History YMMV / Critikal

** "This is the greatest X of All Time."
** "He's pulling his cock out!"[[labelnote:Explanation]] His reaction to a gamer rage quitting and taking off his belt.[[/labelnote]]

* HePannedItNowHeSucks: Critikal gained himself some animosity from the ''WebAnimation/{{RWBY}}'' fandom when he watched the clip of [[spoiler:Ruby Rose having her breakdown]] despite having absolutely no context to it and only coming back to it due to the memes (specifically the ones of Homophobic Ruby) caused by it. The fact that he goes on to bring up Creator/MontyOum’s name to attack the show and the creators and saying [[SeasonalRot "whatever's become of this show is awful"]] (a big BerserkButton for the fandom) only worsen the ire since most detractors do just that.

** "Woooooooo! Yeah, baby! That's what I've been waiting for, that's what it's all about! Woohoo!"[[labelnote:Explanation]] His reaction to a unicorn toy that poops.[[/labelnote]]

* CrossesTheLineTwice: His entire commentary style in summary can be described as this trope. In particular, his very long, ''very detailed'' story from his ''VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddys'' playthrough where he talks about how he tried to receive a blowjob while he had to take a piss.

** From ''VideoGame/FiveNightsAtFreddys'':

* HypeBacklash: Some people who are [[Pun critical]] of Charlie's content find it to be mass produced and low effort, combined with his [[TheStoic apathetic tone]] to whatever he's reacting to.

** That he looks hairy or [[AcceptableTargets must be a hobo impersonating him]] or needs a shave whenever he grows out his hair.

* HePannedItNowHeSucks: Critikal gained himself some animosity from the ''WebAnimation/{{RWBY}}'' fandom when he watched the clip of [[spoiler:Ruby Rose having her breakdown]] despite having absolutely no context to it and only coming back to it due to the memes caused by it. The fact that he goes on to bring up Creator/MontyOum’s name to attack the show and the creators (a big BerserkButton for the fandom) only worsen the ire since most detractors do just that.

* UnacceptableTargets: He will always come to the defense of people in the service industry, such as waiters and cashiers, when they're abused by entitled customers.

* AcceptableTargets:
** [[https://youtu.be/sCqPKad1aCI Douchetubers]] like the Paul Brothers, Creator/{{KSI}}, and [=RiceGum=], as well as other children-exploitative [=YouTube=] content like [[https://youtu.be/JN3WZ79U68o N&A productions]].
** IGN for its infamous plagiarism controversy.
** Basically ''anything'' as of late, if his discussion videos give indication, most tending to be [=YouTube's=] terms of service.
** He's made jokes about ''Fortnite'' being cringe-y, though he later had to make a video clearing up [[UnacceptableTargets he doesn't want his viewers to make fun of children who enjoy it.]]

** In "The Legend of a Real Superhero Named Phoenix Jones", he compares one of the vigilante's costumes to something [[Series/TheOfficeUS Dwight Schrute]] would've made. Creator/RainnWilson, Dwight's actor, had played a vigilante in the movie ''Film/{{Super}}'', though his character's costume is ''way'' more professional in comparison.

** At the beginning of [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aymt3V_7vi0 "The Thickness"]], he says that he's "[[NintendoHard really shitty]]" at [[VideoGame/{{DarkSoulsIII}} Dark Souls III]], so rather than continuing with his first character, Big Moist, he makes another one by the name of [[Creator/{{BrendanFraser}} Brendan Fraser]]. He ends up creating a character with an unnerving SlasherSmile, and it's so disturbing that [=Cr1TiKaL=] ''abandons'' the project and makes a whole new character entirely.

** Especially his ''VideoGame/TheWalkingDead'' commentary. During a particularly gruesome fight with a zombie, he describes the zombie as a prostitute that he is not fighting, but having sex with.

** When he's attacked by an invisible monster in {{VideoGame/Amnesia The Dark Descent}}, he climbs on top of it and attempts to kill it via GoombaStomp. Later, he attempts to attack it with a book.

