Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / DevilButNoGod

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** How did you forget [[spoiler: Morgan kicking Adria's butt at the end of ''Ark of Truth''?]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[DragonAge Dragon Age: Origins]] a rage demon the PC fights with the help of a[[ChurchMilitant templar]} laughs at the templars declarations of faith, taunting him that the god he worships and the heaven he hopes for simply don't exist, but that there are demons. He then attacks the party.

to:

* In [[DragonAge Dragon Age: Origins]] a rage demon the PC fights with the help of a[[ChurchMilitant templar]} a [[ChurchMilitant templar]] laughs at the templars templar's declarations of faith, taunting him that the god he worships and the heaven he hopes for simply don't exist, but that there are demons. He then attacks the party.
party. (There is never any solid indication that the god the templars worship really exists. Their church was started by a prophet who was said to have divine powers, but there is a competing theory that she was simply an incredibly powerful mage.)

Added: 393

Changed: 1054

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Prevalent in the {{ElderScrolls}} series, with the supposed conflict between (the adherents of) The Nine Divines and the Daedra Lords. The Daedra Lords, while not universally evil (some are, in fact, quite decent people, and all tend to hold up their end of a bargain), tend to be amoral, unpredictable, sadistic and, on occasion, prone to attempting world conquest. They are universally reviled as 'evil', and their worshipers are considered misguided at best, and dangerous lunatics at worst. They ''are'', however, very much present in the world. They speak directly to their worshipers, sometimes even appearing in a physical form, and are perfectly willing to offer immediate, tangible rewards for those that choose to do their work. The Nine, on the other hand, do absolutely jack, apart from supposedly granting blessings and healing diseases, but any semi-competent spellcaster could pull ''that'' off.

to:

* Prevalent in the {{ElderScrolls}} series, with the supposed conflict between (the adherents of) The Nine Divines and the Daedra Lords. The Daedra Lords, while not universally evil (some are, in fact, quite decent people, and all tend to hold up their end of a bargain), tend to be amoral, unpredictable, sadistic and, on occasion, prone to attempting world conquest. They are universally reviled as 'evil', and their worshipers are considered misguided at best, and dangerous lunatics at worst. They ''are'', however, very much present in the world. They speak directly to their worshipers, sometimes even appearing in a physical form, and are perfectly willing to offer immediate, tangible rewards for those that choose to do their work. The Nine, on the other hand, do absolutely jack, very little, apart from their altars supposedly granting blessings and healing diseases, but which any semi-competent spellcaster could pull ''that'' off.off. The main time the Divines intervene is during the Knights Of The Nine, when[[spoiler: the prophet of the Nine gives you a new ability, which he says comes from the god Talos, and will allow you to kill the Big Bad of the game's arc [[DeaderThanDead in the dimension he goes to get a new body.]] After the battle, you die too, only to come back after a few days. The only explanation anyone can offer is that the divines brought you back.]] You are the only one to directly benefit from divine interventions in game, apart from a major intervention in a spoiler below.



*** The court mage in Oblivion's Cheydinhal castle asks if you worship the Nine Divines, asking rhetorically if they've ever helped or harmed the PC. She states that were the hero to worship a daedra lord, they would get results. Bad ones, but measurable results. She then states that she considers worshiping gods a waste of time, though the daedra cult of Azura are a nice, reasonable bunch.



