Follow TV Tropes

Following

History MindScrew / LiveActionFilms

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Tarkovsky himself admitted that he didn't understand the full meaning of some of the scenes in ''Film/TheMirror'', which jumps back and forth randomly between different points in the protagonist's childhood and adulthood, ostensibly because the protagonist, Alexei, is having a deathbed stream-of-consciousness dream/reminiscence of his life. The idea that anything is possible in a dream seems the only explanation for such scenes as the one where a strange woman asks Alexei's son Ignat to read a poem by Creator/AlexanderPushkin, only for him to be interrupted by a woman knocking at the door who apologises for getting the wrong address, and when Ignat returns, the strange woman has vanished, but the condensation under her teacup is still on the table.

to:

** Tarkovsky himself admitted that he didn't understand the full meaning of some of the scenes in ''Film/TheMirror'', ''Film/{{The Mirror|1975}}'', which jumps back and forth randomly between different points in the protagonist's childhood and adulthood, ostensibly because the protagonist, Alexei, is having a deathbed stream-of-consciousness dream/reminiscence of his life. The idea that anything is possible in a dream seems the only explanation for such scenes as the one where a strange woman asks Alexei's son Ignat to read a poem by Creator/AlexanderPushkin, only for him to be interrupted by a woman knocking at the door who apologises for getting the wrong address, and when Ignat returns, the strange woman has vanished, but the condensation under her teacup is still on the table.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
True Art Is Incomprehensible is now an in-universe trope as per TRS.


* ''Film/Persona1966'' features an actress who goes mute, except maybe she really isn't but wants to get away from her life. Her nurse wants to become the actress because she hates herself, and maybe she did. Or didn't. The actress also has a son that is involved... somehow. The opening scenes feature dead bodies, a sheep being stabbed with a knife, and [[WriterRevolt an erect penis]]. What does all this have to do with the rest of the film? [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment No idea]], as it's even more out of place than the rest of the movie. Anyone who says they get what's going on [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible is lying]].

to:

* ''Film/Persona1966'' features an actress who goes mute, except maybe she really isn't but wants to get away from her life. Her nurse wants to become the actress because she hates herself, and maybe she did. Or didn't. The actress also has a son that is involved... somehow. The opening scenes feature dead bodies, a sheep being stabbed with a knife, and [[WriterRevolt an erect penis]]. What does all this have to do with the rest of the film? [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment No idea]], as it's even more out of place than the rest of the movie. Anyone who says they get what's going on [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible is lying]].lying.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/ArizonaDream'' by Creator/EmirKusturica. [[CloudCuckoolander Insanely weird characters]]? Check. [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs Odd dreams]]? Check. [[MindScrew Flying fish]]?! You bet! So, what exactly happened in the movie? Well, it sort of varies.

to:

* ''Film/ArizonaDream'' by Creator/EmirKusturica. [[CloudCuckoolander Insanely weird characters]]? Check. [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs Odd dreams]]? dreams? Check. [[MindScrew Flying fish]]?! You bet! So, what exactly happened in the movie? Well, it sort of varies.

Added: 567

Changed: 22

Removed: 329

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/{{Pi}}'' was described by ''The A.V. Club'' [[http://www.avclub.com/articles/pi,19384/ as]] "like ''Film/{{Eraserhead}}'' re-envisioned by {{cyberpunk}} author Creator/WilliamGibson." Mix a paranoid mathematical genius, Hebrew numerology, conspiracies, neurological headaches, the secret name of God, and [[spoiler:the aforementioned paranoid mathematical genius taking [[ThisIsADrill a drill]] to his head to escape all this crap]]. To top it off, it's filmed in [[DeliberatelyMonochrome extremely high-contrast black and white]] and scored to techno music.



