Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DevilButNoGod

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* [[WildMassGuessing Possibly]] ''{{Reaper}}''. The Devil is a main character and several demons have appeared, but neither God nor explicit angels have.

to:

* [[WildMassGuessing Possibly]] ''{{Reaper}}''.''Series/{{Reaper}}''. The Devil is a main character and several demons have appeared, but neither God nor explicit angels have.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A rather curious inversion occurs in TheBible; God and Satan both exist, but it is very clear Satan is far weaker than God and overall he is barely important at all in the Bible. In Revelation, we get lots of supernatural evil/nasty entities, but they were all [[GodIsEvil sent by God]]; things get specially confusing because sometimes its not even clear Satan is working against God at all, as the leopard-like Beast that emerges from the ocean receives gifts from Satan and asks God's permission to kill the saints (which he of course gives).

to:

* A rather curious inversion occurs in TheBible; God and Satan both exist, but it is very clear Satan is far weaker than God and overall he is barely important at all in the Bible. In Revelation, we get lots of supernatural evil/nasty entities, but they were all [[GodIsEvil sent by God]]; God; things get specially confusing because sometimes its not even clear Satan is working against God at all, as the leopard-like Beast that emerges from the ocean receives gifts from Satan and asks God's permission to kill the saints (which he of course gives).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Editing.


** ''TransformersAnimated'' as well. Character designer ([[OneOfUs and fellow fan]][[WordOfGod Derrick Wyatt]] has stated many times that Primus is not in the ''Animated'' universe, but Unicron might exist, albeit simply as a mechanical EldricthAbomination rather than an actual god. Course, given the nature of the Transformers Multiverse as a whole, [[YourMileageMayVary YMMV]] on whether you agree or not.

to:

** ''TransformersAnimated'' as well. Character designer ([[OneOfUs and fellow fan]][[WordOfGod fan]]) [[WordOfGod Derrick Wyatt]] has stated many times that Primus is not in the ''Animated'' universe, but Unicron might exist, albeit simply as a mechanical EldricthAbomination EldritchAbomination rather than an actual god. Course, given the nature of the Transformers Multiverse as a whole, [[YourMileageMayVary YMMV]] on whether you agree or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Editing.

Added DiffLines:

** ''TransformersAnimated'' as well. Character designer ([[OneOfUs and fellow fan]][[WordOfGod Derrick Wyatt]] has stated many times that Primus is not in the ''Animated'' universe, but Unicron might exist, albeit simply as a mechanical EldricthAbomination rather than an actual god. Course, given the nature of the Transformers Multiverse as a whole, [[YourMileageMayVary YMMV]] on whether you agree or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
changed pothole from the show to the trope


* While the ''book'' of ''TheLordOfTheRings'' averts this trope (see below), this is pretty much the impression of someone who only watched the movies and never read any of the book or backstory. Its possible to watch the movies without ever learning that Gandalf is a maia (or even what a [[OurAngelsAreDifferent maia]] is), or the existence of the [[CouncilofAngels Valar]] or [[{{God}} Eru]], or know about the downfall or [[AndManGrewProud Numenor]]. ''Something'' [[MysteriousWays subtly]] influences everyone's fate and sends [[DeusExMachina Gandalf back from the dead]], but it is sufficiently abstract and distant when compared to [[{{Satan}} Sauron]] as to qualify for this trope.

to:

* While the ''book'' of ''TheLordOfTheRings'' averts this trope (see below), this is pretty much the impression of someone who only watched the movies and never read any of the book or backstory. Its possible to watch the movies without ever learning that Gandalf is a maia (or even what a [[OurAngelsAreDifferent maia]] is), or the existence of the [[CouncilofAngels Valar]] or [[{{God}} Eru]], or know about the downfall or [[AndManGrewProud Numenor]]. ''Something'' [[MysteriousWays [[InMysteriousWays subtly]] influences everyone's fate and sends [[DeusExMachina Gandalf back from the dead]], but it is sufficiently abstract and distant when compared to [[{{Satan}} Sauron]] as to qualify for this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** However, Sauron isn't the Devil either. He's just Morgoth' most trusted lieutenant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In CHARMED, the Devil ("the Source", short for "Source of All Evil") appears in several successive versions, but the show is maddeningly vague about who or what is in charge of "up there". The "White lighters" answer to "the Elders", but who do THEY answer to? Blank-out.

