Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / InnocentInaccurate

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** [[spoiler: Which is not what she was told earlier...]]

to:

** [[spoiler: [[UnreliableNarrator Which is not what she was told earlier...]]]]]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[Umineko no naku koro ni]] has Maria explain what was really her mother not caring about her as what basically sums up to her mother being busy and forgetful.

to:

* [[Umineko no naku koro ni]] ''UminekoNoNakuKoroNi'' has Maria explain what was really her mother not caring about her as what basically sums up to her mother being busy and forgetful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added an example.

Added DiffLines:

* [[Umineko no naku koro ni]] has Maria explain what was really her mother not caring about her as what basically sums up to her mother being busy and forgetful.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film has a lot of this. When Roy, is telling the FracturedFairyTale to Alexandria, she imagines things that are clearly not the way he intended them, for example he includes a [[MagicalNativeAmerican Native American]] character that he simply calls [[EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep the Indian]]. Alexandria imagines the character as someone who actually is from India. There's also a heavy subversion later: [[spoiler:at one point Roy starts falling asleep in the middle of storytelling and Alexandria can't wake him back up. The audience thinks that it's because Roy has taken an overdose of morphine is dead while Alexandria innocently thinks that he's just asleep, however the next day we discover that the "morphine" was just a placebo.]]

to:

** The film has a lot of this. When Roy, is telling the FracturedFairyTale to Alexandria, she imagines things that are clearly not the way he intended them, for example he includes a [[MagicalNativeAmerican Native American]] character that he simply calls [[EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep the Indian]]. Alexandria imagines the character as someone who actually is from India. There's also a heavy subversion later: [[spoiler:at one point Roy starts falling asleep in the middle of storytelling and Alexandria can't wake him back up. The audience thinks that it's because Roy has taken an overdose of morphine and is dead while Alexandria innocently thinks that he's just asleep, however the next day we discover that the "morphine" was just a placebo.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei Kafuka Fura]], though whether she's naïve or delusional is up for debate.
* ''ShoujoKakumeiUtena'': Utena [[spoiler: witnessed Anthy's pain at the Ends of the World]] when she was a child. She couldn't possible have understood what she was seeing, and ended up forgetting all of it. She just wanted to grow up and be a cool prince just like the guy who showed her that whatever-it-was. (During this same sequence (but shown ''much'' earlier on in the series, before the ''real'' WhamEpisode) Touga and Saijonji found Utena and tried to save her. It made Saionji, who pretty much misunderstood the whole thing, realize that he wanted "something eternal"... which in turn led to his very misguided attempts at securing Anthy as his "eternal thing". Touga didn't get off much better, trying to emulate a suave prince despite a FundamentalMisunderstanding that his personality couldn't correct. It's complicated.)

to:

* [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei Kafuka Fura]], though whether she's naïve naive or delusional is up for debate.
* ''ShoujoKakumeiUtena'': Utena [[spoiler: witnessed Anthy's pain at the Ends of the World]] when she was a child. She couldn't possible have understood what she was seeing, and ended up forgetting all of it. She just wanted to grow up and be a cool prince just like the guy who showed her that whatever-it-was. (During this same sequence (but shown ''much'' earlier on in the series, before the ''real'' WhamEpisode) Touga and Saijonji found Utena and tried to save her. It made Saionji, who pretty much misunderstood the whole thing, realize that he wanted "something eternal"... which in turn led to his very misguided attempts at securing Anthy as his "eternal thing". Touga didn't get off much better, trying to emulate a suave prince despite a FundamentalMisunderstanding fundamental misunderstanding that his personality couldn't correct. It's complicated.)



** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per se with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]] This flies completely over Christophers head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.

to:

** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per se with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]] This flies completely over Christophers Christopher's head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.



* The start [[spoiler: and end]] of ''Literature/FlowersForAlgernon''. The middle ''may'' count as well, but I'm not sure if being super intelligent eliminated his naivete.

to:

* The start [[spoiler: and end]] of ''Literature/FlowersForAlgernon''. The middle ''may'' count as well, but I'm not sure if being super intelligent eliminated his naivete.naiveté.



