of consequence. For starters, decreasing life span was 2nd Gear's thing, and Luffy already fixed that problem. Not to mention that since thi is the New World, just risking your life won't be enough to get you to your goal. And finally, we have Haki, so I'm pretty sure that Oda's gonna come out with something orginal.
- Considering Luffy says he's been using this to fight the wild beasts in the island he trained in, probably jossed.
- Jossed
- We will see it. I just can't see the right hand of the Joker being killed so simply.
- Jossed.
- It was mentioned that the trick works only with zoan-type fruits. If memory serves, he wasn't shown using his power in flashbacks, so it's possible that Caesar improved Vegapunk ideas in this field as well, though.
- Jossed in chapter 782. We learn that Trebol's Devil Fruit isn't a Logia at all.
- Jossed, he was captured alive by the marines.
It may seem a bit far-fetched, but what if the reason why Doflamingo never used Parasite against Luffy is because of Parasite not being able to affect those with Conqueror's Haki or Will of D? Luffy has both, and Doflamingo knows it fairly well, so it may be that he can't affect Luffy's will because of it, so that's why he doesn't even try to use parasite against him. It is worth noting that Doflamingo didn't use it against Law either, while he could force Law to fight with Luffy, just like he did with Bellamy. And as we know, Law also carries a Will of D, with his real name being Trafalgar D. Water Law.
- Parasa-ito seems to be a flashy move not intended for actual battle with a difficult opponent. Fujitora just caught the string (may be anime-only scene), any logia can just disperse, Law probably can teleport away ("parasite" doesn't hinder mental activity or speech)... It seems unlikely that Luffy, resident hypnosis victim, has any special resistance - more probable that Doflamingo just doesn't think this move can be useful against non-fodder.
- It probably just doesn't work to anyone with sufficiently high Armament Haki. That seems to be the usual type of Haki to resist Fruit powers.
- Jossed. He finally used it on him during the climax of their battle. Although Luffy managed to break the strings, it was more through the brute force of activating Gear Fourth than will/spirit.
- My guess is Doffy will die because of the wounds he received from getting Gamma knifed by Law.
- Jossed.
- Jossed, they're after Shanks.
- Jossed, that didn't happen.
- It doesn't seem likely, she was nowhere near Dressrosa.
- Plus, it took a Gear 4th Luffy to do much damage.
- Jossed. She never returned to Dressrosa to be a factor in the first place.
- Jossed, Sabo had amnesia the whole time and remembered Ace too late.
- That or he'll be in one of the next cover stories.
- Jossed for both of those.
- Jossed. They allowed the Marines to arrest Doflamingo, although Sabo does state they'll be back for the Revolutionaries.
- That seems really unlikely. Bellemeré found Nami when she was just a baby and Luffy is a year younger than her, meaning Bellemeré would have been pregnant when she adopted the girls. Nojiko would have been old enough to recognize a pregnancy, and it would just be weird that she'd never think to mention that their mother had given birth within a few months of adopting them.
- I'd say this is Jossed; the evidence against it is too much for it to happen without a major retcon. Also, they were on two completely different islands.
- Jossed. That would mean that Law would've had to come in close contact with Dellinger and Monet at the same time, but we know Law only recently met Monet and gave her the harpy legs while on Punk Hazard and he hadn't been in contact with any Donquixote pirates before that for 13 years.
- Jossed. They remained in Alabasta after helping form the World Government and never became world nobles in the first place.
- Baby 5 is already set on her marriage to Sai, Jossed.
- The real reason is because his executives have reinforced his massive ego and sociopathy when he was young due to his willpower
- Actually, his fruit is a result of everyone being so loyal to him, being a gift from Trebol.
- Jossed. Drake is working for Kaidou nowadays, who's Law's target, so he's probably not in an alliance with him. And Kid didn't even know what emperor Law was going after, so we know he's not working with him either.
I mean, Luffy always wanted a bronze statue, and he said in Colosseum, when he first saw it, that he wants it. So either he by himself will take it, or Rebecca, Riku or Kyros will grant him it as a present for saving their country.
- Or perhaps both.
- I support this. He deserved it!
- Jossed, Luffy boarded a ship leaving the country without the statue.
- Hmm, it's not too likely. For one thing, Oda would be breaking formula by having two Straw Hats join at a time. Also, they shouldn't have too much to fear about being "found" at this point- even if somebody didn't approve of Kyros and found them, what are they really gonna do about it? If they try to take her back, King Riku will certainly disallow it. Kyros also doesn't want Rebecca ever fighting again, so there's no way he'd let her be a pirate. Lastly, this is just speculative, but... if they both joined, that would make four sword users in the crew. I think Oda's probably going for more variety with whoever the next main character is; I'd put my money on either a Fishman Karate user (coughJimbecough) or a person with a unique Devil Fruit or weapon (like a scythe or nunchaku or something).
- Indeed, it's almost impossible. King Riku and Viola are likely going to help them live in secrecy; and even if they do get busted, Kyros can always pretend he managed to save Rebecca, and Riku could use that as an excuse to officially pardon him for his crimes and accept him back as a bodyguard.
- Jossed: The whole country already knew about Kyros and Rebecca, and even the Dwarves being Dwarves, they all just looked the other way for their sake.
- Plus, the Straw Hats and allies already left without Kyros and Rebecca.