* The Swedish film ''Film/{{Persona 1966}}'' features an actress who goes mute, except maybe she really isn't but wants to get away from her life. Her nurse wants to become the actress because she hates herself, and maybe she did. Or didn't. The actress also has a son that is involved... somehow. The opening scenes feature dead bodies, a sheep being stabbed with a knife, and [[WriterRevolt an erect penis]]. What does all this have to do with the rest of the film? [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment No idea]], as it's even more out of place than the rest of the movie. Anyone who says they get what's going on [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible is lying]].

to:

* The Swedish film ''Film/{{Persona 1966}}'' ''Film/Persona1966'' features an actress who goes mute, except maybe she really isn't but wants to get away from her life. Her nurse wants to become the actress because she hates herself, and maybe she did. Or didn't. The actress also has a son that is involved... somehow. The opening scenes feature dead bodies, a sheep being stabbed with a knife, and [[WriterRevolt an erect penis]]. What does all this have to do with the rest of the film? [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment No idea]], as it's even more out of place than the rest of the movie. Anyone who says they get what's going on [[TrueArtIsIncomprehensible is lying]].



* The movie ''[=Pi=]'' (''Film/{{Pi}}'') has a paranoid mathematical genius, Hebrew numerology, conspiracies, neurological headaches, the secret name of God, and [[spoiler:the protagonist taking [[ThisIsADrill A Drill]] to his head to escape all this crap]]. To top it off, it's in black and white. And is scored to techno music.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* If you don't know the twist in ''TheSixthSense'' you will experience the most thorough fucking of your mind ever. [[spoiler: The protagonist died five minutes in. The other protagonist knew the whole time and kept it a secret. The wife has been grieving this entire time.]] It's not so much that the twist in question happened, but that the audience realizes immediately how much sense it makes.

to:

* If you don't know the twist in ''TheSixthSense'' ''Film/TheSixthSense'' you will experience the most thorough fucking of your mind ever. [[spoiler: The protagonist died five minutes in. The other protagonist knew the whole time and kept it a secret. The wife has been grieving this entire time.]] It's not so much that the twist in question happened, but that the audience realizes immediately how much sense it makes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/FriendOfTheWorld'' is a surreal black and white film that makes the audience question the characters' fate in the second half.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Film/{{Stalker}}'' gives us trains that cause the title character's tiny apartment to rattle, only for the sound to briefly change into the strains of "La Marseillaise" or Wagner's ''Tannhauser'' overture or Ravel's ''Bolero'' or Beethoven's Symphony No.9, and then there's the ending, in which the stalker's daughter, "Monkey", telekinetically pushes three glasses across a table... a scene whose meaning remains hotly debated.

to:

** ''Film/{{Stalker}}'' ''Film/Stalker1979'' gives us trains that cause the title character's tiny apartment to rattle, only for the sound to briefly change into the strains of "La Marseillaise" or Wagner's ''Tannhauser'' overture or Ravel's ''Bolero'' or Beethoven's Symphony No.9, and then there's the ending, in which the stalker's daughter, "Monkey", telekinetically pushes three glasses across a table... a scene whose meaning remains hotly debated.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Film/ArizonaDream'' by Emir Kusturica. [[CloudCuckoolander Insanely weird characters]]? Check. [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs Odd dreams]]? Check. [[MindScrew Flying fish]]?! You bet! So, what exactly happened in the movie? Well, it sort of varies.

to:

* ''Film/ArizonaDream'' by Emir Kusturica.Creator/EmirKusturica. [[CloudCuckoolander Insanely weird characters]]? Check. [[WhatDoYouMeanItWasntMadeOnDrugs Odd dreams]]? Check. [[MindScrew Flying fish]]?! You bet! So, what exactly happened in the movie? Well, it sort of varies.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/PossiblyInMichigan'' is one of the oddest short films ever made. Two women in an empty shopping mall are stalked by a cannibal wearing a latex mask. He keeps popping up behind them, yet they never notice him until later. Most of the dialogue is delivered in a childish sing-song voice. The short ends with [[spoiler: the women killing and eating the cannibal]]...but somehow, he's still alive and well enough to steal wine from them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
page was moved to the Darth Wiki