to:

* In CHARMED, {{CHARMED}}, the Devil ("the Source", short for "Source of All Evil") appears in several successive versions, but the show is maddeningly vague about who or what is in charge of "up there". The "White lighters" answer to "the Elders", but who do THEY answer to? Blank-out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Charmed, Fall of Chronopolis

Added DiffLines:

* THE FALL OF CHRONOPOLIS by BarringtonJBayley. The adversary Hulmu is real and threatening, but the religion of the nameless The Church, insofar as it makes any sense, seems to be a weird version of pantheism.
** This is a CorruptChurch with a purpose. The preservation of the entire space-time continuum is a pretty rock bottom obligation, and the demons and devil worshippers it was designed to fight are real.
** In another twist, the Christian temporal refugees fighting the Chronotic Empire make an actual DealWithTheDevil .... although of course they don't see it that way.


Added DiffLines:

* In CHARMED, the Devil ("the Source", short for "Source of All Evil") appears in several successive versions, but the show is maddeningly vague about who or what is in charge of "up there". The "White lighters" answer to "the Elders", but who do THEY answer to? Blank-out.

Added: 1083

Removed: 862

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* * [[http://bogleech.com/mortasheen.htm Mortasheen]], as it usually does, does this in a weird way. There are no gods (unless you count [[OlympusMons The Ultimates]]), mainly because the creator, [[WordOfGod who said it himself]] is an "agnostic science nut". However, there are [[OurDemonsAreDifferent the equivalents to demons]] The Devilbirds, birds charged in the egg with negative psychic energy to cause and feed off of negative emotions, usually in a HighOctaneNightmareFuel manner. But, there are no angel equivalents. There [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=Necromon&order=9&offset=48#/d4p0bm were]] [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?qh=§ion=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh once]] when Mortasheen was still called Necromon, but the creator couldn't come up with any re-designs for them that he liked, so he scrapped them. AndThatsTerrible.
** Well they did come back [[AbsoluteXenophobe in]] [[DeusEstMachina a]] [[ScaryDogmaticAliens way]] with [[BigBad Wreathe]]. But they aren't all that god-based [[spoiler: unless you count ARE as a god]], so the comparison is a bit moot.



[[AC:WebOriginal]]
* [[http://bogleech.com/mortasheen.htm Mortasheen]], as it usually does, does this in a weird way. There are no gods (unless you count [[OlympusMons The Ultimates]]), mainly because the creator, [[WordOfGod who said it himself]] is an "agnostic science nut". However, there are [[OurDemonsAreDifferent the equivalents to demons]] The Devilbirds, birds charged in the egg with negative psychic energy to cause and feed off of negative emotions, usually in a HighOctaneNightmareFuel manner. But, there are no angel equivalents. There [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=Necromon&order=9&offset=48#/d4p0bm were]] [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?qh=§ion=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh once]] when Mortasheen was still called Necromon, but the creator couldn't come up with any re-designs for them that he liked, so he scrapped them. AndThatsTerrible.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
It is listed twice, so I baleeted the later entry.


* In ''IncarnationsOfImmortality'' by PiersAnthony, the devil is quite active in the world and actively advertises (with billboards!) for Hell. God never intervenes directly, because it would be breaking His own rules (Satan has no such scruples).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** TheStormlightArchive has [[spoiler: several shards (i.e. specialized gods) involved at some point, but by the end of the first book, it is quite clear that the one most definitely invested in saving Roshar from destruction is dead, while the most definitely evil shard who killed him is apparently returning to finish the job. Or something; it's hard to say. Still, Ouch.]]

to:

** TheStormlightArchive Literature/TheStormlightArchive has [[spoiler: several shards (i.e. specialized gods) involved at some point, but by the end of the first book, it is quite clear that the one most definitely invested in saving Roshar from destruction is dead, while the most definitely evil shard who killed him is apparently returning to finish the job. Or something; it's hard to say. Still, Ouch.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the New World, there are demons that can be summoned and bound and which can [[DealWithTheDevil make deals with mortals]], and the books are very clear that where they come from ''is'' Hell. But there's no clear evidence of any benevolent deity in the driver's seat -- the [[VampireTheRequiem Lancea Sanctum]] only ''claims'' they got their BloodMagic from angels, the gods in the [[MageTheAwakening Oneiros]] are just [[ClapYourHandsIfYouBelieve reflections of mortal belief]], and the [[PrometheanTheCreated qashmallim]] are ''far'' from benevolent, fluffy-winged cherubs.

to:

** In the New World, there are demons that can be summoned and bound and which can [[DealWithTheDevil make deals with mortals]], and the books are very clear that where they come from ''is'' Hell. But there's no clear evidence of any benevolent deity in the driver's seat -- the [[VampireTheRequiem Lancea Sanctum]] only ''claims'' they got their BloodMagic from angels, the gods in the [[MageTheAwakening [[TabletopGame/MageTheAwakening Oneiros]] are just [[ClapYourHandsIfYouBelieve reflections of mortal belief]], and the [[PrometheanTheCreated qashmallim]] are ''far'' from benevolent, fluffy-winged cherubs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving Prime Directive examples that fit Alien Non-Interference Clause to that trope. Moving examples that fit Obstructive Code Of Conduct to that trope.


** The ascended beings are sorta stand-ins for angelic beings: clad in white, all-knowing and infuriatingly self-satisfied. Occasionally one of them will get around their own PrimeDirective to pull off a genuine miracle, like when [[spoiler: Oma Desala fights Anubis to a standstill]], or when [[spoiler: Morgan La Fey heals Teal'c]] in ''The Ark of Truth''.

to:

** The ascended beings are sorta stand-ins for angelic beings: clad in white, all-knowing and infuriatingly self-satisfied. Occasionally one of them will get around their own PrimeDirective ObstructiveCodeOfConduct to pull off a genuine miracle, like when [[spoiler: Oma Desala fights Anubis to a standstill]], or when [[spoiler: Morgan La Fey heals Teal'c]] in ''The Ark of Truth''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In MaceTheDarkAge, god or people who wants to usher in a world of absolute order admist the crapsack world is absent.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[DragonAge Dragon Age: Origins]] a rage demon the PC fights with the help of a [[ChurchMilitant templar]] laughs at the templar's declarations of faith, taunting him that the god he worships and the heaven he hopes for simply don't exist, but that there are demons. He then attacks the party. (There is never any solid indication that the god the templars worship really exists. Their church was started by a prophet who was said to have divine powers, but there is a competing theory that she was simply an incredibly powerful mage.)

to:

* In YMMV in [[DragonAge Dragon Age: Origins]] a Origins]]: While it's unsure if the Maker exists, there is no Devil or god of evil, only personifications of character traits. A rage demon the PC fights with the help of a [[ChurchMilitant templar]] laughs at the templar's declarations of faith, taunting him that the god he worships and the heaven he hopes for simply don't exist, but that there are demons. He then attacks the party. (There is never any solid indication that the god the templars worship really exists. Their church was started by a prophet who was said to have divine powers, but there is a competing theory that she was simply an incredibly powerful mage.)



** According to Justice in the ''Awakening'' expansion pack even the spirits don't know if the Maker exists. As for the Devil there are no clear analogues except maybe the four demons that, according to the in-game codex, taught Humanity BloodMagic. You can fight several of them in the games as optional bosses and they are pretty strong.

to:

** According to Justice in the ''Awakening'' expansion pack even the spirits don't know if the Maker exists. As for the Devil there are no clear analogues except maybe the four demons that, according to the in-game codex, taught Humanity BloodMagic. You On the other hand you can fight several of them in the games as optional bosses and bosses, so it's unlikely that they are pretty strong.somekind of Devil.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** It's worth noting that early in the company's history, TSR did publish statistics for God, Jesus and Archangels, but later removed them from publication after heavy criticism. So in the case of DungeonsAndDragons the lack of a God is due to outside pressure and not oversight.

to:

** It's worth noting that early in the company's history, TSR did publish statistics for God, Jesus and Archangels, but later removed them from publication after heavy criticism. So in the case They have tons of DungeonsAndDragons the lack of a God is due to outside pressure other gods though, both evil and not oversight.good.

