Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UsefulNotes / TheFrenchRevolution

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The early part of the Revolution also saw a lot of pro-English and pro-American sentiment which never did die away (at least among the Girondins and moderate republicans), but once France went to war and the Jacobins came to power, there was a lot of CulturalPosturing about how it was a true Republic while England still kept its king. Later, they denounced England as the "Modern Carthage" with themselves being "the Romans". The National Convention refused to send diplomatic missions to nations that were not "true" republics so only America and Switzerland had diplomatic offices, though later for reasons of {{Realpolitik}} they entered into negotiations with Ottoman Turkey.

to:

** The early part of the Revolution also saw a lot of pro-English and pro-American sentiment which never did die away (at least among the Girondins and moderate republicans), but once France went to war and the Jacobins came to power, there was a lot of CulturalPosturing about how it was a true Republic while England still kept its king. Later, they denounced England as the "Modern Carthage" with themselves being "the Romans". The National Convention refused to send diplomatic missions to nations that were not "true" republics so only America and Switzerland had diplomatic offices, though later for reasons of {{Realpolitik}} they entered into negotiations with Ottoman Turkey. The Directory was pragmatic about it and sent diplomatic missions when needed, yet ironically is the one ''[[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Congress_of_Rastatt which got its diplomats assassinated]]''.



** Danton was called ''The Titan, Jove the Thunderer, Mirabeau of the Masses'', Lazare Carnot was called ''Organizer of Victory'', Robespierre was called ''L'Incorruptible'' almost to the point of being used nearly as often as his real name.

to:

** Danton was called ''The ''[[BoisterousBruser The Titan, Jove the Thunderer, Mirabeau of the Masses'', Masses]]'', Lazare Carnot was called ''Organizer ''[[BadassBureaucrat Organizer of Victory'', Victory]]'', Robespierre was called ''L'Incorruptible'' ''[[ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules L'Incorruptible]]'' almost to the point of being used nearly as often as his real name.



** When Napoleon made his big splash in defending Paris from the Chouannerie rebellion, he was called ''"General Vendemmiare"'' by both enemies and friends, which he considered [[IllTakeThatAsACompliment the first real honour he earned]]. Later critics and Jacobins would call him, ''Robespierre on Horseback''. Among his already loyal soldiers, he was, of course, ''[[AFatherToHisMen Le petit caporal]]''

to:

** When Napoleon made his big splash in defending Paris from the Chouannerie rebellion, he was called ''"General Vendemmiare"'' Vendémiaire"'' by both enemies and friends, which he considered [[IllTakeThatAsACompliment the first real honour he earned]]. Later critics and Jacobins would call him, ''Robespierre on Horseback''. Among his already loyal soldiers, he was, of course, ''[[AFatherToHisMen Le petit caporal]]''



** When Kissinger asked Deng Xiaoping about the consequences of the French Revolution, Deng famously replied; "It is too early to say yet".

to:

** When Kissinger asked Deng Xiaoping about the consequences of the French Revolution, [[CommonKnowledge Deng famously replied; "It replied]] "[[InscrutableOriental It is too early to say yet".yet]]". Though it was really about [[NewerThanTheyThink May 1968...]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The early part of the Revolution also saw a lot of pro-English and pro-American sentiment which never did die away, but once France went to war, there was a lot of CulturalPosturing about how it was a true Republic while England still kept its king. The National Convention refused to send diplomatic missions to nations that were not "true" republics so only America and Switzerland had diplomatic offices, though later for reasons of {{Realpolitik}} they entered into negotiations with Ottoman Turkey.

to:

** The early part of the Revolution also saw a lot of pro-English and pro-American sentiment which never did die away, away (at least among the Girondins and moderate republicans), but once France went to war, war and the Jacobins came to power, there was a lot of CulturalPosturing about how it was a true Republic while England still kept its king.king. Later, they denounced England as the "Modern Carthage" with themselves being "the Romans". The National Convention refused to send diplomatic missions to nations that were not "true" republics so only America and Switzerland had diplomatic offices, though later for reasons of {{Realpolitik}} they entered into negotiations with Ottoman Turkey.

Added: 797

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ThePurge: The ReignOfTerror eerily anticipates the Soviet examples. The jury is still out if it was genuinely driven by stresses and tensions of wartime necessity and siege mentality, or a result of Robespierre's desire for power which lead him to cull other factions. After Thermidor, there was the White Terror, where the Thermidorians hunted down Jacobins and Robespierre holdouts, even sponsoring street gangs such as the "jeunesse doree" and the Muscadins who killed with impunity. After Robespierre's death, the Thermidor executed 77 supporters in a single day, the largest single mass guillotine during the Revolution.

to:

* ThePurge: The ReignOfTerror eerily anticipates the Soviet examples. The jury is still out if it was genuinely driven by stresses and tensions of wartime necessity and siege mentality, or a result of Robespierre's desire for power which lead him to cull other factions. After Thermidor, there was the White Terror, where the Thermidorians hunted down Jacobins and Robespierre holdouts, even sponsoring street gangs such as the "jeunesse doree" and the Muscadins who killed with impunity. After Robespierre's death, the Thermidor executed 77 supporters in a single day, the largest single mass guillotine during the Revolution.Revolution.
* PyrrhicVictory: A classic case in the "Glorious First of June". The First Republic, during the Terror, had arranged for a convoy of ships to bring food to the starving French public and cut down on bread riots. To do this they had to break a British blockade, send a convoy along with a navy to America and Haiti, collect rations and come back. The British naturally found out and met them in battle, the French navy met them head on and fought bravely, with one ship "Vengeur du Peuple" being DefiantToTheEnd, crying "Vive le Republique!" as they drowned before retreating. The English won the battle but [[CrowningMomentOfAwesome the convoy reached France absolutely untouched bringing huge quantities of food]]. The French suffered a tactical defeat but totally achieved their strategic aims.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** When Napoleon made his big splash in defending Paris from the Chouannerie rebellion, he was called ''"General Vendemmiare"'' by both enemies and friends, which he considered [[IllTakeThatAsACompliment the first real honour he earned]]. Later critics and Jacobins would call him, ''Robespierre on Horseback''.

