Follow TV Tropes

This is based on opinion. Please don't list it on a work's trope example list.

Following

Tear Jerker / Simon & Garfunkel

Go To

The music (and harmony vocals) of Simon & Garfunkel is often considered to be so hauntingly beautiful, much of their output can really move one to tears.


  • "Seven o'Clock News/Silent Night". There's just something in the juxtaposition of the calm and peaceful melody and all the violence in the news report. Also doubles as Nightmare Fuel.
  • Just stop and really pay attention the next time you hear "The Sound of Silence". The lyrics focus on humanity's inability to communicate, and the singer's doomed attempt to break through the barriers everyone around him has put up. Even better is the original version without the electric instruments.
  • "Bridge Over Troubled Water" can absolutely kill some people (not literally), as do the beautiful cover versions by Eva Cassidy and Roberta Flack.
  • "Scarborough Fair/Canticle" becomes really depressing when you listen to the lyrics and realize what it actually says. On the one hand, there's "Scarborough Fair", about the impossible tasks the singer sets his "true love" (omitting the verses where she sets him similarly impossible tasks), and on the other, there's "Canticle", about the mindlessness of war and the death of innocence it brings. Sarah Brightman's version is particularly haunting.
  • "Old Friends/Bookends" can bring a tear to many a person's eye — and, as time goes on and Simon and Garfunkel keep getting older, it just gets sadder and sadder.
    Preserve your memories,
    They're all that's left you.
  • "He Was My Brother", made worse by the fact that it's based on a true story.
  • "The Boxer" is a haunting picture of destitution and loneliness, to say nothing of the music, which is some of the most ethereal ever set to tape. The wordless chorus somehow makes it even sadder, as though the singer has run out of words to describe his pain, while the plaintive, soaring violin, the smashing percussion, and the resonant bass line that comes in near the end act even more like a musical Gut Punch.
    Asking only workman's wages,
    I come looking for a job, but I get no offers,
    Just a come-on from the whores on Seventh Avenue
    I do declare
    There were times when I was so lonesome that I took some comfort there
  • Their cover of Jackson C. Frank's "Blues Run the Game" manages to out-sad the original, which is no mean feat.
  • The last verse of "A Most Peculiar Man". As if hearing about the title character having no friends - his neighbours shunned him for being unfriendly and, worse, different to them - isn't bad enough, he is hurting so much below his surface anger that he finally decides he can't take it anymore, and it becomes clear that no-one will truly miss him once he's gone:
    He died last Saturday
    He turned on the gas and went to sleep
    With the windows closed, so he'd never wake up
    to a silent world in his tiny room
    And Mrs Riordon says he has a brother somewhere, who should be notified soon
    And all the people said
    "What a shame that he's dead, but
    Wasn't he a most peculiar man?"
  • "I Am a Rock". As happy and triumphant as the singer claims to be, living like a rock in complete isolation from other people, the reason becomes clear with the last two lines.
    And a rock feels no pain
    And an island never cries...
  • "America" sees two lost souls making their way by bus from Pittsburgh to New York, with no idea where they're going next:
    "Kathy, I'm lost," I said,
    Though I knew she was sleeping.
    "I'm empty and aching and I don't know why."
  • "Richard Cory", where the narrator still desperately wants to be the rich titular character even after Richard Cory kills himself.
    He freely gave to charity, he had the common touch,
    And they were grateful for his patronage and thanked him very much,
    So my mind was filled with wonder when the evening headlines read:
    "Richard Cory went home last night and put a bullet through his head."
    But I work in his factory
    And I curse the life I'm living
    And I curse my poverty
    And I wish that I could be,
    Oh, I wish that I could be,
    Oh, I wish that I could be
    Richard Cory.
    • It's possible to interpret from the final chorus that what the narrator envies is not Cory's wealth but his death, which just makes it even worse.
  • "The Dangling Conversation" and "Overs" are painful songs about one partner knowing his relationship has run its course, but has no idea how to end it, and is willing to stay in a loveless relationship out of habit. "The Only Living Boy in New York" is similarly sad, as it's about a deteriorating friendship that neither friend can keep. Considering the third song references "Tom", all three songs could be about Simon and Garfunkel wanting to break up and go solo but their success is preventing them from doing so.

Top