- Luffy:500,000,000 Berries. (For defeating Doflamingo, and to ensure that he maintains the highest bounty in the SHP if/when Jimbei joins)
- Confirmed. Luffy's bounty is precisely this number.
- Zoro:200,000,000 Berries. (Fujitora will witness Zoro's skill and see to it that his bounty reflects his threat level it will also further drive home the fact that Killer is his Evil Counterpart)
- The WMG undersold Zoro: his bounty was raised to as much as 320,000,000 berries.
- Sanji:195,000,000 Berries.(He receive this when word gets out about him wreaking havoc on Big Mom's ship)
- Only 177,000,000 Berries. But as a point of special interest, Sanji's bounty says he's wanted "only alive".
- Robin:160,000,000 Berries.(The Marines will find out that she is connected with the revolutionaries)
- Only 133,000,000 Berries.
- Franky:134,000,000 Berries. (For having Dr.Vegapunk's laser technology)
- Only 94,000,000 Berries. He does not like this much.
- Ussop:100,000,000 Berries.(He was Doflamingo's number one target, and the marines will acknowledge him as a threat. Besides, he claimed to have Luffy's bounty at some point, which probably means he will receive Luffy's bounties in rising order. No clue how far up he'll get though. Remember, every lie Ussop tells comes true at some point.)
- Usopp's bounty has risen as high as 200,000,000 Berries.
- Brook:66,000,000 Berries. (Will receive this for fighting on Big Mom's ship)
- More than that - Brook's new bounty is 83,000,000 Berries.
- Chopper:50,000,000 Berries. (Will receive this when the WG realizes he isn't a pet after he fights on Big Mom's ship)
- Nope, they have not realized it yet - Chopper's bounty has doubled to 100 Berries.
- Nami:46,000,000 Berries. (Will receive this for fighting on Big Mom's ship)
- Alternatively Nami will remain at her current bounty because she doesn't take part in the fight and remains on Sunny to watch Momo
- Nami is worth as high as 66,000,000 Berries, so the above guess is jossed.
- Total Bounty: 1,451,000,000 Berries.
- The WMG was very close - the total bounty was 1,556,000,100 Berries. The more precise numbers fluctuate, either over- or underestimating the bounties of the characters, but in the end it the grand total was a pretty good guess.
- Slight problem with that. Robin's bounty would be higher than Sanji's, considering how big of a deal the Revolutionary Army is. The fact that Robin would have more dirt against the World Government, not to mention how Sabo is there to confirm the threat of said Revolutionaries, would reflect upon Robin's percieved Force of Nature status, thus necessitating her a bounty rise. Her bounty and Sanji's bounty would probably be reverse of what you listed.
- Jossed. Sanji's bounty has risen higher than Robin's now.
- It's also unlikely the crew on the Thousand Sunny will receive a raise, as the marines have no way of knowing what happened on the ship. Besides, no one on Big Mom's side was defeated, as far as we know. Caesar only said they barely got away. Most like, only the members on Dressrosa will receive higher bounties and updated pictures, as they are the ones who changed the most during the timeskip.
- Jossed. The Thousand Sunny crew was raised along with the rest.
- OP here, overall I only got Luffy's bounty correct so I moved this to the Jossed section.
- Jossed? Confirmed? It's interesting how this WMG is worded; it would seem that the marines indeed treated him (since he has a bandage on his head). Meaning... they made sure he was alive to see justice (as you said) so there's no way to actually know if he would have died or not. So... Jossed? Jossed.
- Jossed. They joined as allies.
- Possibly jossed. Bellamy states that while he can't believe Doflamingo would betray him, he respects him far too much to actually stand against him. Time will tell, though...
- Definitely jossed. After Doflamingo's defeat, Bellamy declined joining the Straw Hat Grand Fleet and opted to be an independent pirate who's simply Luffy's friend.
- I find this unlikely. People have survived worse in this series.
- Yeah, except Doflamingo only survived getting his organs fucked up by the Gamma knife by using his Strings to stitch them back together. Besides, This injury is on top of being Red hawked, hit by 5-8 Gear 2 attacks and getting wrecked by Gear 4, attacks that are likely to be much stronger than Gear 3 since they come at at Gear 2 speed. If the bird cage is deactivated, then the Strings holding Doffy's organs are deactivated, causing him to bleed out from the inside. Sure, people have survived things such as haki imbued light speed kicks, Near fatal poisoning, getting frozen in a series where harmless freezing is averted, recoil from a reject dial, getting decked by magma. But remember that the characters still need their organs to survive. Monet died not from getting cut up, but by getting her heart shanked. Ace getting his insides incinerated after getting impaled had a delayed death. Doffy can survive getting his bones broken, but I doubt he can survive having his organs torn apart. Hell, if you look at the most recent chapter, he is barely alive to the point that only one more attack from Luffy will knock him out, undo the stitching, and kill him quite painfully.
- As a side note, Luffy is very much beyond pissed at this point, and an angry enough Luffy will straight up KILL those who try to murder those considered his friends (Just ask Baron from Movie 6.)
- This is unlikely to be the case. Movies are non-canon, and general idea is that Luffy defeats his enemies, shatters their dream (if they had one), but doesn't intentionally go for the kill. Probably only Robin and Law are capable of a premeditated murder on "Luffy side".