to:

** When Napoleon made his big splash in defending Paris from the Chouannerie rebellion, he was called ''"General Vendemmiare"'' by both enemies and friends, which he considered [[IllTakeThatAsACompliment the first real honour he earned]]. Later critics and Jacobins would call him, ''Robespierre on Horseback''. Among his already loyal soldiers, he was, of course, ''[[AFatherToHisMen Le petit caporal]]''

Added: 1308

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JustTheFirstCitizen: The Committee of Public Safety had no leadership positions; Robespierre was just another member, but he soon emerged as the most public and terrifying face of the ReignOfTerror.

to:

* JustTheFirstCitizen: The Committee of Public Safety had no leadership positions; Robespierre was just another member, but he soon emerged as the most public and terrifying face of the ReignOfTerror.
** During the revolution, ''everyone'' addressed each other as "citoyen/citoyenne" depending on "him/her" as a way of instilling republican virtue and equality, from the wealthy bourgeois to the proletarian. This tradition was revived and turned to cliche by international communists addressing each other as "Comrade". The term still had the original usage, as witness the title of ''Film/CitizenKane''.


Added DiffLines:

* TheNicknamer: The Citizens of Paris loved bestowing nicknames on public figures:
** Marie Antoinette was called ''L'Autrichienne, Madame Deficit'' and ''Madame Veto''. Her husband who was initially liked came to be called "Monsieur Veto".
** Danton was called ''The Titan, Jove the Thunderer, Mirabeau of the Masses'', Lazare Carnot was called ''Organizer of Victory'', Robespierre was called ''L'Incorruptible'' almost to the point of being used nearly as often as his real name.
** Saint-Just wins prizes for the coolest and scariest - ''[[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast Angel of Death]]''.
** When Napoleon made his big splash in defending Paris from the Chouannerie rebellion, he was called ''"General Vendemmiare"'' by both enemies and friends, which he considered [[IllTakeThatAsACompliment the first real honour he earned]]. Later critics and Jacobins would call him, ''Robespierre on Horseback''.

Added: 1860

Changed: 1056

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Louis XVI stayed King until 1792. He called the Estates-General in 1789 (the only body in France representing every Estate, or class, which hadn't been called since ''1614'') but some disagreement about the method of voting led to the formation of the National Assembly by the representatives of the Third Estate (peasantry/bourgeoisie). Initially the members of this body were split between those who wanted a constitutional monarchy similar to England (Feuillants) and those who wanted a Republic (Girondins and Jacobins). Robespierre was a leader of the Jacobins, though he only came to the forefront of the Revolution later when the Committee of Public Safety was in power. Lafayette was the leader of the National Guard in Paris until he was accused of being a counter-revolutionary and he fled the country.
* It went to hell when the King tried to suppress the changes leading to the Jacobins gaining power.

to:

* Louis XVI stayed King until 1792. He called the Estates-General in 1789 (the only body in France representing every Estate, or class, which hadn't been called since ''1614'') but some disagreement about the method of voting led to the formation of the National Assembly by the representatives of the Third Estate (peasantry/bourgeoisie). Initially the members of this body were split between those who wanted a constitutional monarchy similar to England (Feuillants) and those who wanted a Republic Republic.
* The King and the Royal Court for his part kept issuing vetoes on every issue,(earning him and his wife the nickname "Monsieur and Madame Veto") led astray by bad advice and the hope that the Revolution was a passing frenzy. Mirabeau and Lafayette tried to urge the King to begin reforms but the Queen was paranoid and distrusted both of them. Constitutional Monarchy at the time was even supported by the Jacobin-Montagnards (even Saint-Just of all people) who were not yet radicalized. The turning point came with the Flight to Varennes, a horrible PR disaster which really split the existing factions into moderate and extreme lines
(Girondins and Jacobins). Robespierre was a leader This and the Storming of the Tuilleries marked the end of Constitutional Monarchy and the birth of the Republic.
* A faction
of the Jacobins, though he only led by Jacques Pierre Brissot came to be called the forefront of Girondins or Brissotins. They were the leading voices in the years 1792-early 1793. They were slow to pass reforms, represented and catered to the provincial cities rather than the Parisian sans-culottes/nascent working-class. They also sought to energize the Revolution later when by declaring war on Austria which Robespierre famously opposed, only to be silenced as it gained support even among extremists like the Committee of Public Safety was in power. Lafayette was Hebertists.
* When
the leader of War started losing ground, and General Dumouriez who the National Guard in Paris until he was accused of being a counter-revolutionary and he fled Girondins had touted as highly sympathetic to the country.
* It went
nation, defected to hell when the King tried enemy along with other noble defections, France found its borders threatened. This led to suppress the changes leading to a city-wide insurrection that put the Jacobins gaining power.in power, the Girondins imprisoned and the proper beginning of the ReignOfTerror, as a wartime measure to meet the armies on France's borders.


