The toys were not incredibly popular at first outside Ty's home market of Chicago. Starting in late 1995-early 1996, the line suddenly grew in popularity, in part due to the marketing strategies of selling them only at small gift shops for $5-$6 each. Furthermore, the company began regularly retiring existing Beanies and introducing new ones. Adding some fuel to the fire was the introduction of the first exclusive-release Beanie, Maple the Bear (sold only in Canada). It was also in 1996 that the toys first included birthdays and short, four-line poems on their tags. In 1997 through 2000, McDonald's jumped on the bandwagon as well, including fun-size "Teenie Beanies" with Happy Meals.
The Beanie Babies franchise remained popular into the 2000s, including an incredible stunt in 1999 when a bear named "The End" was released and Ty decided to let collectors decide whether or not to end the entire line.
Throughout the 2000s, the Beanie Baby franchise did see some decline in popularity, but the toys are still sold, played with, and collected. There are still plenty of retired Beanies who can fetch a pretty penny on the market these days.
The big kids craze after Pogs and before Pokémon.
In 2023, as a Milestone Celebration for the toys' 30th anniversary, Ty rereleased several classic Beanie Babies, primarily from the 90snote with softer fabric and, in most cases, different color schemes (i.e. Patti II being orange-and-teal instead of pink-and-yellow like the original).
Not to be confused with Beanie Kids, an Australian toy. Ty did release their own Beanie Kids line, however.
Tropes present:
- Aerith and Bob: Most of the names are very cartoonish (Bumble, Dizzy, etc.), but there are some with more realistic names such as Erin or Scottie.
- An Aesop: The Beanie Baby "Lucky" the ladybug has a short poem about not spending your money to play the lottery.
- Amazing Technicolor Wildlife: Zig-zagged. Some are realistically colored and designed; others are more cartoonish and less realistically colored, such as certain variants of Dizzy the Dalmatian.
- Ambiguous Gender: Some Beanies' sexes are never stated in their poems. Usually this is because the poem is in first-person, but other times they just manage to get to four lines without using a pronoun. Some are still obvious anyway due to either their names, or other biological traits (for example, all of the kangaroos are assumed to be female since they all have joeys in their pouches).
- Artistic License – Biology: There are a few examples of this. For instance:
- Seaweed the Otter is holding a piece of seaweed in her paws, and her poem mentions that she likes eating it. Otters are carnivorous.
- Double-subverted with Runner, whose species is only given as mustelidae (i.e., weasel family), an unusually prominent example of Shown Their Work on a toy. However, its poem says it can be a "ferret, mongoose, weasel, or mink"; mongoose are in their own family, which is more related to felines than anything else. The inclusion of mongoose may be because it originally was a mongoose, but it shipped with a "mean poem" about killing snakes.
- Bare-Bottomed Monkey: Cheeks the Mandrill, whose name is a pun on the trope and whose poem specifically mentions his colorful bare behind.
- Bedsheet Ghost: Sheets, who is the typical cartoon ghost, wearing a hooded robe.
- Bowdlerize: Runner's original poem was very violent, describing his obsession with murdering cobras, grabbing their heads and whacking them until they die. It was later changed to a much less gruesome one about the vagueness of his species.
- Composite Character: Bananas II is named after the orangutan Beanie Baby from 2000, though he resembles a Palette Swap of Schweetheart more.
- Cunning Like a Fox: Well, it is named Sly, and his poem says "tricky is he." Even Snocap the Arctic Fox is "very sly."
- Cute Kitten: A LOT of kittens and cats.
- Delightful Dragon: Scorch and Legend are cute Western dragons, and the Chinese Zodiac Dragon emphasizes their positive traits. Stretching this trope, the Komodo dragon, Bali, is also described as a happy lizard.
- Doofy Dodo: Downplayed with Dinky the Dodo Bird, who looks like a goofball but isn't said to be particularly stupid. Instead, their poem emphasizes their small stature.
