History NightmareFuel / FaithTheUnholyTrinity

** It is triggered if John refuses to investigate on any single day, instead [[ScrewThisImOutOfHere getting in his car and driving back home.]] In doing this, Gary is ultimately able to bring about the Profane Sabbath and unleash HellOnEarth throughout the entire town. Perhaps the ''entire world''. The thralls are '''everywhere''', surrounding John's home with pixelated heads under the influence of the Second Death. They don't harm John immediately, as though they're welcoming him into there midst for his failure.

* It may be shorter than the other places of interest, but the abandoned daycare has its own creepiness to offer. You’re not in danger, but you soon will be. The tunnels await.

--->''P.S. I almost forgot to thank you for the pet. I will keep it outside my private quarters as a guard against intruders.

* A certain tree in the cemetery turns into a humanoid form and runs away screaming. Bizarre? Yes. Creepy? Yes.

--->''He promised me so much''\\
''I just want to see my little boy again''\\
''The replacement is almost fully formed''\\
''Just a few more bodies''

--->'''Gary:''' SOMETIMES, IT WAITS FOR THE ONE WHO HAS ALREADY WALKED THROUGH IT.\\

* The Crucible. If you break the seal, you finally have the right to enter it. And right below is not another ancient hallway or some foreboding woods. You’re back in a dark, derelict, yet all-too-familiar house. And there’s no explanation as to why the Martin’s house is on the inside of the Crucible. It’s just there.
** It is here you discover a [[TheReveal horrifying truth.]] Miriam willingly and successfully subjects herself to the Second Death. And after '''days''' of sacrifices into the portal, there’s a response. A seemingly normal baby is pulled out and is given a name: '''GARY'''. And all through the house are repeating notes that all say the same thing: [[MadnessMantra "GARY LOVES YOU. GARY IS A NORMAL HUMAN BEING, JUST LIKE YOU AND ME."]]. No, he’s not. He ''never'' was.
* The last battle in Miriam's chamber. It’s not enough John’s in there with the desiccated body of Miriam Bell, but he’s in there with one cornered and very angry Gary. By now he’s seemingly ''melting'' and is coming after you as a bloated, crawling ''thing'' with an empty maw. What’s worse, the already-summoned Malphas soon joins the nightmare.
--->'''Gary:''' I will make you the first mortal to witness the Profane Sabbath, and the first to be consumed by it. But before I do, I will let you in on a secret: ''(Gary turns to face John) '''[[VillainousBreakdown GARY DOES NOT LOVE YOU.]]'''''

* The true final battle. Both demons [[FusionDance fuse themselves with Miriam]] to, after a fake congratulatory fanfare, become an unholy, floating mishmash of all three. Without Amy, this body may be Gary’s alternative to his end goal: a vessel powerful enough to unleash the Profane Sabbath.

** So how do you? When John finally comes face to face with Gary and ''earns the right'' to ask three questions, one of the last ones pertains to the [[SummoningRitual Second Death.]] It's been explained and hinted at through the game, but here is the concrete answer: after preparing a vessel (victim) through the injection[[note]]this is also something you can ask[[/note]] for the UNSPEAKABLE to enter (abuse), their face is carved off with a sacrificial knife. Then a living newborn is fed through the orifice before there's a response. The story [[NothingIsScarier never really explains]] why Amy seems to be the crux for the UNSPEAKABLE, or why no other Second Death participants were as potent as her given all the other people turning into demons from their heads -- meaning any random person in the wrong circumstances could be the perfect candidate to cut their face off and summon ''the Devil itself.''

--->'''"I GO UNWILLINGLY."'''\\
'''"I HAVE THE BODY OF A PIG!"'''\\
'''"RUN! RUN! RUN!"'''

!! Demo

---> '''Graveyard Note''': "What more could I have done? I warned them not to go into the fields. I warned them against straying too far from the sanctuary. Should I have shut them in their quarters and nailed boards over the doors? Now I am digging six graves here in the shadow of the church. Six little graves forever looking to Saint William. Some of the boxes are empty... [[NotEnoughToBury the scattered remains we found couldn't fill them all]]. But I know they're all gone. I know their souls were taken by that thing in the field. I will finish my gruesome work and then [[CrisisOfFaith renounce the ministry]]. I don't want to see anyone from the sanctuary ever again, not even that girl who stayed inside the house last night. I don't believe in the Devil anymore. Whatever did this is much, much worse."

--->'''I'M HERE, PRIEST.'''\\
'''[[ParanoiaFuel HERE I COME.]]'''\\
'''THEY ARE MINE FOREVER.'''

!! Full Game

* In an alternate ending, John finds himself in the midst of a Satanic ritual, where he is approached by a giant red abomination. His eyes cry tears of blood at the sight while a disturbingly triumphant church organ plays. SmashToBlack

!! Demo

!! Full Game

** It is triggered if John refuses to investigate the daycare, instead [[ScrewThisImOutOfHere getting in his car and driving back home.]] In doing this, Gary is ultimately able to bring about the Profane Sabbath and unleash HellOnEarth throughout the entire town. Perhaps the ''entire world''. The thralls are '''everywhere''', surrounding John's home with pixelated heads under the influence of the Second Death. They don't harm John immediately, as though they're welcoming him into there midst for his failure.