* In ''{{The Boy in the Striped Pajamas}}'', an eight year old named Bruno has a father who is very high up and important. His father works for the Fury [[spoiler: (Fuhrer)]], and is forced to leave his old home in Berlin with the rest of the family. They move to a place named Out-With [[spoiler: (Auschwitz)]] wherein he isn't really happy. He never understands why his mother starts taking so many medicinal sherries and long naps, and why the young but cruel Lt. Kotler seems to be around so much. [[spoiler: (She's having an affair with him.)]] He retains his naivete even after meeting and speaking regularly with someone from the other side of the fence, "Shmuel".

to:

* In ''{{The Boy in the Striped Pajamas}}'', ''TheBoyInTheStripedPyjamas'', an eight year old named Bruno has a father who is very high up and important. His father works for the Fury [[spoiler: (Fuhrer)]], and is forced to leave his old home in Berlin with the rest of the family. They move to a place named Out-With [[spoiler: (Auschwitz)]] wherein he isn't really happy. He never understands why his mother starts taking so many medicinal sherries and long naps, and why the young but cruel Lt. Kotler seems to be around so much. [[spoiler: (She's having an affair with him.)]] He retains his naivete naiveté even after meeting and speaking regularly with someone from the other side of the fence, "Shmuel".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[folder:Web Original]]
*The Season 1 ''{{Torchwood}}'' website, now defunct, featured [[EpistolaryNovel Epistolary]] and [[ScrapbookStory Scrapbook Stories]] from Torchwood's past. One of them was about a scientist and his young daughter, who had contacted an alien disease and were now quarantined in a caravan until they died. [[TearJerker It was told from the perspective of the daughter, who had no idea what was going on]].
[[/folder]]

Added: 742

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The five-year-old protagonist of ''TheFall'' pretty clearly had to immigrate to the United States because of a pogrom of some sort against her family--but when the adult protagonist tries to find out more, all she says is that "angry people" were responsible.

to:

* The Alexandria, the five-year-old protagonist of ''TheFall'' pretty clearly had to immigrate to the United States because of a pogrom of some sort against her family--but when the Roy (the adult protagonist protagonist) tries to find out more, all she says is that "angry people" were responsible.responsible.
** The film has a lot of this. When Roy, is telling the FracturedFairyTale to Alexandria, she imagines things that are clearly not the way he intended them, for example he includes a [[MagicalNativeAmerican Native American]] character that he simply calls [[EveryoneCallsHimBarkeep the Indian]]. Alexandria imagines the character as someone who actually is from India. There's also a heavy subversion later: [[spoiler:at one point Roy starts falling asleep in the middle of storytelling and Alexandria can't wake him back up. The audience thinks that it's because Roy has taken an overdose of morphine is dead while Alexandria innocently thinks that he's just asleep, however the next day we discover that the "morphine" was just a placebo.]]

Added: 697

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Chickamauga'' by Ambrose Bierce

to:

* ''Chickamauga'' by Ambrose BierceBierce.
* Etgar Keret's short story "Siren" begins on Holocaust Memorial Day, with the teenage protagonist sitting through a lecture at school by an Auschwitz survivor. Afterwards, the boy has no idea why the janitor is crying like a baby, and at the explanation "I was also in the [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderkommando Sonderkommando]]," he simply wonders what sort of commando unit would take such a skinny fellow. (This is a plot point--a fellow student has just taken the entrance examination to become a naval commando, and to celebrate passing the test he steals the janitor's bike for a joyride. The protagonist reports his action out of outrage that one commando would steal from another.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The opening of ''FinalFantasyVIIAdventChildren'' is narrated by the young Marlene, who simplifies things quite a bit. For example, when describing Sephiroth, the BigBad who tried to summon Meteor to strike the planet so he could become a god, she says "he hated the planet so much, he wanted to make it go away."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[FullMetalAlchemist Maes Hughes's]] daughter at [[spoiler: his funeral]].

to:

* [[FullMetalAlchemist From FullMetalAlchemist, Maes Hughes's]] Hughes's daughter at [[spoiler: his funeral]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Chickamauga'' by Ambrose Bierce
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''UminekoNoNakuKoroNi'', Maria doesn't seem to grasp that [[AbusiveParents Rosa is abusing her]] and instead believes that her mother's beatings are caused by the "bad witch" that sometimes possesses mommy.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Most rodents do. One of our hamsters was having an identity crisis because it didn't have obvious testicles like the other males so we thought it was a female. The vet said otherwise after a lot of inspection.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Rats DO have unusually large testicles though.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei Kafuka Fura]] is basically this trope incarnate, though whether she's naïve or delusional is up for debate.

to:

* [[SayonaraZetsubouSensei Kafuka Fura]] is basically this trope incarnate, Fura]], though whether she's naïve or delusional is up for debate.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The protagonist of ''Milkweed'' is a young boy during the occupation of Poland by Nazis. At first, because he is orphaned and poor and uneducated, he has no idea who or what he is, even saluting and admiring the Nazis as they arrive. At first, the invasion doesn't do much to change his life one way or the other, except make it harder to steal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Jesus cries at this one


