Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Trivia / DoctorWhoS28E1NewEarth

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There were going to be more scenes focusing on the Duke of Manhatten and Frau Clovis.

to:

* ** There were going to be more scenes focusing on the Duke of Manhatten and Frau Clovis.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SparedByTheCut: The Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and reveal his message, and the Doctor forced to let the care patients die to cure them. Davies apparently changed his mind after reading Creator/StephenMoffat’s introduction for the book ''The Season One Shooting Scripts''. He joked about how Davies "creates interesting characters and then melts them", which helped change Davies’ mind and create a happier ending. The Face of Boe was also kept around, both because of Creator/BilliePiper’s decision to leave after Series 2, and the show’s renewal making Davies push it back to fit with that season.

to:

* SparedByTheCut: The Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and reveal his message, and the Doctor forced to let the care patients die to cure them. Davies apparently changed his mind after reading Creator/StephenMoffat’s Creator/StevenMoffat’s introduction for the book ''The Season One Shooting Scripts''. He joked about how Davies "creates interesting characters and then melts them", which helped change Davies’ mind and create a happier ending. The Face of Boe was also kept around, both because of Creator/BilliePiper’s decision to leave after Series 2, and the show’s renewal making Davies push it back to fit with that season.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
General clarification on works content


* SparedByTheCut: The Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and reveal his message, and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. The Face of Boe was kept alive both because of Creator/BilliePiper’s decision to leave after Series 2, and the show’s renewal making Davies push it back to fit with that season. He was also influenced by Moffat ribbing in the introduction about how he "creates interesting characters and then melts them".

to:

* SparedByTheCut: The Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and reveal his message, and the only way Doctor forced to let the care patients die to cure them. Davies apparently changed his mind after reading Creator/StephenMoffat’s introduction for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. book ''The Season One Shooting Scripts''. He joked about how Davies "creates interesting characters and then melts them", which helped change Davies’ mind and create a happier ending. The Face of Boe was also kept alive around, both because of Creator/BilliePiper’s decision to leave after Series 2, and the show’s renewal making Davies push it back to fit with that season. He was also influenced by Moffat ribbing in the introduction about how he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". season.



** Originally, the Face of Boe was to die and deliver his message to the Doctor in this episode. Davies postponed the revelation after the series was renewed for another season.

to:

** Originally, As mentioned above, the Face of Boe was to die and deliver his message to the Doctor in this episode. Davies postponed the revelation after the series was renewed for another season.

Changed: 1819

Removed: 841

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Plagiarism of TARDIS wiki.


* EnforcedMethodActing: Creator/BilliePiper didn't know she was going to be hit with water in the lift. Creator/RussellTDavies kept it in the final cut as he thought it was too funny to cut it.



* SparedByTheCut: In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode (and thus impart his secret to the Doctor a year earlier) and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead. The Face of Boe was spared because his final message was felt to work better in Series 3.

to:

* SparedByTheCut: In the original script, the The Face of Boe was going to die in this episode (and thus impart and reveal his secret to the Doctor a year earlier) message, and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's The Face of Boe was kept alive both because of Creator/BilliePiper’s decision to leave after Series 2, and the show’s renewal making Davies push it back to fit with that season. He was also influenced by Moffat ribbing in the introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he about how he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead. The Face of Boe was spared because his final message was felt to work better in Series 3.



** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that was lost was a moment that would've bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during [[Recap/DoctorWhoS27E2TheEndOfTheWorld "The End of the World"]] and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.

to:

** Because production fell behind schedule, several * There were going to be more scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned focusing on the Duke of Manhattan Manhatten and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that was lost was a moment that would've bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during [[Recap/DoctorWhoS27E2TheEndOfTheWorld "The End of the World"]] and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.Clovis.



** Cassandra's servant was envisioned as a dwarf named Zaggit, but as the character's importance grew during the scripting process, he developed into Chip.
** Had Creator/ZoeWanamaker been unavailable for filming, Davies would have introduced her evil sister "Roseanne".
* WordOfGod: According to Creator/RussellTDavies on the DVDCommentary, Cassandra's earlier self bases Chip on the man who had praised her beauty at the party — Chip himself. Where the "pattern" for Chip comes from in the first instance is thus unclear, creating an ontological paradox.
* WordOfSaintPaul: In the DVDCommentary: Creator/DavidTennant noted that the TARDIS has moved since "[[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion The Christmas Invasion]]". He speculates that there might have been many off-screen adventures, or (observing that it no longer seems like Christmas in the introduction) perhaps that the Doctor "lived there for a bit".