* CriticalResearchFailure:
** Hilariously, Charlie thought the [[https://youtube.com/channel/UCJj91yPSruvqylY9WEsQCiw Arcade Craniacs]] channel was unironic with its 3 AM challenge videos. Even after being told otherwise on streams, [[IRejectYourReality he refuses to believe otherwise]].
** In his “[[https://youtu.be/0B2QzVZN6YA How Star Wars Ruined a Kid’s Entire Life]]” video, the thumbnail depicts an evil silhouette of WesternAnimation/MickeyMouse puppeteering the ''Franchise/StarWars'' logo. Aside from Disney’s controversial treatment of the franchise given visual reference, it has nothing to do with the video. Considering the person who is given subject towards, ''Film/ThePhantomMenace'' as well as the rest of the franchise was still under Creator/TwentiethCenturyStudios when it all began, long before both ''Star Wars'' and its former parent company were bought out by Disney. Basically, the thumbnail insinuates Disney’s involvement with the CreatorBreakdown of the former child actor but there is no connection, to the point Disney was not even given mention in the video which makes the thumbnail choice even more bizarre. Aside from an easy TakeThat on Charlie’s and the thumbnail’s artist’s ends.

** Basically ''anything'' as of late, if his discussion videos give indication, most tending to be [=YouTube's=] Terms of Service.

** Basically ''anything'' as of late, if his discussion videos give indication, most tending to be [=Youtube's=] Terms of Service.

** Basically ''anything'' as of late, if his discussion videos give indication, most tending to be Youtube's TOS.

** "Woooooooo! Yeah, baby! That's what I've been waiting for, that's what it's all about! Woohoo!"[labelnote:Explanation]] His reaction to a unicorn toy that poops.[[/labelnote]]
** "He's pulling his cock out!"

** "Woooooooo! Yeah, baby! That's what I've been waiting for, that's what it's all about! Woohoo!"[labelnote:Explanation]]: His reaction to a unicorn toy that poops.[[/labelnote]]

** "Woo! Yeah, baby! That's what I've been waiting for!"

** In "The Legend of a Real Superhero Named Phoenix Jones", he compares one of the vigilante's costumes to something [[Series/TheOfficeUS Dwight]] would've made. Creator/RainnWilson, Dwight's actor, had played a vigilante in the movie ''Film/{{Super}}'', though his character's costume is ''way'' more professional in comparison.

** "This is the greatest X of All Time"

** His "WOOOOOOOOOOOO! YEAH, BABY! ''That's what I'm talking about!'' WOOHOO!" from his "The Worst Toy Ever Made" video quickly became a reaction video.

** In his “[[https://youtu.be/0B2QzVZN6YA How Star Wars Ruined a Kid’s Entire Life]]” video, the thumbnail depicts an evil silhouette of WesternAnimation/MickeyMouse puppeteering the ''Franchise/StarWars'' logo. Aside from Disney’s controversial treatment of the franchise given visual reference, it has nothing to do with the video. Considering the person who is given subject towards, ''Film/ThePhantomMenace'' as well as the rest of the franchise was still under Creator/TwentiethCenturyStudios when it all began, long before both ''Star Wars'' and its former parent company were bought out by Disney. Basically, the thumbnail insinuates Disney’s involvement with the CreatorBreakdown of the former child actor but there is no connection, to the point Disney was not even given mention at the video which makes the thumbnail choice even more bizarre besides from inserting an easy TakeThat to the company.

** In his “[[https://youtu.be/0B2QzVZN6YA How Star Wars Ruined a Kid’s Entire Life]]” video, the thumbnail depicts an evil silhouette of WesternAnimation/MickeyMouse puppeteering the ''Franchise/StarWars'' logo. Aside from Disney’s controversial treatment of the franchise given visual reference, it has nothing to do with the video. Considering the person who is given subject towards, ''Film/ThePhantomMenace'' as well as the rest of the franchise was still under Creator/TwentiethCenturyStudios, long before both ''Star Wars'' and its former parent company were bought out by Disney. Basically, the thumbnail insinuates Disney’s involvement with the CreatorBreakdown of the former child actor but there is no connection, to the point Disney was not even given mention at the video which makes the thumbnail choice even more bizarre besides from inserting an easy TakeThat to the company.