Follow TV Tropes

Following

Headscratchers / Halloweentown

Go To

  • What kind of monster is Pin Cushion Lady?

  • How is Marnie a weird girl? She seems like any normal 13 year old and could even be popular. Informed Attribute?
    • She's a Nightmare Fetishist who has a fascination with Halloween monsters and creatures. That's not really something most teenage girls are or have ever been into (though depending on your tastes, she could be considered a loser).
  • Aggie mentions the cauldron being passed down through generations of Cromwells, and later mentions knowing King Arthur personally. If she's immortal, what's this about generations of family?
    • She's not quite immortal, only having been around for a few thousand years (having been a young woman at one point). It's likely that, somehow, none of the other Cromwells have been given Aggie's gift of a very long life (where she proportionally ages) as well as that of continued fertility in spite of her physical body being that of a woman in her 60s.
      • That being said, how did Aggie get to live thousands of years longer than her family and presumably everyone besides the Kalabars?
    • In the second movie, how does the Gray Spell affect the interior of Aggie's house, but not the exterior?

Top