Added DiffLines:

* ForeignCultureFetish: Ancient Rome, especially the Republic, Sparta and Greece were as obsessed over during the Revolution as it was during the Renaissance. Brutus, both the founder of the republic and his notorious descendant, were regarded as heroes and during Dechristianization (while Julius Caesar was denounced as a tyrant and his assassination praised as an act of justice), men were given names like Grachhus or Spartacus.
** The early part of the Revolution also saw a lot of pro-English and pro-American sentiment which never did die away, but once France went to war, there was a lot of CulturalPosturing about how it was a true Republic while England still kept its king. The National Convention refused to send diplomatic missions to nations that were not "true" republics so only America and Switzerland had diplomatic offices, though later for reasons of {{Realpolitik}} they entered into negotiations with Ottoman Turkey.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ScrewTheMoneyIHaveRules: The reason why Robespierre was nicknamed ''L'Incorruptible''. Even more so given several high profile revolutionnaries were corrupt, notably Danton and Mirabeau.

Added: 289

Changed: 576

Removed: 263

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Averted with the Gribeauval canon, to which Revolutionary and Napoleonian armies owed their edge in artillery (famously, at Valmy). It was developped under LouisXV and [[{{Irony}} definitively adopted few months after the beginning of the reign of Louis XVI]].



* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]]. All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]]. Not that he was any better.
** For those who don't speak French: ''autrichienne'' means '(female) Austrian', but ''chienne'' means, well, 'female dog' (and is just as insulting as in English). In addition, ''autruche'' means 'ostrich'.

to:

* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]]. All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]]. Not that he was any better.
**
For those who don't speak French: ''autrichienne'' means '(female) Austrian', but ''chienne'' means, well, 'female dog' (and is just as insulting as in English). In addition, ''autruche'' means 'ostrich'.'ostrich'.
** All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]].


Added DiffLines:

** Revolutionary and Napoleonian armies owed their edge in artillery the Gribeauval canon, which famously played a key role at Valmy, was developped under LouisXV and [[{{Irony}} definitively adopted few months after the beginning of the reign of Louis XVI]] after some Court shenaningans.

Added: 263

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's real edge however was the groundbreaking Semaphore line nascent telegraph technology developed by Claude Chappe. This was a telegraph system with mounted visual relays on towers that covered 556 stations across 4800 kms. Its ability to rapidly transmit information about the war from the frontlines to Paris, while the rest of the Coalition struggled in confusion, allowed for superior mobilization of resources.

to:

** It's real edge however was the groundbreaking Semaphore line nascent telegraph technology developed by Claude Chappe. This was a telegraph system with mounted visual relays on towers that covered 556 stations across 4800 kms. Its ability to rapidly transmit information about the war from the frontlines to Paris, while the rest of the Coalition struggled in confusion, allowed for superior mobilization of resources. resources.
** Averted with the Gribeauval canon, to which Revolutionary and Napoleonian armies owed their edge in artillery (famously, at Valmy). It was developped under LouisXV and [[{{Irony}} definitively adopted few months after the beginning of the reign of Louis XVI]].

Added: 1701

Changed: 1434

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AluminumChristmasTrees: The French Revolution introduced a lot of radical features that gave it an edge in its conflict with the rest of Europe:
** It started using hot air balloons in battlefields to provide a high vantage point in which to survey enemy formations. It famously used this in the battle of Fleurus.
** It's real edge however was the groundbreaking Semaphore line nascent telegraph technology developed by Claude Chappe. This was a telegraph system with mounted visual relays on towers that covered 556 stations across 4800 kms. Its ability to rapidly transmit information about the war from the frontlines to Paris, while the rest of the Coalition struggled in confusion, allowed for superior mobilization of resources.



** A lot of 20th Century writers, including Hannah Arendt and recently, Hilary Mantel, have come to see Robespierre himself this way. Even a critic like Francois Furet noted that Robespierre represented the Revolution at its best and most tragic discourse. He represents the recent adage, [[Film/TheDarkKnight "You either die a hero or live long enough to become a villain!"]]

to:

** A lot of 20th Century writers, including Hannah Arendt and recently, Hilary Mantel, have come to see Robespierre himself this way. Even a critic like Francois Furet noted that Robespierre represented the Revolution at its best and most tragic discourse. He represents the recent adage, [[Film/TheDarkKnight "You either die a hero or live long enough to become a villain!"]]villain!"]].



* ReignOfTerror: The TropeNamer. It cast such a dark mark on leftist revolutions that even UsefulNotes/VladimirLenin insisted that he wouldn't institute a Revolution style Reign of Terror in his earlier speeches, though whether the replacement of the Gulag with public executions is a step up, is anyone's guess.
** The Reign lasted for less than a year and while the final tally is a large figure, the executions did not get excessive until towards the end, the start of the Great Terror where an even worse Law of 22 Prairial was instituted, this saw numbers rise from 5 deaths a day to 27, with 38% of the victims being aristocrats, doubling the death toll of the previous year in Paris.

to:

* ReignOfTerror: The TropeNamer. It cast such a dark mark R. R. Palmer's book on leftist revolutions the Terror, ''The Twelve Who Ruled'' demonstrated that even UsefulNotes/VladimirLenin insisted that he wouldn't institute a Revolution style Reign of the Terror in his earlier speeches, though whether was an emergency situation of exceptional circumstances. France was facing civil war inside, and was about to be invaded by all of Europe on its borders, all a consequence of a war started by the replacement of "moderate" Girondins and opposed by Robespierre and a few other Jacobins(with others such as the Gulag with public executions is a step up, is anyone's guess.Hebertists, urging for "spreading the revolution").
** Charged with leading France in this difficult situation, Robespierre and the Committee had to centralize state power, establish peace and well, provide public safety. Napoleon himself stated that the Committee of Public Safety was the only real government of the Revolution. It achieved this by mobilizing France to total war, maintaining supply lines, using police surveillance to ensure steady flow of information, fix prices for bread, provide efficient street lighting at night(one of the few European cities to do so at the time) and also initiating social and cultural reforms (such as opening the Louvre museum to the Public). It was during the Terror, that France abolished slavery.
** The purpose of the committee was also to cut down on mob violence and hangings and other vigilance committees that had already engaged in "Terror trials" on their own. By centralizing the government, the Reign [[RealityIsUnrealistic actually established control over revolutionary excess]]. The vast majority of suspects and political prisoners(except for the high profile ones) were kept in good conditions in abandoned old regime buildings.
** The Reign lasted for less than a year and while the final tally is a large figure, the executions did were not get excessive until towards a continuous bloodletting but came in periods. Historians note that the end, the start of executions really jump right after major victories at wartime. The worst period was the Great Terror where an even worse Law of 22 Prairial was instituted, this saw numbers rise from 5 deaths a day to 27, with 38% of the victims being aristocrats, aristocrats and second highest being clergymen doubling the death toll of the previous year in Paris.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheVillainSucksSong: ''La Carmagnole'' was a popular song after the fall of the Tuilleries, which was pretty much about the King and the Queen sucked after the political disaster of the Flight to Varennes.
--> "Antoinette avait résolu [Antoinette had decided]
--> De nous [[PrecisionFStrike faire tomber sur le cul]]; [To drop us on our arses]
--> Mais le coup a manqué [But the plan was foiled]
--> Elle a le nez cassé." [And she fell on her face.]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Revolt in the Vendée is often portrayed in a more romantic light by historians and novelists. They cite the large scale killings (130,000 but often inflated to 200,000) committed by the Republican side as an example of Revolutionary violence. In truth, the Republican response was driven by a massacre of ''Republican'' Vendeeans committed by Royalist Vendeeans when they killed 200 of them in Machecoul. The Vendean response by the Committee of Public Safety had considerable local support among Republican Vendeeans and peasants who were quite keen on the fact that the government was cutting down on the feudal privileges that the Royalists wanted to reinstate - [[ValuesDissonance namely giving out Church property to peasant landholders]]. One of France's greatest Prime Ministers Georges Clemenceau came from the Vendee and he descended from Republicans who had fought on the side of the Revolutions. Undoubtedly there were atrocities committed by the Revolutionary side, but the Vendeeans own atrocities and sparking the response is under-reported by comparison.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''La Marseillaise'' (Jean Renoir film)
* ''Reign of Terror/The Black Book'' a 1949 BMovie done in a FilmNoir style.
* ''Danton'' (1983 movie, Andrzej Wajda)

to:

* ''La Marseillaise'' (Jean Renoir film)
film). 1938 film which chronicles the early years from Bastille to the Storming of Tuilleries and ending at the Battle of Valmy. Features costumes by Coco Chanel and amazing battle scenes, also depicts the writing, development and MemeticMutation of the song that would become France's National Anthem.
* ''Reign of Terror/The Black Book'' a 1949 BMovie done in a FilmNoir style.
style. The reign is used as a stand-in for the RedScare during UsefulNotes/TheHollywoodBlacklist and features an impressive lack of historical accuracy of any kind.
* ''Danton'' (1983 movie, Andrzej Wajda)Wajda), chronicles the Danton-Robespierre face-off which is based more on Poland's on-going Solidarity movement and ColdWar era blues than the actual events.




to:

* ''Farewell, My Queen'' a 2012 French film starring Diane Kruger as Marie Antoinette.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Later she was actively involved in the Flight to Varennes, where she and the King planned to go to a royalist territory and with support from the Austrian army attack France and re-install the Ancien Regime (which she supported). Supporters of constitutionnal monarchy tried to RetCon it by putting all the blame on Marie-Antoinette, while Louis XVI was as much, if not more, behind it than her. Few people were fooled, though.

to:

*** Later she was actively involved in the Flight to Varennes, where she and the King planned to go to a royalist territory and with support from the Austrian army attack France and re-install the Ancien Regime (which she supported). Supporters of constitutionnal constitutional monarchy tried to RetCon it by putting all the blame on Marie-Antoinette, while Louis XVI was as much, if not more, behind it than her. Few people were fooled, though. And it is this action, not unjustifiably regarded as an act of betrayal by the public, that turned people's attitude towards the Queen, from general dislike or a LoveToHate ButtMonkey, to outright hatred, with people calling for the heads of the King and the Queen. Indeed Danton and Robespierre had delayed her trial and execution because they still hoped to ransom her as a bargaining chip for peace, but the French public put considerable pressure on the Committee calling for her death.

Added: 588

Changed: 177

Removed: 588

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Alpahabetical order


* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]]. All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]]. Not that he was any better.
** For those who don't speak French: ''autrichienne'' means '(female) Austrian', but ''chienne'' means, well, 'female dog' (and is just as insulting as in English). In addition, ''autruche'' means 'ostrich'.
* GorgeousPeriodDress[=/=]PimpedOutDress: The new Greco-Roman inspired high-waisted muslin gowns replacing the aristocratic wigs and full-skirted dresses.



* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]]. All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]]. Not that he was any better.
** For those who don't speak French: ''autrichienne'' means '(female) Austrian', but ''chienne'' means, well, 'female dog' (and is just as insulting as in English). In addition, ''autruche'' means 'ostrich'.
* GorgeousPeriodDress[=/=]PimpedOutDress: The new Greco-Roman inspired high-waisted muslin gowns replacing the aristocratic wigs and full-skirted dresses.