* ''Film/EaglesGathered'' is set in the underworld, which doesn't function according to normal human logic. Bob the (maybe) angel randomly switches bodies without warning, plot threads appear and disappear without warning or explanation, and the main characters' plans only work when they're completely incoherent. And that's the least of it.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ''Film/WhatTheBleepDoWeKnow'' is a ''major, major'' offender of this one. If you can make some sense out of the cryptic, convoluted {{Technobabble}} about Quantum Mechanics, Religion, Life, the Universe and Everything, you'll see how this movie easily beats ''Anime/SerialExperimentsLain'' in terms of head-trippiness, even though even Wiki/TheOtherWiki agrees it's all just quantum mysticism mixed with the ideas of some new age school. [[http://www.intuitor.com/moviephysics/bleep.html According to Intuitor]], it also completely messed up Quantum Physics, horrible research, biases and scientific inaccuracies destroyed any hope of correct science.

to:

* ''Film/WhatTheBleepDoWeKnow'' is a ''major, major'' offender of this one. If you can make some sense out of the cryptic, convoluted {{Technobabble}} about Quantum Mechanics, Religion, Life, the Universe and Everything, you'll see how this movie easily beats ''Anime/SerialExperimentsLain'' in terms of head-trippiness, even though even Wiki/TheOtherWiki Website/TheOtherWiki agrees it's all just quantum mysticism mixed with the ideas of some new age school. [[http://www.intuitor.com/moviephysics/bleep.html According to Intuitor]], it also completely messed up Quantum Physics, horrible research, biases and scientific inaccuracies destroyed any hope of correct science.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/Dementia1955'':
** The film is chock-full of weird surrealistic imagery. The cop who's chasing the woman doesn't seem all that serious about arresting her; it's more like he's content to trail behind her while smiling creepily. The corpse of the rich man is surrounded by faceless people who look on impassively, not even reacting as the woman crawls in between them and cuts the man's hand off with her knife. There's a weird moment after the woman throws the man off the balcony in which the butler, who saw everything, simply laughs approvingly. And when the woman enters the nightclub, the pimp simply throws a cocktail dress at her, and she's instantly wearing it. Much of this is eventually justified by the AllJustADream ending.
** It's not clear what the woman's relationship to the rich man is or why the pimp ushers her into the rich man's car. Is the woman a prostitute? If she's a streetwalker, she isn't dressed for it. Is she his kept woman? Also, why is the detective, who is played by the same actor who plays the woman's father in the flashback, following her around before she's even done anything?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The indie film ''Archie's Final Project'' aka ''My Suicide'' is a bit of a mind screw. The whole movie is meant to be a school project made by the main character, who is a teenage boy with a movie obsession and probably several mental illnesses. The first hour or so has a lot of slightly obscure movie references and a lot of random animation, images, and voice overs that don't really make sense, especially not the first time you watch it.

to:

* The indie film ''Archie's Final Project'' ''Film/ArchiesFinalProject'' aka ''My Suicide'' is a bit of a mind screw. The whole movie is meant to be a school project made by the main character, who is a teenage boy with a movie obsession and probably several mental illnesses. The first hour or so has a lot of slightly obscure movie references and a lot of random animation, images, and voice overs that don't really make sense, especially not the first time you watch it.



* ''Clean, Shaven'' is largely about providing a more objective look at schizophrenia and it's effects. Although the plot is straight forward, it's a mind screw because uses a lot of unusual/disturbing images and sounds to give us an insight into the protagonists condition.

to:

* ''Clean, Shaven'' ''Film/CleanShaven'' is largely about providing a more objective look at schizophrenia and it's effects. Although the plot is straight forward, it's a mind screw because uses a lot of unusual/disturbing images and sounds to give us an insight into the protagonists condition.