- Personally, if he survives those injuries, I'm gonna say Ass Pull. Even if Movie 6 is non canon, it is still a fairly realistic portrayal of what Luffy would do if he believes someone murdered his True Companions. Hell, even if Luffy doesn't kill Doffy, Law will make sure he dies unless Luffy stops him. I'm just sayin, Doffy would be very lucky if he survives having his organs torn apart after stitching them together.
- Plotwise, what's the point of him dying? Luffy just need to get rid of him, not necessarily killing him. If he lives, we could see more about his plan about Ope-ope, Marijoa's treasure; or we could have him appeared later on (like Crocodile) maybe in the final war.
- Even if Luffy won't kill him, Law sure as hell will kill him off. I didn't see a doctor in Doffy's crew that can repair the organ damage.
- Yeah, except Doflamingo only survived getting his organs fucked up by the Gamma knife by using his Strings to stitch them back together. Besides, This injury is on top of being Red hawked, hit by 5-8 Gear 2 attacks and getting wrecked by Gear 4, attacks that are likely to be much stronger than Gear 3 since they come at at Gear 2 speed. If the bird cage is deactivated, then the Strings holding Doffy's organs are deactivated, causing him to bleed out from the inside. Sure, people have survived things such as haki imbued light speed kicks, Near fatal poisoning, getting frozen in a series where harmless freezing is averted, recoil from a reject dial, getting decked by magma. But remember that the characters still need their organs to survive. Monet died not from getting cut up, but by getting her heart shanked. Ace getting his insides incinerated after getting impaled had a delayed death. Doffy can survive getting his bones broken, but I doubt he can survive having his organs torn apart. Hell, if you look at the most recent chapter, he is barely alive to the point that only one more attack from Luffy will knock him out, undo the stitching, and kill him quite painfully.
- He was captured alive.
- I'd just consider the arc ended by chapter 800, so jossed.
- Amazingly, this entire point has been brought up by Fujitora himself, who even went so far as to tell them to form their own government. This theory might end up confirmed.
- Jossed, given they planned to attend the reverie.
- Alternatively, Law will attempt it before Doflamingo is defeated, but Luffy will regain his strength just in time to stop Law from throwing his life away (because a shonen series with an immortal protagonist would be dull).
- Jossed
He strives to defend his kingdom as much as Riku, and is a warrior so he won't fall because of the pacifism that allowed Riku to be manipulated. Plus, his entire arc has been Kyros learning You Are Better Than You Think You Are. What better way to exemplify that then to go from hated street thug to revered king.
- Wouldn't Viola be next in line for the throne, though?
- Depending on succession laws in Dressrosa (often the older sibling having a child places that child above the younger sibling in the line of succession), it'd be either her or Rebecca, yes. Though that doesn't mean they wouldn't try to crown Kyros regardless.
- Viola would probably consider herself disqualified (and might have difficulty finding acceptance) due to her years of collaborating with Doflamingo.
- Scarlet, and through her Rebecca, may also have been legally disqualified by Scarlet's faking her death since, from that moment on, Viola would have been the legal heir to the throne.
- According to the latest chapter, Rebecca is next for the throne after King Riku.
- Jossed; he decides to stay away and distance himself from Dressrosa due to his criminal past; Rebecca throws away her status as princess so they can live together, and the citizens are aware of it but pretend not to know, out of respect.
- Not exactly, they are all SH fanboys.
- Jossed. Neither of them got lucky, hilarity didn't ensue.
- Wrong and impossible. The Ohara incident happened after Gol D. Roger's execution, during which Dragon was already a criminal. Plus, the reason why he only asked about Robin is because he had already heard plenty enough about Luffy from Sabo.
- Jossed. We got a detailed enough look at both their current operations in the Dressrosa Arc (especially Doflamingo's). They don't seem to be working together.
- ...if this doesn't turn out to be canon, I'd be very surprised.
- Comedic quirks have been put through Cerebus Retcon before. Baby 5 came from being regarded as useless by her family and Senor Pink came from his son dying and his wife becoming vegetative so he made her laugh by wearing his son's cloths.
- Jossed. Doflamingo met Sanji in person at Dressrosa and they had nothing personal to say to each other.
- Franky did make modifications. The Brachio Tank V and the Kurosai FR-U IV were upgrades. Plus, there may be others that just haven't been touched on yet.
- No no, those are just additional vehicles like the Mini Merry and Shark Submerge. I'm talking about upgrading the Sunny itself.
- Jossed
- Jossed. The Mink (Wanda) is being pretty straightforward with them, not to mention Nami is alive and well. Maybe she just borrowed some of her clothes?
- Jossed. It's still vague, but from the way the Straw Hats talked, it seems like he's simply left for somewhere. Or, at the very least, their calmness implies he's unharmed.
- Jossed. Jack is someone different entirely. See here
- (Not the original WMG poster here.) I think you're 100% on the mark. That Brook and Momonosuke are also missing indicates they're up to something pervy. This is reinforced by Wanda's mention of how some Minks are attracted to humans. There is no way Sanji is dead, or we'd have seen it at the end of the chapter. Rather, Sanji, and probably Brook and Momonosuke, are surrounded by beautiful Mink women. Nami feels strongly about it all, Sanji first and foremost, because Sanji's stopped paying attention to her.
