Details on what actually happened…
- While the three stories do contradict each other at parts, these are the consistent facts we have so far.
- Applejack drove the ship for most of the trip.
- Rarity did bring a dish of sorts, among them cucumber sandwiches.
- Pinkie brought snacks of her own.
- Rarity's food goes overboard.
- A series of bubbles follow, heralding the bunyip.
- Pinkie sets up a fish pinata and offers the stick to Rarity.
- Applejack's eyes get (partially) covered for a while.
- The waters get turbulent.
- The three ponies all pull at the map.
- The map is lost.
- The ship gets capsized.
- The three surface, never having gotten far from the dock.
While we get a summary of what basically actually happened, we don't know the truthful details. So let's start guessing!
- Joe Mudd 123: Rarity's account of Pinkie's actions is correct, as is Pinkie's account of Applejack's. Rarity's speech is exaggerated in Applejack's story, but her actions are accurate.