* The Netflix-exclusive short film ''Example Show'', re-released under names such as ''Example Short 23.976 Clear Show'', ''Example Short 23.976 Burned In Timecode Remote Content'' and other strange titles. It involves [[LeaveTheCameraRunning lingering shots]] of the Netflix building gardens and a model train carrying toy penguins as the actor/director runs around doing random stuff and eventually quoting ''Theatre/JuliusCaesar''. WordOfGod says that it was short made by a freelancer meant as a way for people streaming from Netflix to test their video players. The short has been subject to much MemeticMutation, usually along the same lines as "Three Wolf Moon."

to:

* The Netflix-exclusive short film ''Example Show'', ''Film/ExampleShow'', re-released under names such as ''Example Short 23.976 Clear Show'', ''Example Short 23.976 Burned In Timecode Remote Content'' and other strange titles. It involves [[LeaveTheCameraRunning lingering shots]] of the Netflix building gardens and a model train carrying toy penguins as the actor/director runs around doing random stuff and eventually quoting ''Theatre/JuliusCaesar''. WordOfGod says that it was short made by a freelancer meant as a way for people streaming from Netflix to test their video players. The short has been subject to much MemeticMutation, usually along the same lines as "Three Wolf Moon."



* ''The Guards'', a 1965 Norwegian film by director Arne Skouen, telling the story of a soldier who neglects his duties because of a moral responsibility for a psych ward full of children with psychological problems. The story revolves around a court martial held afterwards, but to be fair, it is not certain whether the whole trial is in the soldier's head, or if he and the other adults working in the ward are actually as far out as the children they tend to. And then there is the oldest charge, a fourteen year old girl, CreepyChild and psychic to boot. The movie ends with a spectacular GainaxEnding. It tends to be the biggest MindScrew ever made in Norway.

to:

* ''The Guards'', ''Film/TheGuards'', a 1965 Norwegian film by director Arne Skouen, telling the story of a soldier who neglects his duties because of a moral responsibility for a psych ward full of children with psychological problems. The story revolves around a court martial held afterwards, but to be fair, it is not certain whether the whole trial is in the soldier's head, or if he and the other adults working in the ward are actually as far out as the children they tend to. And then there is the oldest charge, a fourteen year old girl, CreepyChild and psychic to boot. The movie ends with a spectacular GainaxEnding. It tends to be the biggest MindScrew ever made in Norway.



* ''I Love Your Work'' isn't as extreme as others on this list, as a simple [[spoiler: "I guess it was all in his head"]] makes sense of it as a whole, as the ending makes that seem like the most likely explanation. But some scenes are still pretty odd.

to:

* ''I Love Your Work'' ''Film/ILoveYourWork'' isn't as extreme as others on this list, as a simple [[spoiler: "I guess it was all in his head"]] makes sense of it as a whole, as the ending makes that seem like the most likely explanation. But some scenes are still pretty odd.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Up To Eleven is a defunct trope


* ''Paranoia 1.0'' (often known only as ''One Point O'') is as mind-screwy as it gets. A man (Jeremy Sisto, no less) receives empty packages while constantly dozing off in front of his computer: he's trying to write a program to meet a deadline, but he's constantly falling asleep and receiving empty packages... and developing an increasingly unhealthy craving for "Nature Fresh Milk". The apartment complex is full of people who have cravings for equally irrelevant things and there is a landlord that watches everything. Everything in the movie (e.g. what the empty packages are, why the landlord has an equivalent craving for packed meat, etc.) is explained in a logical and sensible manner -- that is, until the movie decides to crank up the mind-screw-gears [[UpToEleven to twelve hundred]] and then flat out breaks the gauge and lets the whole thing explode. Thus, you just face an ending that leaves you wondering what you just watched.

to:

* ''Paranoia 1.0'' (often known only as ''One Point O'') is as mind-screwy as it gets. A man (Jeremy Sisto, no less) receives empty packages while constantly dozing off in front of his computer: he's trying to write a program to meet a deadline, but he's constantly falling asleep and receiving empty packages... and developing an increasingly unhealthy craving for "Nature Fresh Milk". The apartment complex is full of people who have cravings for equally irrelevant things and there is a landlord that watches everything. Everything in the movie (e.g. what the empty packages are, why the landlord has an equivalent craving for packed meat, etc.) is explained in a logical and sensible manner -- that is, until the movie decides to crank up the mind-screw-gears [[UpToEleven to twelve hundred]] hundred and then flat out breaks the gauge and lets the whole thing explode. Thus, you just face an ending that leaves you wondering what you just watched.

Top