- Jossed. As of this writing, we still don't know exactly what happened to him; but, both Nami and Brook himself actually assure Luffy that Sanji is in a serious situation.
- At this point, it's completely Jossed. Sanji is forced into an Arranged Marriage, his last name is revealed to be Vinsmoke (apparently part of a noble family), and he kept Nami, Chopper and Brook out of being captured in order to keep them out of the past that's catching up to him.
- Coby told Zoro, when he was tied up by the marines, that only Luffy could save Zoro and only Zoro could save Luffy. Possible allusion towards both their mental states after this current arc.
- He has spent the timeskip with Mihawk, training on his home island. aferwards he seems to be rather calm and stable, but he is also a lot more uncaring to bystanders, like slicing that ship with no excuse and a remark that it was "fate". In other words, tough luck, loser. he still cares for his true companions though. Only time will tell where he will go from now on.
- Jossed. It would seem this WMG was made during the intermission before the Timeskip, and since that's going on six years ago now, he didn't snap "fairly soon" (if at all).
- Jossed. Turns out this is a natural feature of Bepo's race.
- Jossed. Kinemon himself actually asks the Monkey, who's name is Bariete, if he's seen Raizou. Not to mention the Monkey is a Mink and plans on ratting the Samurais out. His job is to guard the gates of the Mokomo Dukedom
- While this would make sense, it's sorta ruined when you learn that Buggy was on a ship just because he wanted to be a pirate. He had no real goal. Usopp has many goals, from becoming a great warrior like his father, to becoming the greatest sniper, to finding the Warrior Paradise. Buggy was really more along for the ride.
- Er - When they reached the Grand Line and did the foot-on-the-barrel oaths, Usopp's was "become a brave warrior of the sea." He wants to do the other things mostly for the purpose of being a great pirate. He certainly has more depth than that (perhaps by dint of being on Luffy's crew; we don't know much about the dynamic on Roger's), but if you were to give a one-sentence summary of his motivation...
- Usopp is physically the weakest of the Straw Hats, but I'd definitely hesitate to rank him as the least effective combatant. His sharpshooting talent, technological advanced arsenal, and tactical ingenuity make him a good guy to have at your back in a fight. Buggy on the other hand seems to have been just a nobody on Roger's crew.
- Buggy's love of treasure, willingness to rob his own crew, and possession of the Map that lead into the Grand Line suggest that he's something of a dark reprise on NAMI, of all people.
- True but if you look at the Strawhats and say "There's an enemy fleet" who's the most likely to have a freak out?
- Chopper, And Nami, as well as Ussop. The weakling Trio are the ones who freak out because they aren't the main fighters. That's all
- also, Ussop is no longer afraid of enemies by the look of the Fishman Island Arc. He's scared of environmental things and forces of nature (angry yonkou must count as this) but he quite happily took on Hordy's forces, even when Hordy himself was on hand to back them up, as well as running back into an army to fight them some more. He's got better.
- I'd count this as Jossed. Usopp has already and is continuing to go down a different path character wise than Buggy.
- Also Usopp has Observation Haki, making him the 4th Straw Hat to have it
- Probably Jossed. Dragon and Smoker were actually both present at Roger's execution; Smoker was just some kid and Dragon was already an adult and wearing revolutionary garb. Intergenerational Friendship is technically possible but ehhh... that's kind of pushing it.
- Well, I don't know if Oda got them "mixed up" in some way, but the second part of this is Jossed. Raizou doesn't have a ponytail.
- Jossed. He was not captured and he's on his own ship. He also tried to kill Zunisha but the elephant swatted him (and his fleet)sending everyone to the bottom of the ocean
- Jossed. It's red because it's one of four Road Poneglyphs, which tell the location of Raftel when combined. The color has nothing to do with the fact that Zou is a living island.
- Maybe in the past, but as of chapter 659 he is on Punk Hazard
- Jossed.
- It might also explain why he decided to take the Samurai along. Maybe in part due to respecting him wanting to save his kid at all costs, and in part due to knowing that this is what his upbringing taught him was right.
- At two points Sanji has specifically stated that he was born in the north blue, so no.
- While true, we haven't learned anything else about him before he and Zeff met. Maybe his parents are from Wano and moved to North Blue for some reason. Otherwise, there's isn't much of a reason for Sanji to know about Wano itself, let alone that a "topknot" is a typical hairstyle there. Before it's mentioned, yes, Brooke did mention that there's a Samurai nation somewhere. However, he only had brief knowledge of the place due to even the marines not being allowed there. There's also a slight possibility that Wano is in North Blue, making everything fit together somehow. Remember, we never saw any of the other Blues other than East.
- Nope, Wano is in the New World. Read One Piece - Wanted!, it tells about Ryuuma, who was a samurai from the country of Wano. It is stated to be in the New World. I think Hogback mentions it in the Thriller Bark Arc as well when he talks about Ryuuma's zombie.
- At two points Sanji has specifically stated that he was born in the north blue, so no.
- Jossed, a long time ago actually. Sorry. [[spoilers: Sanji is descended from North-Blue royalty so.]]
- Jossed. Law recruiting people had nothing to do with his plan to be a Warlord. If you were implying his new crewmates were the ones he took the hearts from, we now know that isn't true since they've finally reappeared in the story (and, furthermore, events in the Dressrosa Arc show that Law wouldn't be the type of guy to do that).