Changed: 62

Removed: 788

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removed incorrect use of \"literally\" and deleted speculative argument.


** Note that most of this takes place in the book of Revelation. Which is... [[MindScrew literally impossible to understand.]]

to:

** Note that most of this takes place in the book of Revelation. Which is... [[MindScrew literally impossible to understand.]]
Revelation.



*** That or it could be that the whole idea of giving an omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent being stats was a bit silly to begin with (unless they were putting infinity signs in front of everything.)
*** Silly to begin with if you assume they bought the idea that god, Jesus and archangels happen to be omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent; by having stats with finite numbers they actually denied such to be the case, before speaking like a fundie remember your milleage may vary.
**** Considering that the use of the word "God" on this page is essentially monotheistic (at least as regards to God, Jesus and Archangels); the above is not an unreasonable assumption to make. If you actually expect someone to define every word before they use it then this page would be affully long.

Added: 404

Changed: 818

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also, it should be noted that when the Heroes notice early in the story that the constellations representing the Queen of Darkness and the Valiant Warrior have vanished from the sky, Raistlin interprets this to mean that "The Dark Queen is here, on Krynn! And the Valiant Warrior has returned as well to fight her." So from the beginning, the heroes have some reason to hope that they are not alone.





to:

\n* In Fred Saberhagen's ''EmpireOfTheEast'' trilogy, TheEmpire has hordes of demons at its command, but Ardneh was not at that point powerful enough to face any but the weakest of them in direct combat. When Chup calls out to the "Powers of the West" to help him against the demon Zapranoth, all Ardneh can give him is guidance, not any actual power. Of course, once Ardneh got the [[spoiler:hydromagnetic core of the fusion power lamp]], all bets were off.
** In Saberhagen's ''BooksOfSwords'', set in the same world but centuries later, the situation is a little different. The gods we see the most of, Vulcan and Mars, are pretty malevolent, and none of the gods seems outright good, but, as Dame Yoldi points out, the creators of Townsaver cannot be all bad. Of course, [[spoiler:the Emperor]] is genuinely good.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->'''John:''' "There's good and bad everywhere, don't you think?"
-->'''Jack:''' "I'd say there's bad everywhere; good, I don't know about."

to:

-->'''John:''' -->'''Jonathan Mardukas:''' "There's good and bad everywhere, don't you think?"
-->'''Jack:''' -->'''Jack Walsh:''' "I'd say there's bad everywhere; good, I don't know about."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Loosely adhered to in {{Brutal Legend}}. Ormagöden, a great fire-beast who flies through the sky, seems to be the nearest thing the setting has to God, and is brought to the earth and killed by the demonic First Ones. His death more-or-less creates the world. Afterwards, there are plenty of demons and other hellish creatures, but the Titans, who were more angelic, have left the world.

to:

* Loosely adhered to in {{Brutal Legend}}. Ormagöden, a great fire-beast who flies through the sky, seems to be the nearest thing the setting has to God, and is brought to the earth and killed by the demonic First Ones. His death more-or-less creates the world. Afterwards, there are plenty of demons and other hellish creatures, but the Titans, who were more angelic, have left the world.
world - though not without leaving behind copious artifacts and '''Metal.'''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* The ''FelixCastor'' novels have several demons lurking on the periphery ever since the recent return of the restless dead, but there's no mention made of angels or God's representatives. Exorcists are nondenominational (and sometimes atheists), and the local ChurchMilitant branch relies mostly on their own exorcists and bunches of [[OurWerewolvesAreDifferent loup-garous]]. Of course, the vast amount of demons may make more sense with [[spoiler: the revelation that human souls can metamorphosize into demons, and that this is likely how the succubus Juliet began her infernal existence]].

