Follow TV Tropes

Following

History UsefulNotes / TheFrenchRevolution

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. Moderate 17th century liberals argued that everything was going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.

to:

Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. Moderate 17th 19th century liberals argued that everything was going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. Moderate 17th century liberals argued that everything was`going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.

to:

Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. Moderate 17th century liberals argued that everything was`going was going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AristocratsAreEvil: A very influential trope at the time and still present in pop-culture depictions, though usually overshadowed by disproportionate focus on Mob Violence.

to:

* AristocratsAreEvil: A very influential trope at the time and still present in pop-culture depictions, though usually overshadowed by disproportionate focus on Mob Violence.mob violence.



** Comte de Mirabeau, the original leader of the Revolution, he rebelled against aristocratic conventions, did time in the Bastille for "libertinage" and ultimately even lost his privileges which made him highly empathetic to the common people and their plight. Because of his complex background he became a popular leader and middleman between the aristocrats who were to be gently coerced to losing their privileges and the angry Third Estate.

to:

** Comte de Mirabeau, the original leader of the Revolution, he Revolution. He rebelled against aristocratic conventions, did time in the Bastille for "libertinage" and ultimately even lost his privileges which made him highly empathetic to the common people and their plight. Because of his complex background he became a popular leader and middleman between the aristocrats who were to be gently coerced to losing their privileges and the angry Third Estate.



** During the Restoration, a number of {{Urban Legend}}s about the Revolution caught life, such as the idea that UsefulNotes/LouisXVI was executed because of a single vote majority (which helped the royalist propaganda that the King was an innocent done in by an evil cabal), that Revolutionaries converted Royalists into GenuineHumanHide and used the leather to bind books (which shows up in some Revolutionary-era fiction like ''Explosion of a Cathedral'' and ''Assassin's Creed Unity''). In addition, there were tropes like [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bals_des_victimes Victims Balls]] where aristocratic women wore mourning clothes and red sashes around their necks as a symbol of the guillotine they narrowly avoided.[[note]]In actual fact only 8% of all victims of the Terror were aristocrats, and until the Great Terror/Law of Prairial there was no attempt to deliberately target aristocrats as victims. The vast majority of victims were either peasants who hoarded foods, actual counter-revolutionaries, suspected counter-revolutionaries and clergy[[/note]] There is no hard evidence to support any of this.

to:

** During the Restoration, a number of {{Urban Legend}}s about the Revolution caught life, such as the idea that UsefulNotes/LouisXVI was executed because of a single vote majority (which helped the royalist propaganda that the King was an innocent done in by an evil cabal), that Revolutionaries converted Royalists into GenuineHumanHide and used the leather to bind books (which shows up in some Revolutionary-era fiction like ''Explosion of a Cathedral'' and ''Assassin's Creed Unity''). In addition, there were tropes like [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bals_des_victimes Victims Balls]] where aristocratic women wore mourning clothes and red sashes around their necks as a symbol of the guillotine they narrowly avoided.[[note]]In actual fact only 8% of all victims of the Terror were aristocrats, and until the Great Terror/Law of Prairial there was no attempt to deliberately target aristocrats as victims. The vast majority of victims were either members of the clergy, peasants who hoarded foods, and actual counter-revolutionaries, or suspected counter-revolutionaries and clergy[[/note]] counter-revolutionaries[[/note]] There is no hard evidence to support any of this.



* ''Les Misérables: Shoujo Cosette'': adsd a cute 3-year old girl to ''Literature/LesMiserables'', bt otherwise follows the basic tale.

to:

* ''Les Misérables: Shoujo Cosette'': adsd adds a cute 3-year old 3-year-old girl to ''Literature/LesMiserables'', bt but otherwise follows the basic tale.

Added: 154

Changed: 750

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/MarieAntoinette2006'', directed by Creator/SofiaCoppola with Creator/KirstenDunst portraying the titular queen. It follows Marie Antoientte's life from her marriage to Louis XVI to the beginning of the French Revolution.
* ''Film/FarewellMyQueen'' a 2012 French film starring Diane Kruger as Marie Antoinette. It explores Versailles in the first three days of the Revolution.

to:

* ''Film/MademoiselleDesiree'', a 1942 French film focusing on Désirée Clary, the first fiancée of Napoleon, who got dumped by him so he could be with UsefulNotes/JosephineDeBeauharnais instead. Désirée's family was part of the bourgeoisie, their intermediary role between the riches of the nobility and the absence of BlueBlood of the common folks amidst the changing social landscape of the Revolution is highlighted by her father early on.
* ''Film/MarieAntoinette2006'', directed by Creator/SofiaCoppola with Creator/KirstenDunst portraying the titular queen. It follows Marie Antoientte's Marie-Antoinette's life from her marriage to Louis XVI to the beginning of the French Revolution.
* ''Film/FarewellMyQueen'' a 2012 French film starring Diane Kruger as Marie Antoinette.Marie-Antoinette. It explores Versailles in the first three days of the Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/AdieuBonaparte'' is about the seldom depicted campaign of General UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte in [[UsefulNotes/ModernEgypt Egypt]] that started in 1798 when France was under the Directory, when the "ideals" of the Revolution were "exported" (via military campaigns).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OffWithHisHead: The use of the guillotine quickly became a symbol of the Revolution, and of the Reign of Terror in particular. Originally designed as a more humane method of execution, it instead became a symbol of ''mass'' execution, as well as becoming associated with the Revolution's egalitarianism and the destruction of the aristocracy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Napoleon|2023}}'' (2023) starts in 1793 during the ReignOfTerror and features the Siege of Toulon, where Napoléon Bonaparte had his first major feat of arms.

to:

* ''Film/{{Napoleon|2023}}'' (2023) is a Napoleon Bonaparte biopic which early parts are set during the Revolution era. The film starts in 1793 with Marie-Antoinette's execution during the ReignOfTerror and ReignOfTerror, then features the Siege of Toulon, where Toulon (where Napoléon Bonaparte had his first major feat of arms.arms), the fall of Robespierre, the [[[[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_Vendemiaire 13 Vendémiaire revolt]], the Egypt campaign, and the 1799 coup.



* ''[[Series/Napoleon2002 Napoléon]]'' is a four-parts miniseries covering the life of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. The first episode is mostlty set during the Directory era[[note]]the episode ends with the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_of_the_rue_Saint-Nicaise Plot of the rue Saint-Nicaise]], during the Consulate era[[/note]] and the events depicted include [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_Vendemiaire 13 Vendémiaire revolt]], the Italy and Egypt campaigns, and the 1799 coup.

to:

* ''[[Series/Napoleon2002 Napoléon]]'' is a four-parts miniseries covering the life of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. The first episode is mostlty set during the Directory era[[note]]the episode ends with the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_of_the_rue_Saint-Nicaise Plot of the rue Saint-Nicaise]], during the Consulate era[[/note]] and the events depicted include [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_Vendemiaire the 13 Vendémiaire revolt]], revolt, the Italy and Egypt campaigns, and the 1799 coup.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Meanwhile, the citizens of Paris, emboldened by the initiative of the National Assembly and responding to rumors (some of which were true) that troops were marching to shut down the Third Estate, stormed the Bastille (a French fortress) in search of arms. This marked the start of the Revolution, with a peasant revolt breaking out in the countryside as peasants attacked castles and noble mansions and literally set fire to records containing list of dues they owed to their master. The National Assembly, very concerned by these actions and trying to calm the rebellious anger,[[note]]Even the Third Estate delegates were by and large fairly conservative (for now) as the only people who could afford to be candidates, were charismatic enough to win election, and had the time to travel to Paris were the upper-class, the bourgeois; the merchants, landlords, and most particularly, lawyers, all of whom had no interest in unleashing anarchy, and were watching the nation's records literally go up in smoke in absolute horror.[[/note]] figuratively get high off patriotism and self-sacrifice and then literally tear down feudalism overnight with the August Decrees of 1789, by magnanimously surrendering their privileges and then calling on others to do the same, abusing the hell out of peer pressure. Finally, in October, the King and Queen were dragged from Versailles to the Tuileries Palace in the city by the women of Paris. By which point, NothingIsTheSameAnymore.

to:

Meanwhile, the citizens of Paris, emboldened by the initiative of the National Assembly and responding to rumors (some of which were true) that troops were marching to shut down the Third Estate, stormed the Bastille (a French fortress) in search of arms. This marked the start of the Revolution, with a peasant revolt breaking out in the countryside as peasants attacked castles and noble mansions and literally set fire to records containing list of dues they owed to their master. The National Assembly, very concerned by these actions and trying to calm the rebellious anger,[[note]]Even the Third Estate delegates were by and large fairly conservative (for now) as the only people who could afford to be candidates, were charismatic enough to win election, and had the time to travel to Paris were the upper-class, the bourgeois; the merchants, landlords, and most particularly, lawyers, all of whom had no interest in unleashing anarchy, and were watching the nation's records literally go up in smoke in absolute horror.[[/note]] figuratively get got high off patriotism and self-sacrifice and then literally tear tore down feudalism overnight with the August Decrees of 1789, by magnanimously surrendering their privileges and then calling on others to do the same, abusing the hell out of peer pressure. Finally, in October, the King and Queen were dragged from Versailles to the Tuileries Palace in the city by the women of Paris. By which point, NothingIsTheSameAnymore.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Les Misérables: Shoujo Cosette'': adsd a cute 3-year old girl to ''Literature/LesMiserables'', bt otherwise follows the basic tale.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/CastlevaniaNocturne'' will follow a vampire hunter in the French Revolution.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Napoleon}}'' (1927), a huge French silent movie directed by Abel Gance, who himself appears in the film as Saint-Just. As Napoleon is the hero, he gets inserted into scenes not based on history, such as the already completely inaccurate scene of the first performance of the Marseillaise in Paris which finishes with captain Bonaparte shaking Rouget de Lisles's hand and congratulating him for his good work for the republic.

to:

* ''Film/{{Napoleon}}'' ''[[Film/Napoleon1927 Napoléon]]'' (1927), a huge French silent movie directed by Abel Gance, who himself appears in the film as Saint-Just. As Napoleon is the hero, he gets inserted into scenes not based on history, such as the already completely inaccurate scene of the first performance of the Marseillaise in Paris which finishes with captain Bonaparte shaking Rouget de Lisles's hand and congratulating him for his good work for the republic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/{{Napoleon}}'' is a four-parts miniseries covering the life of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. The first episode is mostlty set during the Directory era[[note]]the episode ends with the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_of_the_rue_Saint-Nicaise Plot of the rue Saint-Nicaise]], during the Consulate era[[/note]] and the events depicted include [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_Vendemiaire 13 Vendémiaire revolt]], the Italy and Egypt campaigns, and the 1799 coup.

to:

* ''Series/{{Napoleon}}'' ''[[Series/Napoleon2002 Napoléon]]'' is a four-parts miniseries covering the life of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. The first episode is mostlty set during the Directory era[[note]]the episode ends with the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plot_of_the_rue_Saint-Nicaise Plot of the rue Saint-Nicaise]], during the Consulate era[[/note]] and the events depicted include [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/13_Vendemiaire 13 Vendémiaire revolt]], the Italy and Egypt campaigns, and the 1799 coup.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but led to the rise of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte.

to:

The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but led to the rise of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte.UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte and engulfed UsefulNotes/{{Europe}} in [[UsefulNotes/TheNapoleonicWars war]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but led to the rise of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. He marched across Europe, stopped only by Richard Literature/{{Sharpe}} or the [[Literature/WarAndPeace Russian winter]], depending on your nationality.

to:

The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but led to the rise of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. He marched across Europe, stopped only by Richard Literature/{{Sharpe}} or the [[Literature/WarAndPeace Russian winter]], depending on your nationality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but [[MeetTheNewBoss led to the rise of]] UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. He marched across Europe, stopped only by Richard Literature/{{Sharpe}} or the [[Literature/WarAndPeace Russian winter]], depending on your nationality.

to:

The era in UsefulNotes/{{Fr|ance}}ench history known for UsefulNotes/MarieAntoinette [[BeamMeUpScotty allegedly]] giving her subjects some dietary advice. The people responded by storming the Bastille, then Versailles, until they found her and [[UsefulNotes/LouisXVI her husband]] and guillotined them, and a few other nobles for good measure. It promised Liberty, Equality, Fraternity but [[MeetTheNewBoss led to the rise of]] of UsefulNotes/NapoleonBonaparte. He marched across Europe, stopped only by Richard Literature/{{Sharpe}} or the [[Literature/WarAndPeace Russian winter]], depending on your nationality.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Napoleon|2023}}'' (2023) starts in 1793 during the ReignOfTerror and features the Siege of Toulon, where Napoléon Bonaparte had his first major feat of arms.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''VideoGame/AssassinsCreedUnity'' is set between 1789 and 1793.

to:

* ''VideoGame/AssassinsCreedUnity'' is set follows the course of the Revolution between 1789 and 1793.1793 and several historical figures impact the plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

%%* ''Series/LaRevolution''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular supportn Moderate 17th century liberals argued that everything was`going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.

to:

Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular supportn support. Moderate 17th century liberals argued that everything was`going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but`then lost control`of`eventsn[[onote]]) and`had zero`popular supportn Moderate 1yth`century liberals argued`that`everything was`going`fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.

to:

Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but`then but then lost control`of`eventsn[[onote]]) and`had zero`popular control of events[[/note]]) and had zero popular supportn Moderate 1yth`century 17th century liberals argued`that`everything was`going`fine argued that everything was`going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The other radical measure is the first general abolition of slavery in the Western world, without pre-conditions or compensation for slaveowners. This took place in February 1794, in response to the Revolution in Haiti.[[note]]Initial attempts by Mirabeau to get his colleagues to support total abolition fell on deaf years, and the Assembly largely followed a moderate line of expanding rights to mulattos and freedmen in France's Caribbean colonies but made no calls for total abolition since [[OlderThanTheyThink the slaveowning lobby of Club Massiac]] was quite active and influential in stifling these calls. The Committee of Public Safety dispatched Victor Hugues to enforce abolition in France's colonies and in Guadaloupe, Hugues commanded a desegregated army of Frenchmen, Freedmen and rebellious slaves to repel an alliance of slaveowners and Englishmen. But after Thermidor, the Republic was less interested in enforcing the decree, backsliding on enforcing it in the island of Reunion, before Napoleon halted and reversed the decree, appointing the same Victor Hugues to re-enslave manumitted slaves and send them back to their masters.[[/note]]

to:

The other radical measure is the first general abolition of slavery in the Western world, without pre-conditions or compensation for slaveowners. This took place in February 1794, in response to the Revolution revolution and [[SlaveLiberation slave revolt]] in Haiti.UsefulNotes/{{Haiti}}.[[note]]Initial attempts by Mirabeau to get his colleagues to support total abolition fell on deaf years, and the Assembly largely followed a moderate line of expanding rights to mulattos and freedmen in France's Caribbean colonies but made no calls for total abolition since [[OlderThanTheyThink the slaveowning lobby of Club Massiac]] was quite active and influential in stifling these calls. The Committee of Public Safety dispatched Victor Hugues to enforce abolition in France's colonies and in Guadaloupe, Hugues commanded a desegregated army of Frenchmen, Freedmen and rebellious slaves to repel an alliance of slaveowners and Englishmen. But after Thermidor, the Republic was less interested in enforcing the decree, backsliding on enforcing it in the island of Reunion, before Napoleon halted and reversed the decree, appointing the same Victor Hugues to re-enslave manumitted slaves and send them back to their masters.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The oath particularly stung, since papal supremacy in spiritual matters is a core Catholic tenet, and the new oath didn't seem to leave any room for that. The state wages were not really a problem, being a logical extension of the "Gallican" theory of papal power of which France had long been a bastion. The Gallican theory was that the Pope had no authority over temporal affairs outside of lands he personally ruled, and that included decisions about Church administration and what amounted to Church HR. For centuries, the French Crown had enjoyed the absolute right to appoint all bishops and abbots in France -- with a theoretical but never-used papal veto--and there was no expectation this would change.

to:

The oath particularly stung, since papal supremacy in spiritual matters is a core Catholic tenet, and the new oath didn't seem to leave any room for that. The state wages were not really a problem, being a logical extension of the "Gallican" theory of papal power of which France had long been a bastion. The Gallican theory was that the Pope had no authority over temporal affairs outside of lands he personally ruled, and that included decisions about Church administration and what amounted to Church HR. For centuries, the French Crown had enjoyed the absolute right to appoint all bishops and abbots in France -- with France--with a theoretical but never-used papal veto--and veto[[note]]Which itself was actually a relatively modern innovation. Medieval kings across Catholic Europe claimed the right to choose bishops in their lands without even a theoretical papal veto whenever and wherever they could, and often got away with it. The French kings and German Holy Roman Emperors are famous for getting into interminable spats with the Pope about it, but the, er, kings of this are indisputably those of [[UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfWessex Anglo-Saxon England]] in the 9th-11th centuries, who could and did appoint bishops as they pleased across England, and there was nothing the Pope could do about it. (This is largely because the Anglo-Saxons had the most centralised, capable royal state of any country in Western Europe; indeed, arguably only the UsefulNotes/ByzantineEmpire surpassed England in state capacity in Christian Europe during the 10th and 11th centuries.) The Pope backed [[UsefulNotes/TheHouseOfNormandy William the Conqueror]]'s bid for the English throne because he super-promised to allow the Pope to pick the Archbishop of Canterbury at least--a promise William reneged on as soon as it became convenient. The point being that Gallicanism was being ''generous'' to the Pope in giving him a veto he was supposed to never use.[[/note]]--and there was no expectation this would change.



Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then lost control of events.[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. Moderate 19th century liberals argued that everything was going fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.

to:

Ever since the Revolution took place, it has been one of the most debated and contested of all historical events, if not ''the'' most contested and debated event. Conservatives disapproved of such radical social transformation on basic principle, with some (as well as many reactionaries) going so far as to argue that the whole event was arranged by a small minority (possibly members of the Freemasons and/or TheIlluminati, though French reactionaries at the time actually tended to blame the Duke of Orléans[[note]]Whom they thought had started the revolution as a way to prise the crown from his royal cousins, but then but`then lost control of events.[[/note]]) and had zero popular support. control`of`eventsn[[onote]]) and`had zero`popular supportn Moderate 19th century 1yth`century liberals argued that everything was going fine argued`that`everything was`going`fine until it was derailed by bloodthirsty radicals who gave power to completely unqualified people, rather than trusting in carefully elected elites. Radical revolutionaries looked at the Terror and said, [[UtopiaJustifiesTheMeans "Yes, more of that, please,"]] and believed that events failed because its leaders weren't ruthless ''enough''. Unsurprisingly, these interpretations usually say more about later political developments than they do about the actual events. UsefulNotes/PoliticalIdeologies of the 19th and 20th Century, and the [[UsefulNotes/StandardEuropeanPoliticalLandscape European political spectrum]], to this very day, is largely oriented by one's opinions on the French Revolution: the terms "left" and "right" themselves originate in where the delegates sat in the national assembly (other cool terms like Montagnard (Mountaineer) have not survived).[[note]]The French Revolution also influenced American politics. Many political clubs developed in America in imitation of the French, much to President George Washington's displeasure. The pro-Revolution camp was called "Democrat" by Citizen Genet (a Girondin ambassador who got stranded in America when the ReignOfTerror was unleashed).[[/note]] The Revolution also [[TropeMaker made]] and [[TropeCodifier codified tropes]] associated with nationalism, such as national flags, national festivals, national holidays on significant anniversaries, monuments open to the public, museums and institutions for public education.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


After this, the Revolution faced a series of problems, many of them revolving on debates that were OlderThanFeudalism but got stirred up during UsefulNotes/TheEnlightenment. Obviously old-fashioned autocratic Kingdom, DivineRightOfKings, feudal class distinctions and religious control on social levers was getting increasingly unacceptable. If the King and Church was removed, or at least, if their power was limited anyhow, what could take its place? The suggestion put forth was "the Nation" revolving around a conception of French identity that individuals of all classes, all beliefs in all regions could share and accept. Problem was that most of France, outside of the Paris Basin, didn't really feel this unified 'French' identity, and nobody was sure about how, if at all, this idea of the "French nation" was ever to really replace the local traditions of feudal monarchy, always backed by the Church that was more than a millennium old.

to:

After this, the Revolution faced a series of problems, many of them revolving on debates that were literally OlderThanFeudalism and many more that were as old (because they were ''about'' feudalism) but got stirred up during UsefulNotes/TheEnlightenment. Obviously old-fashioned autocratic Kingdom, DivineRightOfKings, feudal class distinctions and religious control on social levers was getting increasingly unacceptable. If the King and Church was removed, or at least, if their power was limited anyhow, what could take its place? The suggestion put forth was "the Nation" revolving around a conception of French identity that individuals of all classes, all beliefs in all regions could share and accept. Problem was that most of France, outside of the Paris Basin, didn't really feel this unified 'French' identity, and nobody was sure about how, if at all, this idea of the "French nation" was ever to really replace the local traditions of feudal monarchy, always backed by the Church that was more than a millennium old.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/LaVendee'' by Creator/AnthonyTrollope, which predated ''A Tale of Two Cities'' by nine years and focused on the Vendean uprising.

Top