- Very much so. Laws crew is alive and well (somewhat battered but) when they encounter Luffy in a forest on Zou.
- Jossed; Oda confirmed in an interview that the One Piece is a physical reward.
- This is highly unlikely. For one thing, the original premise for this is Jossed completely, considering Kin'emon isn't even Momo's real father. Now if Momo's real father, Oden, just so happened to have had an affair with the shogun's wife, then this is technically still possible; so, it's not quite Jossed yet, but the odds are against it. For one thing, Oda likely wouldn't get into the whole "romance affair" thing for a source of drama. Also, we know that the shogun did have Oden killed, but for political reasons.
- As shown in chapters 818 and 819, this is completely jossed. Both of Momo's parents were done in by Kaido and the shogun, and the reason had nothing to do with an affair, but rather the fact that Oden set foot on Raftel and learned the world's true history.
- Honestly, it's hard to understand why someone thinks Trebol is logia-type. Author words: "logia fruit makes you a force of nature" (from the same explanation: Whitebeard is paramecia-type because he creates quakes, not becomes one). "Stickiness" is no large-scale natural phenomenon.
- Jossed, It's a paramecia that he makes to look like a logia
- Isn't it jossed already? As far as we know, only one man can have power of a given fruit at any given moment. Also, having logia families around would be a big deal.
- Of the named Corrida Colosseum combatants, only two of them completely vanished after their defeat: Jean Ango and Acilia. Everyone else was at least present in crowd scenes after Usopp restored everyone turned into toys. While Acilia's whereabouts are unaccounted for and I have no explanation, Jean is a bounty hunter and has most likely followed the Thousand Sunny between when he was restored and when the Birdcage went up in order to claim the bounties on Sanji, Brook, Nami, and maybe Chopper. Jean is way out of their league though, and is probably lying bleeding and humiliated somewhere on the Thousand Sunny, on his own ship, or on Zou. What happened during then will be explained in a chapter title page story.
- Jossed. The Straw Hats have been on Zou for a while chapter-wise,, and there's been no mention of him at all.
- Jossed. Sanji's father Judge is the head of a family of assassins, as well as a mysterious army. The reason why Sanji is only wanted alive is suspected by him to be because of his Arranged Marriage.
- Jossed. He's been kidnapped by the Big Mom Pirates and their allies the Firetank Pirates.
- According to Word of God, that shape is actually the traditional shape for Jolly Roger type symbols in North Blue. So all that means is that Whitebeard is also from North Blue originally.
- Jossed. We know just about everything about Law's life now, and there's nothing that connects him to Whitebeard. Besides, if Law was that close to Whitebeard, he almost certainly would have been on the front lines in the Battle of Marineford.
- By proving that they're only capable of getting anything done via underhanded tactics? Sounds like a great way to shoot themselves in the foot. Again.
- Jossed. He's built a rather large pirate hunting business as a Warlord these past two years. If they were gonna kill him for being a Roger Pirate, they'd have done it already.
- If by "Animal Island" arc you mean Zou, it's jossed; the reason why he can't hit a woman was never brought up. Besides, Oda stared that it was more due to his upbringing than anything; if he's going to give more details about that, it won't be in the Zou arc, which is almost/pretty much over.
- More hearts don't increase the amount of blood in your body. It's produced by the bone marrow.
- It would pump the blood faster. But either way, this seems incredibly unlikely.
- Jossed.
- Jossed. It's not only alive, but also sentient, and can die.
- It is supposed to say Dead or Alive. That'll be the biggest troll Oda pulled though.
- Jossed
- Jossed so far, unless the Straw Hat meet him again
- Jossed so hard. Kin'nemon really IS a ninja.
- Jossed. While it's too early to tell whether it's the other way around or the Revolutionaries were at least able to put up a good fight, Baltigo was destroyed by the Blackbeard Pirates, so Dragon didn't crush them at all.
- Jossed, it lasted only 21 chapters.
- Jossed. He's not doing anything about Doflamingo. All he has to say about him is that it's a shame he's so "weak".
- One of Kaido's top officials Jack "the Drought" was one who tried to retrieve Doflamingo.
- Jossed to holy hell.
- Bepo is interested in girl bears. Must have been a pervert.
- Jossed he's part of the Mink race.
- Well, it can't be jossed until the Pirate Alliance Saga is over, but...the fruit was confirmed as being created by Vegapunk. There's no reason to assume that's not true, especially since Doflamingo has shown no ability for science or anything like that. Also, a huge part of why he was so mad at Law for kidnapping Caesar is that he needed him to make the devil fruits, so it's not likely he can just make them himself. Also, the connection was actually summed up as just being that Momonosuke once snuck up on Doffy in Dressrosa and saw him torturing a man, which traumatized him.
- Jossed: Vegapunk is the one who made it.
- Jossed. Carrots more likely.
- Coby told Zoro, when he was tied up by the marines, that only Luffy could save Zoro and only Zoro could save Luffy. Possible allusion towards both their mental states after this current arc.
- He has spent the timeskip with Mihawk, training on his home island. afterwards he seems to be rather calm and stable, but he is also a lot more uncaring to bystanders, like slicing that ship with no excuse and a remark that it was "fate". In other words, tough luck, loser. he still cares for his true companions though. Only time will tell where he will go from now on.