*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largely reformed when TheAffairOfTheNecklace happened and discredited her even more while she was completely innocent.

to:

*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads ''loads'' of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably liked. Among other things, she forced the French Treasury to pay for the debts of the Polignac family), to the point family, which cost 400,000 ''livres tournois'' (roughly ''five millions'' of being 2014 euros). No wonder Marie-Antoinette got nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largely reformed when TheAffairOfTheNecklace happened and discredited her even more while she was completely innocent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when TheAffairOfTheNecklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.

to:

*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley largely reformed when TheAffairOfTheNecklace happenned happened and discredited her even more whil while she was completely innocent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when the Affair of the Diamond Necklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.

to:

*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when the Affair of the Diamond Necklace TheAffairOfTheNecklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]].

to:

* GodSaveUsFromTheQueen: [[IncrediblyLamePun L'autrichienne]]. All in all, she had ''horrible'' political sense and her pieces of advice to Louis XVI [[WithFriendsLikeThese made more ill than good]]. Not that he was any better.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette is portrayed as more of a naive but good natured woman recently, with films like Sofia Coppola's and Antonia Fraser's biography citing the horrific smear campaign she endured. In truth, the smear campaign by Jacques Hebert while exceptionally vicious by any standards (going as far as false accusations of incest during her trial) was part of a political strategy to criticize the Royalist government since the 1791 Constitution refused to allow criticism of the King but left his family members [[LoopholeAbuse an open target]].
*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when the Affair of the Diamond Necklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.

to:

** UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette is portrayed as more of a naive but good natured woman recently, with films like Sofia Coppola's and Antonia Fraser's biography citing the horrific smear campaign she endured. In truth, the smear campaign by Jacques Hebert Hébert while exceptionally vicious by any standards (going as far as false accusations of incest during her trial) was part of a political strategy to criticize the Royalist government since the 1791 Constitution refused to allow criticism of the King but left his family members [[LoopholeAbuse an open target]].
*** Likewise the people of France didn't turn against ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely capricious and spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when the Affair of the Diamond Necklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.

Added: 974

Changed: 425

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette is portrayed as more of a naive but good natured woman recently, with films like Sofia Coppola's and Antonia Fraser's biography citing the horrific smear campaign she endured. In truth, the smear campaign by Jacques Hebert while exceptionally vicious by any standards was part of a political strategy to criticize the Royalist government since the 1791 Constitution refused to allow criticism of the King but left his family members [[LoopholeAbuse an open target]]. Likewise the people of France didn't turn against "L'Autrichienne" for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they did it because she was actively involved in the Flight to Varennes, where she and the King planned to go to a royalist territory and with support from the Austrian army attack France and re-install the ancien regime (which she supported).

to:

** UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette is portrayed as more of a naive but good natured woman recently, with films like Sofia Coppola's and Antonia Fraser's biography citing the horrific smear campaign she endured. In truth, the smear campaign by Jacques Hebert while exceptionally vicious by any standards (going as far as false accusations of incest during her trial) was part of a political strategy to criticize the Royalist government since the 1791 Constitution refused to allow criticism of the King but left his family members [[LoopholeAbuse an open target]]. target]].
***
Likewise the people of France didn't turn against "L'Autrichienne" ''"L'Autrichienne"'' for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they primarily did it because she was extremely spendthrift in the first years of Louis XVI's reign, wasting loads of public money in gambling and for people she liked (notably the Polignac family), to the point of being nicknamed ''"Madame Déficit"'' (Mrs. Deficit). Ironically, she had largley reformed when the Affair of the Diamond Necklace happenned and discredited her even more whil she was completely innocent.
*** Later
she was actively involved in the Flight to Varennes, where she and the King planned to go to a royalist territory and with support from the Austrian army attack France and re-install the ancien regime Ancien Regime (which she supported). Supporters of constitutionnal monarchy tried to RetCon it by putting all the blame on Marie-Antoinette, while Louis XVI was as much, if not more, behind it than her. Few people were fooled, though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette is portrayed as more of a naive but good natured woman recently, with films like Sofia Coppola's and Antonia Fraser's biography citing the horrific smear campaign she endured. In truth, the smear campaign by Jacques Hebert while exceptionally vicious by any standards was part of a political strategy to criticize the Royalist government since the 1791 Constitution refused to allow criticism of the King but left his family members [[LoopholeAbuse an open target]]. Likewise the people of France didn't turn against "L'Autrichienne" for being a lesbian foreigner who hated the poor, they did it because she was actively involved in the Flight to Varennes, where she and the King planned to go to a royalist territory and with support from the Austrian army attack France and re-install the ancien regime (which she supported).


Added DiffLines:

* WrittenByTheWinners: During the Revolution, every side were busy engaging in a propaganda campaign against the other side, while the Coalition conducted their own campaign against the Revolution. In a way, it still goes on today, depending on the political perspectives of people who control the media industry:
** The Jacobin Party as a whole were vilified for the longest time in the Anglo-American press and media, and likewise got much bad press within France for being too extreme in pushing for demands. The tendency is to be more sympathetic towards constitutional monarchy and the moderates who came back to power after the Thermidorian reaction and discredited several Jacobins (as well as conducting their own purge against them). The Jacobins were far from innocent but their actions weren't un-justified. The Girondins were engaged in high level corruption and behind the scenes dealing with Austria and England, they later declared a war against Austria, which Robespierre denounced as a BreadAndCircuses move to divert away from the reforms they had consistently failed to uphold, and when the early phase of the war had started going against France leading to Austria coming in hair's breadth of occupying Paris, the Jacobins supported by the Paris crowd went in open insurrection to protect the Revolution and the French people. It was the Jacobin party that led France to victory in the early stages of the Revolutionary Wars thanks to their open meritocracy, their culling of aristocratic nobles and royals from army positions and introduction of {{Conscription}}.