* Horrible example in WorldWarZ, as befitting a ZombieApocalypse. One interviewee was a little girl when her family was killed after the dead siege the church they and many others had looked for shelter. The ammo was running out and the dead had broken in and were chewing through the crush of people. The last she saw of her mother was as she was trying to strangle her for a MercyKill. She related this all in the voice of a little girl (with sound effects!) despite being a in a 20 something woman.

to:

* Horrible example in WorldWarZ, as befitting a ZombieApocalypse. One interviewee was a little girl when her family was killed after the dead siege the church they and many others had looked for shelter. The ammo was running out and the dead had broken in and were chewing through the crush of people. The last she saw of her mother was as she was trying to strangle her for a MercyKill. She related this all in the voice of a little girl (with sound effects!) despite being a in a 20 something woman.



** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per say with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]] This flies completely over Christophers head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.

to:

** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per say se with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]] This flies completely over Christophers head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.

Changed: 197

Removed: 194

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per say with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]]
This flies completely over Christophers head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.

to:

** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per say with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]]
breasts]] This flies completely over Christophers head. head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.

Added: 367

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** It's worth noting that he is actually more upset by the fact that strangers are trying to talk to him and doesn't seem to pay much attention to what they're ''actually saying'' (one woman is actually asking if he's okay,) and he informs them (not threatening, just informing) that he has a small saw blade on his Swiss army knife [[NightmareFuel with which he could cut off their fingers]]. What he leaves out is that he's uncomfortable (at best) around strangers, so the other people take this as a threat and leave him alone, not because "he's fine on his own," but because "this kid is messed up."

to:

*** It's worth noting that he is actually more upset by the fact that strangers are trying to talk to him and doesn't seem to pay much attention to what they're ''actually saying'' (one woman is actually asking if he's okay,) and he informs them (not threatening, just informing) that he has a small saw blade on his Swiss army knife [[NightmareFuel with which he could cut off their fingers]]. What he leaves out is that he's uncomfortable (at best) around strangers, so the other people take this as a threat and leave him alone, not because "he's fine on his own," but because "this kid is messed up." "
** My teacher also noted when his father started getting, physical, per say with his much older neighbour [[spoiler: You know, lying his head inside/on top of her breasts]]
This flies completely over Christophers head. Most readers will get the implication, but to him it's just what happened. He didn't see the romantic/sexual connotations of that particular choice.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''28 Days'' in a flashback, the sisters' alcoholic mother dies when they are young. When their aunt takes the girls away because their mother is 'sleeping and won't wake up' the younger girl says 'oh that's ok, just slap her real hard and she'll wake up'.

to:

* In ''28 Days'' in a flashback, the sisters' alcoholic mother dies when they are young. When their aunt takes the girls away because their mother is 'sleeping and won't wake up' the younger girl says 'oh that's ok, OK, just slap her real hard and she'll wake up'.



* Horrible example in WorldWarZ, as befitting a ZombieApocalypse. One interviewee was a little girl when her family was killed after the dead sieged the church they and many others had looked for shelter. The ammo was running out and the dead had broken in and were chewing through the crush of people. The last she saw of her mother was as she was trying to strangle her for a MercyKill. She related this all in the voice of a little girl (with sound effects!) despite being a in a 20 something woman.

to:

* Horrible example in WorldWarZ, as befitting a ZombieApocalypse. One interviewee was a little girl when her family was killed after the dead sieged siege the church they and many others had looked for shelter. The ammo was running out and the dead had broken in and were chewing through the crush of people. The last she saw of her mother was as she was trying to strangle her for a MercyKill. She related this all in the voice of a little girl (with sound effects!) despite being a in a 20 something woman.



*** It's worth noting that he is actually more upset by the fact that strangers are trying to talk to him and doesn't seem to pay much attention to what they're ''actually saying'' (one woman is actually asking if he's okay,) and he informs them (not threatening, just informing) that he has a small saw blade on his swiss army knife [[NightmareFuel with which he could cut off their fingers]]. What he leaves out is that he's uncomfortable (at best) around strangers, so the other people take this as a threat and leave him alone, not because "he's fine on his own," but because "this kid is messed up."

to:

*** It's worth noting that he is actually more upset by the fact that strangers are trying to talk to him and doesn't seem to pay much attention to what they're ''actually saying'' (one woman is actually asking if he's okay,) and he informs them (not threatening, just informing) that he has a small saw blade on his swiss Swiss army knife [[NightmareFuel with which he could cut off their fingers]]. What he leaves out is that he's uncomfortable (at best) around strangers, so the other people take this as a threat and leave him alone, not because "he's fine on his own," but because "this kid is messed up."