- Early-Installment Weirdness:
- Until about 1996, the toys generally had much plainer, generally more realistic designs and more common species of animals before branching out into Amazing Technicolor Wildlife and more obscure species. It was also at this point that they began to be distributed outside of Chicago.
- Originally, the heart-shaped tags had only the toy's name and copyright information, and they were a single two-sided tag. They quickly changed to a folding tag that opens up, but it originally had just "To/From" blanks inside to encourage gift-giving. Starting in 1996 the tags began including dates of birth and a four-line poem about the toy. The font changed from Times New Roman to Comic Sans a year later, and only minor cosmetic changes have ensued in the subsequent generations.
- Fuzzball Spider: Creeps the Spider in the Halloweenie collection is a fuzzy spider. He has a round, black head with yellow eyes and a smiling red mouth, along with orange-and-black-striped legs protruding from the sides.
- Gratuitous German: Germania the bear had its poem written in German. Justified by the fact it was only officially available in Germany.
- Gratuitous Japanese: Similarly to Germania, both Sakura and Sakura II's poems were written in Japanese. Justified in that they were only released in Japan.
- Informed Species:
- Doby the Doberman Pinscher may look more like a Rottweiler to many folks, due to him having the latter breed's "floppy" ears instead of the former's more pointy ears. In actuality, Dobermans ears are naturally floppy, and the more famous pointy ears are the result of cropping, not of breeding. Both breeds also often have docked tails, which is better known.
- Dinky the Dodo Bird looks more like a duck
◊ than a dodo bird. - Rusty the Red Panda was commonly mistaken to be a fox or a raccoon instead of a red panda.
- Kangaroos Represent Australia: There's an Australian-exclusive named Bounder.
- Long-Runners: The toys have been consistently in production since 1993.
- Meaningful Name: Why do you think they named a rabbit "Ears"? Or a bee "Bumble"?
- Messy Pig: Averted with Squealer who is "the class clown", and Stubby who "would rather eat a big dessert." Knuckles the Pig, however, makes mud pies.
- Palette Swap: Most of the 30th anniversary Beanie Babies have different, brighter colors than their counterparts. Some, like Zip II and Dottie II, avert this, and are primarily differentiated by their softer material.
- Playful Otter: Seaweed is her name.
- Precious Puppies: There are a couple that are explicitly stated to be puppies, but even the ostensibly adult dog types are usually puppylike.
- Prehistoric Monster: Averted with the dinosaur Beanie Babies, which are adorable.
- Pun: Any Beanie with a tie-dye appearance is officially listed as "Ty-dye."
- Punny Name: Chocolate the Moose and Claude the Crab are but a few of the many examples.
- Retcon:
- A subtle one. Splash was originally identified as just a whale, but this was later specified to orca.
- Done a little less subtly with some of the Beanies that were renamed. Some renames were done to avoid copyright issues (e.g. Tabasco the bull being renamed Snort), while others seem to be done for little reason other than to encourage collectors to buy the rarer, alternately-named version (e.g. Nana vs. Bongo the monkey, Brownie vs. Cubbie the bear).
- Runner the mongoose-turned-mustelid, as seen above.
- At least two Beanies had their birthdays changed for no reason.
- Rouge Angles of Satin: Many of the early Beanies had typos in their poems. Perhaps one of the most egregious is "moose" somehow becoming "rnoose" on Chocolate's poem. Information on errors is available here. Some are so obvious that they seem deliberate, just to drive up the price and make one type seem "rarer" just because its poem's misspelled or has a different line.
- Santa Claus: Yes, even he exists in Beanie Baby form.
- Scary Stitches: Frankenteddy is covered with simulated stitching.
- Shout-Out:
- Humphrey the Camel may or may not be a reference to the Jack Blanchard & Misty Morgan song.
- Red bull Snort was originally named Tabasco before being renamed due to copyright issues.
- The first Ty-dyed bear was originally named Garcia before being renamed Peace, also due to copyright issues.
- There's a
walrus named Paul. - According to the poem on the inside of the tag, Mel the Koala is supposedly named after Mel Gibson.