Added: 201

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Sorry, I made a mistake...Talleyrand was close to a lot of Girondins, Madame de Stael especially.


* FamousLastWords: It was a golden age for this. Among the most famous is Madame Roland's:
--> ''"O Liberté, que de crimes on commet en ton nom!"
--> (Oh Liberty, what crimes are committed in thy name!)



** Georges-Jacques Danton got this a lot especially after the film, ''Danton'' where he was played by Gerard Depardieu and especially for the fact that he and Camille Desmoullins made a commendable effort in trying to stop the Terror. In actual fact, Danton was a highly pragmatic individual who played the angles and who used the Revolution to line his pockets, while at the same time organizing city resistance and inspiring revolutionary fervour. He also instigated the famous September Massacres and created the very instruments of the ReignOfTerror : The Law of Suspects and the Committee of Public Safety. Robespierre only got elected there after he had left. The Committee called him to trial because they cited undisclosed funds, his extravagant lifestyle and a recent financial scandal involving shares from the French East India Company that he had involved himself in.

to:

** Georges-Jacques Danton got this a lot especially after the film, ''Danton'' where he was played by Gerard Depardieu and especially for the fact that he and Camille Desmoullins made a commendable effort in trying to stop the Terror. In actual fact, Danton was a highly pragmatic individual who played the angles and who used the Revolution to line his pockets, while at the same time organizing city resistance and inspiring revolutionary fervour.fervor. He also instigated the famous September Massacres and created the very instruments of the ReignOfTerror : The Law of Suspects and the Committee of Public Safety. Robespierre only got elected there after he had left. The Committee called him to trial because they cited undisclosed funds, his extravagant lifestyle and a recent financial scandal involving shares from the French East India Company that he had involved himself in.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bertrand Barère is seldom, if at all, mentioned as a key figure of the Revolution, while he is the man who had the longest run as member of the Committee of Public Safety and is behind some extreme measures Robespierre disagreed with. He famously said "''Vendée must be destroyed''".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
lolwhut? Talleyrand wasn\'t even in France when the Girondins held power.


** Of course, it turns out that many of the people in Napoleon's cabinet never had real loyalty to the man and were secretly working to undermine him all the time and return France to a more democratic system. Talleyrand, ex-Bishop and Girondin, was the main glue in this.

to:

** Of course, it turns out that many of the people in Napoleon's cabinet never had real loyalty to the man and were secretly working to undermine him all the time and return France to a more democratic system. Talleyrand, ex-Bishop and Girondin, ex-Bishop, was the main glue in this.

Added: 1827

Changed: 64

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ConflictKiller: After ten years of Royalists, Girondins and Jacobins fighting and killing each other in the streets of Paris and failing to establish a stable government after the fall of Robespierre, in comes Napoleon a belove war-hero who proposes a third option, make me Dictator! Quite a few Girondins were opposed to Napoleon taking power as were others but a broad majority tired of the in-fighting and lack of agreement voted for him since it kept the other side from getting a majority. Napoleon than managed [[GenghisGambit to unite the internecine factions by conquering Europe]] "spreading the Revolution", all the while suppressing all newspapers, instituting censorship and bringing slavery back and becoming a military dictator in the process.
** Of course, it turns out that many of the people in Napoleon's cabinet never had real loyalty to the man and were secretly working to undermine him all the time and return France to a more democratic system. Talleyrand, ex-Bishop and Girondin, was the main glue in this.



* EatTheRich: The UrExample for this StockPhrase came about near this time when Jean-Jacques Rousseau reportedly said, "When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich", which would make an interesting corollary with Marie Antoinette's alleged "Let them eat cake" comments. Note that Rousseau died in 1778, though...

to:

* EatTheRich: The UrExample for this StockPhrase came about near this time when Jean-Jacques Rousseau reportedly said, "When the people shall have nothing more to eat, they will eat the rich", which would make an interesting corollary with Marie Antoinette's alleged "Let them eat cake" comments. Note that Rousseau died in 1778, though...1778.



** The Thermidorian Faction of Tallien, Fouche and Barras were full supporters of the ReignOfTerror, with Tallien and Fouche committing atrocities that Robespierre himself called as excessive. He denounced them and drove them into hiding, they later plotted his defeat and the takeover of the Directory, and soon started persecuting their ex-Jacobins and friends in the White Terror campaign. Later Fouche became Napoleon's spymaster and much later betrayed him causing his downfall.
** France itself suffered this, especially in the eyes of the Americans and (to a lesser extent) British and Dutch. While the Absolutists were naturally horrified by the idea of popular sovereignty and democratic republicanism, the major Western maritime powers were liberal and democratic in their on right and initially had sympathy for it on the whole. However, they were increasingly turned off by the various things the revolution turned to, and the MoralEventHorizon for the British was the terror and/owr Republican France's declaration of war against the Dutch Republic and "Crowned" Republic of Great Britain. Likewise, America suffered this to the French revolutionaries for applauding its' "sister revolution" only to declare neutrality when it started declaring wars, even going so far as to say the alliance it had with the Ancien Regime did not apply to the new Republic.

to:

** The Thermidorian Faction of Tallien, Fouche and Barras were full supporters of the ReignOfTerror, with Tallien and Fouche committing atrocities that Robespierre himself called as excessive. He denounced them and drove them into hiding, they later plotted his defeat and the takeover of the Directory, and soon started persecuting their ex-Jacobins and friends in the White Terror campaign. Later Fouche became Napoleon's spymaster and much later betrayed him causing his downfall.
** France itself suffered this, especially in the eyes of the Americans and (to a lesser extent) British and Dutch. While the Absolutists were naturally horrified by the idea of popular sovereignty and democratic republicanism, the major Western maritime powers were liberal and democratic in their on right and initially had sympathy for it on the whole. However, they were increasingly turned off by the various things the revolution turned to, and the MoralEventHorizon for the British was the terror and/owr and/own Republican France's declaration of war against the Dutch Republic and "Crowned" Republic of Great Britain. Likewise, America suffered this to the French revolutionaries for applauding its' "sister revolution" only to declare neutrality when it started declaring wars, even going so far as to say the alliance it had with the Ancien Regime did not apply to the new Republic.



* TheManBehindTheMan: Paul Barras is probably quite close to this. A wealthy bourgeois and minor Nobleman, he was an active member of the Jacobin Club and hoped to profit from the revolution via his business contacts and his network in the Provence. He was an active terrorist and quite unscrupulous, which earned him Robespierre's loathing. He plotted Robespierre's downfall with Fouche and Tallien. During the revolution, he established contacts with many former aristocrats and even counted Therese Cabarras and the young Marie-Rose Joseph de Tascher as his mistress. When Napoleon renamed Marie-Rose as Josephine, Paul Barras sponsored the wedding and his rise to power. He somehow managed to get a cozy exile during the Bourbon restoration despite having voted for the death of the King.



* ThePurge: The ReignOfTerror eerily anticipates the Soviet examples. The jury is still out if it was genuinely driven by stresses and tensions of wartime necessity and siege mentality, or a result of Robespierre's desire for power which lead him to cull other factions. After Thermidor, there was the White Terror, where the Thermidorians hunted down Jacobins and Robespierre holdouts, even sponsoring street gangs who killed like Muscadins who killed with impunity. After Robespierre's death, the Thermidor executed 77 supporters in a single day, the largest single mass guillotine execution during the Revolution.

to:

* ThePurge: The ReignOfTerror eerily anticipates the Soviet examples. The jury is still out if it was genuinely driven by stresses and tensions of wartime necessity and siege mentality, or a result of Robespierre's desire for power which lead him to cull other factions. After Thermidor, there was the White Terror, where the Thermidorians hunted down Jacobins and Robespierre holdouts, even sponsoring street gangs who killed like such as the "jeunesse doree" and the Muscadins who killed with impunity. After Robespierre's death, the Thermidor executed 77 supporters in a single day, the largest single mass guillotine execution during the Revolution.

Added: 280

Changed: 95

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ButForMeItWasTuesday: Much like the "King George III wrote 'nothing important' in his diary on [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution July 4, 1776]]" story, Louis XVI wrote "Nothing." in his journal on July 14, 1789. This is a subversion however, as a) he was referring to his unsuccessful hunting trip that day, and b) an aide burst in shortly after and informed him of the revolt (which is where we get the dialogue at the top of the page).

to:

* ButForMeItWasTuesday: Much like the "King George III wrote 'nothing important' in his diary on [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution July 4, 1776]]" story, Louis XVI wrote "Nothing." in his journal on July 14, 1789. This is a subversion however, as a) he was referring to his unsuccessful hunting trip that day, and b) an aide burst in shortly after his bedroom the night after, awoke him and informed him of the revolt (which is where we get revolt:
-->'''Duke of La Rochefoucauld''': ''Sire,
the dialogue at Bastille has been taken.''
-->'''Louis XVI''': ''Taken? But by who?''
-->'''Duke of La Rochefoucauld''': ''By
the top people, sire.''
-->'''Louis XVI''': ''Is it a revolt?''
-->'''Duke
of the page).La Rochefoucauld''': ''No Sire, it is a revolution.''

Added: 724

Changed: 754

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The Rosetta stone had been used as construction material and was discovered by French soldiers, not stolen. It\'s like the discovery of the Victoire de Samothrace.


* WarForFunAndProfit: While it took the form of authentic national liberation at first, the French Revolutionary Wars also had this character. The war was originally declared by Revolutionary France itself in the hope of expanding its borders under the idea that they would "spread the Revolution", the same justification used by Napoleon. The new Republics in Holland and Italy which they established were forced to pay a great deal of tax to the French government. The Louvre Museum actually built its collections from art theft committed by the Army during this period, including the famous Apollo Belvedere and the Horses of Saint Mark which Napoleon took down from Venice and sent to France. Napoleon's invasion of Egypt likewise involved quite a few of the same, including the Rosetta Stone which the English eventually got hold of, and which the Egyptians desperately want back to this day.

to:

* WarForFunAndProfit: While it took the form of authentic national liberation at first, the French Revolutionary Wars also had this character.
**
The war was originally declared by Revolutionary France itself in the hope of expanding its borders under the idea that they would "spread the Revolution", the same justification used by Napoleon. The new Republics in Holland and Italy which they established were forced to pay a great deal of tax to the French government.
**
The Louvre Museum actually built an important part[[note]]The rest, Mona Lisa to begin with, was already part of Royal collections.[[/note]] of its collections first collection from art theft committed by the Army during this period, including the famous Apollo Belvedere and the Horses of Saint Mark which Napoleon took down from Venice and sent to France. Everything was given back after Napoleon's invasion of Egypt likewise involved quite a few of the same, including the Rosetta Stone which the English eventually got hold of, and which the Egyptians desperately want back to this day.defeat, though.

