Being a game made by Deep-Sea Prisoner, the creator of Mogeko Castle, it is to be expected Gray Garden has its share of nightmare-inducing moments as well. And that it starts as such a happy game only makes it all worse.
- The second scene between Yosafire and Froze in the flower garden, where Froze enters to find Yosafire covered in blood and on the brink of death.
- Raspbel's Secret reveals more than you probably wanted to know about her. Rawberry eats Macarona, and after finding out she killed her, goes to tell her sister about it. However, Raspbel, who is doing something she doesn't want anyone to see, retaliates by eating Rawberry. The last shot of the bonus video is a nightmarish closeup of Raspbel's face, wherein she sports a Slasher Smile on her bloodstained face. And then there's her final line towards her now-dead sister:Raspbel: But it's your fault, you know? Good girls should be in bed by now...
- Similarly, what Rawberry does to Macarona in Bad End 3. The latter freaks out, and the former turns on her and eats her.
- The Flame Demons seem to take torture, murder, and Attempted Rape (if Yosafire's reaction when Ivlis has her in his grasp is any indication) in their stride, the youngest amongst them (Poemi) even acting as a Torture Technician during Bad End 2.