- Jossed. It would seem this WMG was made during the intermission before the Timeskip, and since that's going on six years ago now, he didn't snap "fairly soon" (if at all).
- This can be jossed now since we recently learned that Awakened Zoans are a form of Devil fruit Awakening for Zoans, We also got a Paramecia Awakening from Doffy in the form of turning everything into strings.
The theory is this: The reason why the ability of a devil fruit can't be discerned before it's eaten is that it doesn't have any specific ability, just a raw power. The ability that will be given is chosen the moment that someone takes the first bite, based off of the personality of the person who eats it. This would also explain why the fruit doesn't work for anyone else after it's been partially eaten; the fruit "imprints" itself on the first person to take a bite.
- Actually, a devil fruit's ability can be discerned before it's eaten. Blackbeard stated he killed Thatch and stole his devil fruit specifically because he knew it was the Yami Yami fruit. And I believe Sanji mentioned there was some sort of catalog with various devil fruits listed in them.
- Not necessarily. He could have been misinformed, but because it was the fruit he wanted so much, it's what he ended up with anyway. Also, could you provide a link about the catalog?
- Sanji mentions the book/catalog in chapter 464. See also the One Piece wiki on Devil Fruit indentification Identification here.
- Not necessarily. He could have been misinformed, but because it was the fruit he wanted so much, it's what he ended up with anyway. Also, could you provide a link about the catalog?
- Shanks and his crew already knew what the Gomu Gomu no Mi could do before Luffy ate it.
- Blackbeard was also looking for the the one he ate for decades. That's why he became part of Whitebeard's crew in the first place.
- By proving that they're only capable of getting anything done via underhanded tactics? Sounds like a great way to shoot themselves in the foot. Again.
- Jossed. He's built a rather large pirate hunting business as a Warlord these past two years. If they were gonna kill him for being a Roger Pirate, they'd have done it already.
- Jossed, the replacements are Fujitora (Gravity man) and Ryokugyu (Power unknown)
- Uh...one problem...Brook wasn't from Roger's crew. He was a part of the Rumbar Pirates. Crocus was there because that's where he lived before the Roger Pirates came through. Crocus left Laboon for the 3 years that he traveled. Since Brook refers to Roger as being an amateur in his day, it's assumed that Roger conquered the seas for...about 30 years. Maybe the 3 year journey Crocus went on was Roger's last one so Roger could hide the One Piece that was the treasure, if that makes sense.
- Franky did make modifications. The Brachio Tank V and the Kurosai FR-U IV were upgrades. Plus, there may be others that just haven't been touched on yet.
- No no, those are just additional vehicles like the Mini Merry and Shark Submerge. I'm talking about upgrading the Sunny itself.
- Jossed
- As if he would be given the offer in the first place, given the fact he has been a huge thorn in the WG's side. Unless of course, Garp has something to do with it.
- He's his father's son after all and the WG will never forget that, even if he wasn't causing the WG any problems.
- Later events make this likely Jossed. That character is now an ally of the Strawhats.
- Jossed. Law recruiting people had nothing to do with his plan to be a Warlord. If you were implying his new crewmates were the ones he took the hearts from, we now know that isn't true since they've finally reappeared in the story (and, furthermore, events in the Dressrosa Arc show that Law wouldn't be the type of guy to do that).
- Pluton was built in Water 7 hundreds of years ago, way before Dr Vegapunk's time. And it has been confirmed to be some sort of a warship.
- Jossed. Drake is [[spoiler working for Kaidou nowadays, who's Law's target, so he's probably not in an alliance with him]]. And Kid didn't even know what emperor Law was going after, so we know he's not working with him either.
- also currently Kid is under the [Sarcam Mode]: tender loving care of the Yonko Kaido .
- Well, it technically is still possible... but this is probably supremely pre-Jossed at the moment due to evidence. Revolutionaries Sabo and Koala show up in Dressrosa and make no mention of Law in their plans or even seem to know him so far. It's also been heavily implied at this point that Law was only using the "take down Kaido" ploy to get Luffy to join him in defeating Doflamingo, his real goal. Furthermore, Law's hatred for the government is due to them helping the leaders of his Doomed Hometown escape while they allowed neighboring towns to slaughter them under the false pretense that Amber Lead poisoning was contagious- all of which lead to his family's deaths. Lastly, Law has already confirmed that his crew is alive.
- In the latest chapter, 692, there is some focus on a "Jack" character during a meeting with the Underworld Brokers. One of them suggests to bear the bad news to some "Jack" character, while one responds that they'd be in deep trouble if they did. My guess is that Jack is either A) Doflamingo's main ally outside of his crew itself, or B) An entirely different Broker who is (POSSIBLY) a rival with Doffy.
- what is also noticable is that in the panel to the left is another clue that one of the brokers we have been seeing is Rob Lucci,(apart from his long curly hair and top hat) specifically the one who said "it's probably the 'league' inform the whole world, this isn't just a problem for the underworld anymore". if you look closely, the man that he is talking to could very easily be Blueno.
- Jossed, Jack works for Kaido.
- Couldn't he just use those same SMILES to keep appeasing Kaido for a while?