Added: 1834

Changed: 525

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The French Revolution is usually considered to be a radical alternative to UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution. Ironically, at the time the French and American revolutions were seen as ideological twins (subject peoples inspired by [[RomanticismVersusEnlightenment radical liberal ideas]] overthrowing aristocracies, lead by radicalised members of the middle class like Robespierre and Washington) and supporters of one were usually supporters of the other (Creator/ThomasPaine, the Anglo-US radical, considered a traitor by the British for his support of the American revolution, was an equally-fierce supporter of the revolution in France; he later turned against the leaders of both considering them what we would now call sell-outs). Also ironically, the most famous man to say anything about both revolutions, Irish statesman Edmund Burke, supported the American Revolution but not the one in France - he supported the Americans because they were fighting for freedom but opposed what the French were doing because they were trying to change too much too fast and based only on largely untested ideas.

to:

The French Revolution is usually considered to be a radical alternative to UsefulNotes/TheAmericanRevolution. Ironically, at the time the French and American revolutions were seen as ideological twins (subject peoples inspired by [[RomanticismVersusEnlightenment radical liberal ideas]] overthrowing aristocracies, lead led by radicalised members of the middle class like Robespierre and Washington) and supporters of one were usually supporters of the other (Creator/ThomasPaine, the Anglo-US radical, considered a traitor by the British for his support of the American revolution, was an equally-fierce supporter of the revolution in France; he later turned against the leaders of both considering them what we would now call sell-outs). Also ironically, the most famous man to say anything about both revolutions, Irish statesman Edmund Burke, supported the American Revolution but not the one in France - he supported the Americans because they were fighting for freedom but opposed what the French were doing because they were trying to change too much too fast and based only on largely untested ideas.



* EvilCripple: Georges Couthon was condemned by Thermidorians because of that.

to:

* EvilCripple: Georges Couthon was condemned by Thermidorians because of that. In their defense, Couthon was the man who instituted the dreaded Law of 22 Prairial, with Robespierre's support, by which suspects brought to tribunals could not be allowed witnesses or evidence. The Terror became bloody after that, with most of the new victims being wealthy nobleman and clergy, and in Paris alone, doubling the number of victims in two months than all the numbers in the previous year.



* FullCircleRevolution: The Girondins wanted to establish a liberal democracy with a constitutional framework but their failings resulting from them instigating a foolish war, resulted in the Jacobins starting the ReignOfTerror and establishing Robespierre as dictator. Years later, the Thermidorians, the Directory and others brought Napoleon into power as a compromise between the few radicals that remained and the monarchists, neither of whom they wanted back.
--> '''Madame de Staël''': ''"Robespierre on Horseback"'' [[describing Napoleon]]

to:

* FullCircleRevolution: The Girondins wanted to establish a liberal democracy with a constitutional framework but their failings resulting from them instigating a foolish war, resulted in the Jacobins starting the ReignOfTerror and establishing Robespierre as informal dictator. Years later, the Thermidorians, the Directory and others brought Napoleon into power as a compromise between the few radicals that remained and the monarchists, neither of whom they wanted back.
the other in power. Most famous was the view of one observer:
--> '''Madame de Staël''': ''"Robespierre ''"[[MeetTheNewBoss Robespierre on Horseback"'' [[describing Napoleon]]Horseback]]"''


Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: Quite a few characters get this:
** Georges-Jacques Danton got this a lot especially after the film, ''Danton'' where he was played by Gerard Depardieu and especially for the fact that he and Camille Desmoullins made a commendable effort in trying to stop the Terror. In actual fact, Danton was a highly pragmatic individual who played the angles and who used the Revolution to line his pockets, while at the same time organizing city resistance and inspiring revolutionary fervour. He also instigated the famous September Massacres and created the very instruments of the ReignOfTerror : The Law of Suspects and the Committee of Public Safety. Robespierre only got elected there after he had left. The Committee called him to trial because they cited undisclosed funds, his extravagant lifestyle and a recent financial scandal involving shares from the French East India Company that he had involved himself in.


Added DiffLines:

* WarForFunAndProfit: While it took the form of authentic national liberation at first, the French Revolutionary Wars also had this character. The war was originally declared by Revolutionary France itself in the hope of expanding its borders under the idea that they would "spread the Revolution", the same justification used by Napoleon. The new Republics in Holland and Italy which they established were forced to pay a great deal of tax to the French government. The Louvre Museum actually built its collections from art theft committed by the Army during this period, including the famous Apollo Belvedere and the Horses of Saint Mark which Napoleon took down from Venice and sent to France. Napoleon's invasion of Egypt likewise involved quite a few of the same, including the Rosetta Stone which the English eventually got hold of, and which the Egyptians desperately want back to this day.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FullCircleRevolution: The Girondins wanted to establish a liberal democracy with a constitutional framework but their failings resulting from them instigating a foolish war, resulted in the Jacobins starting the ReignOfTerror and establishing Robespierre as dictator. Years later, the Thermidorians, the Directory and others brought Napoleon into power as a compromise between the few radicals that remained and the monarchists, neither of whom they wanted back.
--> '''Madame de Staël''': ''"Robespierre on Horseback"'' [[describing Napoleon]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** See also SocietyMarchesOn below for some measures who were seen as "extreme" at the time, but are fairly mundane parts of our lives now.

Top