Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / MagicalNegro

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


With such [[CloserToEarth deep spiritual wisdom]] (and sometimes — though not always — actual [[EthnicMagician supernatural powers]]), you might wonder why the Magical Negro doesn't step up and save the day himself. This will never happen. [[IncorruptiblePurePureness So enlightened and selfless is he]] that he [[GoodSamaritan has no desire to gain glory for himself]]; he only wants to help those who need guidance... which ''just happens'' to mean [[WhiteMaleLead those who are traditionally viewed by Hollywood as better suited for protagonist roles]], not, say, his own oppressed people. In fact, the Magical Negro really seems to have no goal in life other than [[TokenBlackFriend helping white people]] achieve their fullest potential; he may even be [[MentorOccupationalHazard ditched or killed outright once he's served that purpose]]. If he does express any selfish desires, it will only be in the context of helping the white protagonists realize their own racism and thereby become better people.

to:

With such [[CloserToEarth deep spiritual wisdom]] (and sometimes — though not always — actual [[EthnicMagician supernatural powers]]), you might wonder why the Magical Negro doesn't step up and save the day himself. [[WhiteMaleLead For the sake of Hollywood's target audience]], This will never happen. [[IncorruptiblePurePureness So enlightened and selfless is he]] that he [[GoodSamaritan has no desire to gain glory for himself]]; he only wants to help those who need guidance... which ''just happens'' to mean [[WhiteMaleLead those who are traditionally viewed by Hollywood as better suited for protagonist roles]], not, say, his own oppressed people. happen.
In fact, the Magical Negro really seems to have no goal in life other than [[TokenBlackFriend helping white people]] achieve their fullest potential; he may even be [[MentorOccupationalHazard ditched or killed outright once he's served that purpose]]. If he does express any selfish desires, it will only be in the context of helping the white protagonists realize their own racism and thereby become better people.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Morgan Freeman's role as God in this movie does somewhat downplay the trope since there are actual given reasons for this trope to play.


** The ''[[Film/BruceAlmighty Bruce]]/Film/EvanAlmighty'' films, where the main characters are selfish white guys who need his assistance to find wisdom. He's almost literally magical in this case, as he's playing {{God}}.

to:

** The ''[[Film/BruceAlmighty Bruce]]/Film/EvanAlmighty'' films, where the main characters are selfish white guys who need his assistance to find wisdom. He's almost literally magical in this case, as he's playing {{God}}.widsom. Given that he plays the role of {{God}}, his character has [[JustifiedTrope actual good reasons]] for mentoring them selflessly.

Added: 262

Changed: 388

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The literally magical Vitruvius in ''WesternAnimation/TheLEGOMovie'' serves to play with this trope.

to:

** The literally magical Vitruvius in ''WesternAnimation/TheLEGOMovie'' serves to play with this trope.trope as a parody of Freeman's usual wise mentor roles, with him being the OnlySaneMan compared to the rest of the cast's antics. Then it's revealed [[spoiler:he made the whole chosen one prophecy up out of desperation, but despite this he gives Emmet some final advice to save the day]].



%%* Gloria in '' Literature/BecauseOfWinnDixie'' is a [[TwoferTokenMinority fourfer:]] [[InspirationallyDisadvantaged blind]], black, female, and a dry alcoholic.

to:

%%* * Gloria in '' Literature/BecauseOfWinnDixie'' is a [[TwoferTokenMinority fourfer:]] [[InspirationallyDisadvantaged blind]], black, female, and a dry alcoholic.alcoholic who teaches the protagonist about dealing with grief and not judging others before you know their story.
* In ''Film/{{Daredreamer}}'', Zach's main role is to share wisdom with Winston, recover Jennie's writing, and encourage Winston to share his daydreams with the class. It's a more literal example than normal, as he also appears in the dream world to give advice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Subverted in ''Series/TheGoodPlace''. Former moral philosophy professor Chidi is initially presented as the wise and altruistic foil to the immensely selfish Eleanor, who got into Heaven with him due to a cosmic mistake. She begs him to give her lessons on ethics so she won't get kicked out, and he complies - even though she barely listens to him, expresses casual racism such as [[AfricaIsACountry referring to Africa as a country]], and expects him to do all her chores. Eventually it all gets too much for him, and he vents about how burdensome it is that his entire afterlife revolves around her. It also turns out he has a ton of his own issues, and instead of solving problems for his friends in life, he caused them with his [[TheDitherer chronic indecisiveness]] and unmanaged anxiety.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Harlan, Adam's family's old driver in ''Film/{{Adam}}'' seems to have nothing better to do than give him advice, and look bemused, of course.