to:

** Cassandra's servant was envisioned as a dwarf named Zaggit, but as the character's importance grew during the scripting process, he developed into Chip.
** Had Creator/ZoeWanamaker been unavailable for filming, Davies would have introduced her evil sister "Roseanne".
* WordOfGod: According to Creator/RussellTDavies on the DVDCommentary, Cassandra's earlier self bases Chip on the man who had praised her beauty at the party — Chip himself. Where the "pattern" for Chip comes from in the first instance is thus unclear, creating an ontological paradox.
"Roseanne".
* WordOfSaintPaul: In the DVDCommentary: Creator/DavidTennant noted surmises that the TARDIS has moved since Doctor had several adventure elsewhere between "[[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion The Christmas Invasion]]". He speculates that there might have been many off-screen adventures, or (observing that it no longer seems like Christmas in the introduction) perhaps that the Doctor "lived there for a bit".Invasion]]" and this episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* {{Corpsing}}: Creator/BilliePiper makes a valiant effort to hide her amusement during the "Goodness me, I'm a man!" scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Had Creator/ZoëWanamaker been unavailable for filming, Davies would have introduced her evil sister "Roseanne".

to:

** Had Creator/ZoëWanamaker Creator/ZoeWanamaker been unavailable for filming, Davies would have introduced her evil sister "Roseanne".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that was lost was a moment that would've bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during [[DoctorWho/Recap/S27E2TheEndOfTheWorld "The End of the World"]] and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.

to:

** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that was lost was a moment that would've bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during [[DoctorWho/Recap/S27E2TheEndOfTheWorld [[Recap/DoctorWhoS27E2TheEndOfTheWorld "The End of the World"]] and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.

Added: 115

Changed: 179

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added new trope example


** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that would've been cut would've been a scene that bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during "The End of the World" and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.
** Originally, the Face of Boe was to deliver his message to the Doctor in this episode.

to:

** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that was lost was a moment that would've been cut would've been a scene that bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during [[DoctorWho/Recap/S27E2TheEndOfTheWorld "The End of the World" World"]] and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.
** Originally, the Face of Boe was to die and deliver his message to the Doctor in this episode.episode. Davies postponed the revelation after the series was renewed for another season.


Added DiffLines:

** Had Creator/ZoëWanamaker been unavailable for filming, Davies would have introduced her evil sister "Roseanne".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added new trope

Added DiffLines:

* RealLifeWritesTheHairstyle: Rose is suddenly wearing her hair up in the episode's final scene, in order to hide Creator/BilliePiper's hair extensions from [[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion "The Christmas Invasion"]], which was still in production when the Cassandra drinks party sequence was filmed.

Added: 363

Removed: 359

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Since Tennant was the lead actor at the time of recording and not merely saying this off the cuff after he left the role, this should be under Word Of Saint Paul


* WordOfDante: In the DVDCommentary: Creator/DavidTennant noted that the TARDIS has moved since "[[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion The Christmas Invasion]]". He speculates that there might have been many off-screen adventures, or (observing that it no longer seems like Christmas in the introduction) perhaps that the Doctor "lived there for a bit".



* WordOfSaintPaul: In the DVDCommentary: Creator/DavidTennant noted that the TARDIS has moved since "[[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion The Christmas Invasion]]". He speculates that there might have been many off-screen adventures, or (observing that it no longer seems like Christmas in the introduction) perhaps that the Doctor "lived there for a bit".



Added: 616

Removed: 601

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SparedByTheCut: In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode (and thus impart his secret to the Doctor a year earlier) and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead. The Face of Boe was spared because his final message was felt to work better in Series 3.



** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode (and thus impart his secret to the Doctor a year earlier) and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead. The Face of Boe was spared because his final message was felt to work better in Series 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added new trope

Added DiffLines:

* RecastAsARegular: Sister Jatt is played by Adjoa Andoh, who would go on to play Martha Jones's mother Francine in Series 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.

to:

** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode (and thus impart his secret to the Doctor a year earlier) and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead. The Face of Boe was spared because his final message was felt to work better in Series 3.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnforcedMethodActing: Creator/BilliePiper didn't know she was going to be hit with water in the lift, Creator/RussellTDavies kept it in the final cut as he thought it was too funny to cut it.

to:

* EnforcedMethodActing: Creator/BilliePiper didn't know she was going to be hit with water in the lift, lift. Creator/RussellTDavies kept it in the final cut as he thought it was too funny to cut it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RecycledSet: The scenes taking place in the Sisterhood's industrial Intensive Care Unit were filmed in the since-demolished Ely Paper Mill in Grangetown, Cardiff, which also served as the location for the underground Nestene lair in [[Recap/DoctorWhoS27E1Rose "Rose"]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WordOfDante: In the DVDCommentary: Creator/DavidTennant noted that the TARDIS has moved since "[[Recap/DoctorWho2005CSTheChristmasInvasion The Christmas Invasion]]". He speculates that there might have been many off-screen adventures, or (observing that it no longer seems like Christmas in the introduction) perhaps that the Doctor "lived there for a bit".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BuxomIsBetter: Creator/BilliePiper's physical transformation from Rose to Cassandra was all about support. For her Cassandra scenes, she put on a different shade of lipstick, and wore a Wonderbra to enhance her cleavage and make her character a bit more shapely (in some shots, the outline of the bra is visible through her shirt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BuxomIsBetter: Creator/BilliePiper's physical transformation from Rose to Cassandra was all about support. For her Cassandra scenes, she wore a Wonderbra to enhance her cleavage and make her character a bit more shapely (in some shots, the outline of the bra is visible through her shirt).

to:

* BuxomIsBetter: Creator/BilliePiper's physical transformation from Rose to Cassandra was all about support. For her Cassandra scenes, she put on a different shade of lipstick, and wore a Wonderbra to enhance her cleavage and make her character a bit more shapely (in some shots, the outline of the bra is visible through her shirt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BuxomIsBetter: Creator/BilliePiper's physical transformation from Rose to Cassandra was all about support. For her Cassandra scenes, she wore a Wonderbra to enhance her cleavage and make her character a bit more shapely (in some shots, the outline of the bra is visible through her shirt).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* WordOfGod: According to Creator/RussellTDavies on the DVDCommentary, Cassandra's earlier self bases Chip on the man who had praised her beauty at the party — Chip himself. Where the "pattern" for Chip comes from in the first instance is thus unclear, creating an ontological paradox.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients.

to:

** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients. Another scene that would've been cut would've been a scene that bridged the gap between the Doctor and Rose leaving the hospital with Cassandra and arriving at the party where she dies in Chip's body. The missing scene would've had the Doctor making clear he hadn't forgotten the deaths Cassandra caused on Platform One during "The End of the World" and added more context to Cassandra's death scene.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* ActingForTwo: Creator/DavidTennant and Creator/BilliePiper have to do the double duty of being the Doctor and Rose as well as Cassandra.

Added: 4

Changed: 4

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


----



** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanase them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.

to:

** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanase euthanize them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he "creates interesting characters and then melts them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.

Added: 4

Changed: 16

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanase them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he 'creates interesting characters and then melts them'. This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.
* WorkingTitle: ''Body Swap'' and ''The Sunshine Camp''.

to:

** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanase them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he 'creates "creates interesting characters and then melts them'.them". This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.
* WorkingTitle: ''Body Swap'' "Body Swap" and ''The "The Sunshine Camp''.Camp".

----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EnforcedMethodActing:

to:

* EnforcedMethodActing: Creator/BilliePiper didn't know she was going to be hit with water in the lift, Creator/RussellTDavies kept it in the final cut as he thought it was too funny to cut it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* EnforcedMethodActing:
* WagTheDirector: The episode came about because Creator/BilliePiper requested an opportunity to be funny, as a counterpoint to the often very serious material she had tackled in the first season.
* WhatCouldHaveBeen:
** Because production fell behind schedule, several scenes were dropped. Many of these concerned the Duke of Manhattan and Frau Clovis. Originally, they first appeared in the hospital foyer when the Doctor initially arrives; as scripted, the Doctor immediately earns the Sisters of Plenitude's disfavour when he saves the Duke's life. Later, Clovis mutinies when the Duke refuses to help defend the hospital against the Intensive Care patients.
** Originally, the Face of Boe was to deliver his message to the Doctor in this episode.
** Cassandra's servant was envisioned as a dwarf named Zaggit, but as the character's importance grew during the scripting process, he developed into Chip.
** In the original script, the Face of Boe was going to die in this episode and the only way for the Doctor to cure all the diseased was to euthanase them all. But then Creator/RussellTDavies read Creator/StevenMoffat's introduction segment in ''The Season One Shooting Scripts'' book, in which Moffat good naturedly mocked Davies, saying he 'creates interesting characters and then melts them'. This made Davies decide to have them all survive instead.
* WorkingTitle: ''Body Swap'' and ''The Sunshine Camp''.

Top