Follow TV Tropes

Following

Playing With / Ambiguously Jewish

Go To

Basic Trope: A character displays Jewish stereotypes but it's unclear if they're actually Jewish or not.

  • Straight: Alice Bernstein is a bookworm and speaks Yiddish as a Second Language, but it's never stated if she's Jewish.
  • Exaggerated: Alice Bernstein exhibits all the stereotypes: speaks Yiddish, is a bookworm, is a Deadpan Snarker, is a cheapskate, is very argumentative, has a large nose, etc., but it's still never been confirmed. Also, we have no clue on whether she keeps kosher as she's never seen eating.
  • Downplayed: Alice doesn't have any stereotypical Jewish traits except for the last name of "Bernstein".
  • Justified:
    • People with these traits do exist in real life, some of whom are Jewish and some of whom aren't.
    • Alice is a converted Judaist.
    • Alice is a secular Jew who doesn’t actively engage much with her heritage, but still has some of the culture from her family or community.
  • Inverted:
    • Alice is explicitly Jewish, but inverts all the stereotypes (has a small nose, is Book Dumb, is generous with money, etc).
    • In a mostly-Jewish cast, Alice is hinted to not be Jewish.
  • Subverted: In a a later episode, we see Alice Bernstein at synagogue (proving she is Jewish) or church (proving she's not).
  • Double Subverted: She then is revealed to have had an ulterior motive for going there.
  • Parodied:
  • Zigzagged: The writers make conflicting statements on whether Alice is Jewish.
  • Averted:
    • Alice is either explicitly Jewish or not.
    • Alice doesn't exhibit any traits stereotyped of Jews.
  • Enforced:
    • The story was written by a bigot, and Alice is a villain. The writer doesn't say she's Jewish outright because they honestly believe that the stereotypes and her villain status make it already obvious.
    • "We want to export this series to the Arab World, don't making her obviously Jewish to avoid political and cultural complaint from them!"
  • Lampshaded: "Is Alice Jewish? I can't tell."
  • Invoked: Alice is deliberately cryptic about her religious identity.
  • Exploited: The series takes place during WWII, and the Nazis don't know whether to persecute Alice.
  • Defied: Alice tells the audience whether or not she's Jewish.
  • Discussed: "Some people may be brainy, speak Yiddish, or have a last name like Bernstein, but that doesn't necessarily mean they're Jewish."
  • Conversed: "Is that Alice character Jewish or not? If she was, she'd be a walking stereotype!"
  • Implied:
  • Deconstructed:
  • Reconstructed:
  • Played for Laughs:
  • Played for Drama:
    • In a World War Two setting her stereotypical behaviour leads to her being assumed to be Jewish and murdered or nearly murdered by the Nazis.
    • Alternatively, in the modern setting, Alice is severely beaten or even murdered by the bunch of Neo-Nazis, whether she's Jewish or not.
  • Played for Horror:

Back to Ambiguously Jewish.

Top