Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / PeriodPiece

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]]. Or a [[GrammarNazi period]]. And the song "Period Piece" by Lloyd Cole is only vaguely this trope.

to:

[[IThoughtItMeant [[JustForFun/IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]]. Or a [[GrammarNazi period]]. And the song "Period Piece" by Lloyd Cole is only vaguely this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


More specific genres include SwordAndSandal, JidaiGeki and TheWestern.

to:

More specific genres include SwordAndSandal, {{Wuxia}}, JidaiGeki and TheWestern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]]. Or a [[GrammarNazi period]].

to:

[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]]. Or a [[GrammarNazi period]]. And the song "Period Piece" by Lloyd Cole is only vaguely this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical due to ValuesDissonance. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812. (Even further proved that, in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries, they had to change Lydia's scandal to make the plotline work).

to:

There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical due to ValuesDissonance. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' ''Literature/PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812. (Even further proved that, in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries, they had to change Lydia's scandal to make the plotline work).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'' His historical novel about Agincourt was quite good considered as a modern historical novel; that is, considered as the adventures of a modern public schoolboy at a fancy dress ball. ''
--->--'''Creator/GKChesterton''', ''Literature/TheReturnOfDonQuixote''

to:

-->'' His ->''"His historical novel about Agincourt was quite good considered as a modern historical novel; that is, considered as the adventures of a modern public schoolboy at a fancy dress ball. ''
--->--'''Creator/GKChesterton''', ''Literature/TheReturnOfDonQuixote''
ball."''
-->-- '''Creator/GKChesterton''', ''The Return of Don Quixote''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative -- \\
is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form --"''
-->-- '''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''Literature/SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

to:

->''"The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative -- \\
is always more or less an infusion of the
-->'' His historical novel about Agincourt was quite good considered as a modern spirit into historical novel; that is, considered as the ancient form --"''
-->-- '''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''Literature/SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''
adventures of a modern public schoolboy at a fancy dress ball. ''
--->--'''Creator/GKChesterton''', ''Literature/TheReturnOfDonQuixote''

Added: 83

Changed: 85

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''"The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative -- is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form --"''

to:

->''"The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative -- \\
is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form --"''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]] -- and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se'' -- something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.

to:

You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]] -- and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se'' -- something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.
ago - because any period of time greater than 25 years tends to shade into "when your parents were kids", which would obviously be pretty unrecognizable to you.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->-- '''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

to:

-->-- '''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''
''Literature/SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

to:

-->--'''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', -->-- '''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of the Brontë sisters, Creator/JaneAusten, or Creator/CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.

to:

Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful purposeful attempt that to recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of the Brontë sisters, Creator/JaneAusten, or Creator/CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheBBC makes a lot of these, and Creator/{{PBS}} imports them wholesale. The BBC have sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on costume dramas when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, they're very ''good'' at making them: they usually garner a lot of praise, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.

to:

TheBBC Creator/TheBBC makes a lot of these, and Creator/{{PBS}} imports them wholesale. The BBC have sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on costume dramas when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, they're very ''good'' at making them: they usually garner a lot of praise, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC Creator/TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]].

to:

[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]]. Or a [[GrammarNazi period]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Creator/EmilyBronte, Creator/JaneAusten, or Creator/CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.

to:

Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Creator/EmilyBronte, the Brontë sisters, Creator/JaneAusten, or Creator/CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Menstrual Menace is about supernatural horrors caused by a woman\'s period. All Periods Are PMS is about women being cranky that time of the month. See this Trope Repair Shop thread for more info.


[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[MenstrualMenace period]].

to:

[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[MenstrualMenace [[AllPeriodsArePMS period]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical due to ValuesDissonance. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812.

to:

There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical due to ValuesDissonance. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812.
1812. (Even further proved that, in The Lizzie Bennet Diaries, they had to change Lydia's scandal to make the plotline work).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Extra credit if they use the [[VanityPlate studio logo]] [[LogoJoke from the era the work is set in]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheBBC makes a lot of these, and {{PBS}} imports them wholesale. The BBC have sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on costume dramas when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, they're very ''good'' at making them: they usually garner a lot of praise, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.

to:

TheBBC makes a lot of these, and {{PBS}} Creator/{{PBS}} imports them wholesale. The BBC have sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on costume dramas when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, they're very ''good'' at making them: they usually garner a lot of praise, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

On the other end of the scale, if the story would make ''more'' sense set in the present because the characters exhibit modern values that's PurelyAestheticEra; if it's set around a specific event in the recent past, enough that the lack of distance from the era leads to sloppy set mistakes it's PresentDayPast.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--'''GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

to:

-->--'''GeorgeEliot''', -->--'''Creator/GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

Changed: 29

Removed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Emily Bronte, JaneAusten, or CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.

to:

Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Emily Bronte, JaneAusten, Creator/EmilyBronte, Creator/JaneAusten, or CharlesDickens Creator/CharlesDickens are especially common.) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.




----
<<|FilmGenres|>>

to:

\n----\n<<|FilmGenres|>>----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheBBC makes a lot of these. They've sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on them when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, when they do make them, they usually get a lot of praise for them, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.

to:

TheBBC makes a lot of these. They've these, and {{PBS}} imports them wholesale. The BBC have sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on them costume dramas when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, when they do make them, they're very ''good'' at making them: they usually get garner a lot of praise for them, praise, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.
Camacan MOD

Changed: 13

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


->''The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative–is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form,''
-->'''GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

to:

->''The ->''"The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative–is approximative -- is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form,''
-->'''GeorgeEliot''',
form --"''
-->--'''GeorgeEliot''',
''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


TheBBC makes a lot of these. They've sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on them when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, when they do make them, they usually get a lot of praise for them, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.

to:

TheBBC makes a lot of these. They've sometimes even been accused of "falling back" on them when they've got into trouble for something or when the licence renewal is coming up and they need to show they can do some "proper" drama. That said, when they do make them, they usually get a lot of praise for them, and the end result is packaged into box sets for sale during PBS pledge drives. As a side effect of their decades of PeriodPiece production, TheBBC has accumulated a vast stockpile of costumes and expertise, which is occasionally raided by sister shows such as ''DoctorWho'' ''Series/DoctorWho'' when they decide to do a historical episode.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Compare HistoricalFiction. Closely related to the CostumeDrama.

to:

Compare HistoricalFiction. Closely related to the CostumeDrama.
CostumeDrama. Contrast UnintentionalPeriodPiece.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Emily Bronte, JaneAusten, or CharlesDickens are especially common.)

to:

Very often OscarBait. Sometimes it's based on literature that was contemporary when published, but feels like a purposesful attempt that recapture that era for new audiences. (Adaptations of Emily Bronte, JaneAusten, or CharlesDickens are especially common.)
) Useful if the period predates a TropeBreaker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Added DiffLines:

[[IThoughtItMeant Not to be confused with]] a piece about ''having'' a [[MenstrualMenace period]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]]—and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se'' -- something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.

to:

You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]]—and costumes]] -- and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se'' -- something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.

Added: 550

Changed: 643

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]]—and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se''—something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.

to:

->''The finest effort to reanimate the past is of course only approximative–is always more or less an infusion of the modern spirit into the ancient form,''
-->'''GeorgeEliot''', ''SillyNovelsByLadyNovelists''

You know those things. Takes place in the past. Invites lavish production values like [[SceneryPorn art direction]] and [[GorgeousPeriodDress costumes]]—and usually cinematography while you're at it. It's kind of hard to define what defines "period" films ''per se''—something se'' -- something that took place a decade ago could count, technically, but period pieces set in the very recent past are rare unless it's to poke fun at the era in question. Big budget period pieces are often dramas, frequently big epic ones, and take place at least thirty years ago.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812.

to:

There's no real need for examples. Just about any show set in the past counts. You'd know one if you saw one. Some Tropers restrict this trope to "any show set in the past that could have been set in the present", but that ignores the fact that it's impossible for most period pieces to be set in the present day because the plot and the characters' motivations would be nonsensical.nonsensical due to ValuesDissonance. For example, setting ''PrideAndPrejudice'' in the present day as is would make the crisis (Wickham's eloping with Lydia) seem inconsequential and the reaction silly, since the ''entire point'' of the crisis is that if Lydia doesn't marry Wickham and clear the family name, the rest of the sisters will end up as impoverished old maids because no gentleman will marry them. That's the way life was in 1812.

Top