- Jossed he's got a one way ticket to Impel-Down.
- The real reason is because his executives have reinforced his massive ego and sociopathy when he was young due to his willpower
- Actually, his fruit is a result of everyone being so loyal to him, being a gift from Trebol.
- He left the government when he was a Rear Admiral likely because he couldn't stand working for them, so it would be out of character to go back and work for the organization he left. So kinda jossed. Plus he's working for Kaido as of right now.
- Definitely jossed the last Shichibukai Edward Weevil the so called "Whitebeard Jr."
- Jossed. Luffy's Gum Gum Fruit has been confirmed as a Paramecia many times. There are several things that make it not a Logia. He can't generate limitless amounts of rubber nor move it by itself without force like all Logias have shown the ability to do. His body can also be hurt by plain blunt attacks (Lucci, anyone?), which is major evidence against him being Logia; even solid Logias like Aokiji's ice and Crocodile's sand aren't hurt by plain blunt attacks, they don't even feel them. Also, there are other Paramecias that are permanently "on" at all times, like Buggy's Chop Chop fruit (after all, he can't "turn off" his body splitting up when it gets cut, as shown when Mihawk cut him by surprise).
- Uh, isn't plant and animal are different?
- Probably Jossed since we found out Bepo is a Minkman.
- Jossed. That would mean that Law would've had to come in close contact with Dellinger and Monet at the same time, but we know Law only recently met Monet and gave her the harpy legs while on Punk Hazard and he hadn't been in contact with any Donquixote pirates before that for 13 years.
- That seems really unlikely. Bellemeré found Nami when she was just a baby and Luffy is a year younger than her, meaning Bellemeré would have been pregnant when she adopted the girls. Nojiko would have been old enough to recognize a pregnancy, and it would just be weird that she'd never think to mention that their mother had given birth within a few months of adopting them.
- I'd say this is Jossed; the evidence against it is too much for it to make sense without a major retcon. Also, they were on two completely different islands.
- Jossed
- Seems quite unlikely by now, since we still haven't seen them.
- It doesn't seem likely, she was nowhere near Dressrosa.
- Plus, it took a Gear 4th Luffy to do much damage.
- Jossed
- Jossed to holy hell.
- HIGHLY unlikely, if not outright Jossed. Kuina is the sensei's daughter, and it's very unlikely that he'd do something like that.
- Jossed
- Jossed for now
- Bepo is interested in girl bears. Must have been a pervert.
- Jossed. He's a Mink.
- Jossed. He ate the Kame Kame no Mi (Turtle-Turtle Fruit), which is standard. The fruit combines with him being a lion does make him resemble a tarasque, though.
- Jossed. Pluton is already confirmed to be a warship.
- WTF? Impossible, Sanji never met Kuina, let alone had a role in her death.
- Well, it can't be jossed until the Pirate Alliance Saga is over, but...the fruit was confirmed as being created by Vegapunk. There's no reason to assume that's not true, especially since Doflamingo has shown no ability for science or anything like that. Also, a huge part of why he was so mad at Law for kidnapping Caesar is that he needed him to make the devil fruits, so it's not likely he can just make them himself. Also, the connection was actually summed up as just being that Momonosuke once snuck up on Doffy in Dressrosa and saw him torturing a man, which traumatized him.
- Jossed.
- Doubt it. We have seen how much Monet treasures her life. Also, that would mean Law already knew he will get caught.
- Her being killed meant failing the mission which was given to her by Joker, and it was simply unacceptable. If she was killed by Law, it would have left both base and Caesar unprotected and being in danger of being destroyed by Law and anyone else (Straw Hats in that certain day). And while Law didn't know that Vergo arrived, he could predict that something would go wrong, he is constantly portrayed as Chessmaster through this saga, who always plans one step forward or even two. Besides if it was not Law telling Monet to do this, every other way it doesn't make sense either, because Law couldn't do it by himself without being prepared, and even with being prepared, having everyone watching him and him being chained would have stopped him from doing it by himself. Not only that, but the manga panel implied that it was Monet, and Monet herself was undoubtedly loyal to Joker and couldn't assist Straw Hats by her own will, even if she wanted to help them or children. Plus I just don't see what could be the request of Law, if not that. What another ability could Monet lend to him?
- Jossed
- The story is currently taking place on the wastelands of Punk Hazard inhabited by mythological creatures and a shady organization (which dosen't seem to be connected to the WG) of strange looking man in hazmat suits and their mysterious leader "M". It probably would have been another fine day of conspiracy and morally questionable experiments for the, had they not made the mistake of choosing the Strawhats as their newest guinea pigs (how the hell did they not recognize them anyway?). The next logical step is of course that the Strawhats unite and reduce their face, their base and probably half of the island into finely ground dust. However, Smoker's ship is anchored right next to the island and will undoubtedly report the awesome battle he witnessed. Wheter he does it right away,or after engaging Luffy and (finally)getting his ass kicked is a different WMG.
- Except that it seemed Punk Hazard is going to be no where near as easy as Fishman Island. And currently Luffy and Law are both down, while Smoker and Sanji are somewhat crippled (...by Law).
- Nico Robin had a higher bounty than Luffy initially, so your logic isn't sound.
