The quickest and most basic explanation for the tropes associated with the Stock Light-Novel Hero is to understand the differences between drawn media and written media.
Light Novel protagonists tend to be more stoic or introverted than their
Shonen cousins because the stories tend to be written in either first-person perspective or very close-third perspective. This means that the reader has access to every thought, realization and idea the protagonist has, requiring that they be rather observant to exposit on the world around them. And making them an
Ordinary High-School Student provides a grounding for the reader to connect with the character and understand their thoughts and reactions. While it's not impossible to write an observant
Idiot Hero, it's much more difficult—and unnecessary, thanks to the next point.
Power Acquisition
Manga artists, especially those that work for known shonen publishers, are under pressure to draw impressive visuals and fight scenes that will amaze readers. On the other hand, Light Novels rely largely on limited amounts of text, and long, drawn-out fights are sure ways to eat up that text. In addition, reading about a fight doesn't have the same impact as seeing it, so it'll typically be brief and be constructed in a way that the writer can explain why The Hero won through exposition (such as
unlocking a new ability).
Harems Everywhere
The reliance on
Harem Genre tropes is a related issue. As we said, illustrations in
light novels are limited. So...if the creators can't rely on fights to impress the reader, then what works just as well (if not better)?
Sex appeal! The occasional picture is perfect for showcasing one of the story's female characters in
Fanservice moments, because it doesn't have to be followed up with anything. The picture stands by itself. There's also a bit of carryover from the
Dating Sim and
Visual Novel genres, which are also rather text-based and thus can transfer over well into
light novels. Plus, a harem allows the writer to introduce new girls constantly, which adds variety.
Extranormal Institute
The first subgenre that saturated light novel works was the
Extranormal Institute/
Magical Academy show which featured a protagonist entering some sort of elite school and rising to become one of its most famous and talented students. Examples include
Maburaho,
The Irregular at Magic High School,
Absolute Duo,
World Break: Aria of Curse for a Holy Swordsman,
Undefeated Bahamut Chronicle, and many,
many more. As theorized by YouTuber
Mother's Basement, the outbreak of these stories was caused by the popularity of
Harry Potter both in the West and Japan. It made for a very easy form of
Wish-Fulfillment where some otherwise
Ordinary High-School Student (as noted above) can learn cool abilities that no ordinary school could teach, in addition to gaining the admiration of any girls that attended (especially if it happened to be an all-girls school). In the early 2010s, however, that genre began to slowly die out, largely to be replaced with...
Summoned to Another World
The
isekai plot existed before, such as in stories like
Inuyasha,
Vision of Escaflowne,
.hack, and many other stories. However, these stories were more the
Ur Examples of the trope and bear little resemblance to the sea of isekai plots in
Light Novel stories. YouTuber
Gigguk did the research and found that the trope took off in popularity due to the popularity of
Sword Art Online (and, to a lesser extent
Log Horizon). In fact, the protagonist Kirito became
the bog standard definition of what a
Stock Light-Novel Hero should be. Absurdly powerful, rather plain visually, and surrounded by gorgeous girls.
SAO also codified the
RPG Mechanics 'Verse trope in
Light Novel works, which is another reason why the crossover with games is so prominent.
In Summation
The rapid proliferation of these tropes can be attributed to how easy it is to write
light novels—literally anyone with a keyboard (and either decent artistic ability or enough money to commission a few illustrations) can make one in no time at all. In fact, there are sites (such as ''Shōsetsuka Ni Narōu, which literally translates as "
Becoming a Novelist") that allow anyone to upload their work for others to read, making it easy for readers to access and publishers to find new talent.