- They also have a platypus named Perry.
- Smelly Skunk: Yep, named Stinky, given perfume and mints as gifts, and "hop[es] one day he wouldn't stink."
- Snake Versus Mongoose: There was a character named Runner the Mongoose, whose poem was all about how much he loved to kill snakes.
- Stock Animal Diet: Of the squirrels Nuts, Nutty and Treehouse, the latter two are holding acorns.
- Spin-Off:
- Attic Treasures were introduced in the same year as Beanie Babies. These were given a more retraux style with sepia-tone tags, textured fur, clothing, and hinged limbs. They were quietly retired at the beginning of the 21st century, but returned in 2017.
- Ty has made two lines intended to appeal to toddlers:
- Pillow Pals were large plush toys whose designs were expys of pre-existing Beanie Babies. The earlier versions looked near-identical to their basis before being redesigned with brighter colors (i.e. Paddles the Platypus initially◊ having an identical color scheme to Patti before being revised◊ to be green-and-orange). Unlike Beanie Babies, they had embroidered eyes instead of safety eyes and lacked plastic pellets, both so they could function as pillows and to reduce choking hazards.
- Baby Ty was introduced in 2000, and featured softer, fleece-like fabric in addition to the usual embroidered eyes and lack of pellets. However, these looked more like conventional stuffed animals rather than larger Beanie Babies. They returned in 2018 and were manufactured until 2022.
- Pillow Pals were large plush toys whose designs were expys of pre-existing Beanie Babies. The earlier versions looked near-identical to their basis before being redesigned with brighter colors (i.e. Paddles the Platypus initially
- Ty Pluffies were similar to Baby Ty, having soft fabric and being designed after traditional stuffed animals, but had plastic pellets in their limbs and (in some cases) safety eyes instead of embroidered eyes.
- There were also Beanie Buddies, which were larger, softer and larger counterparts of existing Beanie Babies, sometimes with trivia about the corresponding Beanie in the swing tag. Both these and Baby Ty were made with a new fabric called "Tylon."
- Ty Punkies, which has frizzy, loose-hair fur known as "Ty Tips".
- Ty Girlz, which are basically plush Bratz dolls, and had their own online world a la Webkinz.
- Ty Li'l Ones, itself a spinoff of Ty Girlz, were smaller, more conventional dolls.
- Beanie Babies 2.0, Ty's answer to the above-mentioned Webkinz. The plushies themselves had lightning bolt buttons on their body (usually their rear).
- Beanie Kids and Beanie Boppers were more conventional plush dolls of kids. They also had extra clothing known as Ty Gear that could be purchased individual.
- Teenie Beanies, smaller versions of pre-existing Beanie Babies meant for distribution at McDonald's. The New '10s also had Teenie Beanie Boos, which were smaller versions of Beanie Boos (see below), and Teeny Tys, which were basically small Beanie Boos shaped like tsum tsums.
- Ty Classic, which are larger and have more realistic proportions than Beanie Babies. They harken back to Ty's original plush Himalayan cats.
- Beanie Boos, plush dolls which are more firmly stuffed and have bigger heads and glittery eyes as well as bolder colors. Initially a spinoff of Beanie Babies, Beanie Boos eventually overtook the Babies, becoming Ty's main toy line. Beanie Boo design tropes (such as larger heads and sparkly eyes) bled their way into regular Beanie Babies as well.
- Wild Wild Bests were similar to Beanie Boos, as they had large eyes and cartoony proportions, though they still looked more realistic otherwise.
- Beanie Ballz, which were, well, ball-shaped plushies stuffed with beans. They were succeeded by the similar, slightly-smaller Pluffies.
- Ty Monstaz, rotund and fuzzy cartoonish monster plushies.
- Theme Naming:
- The first five cats were named Zip, Nip, Chip, Flip and Snip.
- Three pastel-colored rabbits were named Hippity, Hoppity and Floppity.
- Wicked Witch: Scary the Witch.