to:

* Harlan, Adam's family's old driver in ''Film/{{Adam}}'' ''Film/Adam2009'' seems to have nothing better to do than give him advice, and look bemused, of course.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
renamed trope


** Strangest of all is Patrick, who is a Magical ''Irishman.'' He befriends Liz and Spike (the two grimmest girls in the show). Then he teaches them to live and enjoy life again, to a degree where he's like a mild male version of the ManicPixieDreamGirl. The effect -- a boy dressed like a stock Irish laborer from old movies, singing Celtic love songs (which he writes and composes) in a thick brogue -- is hard to describe. We never see him do ''anything'' that doesn't involve helping these girls, and he eventually [[BrotherChuck vanishes without a trace]].

to:

** Strangest of all is Patrick, who is a Magical ''Irishman.'' He befriends Liz and Spike (the two grimmest girls in the show). Then he teaches them to live and enjoy life again, to a degree where he's like a mild male version of the ManicPixieDreamGirl. The effect -- a boy dressed like a stock Irish laborer from old movies, singing Celtic love songs (which he writes and composes) in a thick brogue -- is hard to describe. We never see him do ''anything'' that doesn't involve helping these girls, and he eventually [[BrotherChuck [[ChuckCunninghamSyndrome vanishes without a trace]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In the story "Franchise/{{Batman}} R.I.P.", Bruce Wayne is found lost on the street with no memory of who he is, when he comes across a black homeless man named Honor Jackson. Honor helps Bruce start his path to recovery, but then disappears and is revealed to have already been dead. However, while it looks like this trope at first, it's actually a subversion -- it's eventually revealed that Honor is looking for his own personal redemption, saying that he'd never done anything he could be proud of, but was now happy to save one man's life. In a blink-and-you'll-miss-it appearance, Honor Jackson gets a page in the first issue of Morrison's Batman run. Batman gives him a few bucks when the Batmobile is stopped nearby, noting to Robin that there's always time to help people. Honor apparently uses this money to drink himself to death. Arguably the Honor that Bruce met later during Batman R.I.P. was never anything more than a fragment of Bruce's psyche, which raises a few questions about Bruce.

to:

* In the ''ComicBook/BatmanGrantMorrison'' story "Franchise/{{Batman}} "Batman R.I.P.", Bruce Wayne is found lost on the street with no memory of who he is, when he comes across a black homeless man named Honor Jackson. Honor helps Bruce start his path to recovery, but then disappears and is revealed to have already been dead. However, while it looks like this trope at first, it's actually a subversion -- it's eventually revealed that Honor is looking for his own personal redemption, saying that he'd never done anything he could be proud of, but was now happy to save one man's life. In a blink-and-you'll-miss-it appearance, Honor Jackson gets a page in the first issue of Morrison's Batman run. Batman gives him a few bucks when the Batmobile is stopped nearby, noting to Robin that there's always time to help people. Honor apparently uses this money to drink himself to death. Arguably the Honor that Bruce met later during Batman "Batman R.I.P. " was never anything more than a fragment of Bruce's psyche, which raises a few questions about Bruce.



* ''ComicBook/WhatIf ... ComicBook/CaptainAmerica Fought In [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar The Civil War]]?'' reduces ComicBook/TheFalcon to a cross between a Magical Negro and a MagicalNativeAmerican (in this version he was raised by the Shawnee tribe and became a shaman). He gives Steve Rogers a [[WhoopiEpiphanySpeech speech about seeing the similarities in people]], uses his [[ReligionIsMagic mystic abilities]] to give Steve superpowers, and then gets killed.
* In Neil Gaiman's ''ComicBook/TheSandman'' series, the character Maisie Hill in the Game of You story arc (otherwise known as the I-don't-like-dogs-lady) changes one main character's perceptions of "subway people" and literally saves another main character's life with the sacrifice of her own.

to:

* ''ComicBook/WhatIf ... ComicBook/CaptainAmerica Fought In [[UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar The Civil War]]?'' reduces ComicBook/TheFalcon the Falcon to a cross between a Magical Negro and a MagicalNativeAmerican (in this version he was raised by the Shawnee tribe and became a shaman). He gives Steve Rogers a [[WhoopiEpiphanySpeech speech about seeing the similarities in people]], uses his [[ReligionIsMagic mystic abilities]] to give Steve superpowers, and then gets killed.
* In Neil Gaiman's ''ComicBook/TheSandman'' series, ''ComicBook/TheSandman1989'', the character Maisie Hill in the Game of You story arc (otherwise known as the I-don't-like-dogs-lady) changes one main character's perceptions of "subway people" and literally saves another main character's life with the sacrifice of her own.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''FilmTheKillingBox'': Rebecca is a mute escaped slave who is knowledgeable about the magic behind thwarting the zombies and makes Strayn question some of the Confederacy's beliefs after he falls in love with her.

Added: 394

Changed: 260

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Parodied--or something--in Bill Fitzhugh's ''Pest Control''. Just when the protagonist Bob Dillon ([[RunningGag no relation to]] Music/BobDylan) is at his lowest ebb, with his wife and daughter having left, and he without enough money to so much as buy a nice dinner, he stumbles upon a southern Black woman who runs the Beebe Avenue Mission. While giving him some advice, snark, and soup, she happens to mention that she opened the mission specifically to fix people's broken dreams. Which means she's not there just to help Bob, she's doing her best to help ''everyone''. [[spoiler:At the end of the book, Bob sends her a good portion the money he earned from faking his own assassination. She notes that she can fix a lot of dreams with this.]]

to:

* Parodied--or something--in Bill Fitzhugh's ''Pest Control''. Just when the protagonist Bob Dillon ([[RunningGag no relation to]] Music/BobDylan) is at his lowest ebb, ebb; his wife left with his wife and daughter having left, daughter, and he without doesn't even have enough money to so much as even buy a nice dinner, he dinner. He stumbles upon a southern Black woman who runs the Beebe Avenue Mission. While giving she gives him some advice, snark, and soup, she happens to mention that she opened the mission specifically to fix people's broken dreams. "broken dreams". Which means she's not there just to help Bob, she's doing her best to help ''everyone''. [[spoiler:At ''everyone''.
** In the climax, Bob [[spoiler:pays it forward by giving hope to Klaus, the depressive, suicidal hitman who's been helping Bob. Specifically, he comes up with a plan that will let Bob's family and Klaus fake their deaths, and start over with a shedload of money.]]
** At
the end of the book, Bob [[spoiler:Bob sends her a good portion the money he earned from faking his own assassination. money. She notes says that she can fix a lot of dreams with this.it.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Despite receiving applause for introducing Jo Martin as the first black female incarnation of the famous Time Lord (officially dubbed "The Fugitive Doctor"), showrunner Chris Chybnall couldn't help but have her fall back into this trope - the Fugitive Doctor appears as a vision to the Thirteenth Doctor during "[[Recap/DoctorWhoS38E10TheTimelessChildren The Timeless Children]]", purely in order to give her a motivating pep talk. Later appearances of the Fugitive Doctor show her having her own adventures and working to her own agenda, though these are still framed as inspiration for her later, white incarnation.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* An old homeless man named Crackajack Jackson made a huge impression on the Hulk in ''[[ComicBook/TheIncredibleHulk1968 The Incredible Hulk]]'' #182 by teaching him to read a little bit, and just by being a genuinely loving and nonjudgmental friend. When he was accidentally killed by his own son during a battle with the Hulk, the Hulk mourned his passing for years afterward.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Walt was apparently intended to have this type of role as he’s a child implied to have psychic connection with the island, but his character was soon minimized due to the logistical difficulties of keeping a child actor in a show that went on to spend several seasons on less than a year passing in the story. Still, he continues to pop up every now and then (sometimes in the course of visions by other characters), where he does fulfill this sort of role.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How Nick Fury is largely portrayed in the films (bonus points for being another Creator/SamuelLJackson example) while also combining this with being the BigGood and BaldBlackLeaderGuy, as despite being the leader of SHIELD, and a badass in his own right, he still leaves the world-saving largely up to the (all white) Avengers, and as time goes on he's seemingly became more of this. PlayedWith at least in that [[RaceLift Fury was white in the original comics]], but there he actually had his own story as the lead character and was more functionally a HeroOfAnotherStory or ReasonableAuthorityFigure.

to:

** How Nick Fury is largely portrayed in the films (bonus points for being another Creator/SamuelLJackson example) while also combining this with being the BigGood and BaldBlackLeaderGuy, BaldOfAuthority, as despite being the leader of SHIELD, and a badass in his own right, he still leaves the world-saving largely up to the (all white) Avengers, and as time goes on he's seemingly became more of this. PlayedWith at least in that [[RaceLift Fury was white in the original comics]], but there he actually had his own story as the lead character and was more functionally a HeroOfAnotherStory or ReasonableAuthorityFigure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A very literal example appears [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment inexplicably]] at the end of Film/SgtPeppersLonelyHeartsClubBand, [[DeusExMachina rewinding the protagonist's suicide-in-progress and resurrecting his sweetheart]]. All while singing The Beatles' "Get Back".

to:

* A very literal example appears [[BigLippedAlligatorMoment inexplicably]] at the end of Film/SgtPeppersLonelyHeartsClubBand, Film/SgtPeppersLonelyHeartsClubBand. The statue of Sgt. Pepper (a white guy) comes to life as Creator/BillyPreston, using the power of The Beatles' "Get Back" to [[DeusExMachina rewinding rewind the protagonist's suicide-in-progress and resurrecting resurrect his sweetheart]]. All while singing The Beatles' (This was no simple RaceLift. Preston had played on a number of Beatles tracks, and the original "Get Back".Back" was credited to "The Beatles with Billy Preston".)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* When you think about it, the novelty song ''The Witch Doctor'' is this: the protagonist seeks out the "guy who's so much wiser" for the magic words to win a girl's heart.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
per Is this an example thread, not an example


[[folder:Advertising]]
* An interesting variation is when a black character gets advice from their mature, future self. They may literally ''be'' magical, as we never learn how the future self appears in the present.
** In a milk commercial [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ra6Gm-Xpu7A]], a little girl meets a frowsy, tired woman who says "I'm you from the future". When the girl drinks milk, the woman suddenly becomes an award-winning athlete.
** There's a car commercial where a young man gets a ride from his older self, showing him the type of car he could get. When he drops the younger man off, he says "By the way...your future wife is in there."
** A 2022 commercial for Crypto.com [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KymZ-28tIjc]] takes place in the bedroom of LeBron James in 2003. The present-day LeBron is telling him about the future, but declines to tell him whether he should turn pro.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The premise of ''Series/NewAmsterdam'' is that a MightyWhitey saves the life of a MagicalNativeAmerican and in return they use their magic to make him immortal. Naturally, it never occurs to them to make the members of their own tribe immortal, perhaps because the immortal magic only works on superior white genes. However, they only made him immortal until he found his true happiness (BlessedWithSuck?), at which point he'd become mortal again. Since they're not around anymore, the implication is that they were already quite happy the way they were, making it less Magical Negro and more NobleSavage (recovering MagicalNativeAmerican).

to:

* The premise of ''Series/NewAmsterdam'' ''Series/NewAmsterdam2008'' is that a MightyWhitey saves the life of a MagicalNativeAmerican and in return they use their magic to make him immortal. Naturally, it never occurs to them to make the members of their own tribe immortal, perhaps because the immortal magic only works on superior white genes. However, they only made him immortal until he found his true happiness (BlessedWithSuck?), at which point he'd become mortal again. Since they're not around anymore, the implication is that they were already quite happy the way they were, making it less Magical Negro and more NobleSavage (recovering MagicalNativeAmerican).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Vadinho from the ''Film/PumaMan'', whose job it is to hand the protagonist the magic belt with the mystical powers of the Puma Man and make him realize his destiny without using these awesome powers for himself, instead becoming the hero's {{sidekick}}. The problem is, the hero is so ineffectual that Vadinho ends up looking like TheHero by comparison and making the film unintentionally subvert the trope.

to:

* Vadinho from the ''Film/PumaMan'', ''Film/ThePumaman'', whose job it is to hand the protagonist the magic belt with the mystical powers of the Puma Man and make him realize his destiny without using these awesome powers for himself, instead becoming the hero's {{sidekick}}. The problem is, the hero is so ineffectual that Vadinho ends up looking like TheHero by comparison and making the film unintentionally subvert the trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Advertising]]
* An interesting variation is when a black character gets advice from their mature, future self. They may literally ''be'' magical, as we never learn how the future self appears in the present.
** In a milk commercial [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ra6Gm-Xpu7A]], a little girl meets a frowsy, tired woman who says "I'm you from the future". When the girl drinks milk, the woman suddenly becomes an award-winning athlete.
** There's a car commercial where a young man gets a ride from his older self, showing him the type of car he could get. When he drops the younger man off, he says "By the way...your future wife is in there."
** A 2022 commercial for Crypto.com [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KymZ-28tIjc]] takes place in the bedroom of LeBron James in 2003. The present-day LeBron is telling him about the future, but declines to tell him whether he should turn pro.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** How Nick Fury is largely portrayed in the films (bonus points for being another Creator/SamuelLJackson example) while also combining this with being the BigGood and BlackBaldLeaderGuy, as despite being the leader of SHIELD, and a badass in his own right, he still leaves the world-saving largely up to the (all white) Avengers, and as time goes on he's seemingly became more of this. PlayedWith at least in that [[RaceLift Fury was white in the original comics]], but there he actually had his own story as the lead character and was more functionally a HeroOfAnotherStory or ReasonableAuthorityFigure.

to:

** How Nick Fury is largely portrayed in the films (bonus points for being another Creator/SamuelLJackson example) while also combining this with being the BigGood and BlackBaldLeaderGuy, BaldBlackLeaderGuy, as despite being the leader of SHIELD, and a badass in his own right, he still leaves the world-saving largely up to the (all white) Avengers, and as time goes on he's seemingly became more of this. PlayedWith at least in that [[RaceLift Fury was white in the original comics]], but there he actually had his own story as the lead character and was more functionally a HeroOfAnotherStory or ReasonableAuthorityFigure.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/StephenKing seems to have issues on this subject; many of his writings and their [[TheFilmOfTheBook film adaptations]] include examples of this trope. To be fair to King, he does acknowledge his tendency to write characters such as Dick Hallorann and Mother Abigail as superblack heroes (his words) and says they are products of his white liberal guilt.

to:

* Creator/StephenKing seems to have issues on this subject; many of his writings and their [[TheFilmOfTheBook film adaptations]] include examples of this trope. To be fair to King, he does acknowledge his tendency to write characters such as Dick Hallorann and Mother Abigail as superblack heroes (his words) and says [[WriteWhatYouKnow they are products of his white liberal guilt.guilt]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheIrregulars'': The Linen Man rescues Jessica from the Plague Doctor with a magical cloud of butterflies, explains what she is and why she is seeing things, and advises her on how to figure out what is going on. But he can't solve her problems directly as Jessica is in London and he is physically in Louisiana. [[spoiler: Brutally subverted when he shows up in London for real and starts killing people.]]

to:

* ''Series/TheIrregulars'': The Linen Man rescues Jessica from the Plague Doctor with a magical cloud of butterflies, explains what she is and why she is seeing things, and advises her on how to figure out what is going on. But he can't solve her problems directly as Jessica is in London and he is physically in Louisiana. [[spoiler: Brutally subverted Subverted when he shows up in London for real and starts killing people.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
mentally disabled magic people have their own trope: Inspirationally Disadvantaged


** ''Literature/{{Dreamcatcher}}'': Duddits is a white, saintly brain-damaged kid.
** Magic, mentally disabled guys are arguably a ''literal'' trope in themselves with Stephen King. They seem to have special immunity to dark magic and what-not.



** ''Franchise/TheDarkTower'': Sheemie Ruiz, the slightly retarded [[spoiler: psychic and teleporter]]. Avoided, however, with Susannah, who is black and disabled, but also a fully-rounded, three-dimensional character with no mysterious powers.



** When asked by Magazine/{{Playboy}} why he/Hollywood does that, King replied, "white liberal guilt."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not an aversion, she's explicitly magic in the book


** ''Literature/TheStand'': Mother Abigail, elderly and black; Nick Andros, deaf-mute; Tom Cullen, mentally disabled. Abigail is arguably an aversion, since she's the single most powerful person in Boulder. Also averted in that we spend quite a lot of time inside Mother Abigail's head, and her self-doubt complicates the situation for the heroes in the second act. Joe, a twelve-to-fourteen-year old who, due to trauma, regressed into a non-speaking, sometimes violent savage. Larry at one point realizes that Joe is ''reading his mind''.

to:

** ''Literature/TheStand'': Has Mother Abigail, elderly and black; Nick Andros, deaf-mute; Tom Cullen, mentally disabled. Abigail who is arguably an aversion, since she's positioned as the single most powerful person in Boulder. Also averted in "good" magical counterpart of the evil Flagg. It's her visions that we spend quite a lot of time inside Mother Abigail's head, lead the various protagonists to Boulder, and it's around her self-doubt complicates the situation for the heroes in the second act. Joe, a twelve-to-fourteen-year old who, due to trauma, regressed into a non-speaking, sometimes violent savage. Larry at one point realizes that Joe is ''reading his mind''.the first post plague society organizes itself.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


[[folder:Web Comics]]
* In ''Webcomic/{{Sinfest}}'', [[http://sinfest.net/view.php?date=2007-11-12 Slick knows to consult one.]]
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE


* The title character in Bernard Malamud's short story "The Angel Levine" is an early (and very blatant) example.
* ''The Cay,'' by Theodore Taylor, features an old black man who rescues a racist white boy who had become blinded when their ship sinks. The two live together in a tropical island and the black man lives long enough to make the boy a better person before [[DeathByNewberyMedal dying in a hurricane.]] The book won a number of awards before suffering a backlash due to accusations of racism. Nonetheless it remains a classic children's book.

to:

* %%* The title character in Bernard Malamud's short story "The Angel Levine" is an early (and very blatant) example.
* ''The Cay,'' ''Literature/TheCay,'' by Theodore Taylor, features an old black man who rescues a racist white boy who had become blinded when their ship sinks. The two live together in a tropical island and the black man lives long enough to make the boy a better person before [[DeathByNewberyMedal dying in a hurricane.]] The book won a number of awards before suffering a backlash due to accusations of racism. Nonetheless it remains a classic children's book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
natter


** This is a parody though, he tells Robin that he couldn't be bothered to remember their names and implies that however poetically he may have pretended to phrase it for them, he was leaving because he was bored.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
convo on the main page


** However, while Guinan fits the trope closely enough to be a definite example, she's also a little more complex than most Magical Negroes -- it's strongly implied that she led her own long life of adventure and heroism before settling down as a bartender, and on rare occasions she does realize she was wrong about something instead of being mysteriously right all the time.

Changed: 492

Removed: 475

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
indentation fix, removing shoehorned example


* Rose on ''Series/{{Lost}}'' consistently dispenses sensible, down-to-earth wisdom. She leads Charlie in prayer after his DisneyDeath. She mystically "knows" her husband is alive elsewhere on the island. In general, if she believes a character is good, she's correct.
** However, Rose later grew a bit, becoming a character in her own right in season 2 with a back story and her own side plot. And by season 4, she's actively snarking at Jack. And then she decides to [[spoiler:just give up and just live in "retirement" with Bernard]].

to:

* ''Series/{{Lost}}'':
**
Rose on ''Series/{{Lost}}'' consistently dispenses sensible, down-to-earth wisdom. She leads Charlie in prayer after his DisneyDeath. She mystically "knows" her husband is alive elsewhere on the island. In general, if she believes a character is good, she's correct.
**
correct. However, Rose later grew a bit, becoming a character in her own right in season 2 with a back story and her own side plot. And by season 4, she's actively snarking at Jack. And then she decides to [[spoiler:just give up and just live in "retirement" with Bernard]].



** Locke initially seems to fit the role of a strange white version of a Magical Negro, possessing mystical, almost shamanistic knowledge and a deep, unexplained communion with the island, always ready to dispense nice bits of pop-wisdom and jungle smarts... that is, until later in the series when he goes from subservient shaman spirit-guide to full-blown [[MessianicArchetype Messiah]]. And then crazy person/gullible dupe, responsible for much ill-advised StuffBlowingUp.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Averted in ''Series/{{Oz}}''. While Kareem Said is a brilliant leader and fiercely intelligent, he deals with many of his own problems. Character depth also prevents him from just being a cliche. His friendship with Tobias Beecher is also more destructive in a sense than helpful.

to:

* Averted in ''Series/{{Oz}}''. While Kareem Said is a brilliant leader and fiercely intelligent, he deals with many of his own problems. Character depth also prevents him from just being a cliche. His friendship with Tobias Beecher is also more destructive in a sense than helpful.helpful; if anything, Beecher is the one who enriches Said's life rather than the other way around, [[HonestAdvisor by calling him out on his ego and martyr complex]].

Top