- Well it depends on how you count it because while she joined while his bounty was 30 million his bounty was raised to 100 million right after she joined
- Jossed, he got a raise after Dressrosa
- Koala would be what...30? By now? Just about...Would be interesting to see that, really. But she might just get a cameo as a revolutionary. Knowing Oda, that's very likely, actually.
- Koala is 23... I think? If I'm not mistaken, her flashback was from 12 years ago. We need more crew member that has some kind of emotional connection with the fishmen, but no really important whether the crew is a fishmen or no. By having a human with that kind of ideal has more impact because after the Straw Hats action against Hody, the only people who still have doubt of human-fishmen co-exist are humans themselves. Seeing one of them has that kind of view surely shaken them up.
- I agree with the view that Jinbe would be a better fit for having the whole "dream to unite Fishmen and humans" as well as having a better reason to be with the Straw Hat crew itself to begin with (considering how close he feels to Luffy and how guilty he feels for Arlong's treatment of Nami). Then there's also a WMG near the top of this page outlining Jinbe joining the crew - see above.
- Shirahoshi could also fit that bill, with previous WMG putting her on potential true companion shortlist. Who better to fulfill her mother's dream of experiencing all humanity has to offer than her previously-isolated daughter?
- But what would Shirahoshi contribute to the Straw Hats? Plus, she's too big to fit on the Thousand Sunny anyway, and besides, she'd be in constant danger from persons who'd want to sell mermaids as slaves. Again, I believe Jinbe is a better fit (he at least has experience on board ships, and can certainly defend himself well enough).
- 1. Shirahoshi was shown in chapter 625 to have a legendary power over Sea Kings. 2. She's a gigantic mermaid. She could probably outpace the Thousand Sunny. 3. Shirahoshi won't be in any more danger from wannabe slavers than Luffy was for punching a world noble in the face. 4. We don't know how well Shirahoshi can defend herself. This is One Piece, for crying out loud. Being a sheltered crybaby doesn't prevent her from being a badass any more than Usopp's cowardice or Foxy's lack of confidence makes them pushovers. 5. Most importantly, the Straw Hats still need a counterpart for San Juan Wolf.
- Chapter 626 mentions a prophesy that someone will appear to guide Shirahoshi and help her change the world. If that's not Foreshadowing then I don't know what is.
- But what would Shirahoshi contribute to the Straw Hats? Plus, she's too big to fit on the Thousand Sunny anyway, and besides, she'd be in constant danger from persons who'd want to sell mermaids as slaves. Again, I believe Jinbe is a better fit (he at least has experience on board ships, and can certainly defend himself well enough).
- Unlikely, since [[she's a revolutionary. Hats off to the guy above who got that right]].
- I'd put it in Jossed I guess
- Sabo has been found alive, but doesn't look like he's joining
- Jossed, he seemed too busy in the Revolutionary
- Alternatively, he's going to get kidnapped and enslaved by the World Nobles.
- Or, he betrays Ace and Luffy.
- Before Ace died, he mentioned Sabo as one of his good friends.
- More proof: Sabo was part of the brothers ceremony thereby becoming one of Luffy's brothers; yet Luffy specifically stated during the War on Marineford, "Ace is the only brother I have in the world."
- Confirmed, his ship was blown up.
- This may be on its way to being jossed now that Chapter 668's page shows that someone has brought the news of the Straw Hats' return, as if telling Ace that his brother is fine. To top it off, nearby, there's a bottle and three sake cups.
- With Chapter 731, NOW FULLY JOSSED.
- It's likely that they aren't intending to fight her at all right now; remember that the crew is only at half strength (plus help from Pedro, Carrot, and potentially Pekoms) and, even if they had the whole crew with them, they're not going to try and screw with one Emperor when they've already pissed off another one. This mission isn't going to be one where they fight (much); it's gonna be one where they extract Sanji and then get the hell out because Charlotte Linlin is gonna go berserk.
- OP here, jossing my own theory. The Straw Hats have reached Whole Cake Island, and Big Mom's still there.
- I don't get it though, she WAS a beautiful-lady-swordsmen-with-meat in that situation...
- I know, I just that Rebecca had so much hype,but turn out to be a disappointment
- I'm just going to count this as jossed since Rebecca was indeed a beautiful-lady-swordsman-with-meat (regardless of her competence). There will probably be another one though.
- Jossed so far.
- Diamond is just crystallized Carbon which has a density of 3,500, fairly middle of the road density (Osmium and Iridium are the most dense). Diamond is the HARDEST substance, but it is not the TOUGHEST (a regular hammer can smash Diamond.) Also, it melts at 4200K (meaning a Cyanogen fire can melt it) and is a good conducter. Basically, a character with Fire powers or lightning powers can screw him up.
- Jossed by the narration's own declaration that Kaido is actually the strongest creature alive. Besides, I think a giant or any other really strong character would have been able to lift that iceberg. I mean, this is One Piece and science only goes so far to explain the things in the series- if the muscles of mid-tier characters like the pre-timeskip CP9 in this universe can be tightened to be stronger than steel, there's no reason to assume that the top tiers would have any troubles with muscle durability. I mean, do any of us REALLY believe that Kaido wouldn't be able to lift that iceberg?
- Also, lastly, the logic behind this doesn't work because Jozu is a Paramecia, not a Logia; He covers his body in diamond, he isn't actually made of diamonds.