* At the beginning of ''TheSecretGarden'', the 10-year-old Mary Lennox lives through a cholera outbreak in India. She wakes to find herself alone but despite the unsettling signs all around does not realise the whole household has died.

to:

* At the beginning of ''TheSecretGarden'', the 10-year-old Mary Lennox lives through a cholera outbreak in India. She wakes to find herself alone but despite the unsettling signs all around does not realise realize the whole household has died.



* In ''EerieCuties'', [[http://www.eeriecuties.com/d/20091207.html Nina's history assigment]] about an ancient vampire queen.

to:

* In ''EerieCuties'', [[http://www.eeriecuties.com/d/20091207.html Nina's history assigment]] assignment]] about an ancient vampire queen.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A possible inversion in {{Achewood}}'s strip: Lie Bot is telling Phillipe about the saddest thing: http://m.assetbar.com/achewood/uua2mp3dR

to:

* A possible inversion in {{Achewood}}'s strip: Lie Bot is telling Phillipe about the saddest thing: http://m.[[http://m.assetbar.com/achewood/uua2mp3dRcom/achewood/uua2mp3dR strip:]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* A possible inversion in {{Achewood}}'s strip: Lie Bot is telling Phillipe about the saddest thing: http://m.assetbar.com/achewood/uua2mp3dR
-->'''Phillipe:''' Lie Bot, what is the saddest thing?
-->'''Lie Bot:''' The saddest thing is a retarded man who is crying and promising a broken egg that it will still be a chicken someday.
-->'''*{{Beat}}*'''
-->'''Lie Bot:''' And that they'll play together in a field when it gets better.
-->'''Phillipe:''' [[BigNo Noooo!]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Used in MyNameIsKhan, in which the main character has Asperger's. [[spoiler: He is mistaken for a terrorist and ends up in the equivalent of Guantanamo bay, where the guards change the temperature in his cell from extreme cold to extreme heat as a form of torture. His internal monologue: "This is a strange place. Sometimes it's too cold, sometimes it's too hot. Maybe they're having problems with the air conditioning."]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The five-year-old protagonist of ''The Fall'' pretty clearly had to immigrate to the United States because of a pogrom of some sort against her family--but when the adult protagonist tries to find out more, all she says is that "angry people" were responsible.

to:

* The five-year-old protagonist of ''The Fall'' ''TheFall'' pretty clearly had to immigrate to the United States because of a pogrom of some sort against her family--but when the adult protagonist tries to find out more, all she says is that "angry people" were responsible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* The five-year-old protagonist of ''The Fall'' pretty clearly had to immigrate to the United States because of a pogrom of some sort against her family--but when the adult protagonist tries to find out more, all she says is that "angry people" were responsible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Humpty Dumpty from the ''ComicBook/{{Batman}}'' mini-series ''Arkham Asylum: Living Hell'' who dissected his abusive grandmother and sewed her back together with bootlace in an ill-thought attempt to "fix" her.

to:

* Humpty Dumpty from the ''ComicBook/{{Batman}}'' mini-series ''Arkham ''[[ArkhamAsylumLivingHell Arkham Asylum: Living Hell'' Hell]]'' who dissected his abusive grandmother and sewed her back together with bootlace in an ill-thought attempt to "fix" her.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheKidsInTheHall sketch about how "Daddy drank for the government."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''ShoujoKakumeiUtena'': Utena [[spoiler: witnessed Anthy's pain at the Ends of the World]] when she was a child. She couldn't possible have understood what she was seeing, and ended up forgetting all of it. She just wanted to grow up and be a cool prince just like the guy who showed her that whatever-it-was. (During this same sequence (but shown ''much'' earlier on in the series, before the ''real'' WhamEpisode) Touga and Saijonji found Utena and tried to save her. It made Saionji, who pretty much misunderstood the whole thing, realize that he wanted "something eternal"... which in turn led to his very misguided attempts at securing Anthy as his "eternal thing". It's complicated.)

to:

* ''ShoujoKakumeiUtena'': Utena [[spoiler: witnessed Anthy's pain at the Ends of the World]] when she was a child. She couldn't possible have understood what she was seeing, and ended up forgetting all of it. She just wanted to grow up and be a cool prince just like the guy who showed her that whatever-it-was. (During this same sequence (but shown ''much'' earlier on in the series, before the ''real'' WhamEpisode) Touga and Saijonji found Utena and tried to save her. It made Saionji, who pretty much misunderstood the whole thing, realize that he wanted "something eternal"... which in turn led to his very misguided attempts at securing Anthy as his "eternal thing". Touga didn't get off much better, trying to emulate a suave prince despite a FundamentalMisunderstanding that his personality couldn't correct. It's complicated.)

Top