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**** Considering that the use of the word "God" on this page is essentially monotheistic (at least as regards to God, Jesus and Archangels); the above is not an unreasonable assumption to make. If you actually expect someone to define every word before they use it then this page would be affully long.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** According to Justice in the ''Awakening'' expansion pack even the spirits don't know if the Maker exists. As for the Devil there are no clear analogues except maybe the four demons that, according to the in-game codex, taught Humanity BloodMagic. You can fight several of them in the games as optional bosses and they are pretty strong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Looks like the Darkrai blanker struck again...


* Inverted in the ''{{Pokemon}}'' series games and anime where there is a counterpart for God called Arceus, but there is no counterpart for the Devil. Played straight in the ''PokemonMysteryDungeon'' games however, where Arceus is nowhere to be seen, and that only one Pokemon, [[spoiler: _______]] is the true evil one.

to:

* Inverted in the ''{{Pokemon}}'' series games and anime where there is a counterpart for God called Arceus, but there is no counterpart for the Devil. Played straight in the ''PokemonMysteryDungeon'' games however, where Arceus is nowhere to be seen, and that only one Pokemon, [[spoiler: _______]] [[spoiler:Darkrai]] is the true evil one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Trigon in ''TeenTitans'' is built up as the series' parallel to Satan in almost every way, but there doesn't seem to be a contrasting "God" figure at all.

to:

* Trigon in ''TeenTitans'' ''WesternAnimation/TeenTitans'' is built up as the series' parallel to Satan in almost every way, but there doesn't seem to be a contrasting "God" figure at all.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


-->--''Midnight Run''

to:

-->--''Midnight Run''
-->--''MidnightRun''

Added: 784

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In DeathNote, the only supernatural beings are the mostly malvolent {{Shinigami}}, and their world is a rather hellish place.

to:

* In DeathNote, the only supernatural beings are the mostly malvolent malevolent {{Shinigami}}, and their world is a rather hellish place.


Added DiffLines:

** Yeah; or more like we just happen to be their natural prey, although the notebooks seem contrived, and their fall into ennui is just a thing that happened.
*** Possibly once upon a time they didn't have them, and had to buzz around getting humans to trade life for "eyes and wings and things," as Light puts it, or at least had some less sophisticated life-capture system, before the Shinigami King invented and distributed these marvelous new tools. Whereupon there was no purpose or tension in life and they slowly rotted into what they are today, rather like Light did after he offed his great adversary. Meaning the Death Notes corrupted them just as badly as they do humans, and not through any supernatural agency but by sloth and pride. It would fit the universe really well.

Added: 237

Changed: 694

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None




to:

\n* FullmetalAlchemist has a lot of talk about God, from Lior's Leto to the faces of Ishbala to King Bradley, Edward Elric, and Maes Hughes' very different atheisms to Father's affectations to...The Truth. But the first two gods are silent, Father is a monster, and the Truth--which claims, among other things, the title God, and which Father seems to be referring to when he wants to kill God--is a ''dick'' that makes 'equivalent exchange' as painful, meaningless, and ironic as possible and sniggers about it, and otherwise has no apparent interactions with humanity. Where in such a world is there God?
--->'''Hughes:''' So what will bring wrath down upon us is not God, but probably 'humans.'
** This line refers mostly to Scar, but it's given in a floating speech bubble above Bradley who is framed against the sunset. [[spoiler: Ironically, since he eventually turns out to be Wrath, who "has [his] own pride as a homunculus."]]

Changed: 180

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
The important phrase there is \"heaven is shown\". As is God for that matter.


* Taken to unfathomable levels in the SouthPark movie (as well as the TV show). Heaven is shown to have only about two thousand residents while Hell has over a ''hundred million''.

to:

* Taken to unfathomable levels in the SouthPark movie (as well as the TV show). Heaven is shown to have only about two thousand residents while Hell has over a ''hundred million''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* God makes only a few appearances in SouthPark while Satan certainly has far more. In fact, everyone goes to Hell who isn't Mormon.

to:

* God makes only a few appearances in SouthPark while Satan certainly has far more. In fact, everyone goes to Hell who isn't Mormon.Mormon goes to hell.

Top