** [[ElderScrolls Oblivion]] and {{Morrowind}} drop huge metaphysical bombshells on this subject. As it turns out [[spoiler: the world as you know it is probably Lorkhan's daedra realm, therefore men, elves, the missing dwarves and all animals or monsters, you're probably all daedra. Daedra have unearthly and demonic connotations, but only because people are ignorant of the fact that they and the animals or monsters that live around them are likely the metaphysical equals of the 'demons' that live in other realms. Hell, there are extremely "human" daedra and the magic of men and daedra are not only equivalent but work based on the same fundamental rules. The "gods" or Aedra do exist, or at least one of them does, and the story goes that most were daedric servants who rebelled against the realm's trickster creator god.]]

to:

** [[ElderScrolls Oblivion]] and {{Morrowind}} drop huge metaphysical bombshells on this subject. As it turns out [[spoiler: the world as you know it is probably possibly Lorkhan's daedra realm, therefore men, elves, the missing dwarves and all animals or monsters, you're probably all daedra. Daedra have unearthly and demonic connotations, but only because people are ignorant of the fact that they and the animals or monsters that live around them are likely the metaphysical equals of the 'demons' that live in other realms. Hell, there are extremely "human" daedra and the magic of men and daedra are not only equivalent but work based on the same fundamental rules. The "gods" or Aedra do exist, or at least one of them does, and the story goes that most were daedric servants who rebelled against the realm's trickster creator god. Of note is that the person who floats the idea seems ignorant about a lot of metaphysical trivia, thus possibly meaning he's wrong about this.]]




to:

* In [[DragonAge Dragon Age: Origins]] a rage demon the PC fights with the help of a[[ChurchMilitant templar]} laughs at the templars declarations of faith, taunting him that the god he worships and the heaven he hopes for simply don't exist, but that there are demons. He then attacks the party.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In Marvel Comics, Satan was a recurring character in the Son of Satan series. God, Jesus or the Angels never appeared or interfered. Later, it was {{RetCon}}ned that Satan was being impersonated by demons such as Mephisto, and that the true Devil had NEVER appeared in a Marvel story. Recently in Ghost Rider Angel;s and even heaven have shown up.

to:

* In Marvel Comics, Satan was a recurring character in the Son of Satan series. God, Jesus or the Angels never appeared or interfered. Later, it was {{RetCon}}ned that Satan was being impersonated by demons such as Mephisto, and that the true Devil had NEVER appeared in a Marvel story.story [[prottip:*:It has since been revealed that there are several Netherrealms claiming to be Hell, and that its rulers ''inspired'' legends of the Devil rather than directly being him, and the only souls they lay claim to are those who made bargains with them.]]. Recently in Ghost Rider Angel;s and even heaven have shown up.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Redwall}}, the picture provider, has several bad guys mention "Hellgates", and one of them drops the name of Vulpuz, some sort of evil diety. The good guys have an afterlife, Dark Forest, and earlier in the series at least the appearance of having actual religion, although it was never discussed.

to:

* {{Redwall}}, the picture provider, has several bad guys mention "Hellgates", and one of them drops the name of Vulpuz, some sort of evil diety. The good guys have an afterlife, afterlife called Dark Forest, and earlier in the series at least the appearance of having actual religion, although it was is never discussed.discussed. (This is pretty odd for a series whose title location is an ''abbey,'' populated by what was clearly, in the beginning, a monastic order. The not-quite-religion fades as the series continues.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
more on Vorlons


*** In Season Four, it's revealed that [[spoiler:the Vorlons aren't the good guys, they're almost as bad as the Shadows, and they only appear to be angels because they genetically and telepathically manipulated the younger races.]] Even Lorien, the oldest and most powerful being in the galaxy, refers to the universe itself as the creator of life.

to:

*** In Season Four, it's revealed that [[spoiler:the Vorlons aren't the good guys, they're almost as bad as the Shadows, and they only appear to be angels because they genetically and telepathically manipulated the younger races. When their true form is finally revealed, they're clearly StarfishAliens.]] Even Lorien, the oldest and most powerful being in the galaxy, refers to the universe itself as the creator of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** In Season Four, it's revealed that [[spoiler:the Vorlons are just as bad as the Shadows, and they only appear to be angels because of genetic and telepathic manipation of the younger races.]] Even Lorien, the oldest and most powerful being in the galaxy, refers to the universe itself as the creator of life.

to:

*** In Season Four, it's revealed that [[spoiler:the Vorlons are just aren't the good guys, they're almost as bad as the Shadows, and they only appear to be angels because of genetic they genetically and telepathic manipation of telepathically manipulated the younger races.]] Even Lorien, the oldest and most powerful being in the galaxy, refers to the universe itself as the creator of life.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
more about Babylon 5

Added DiffLines:

*** In Season Four, it's revealed that [[spoiler:the Vorlons are just as bad as the Shadows, and they only appear to be angels because of genetic and telepathic manipation of the younger races.]] Even Lorien, the oldest and most powerful being in the galaxy, refers to the universe itself as the creator of life.

Added: 149

Changed: 2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** Most of the religion in the Devil May Cry series revolves around worshiping demons, with Dante's father being a good demon messiah. Also, there are demons that appear to be angels. It seems as if in this universe, that instead of demons being fallen angels - [[HeelFaceTurn angels are demons who fell up.]]

to:

*** ** Most of the religion in the Devil May Cry series revolves around worshiping demons, with Dante's father being a good demon messiah. Also, there are demons that appear to be angels. It seems as if in this universe, that instead of demons being fallen angels - [[HeelFaceTurn angels are demons who fell up.]] ]]
** In a speech near the end of ''4'', Nero makes an explicit reference to God, although it's anyone's guess if it's ''God'' God, or the PowersThatBe.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Although, the Shinigami are not truly malevolent, they're just doing what they're supposed to. In a sense, they as a whole, are sort of a cosmic life/death bureaucracy.


Added DiffLines:

** Though Jacob is described by Mark Pellegrino as a Jesus analog.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* In DwarfFortress, the various gods civilizations worship have no effect on the world beyond temples being built in the honor and very rarely, holy wars in their name. Demons are actively involved in the world, taking over human and goblin civilizations by posing as the aforementioned dead gods and beating their way to the top, respectively. [[spoiler:More show up if you've DugTooDeep]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

** There ''is'' a God. He just intervene much cos he's too busy [[spoiler: being a barman]].




to:

** Note that most of this takes place in the book of Revelation. Which is... [[MindScrew literally impossible to understand.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Prevalent in the {{ElderScrolls}} series, with the supposed conflict between (the adherents of) The Nine Divines and the Daedra Lords. The Daedra Lords, while not universally evil (some are, in fact, quite decent people, and all tend to hold up their end of a bargain), tend to be amoral, unpredictable, sadistic and, on occasion, prone to attempting world conquest. They are universally reviled as 'evil', and their worshippers are considered misguided at best, and dangerous lunatics at worst. They ''are'', however, very much present in the world. They speak directly to their worshippers, sometimes even appearing in a physical form, and are perfectly willing to offer immediate, tangible rewards for those that choose to do their work. The Nine, on the other hand, do absolutely jack, apart from supposedly granting blessings and healing diseases, but any semi-competent spellcaster could pull ''that'' off.
** This is mentioned by the Oblivion NPC Else God Hater, a [[spoiler:Deadra Lord worshipper.]] "The gods don't do a damn thing. Do they even exist? How could anyone tell? Daedra Lords, sure. They exist. They do things. Bad things, mostly, but things you can see. The gods? They don't do a damn thing. So why do we build big chapels and sit around and mumble, and ask them to save us from this and that? It's stupid. And chapels and priests and folks groveling on their knees, they're stupid, too."

to:

* Prevalent in the {{ElderScrolls}} series, with the supposed conflict between (the adherents of) The Nine Divines and the Daedra Lords. The Daedra Lords, while not universally evil (some are, in fact, quite decent people, and all tend to hold up their end of a bargain), tend to be amoral, unpredictable, sadistic and, on occasion, prone to attempting world conquest. They are universally reviled as 'evil', and their worshippers worshipers are considered misguided at best, and dangerous lunatics at worst. They ''are'', however, very much present in the world. They speak directly to their worshippers, worshipers, sometimes even appearing in a physical form, and are perfectly willing to offer immediate, tangible rewards for those that choose to do their work. The Nine, on the other hand, do absolutely jack, apart from supposedly granting blessings and healing diseases, but any semi-competent spellcaster could pull ''that'' off.
** This is mentioned by the Oblivion NPC Else God Hater, a [[spoiler:Deadra [[spoiler:Daedra Lord worshipper.worshiper.]] "The gods don't do a damn thing. Do they even exist? How could anyone tell? Daedra Lords, sure. They exist. They do things. Bad things, mostly, but things you can see. The gods? They don't do a damn thing. So why do we build big chapels and sit around and mumble, and ask them to save us from this and that? It's stupid. And chapels and priests and folks groveling on their knees, they're stupid, too."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Berserk}}'', which has the "God Hand", a group of five powerful demons as the closest thing to gods. The only other set of deities, the Four Elemental Kings, are said to be loving and protective of humanity, but only seem to help out if consciously summoned.

to:

* ''{{Berserk}}'', which has the "God Hand", a group of five powerful demons as the closest thing to gods. The only other set of deities, the Four Elemental Kings, are said to be loving and protective of humanity, but only seem seen to help out if consciously summoned.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{The Icemark Chronicles}}by Stuart Hill has a being called 'Cronus'
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also, in the original film there are hints by some characters that Gozer is the harbinger of the Biblical Apocalypse, and not just it's own brand of doom.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''{{Jimmy Two-Shoes}}'': [[CrapsackWorld Miseryville]] is practically {{Hell}} (in the original pitch, it ''was'' Hell, no question), with Lucius obviously a stand-in for {{Satan}}. Yet we never hear anything for the opposing side. In the original pitch, Jimmy was there on accident, which begs the question as to why God (if he exists) hasn't done anything.

to:

* ''{{Jimmy Two-Shoes}}'': [[CrapsackWorld Miseryville]] is practically {{Hell}} (in the original pitch, it ''was'' Hell, no question), with Lucius obviously a stand-in for {{Satan}}. Yet we never hear anything for the opposing side. In the original pitch, Jimmy was there on accident, which begs the question as to why God {{God}} (if he He exists) hasn't done anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''{{Jimmy Two-Shoes}}'': [[CrapsackWorld Miseryville]] is practically {{Hell}} (in the original pitch, it ''was'' Hell, no question), with Lucius obviously a stand-in for {{Satan}}. Yet we never hear anything for the opposing side. In the original pitch, Jimmy was there on accident, which begs the question as to why God (if he exists) hasn't done anything.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Bone}} sort of seems to have The Lord of the [[spoiler: [[ChekhovsGun Locusts]]]] as an example of the trope because he is a formless being who appears to have a lot of powers and influence on the real world, and [[DidYouJustPunchOutCthulhu he actually ''killed'' the closest thing they had to a God]]. Sort of. ''[[{{Prequel}} Rose]]'' implies that the God figure was responsible for her own death, not the Satan figure. Either way, she's dead for the majority of the story.

to:

* {{Bone}} sort of seems to have The Lord of the [[spoiler: [[ChekhovsGun Locusts]]]] as an example of the trope because he is a formless being who appears to have a lot of powers and influence on the real world, and [[DidYouJustPunchOutCthulhu he actually ''killed'' actually]] ''[[DidYouJustPunchOutCthulhu killed]]'' [[DidYouJustPunchOutCthulhu the closest thing they had to a God]]. Sort of. ''[[{{Prequel}} Rose]]'' implies that the God figure was responsible for her own death, not the Satan figure. Either way, she's dead for the majority of the story.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

* {{Bone}} sort of seems to have The Lord of the [[spoiler: [[ChekhovsGun Locusts]]]] as an example of the trope because he is a formless being who appears to have a lot of powers and influence on the real world, and [[DidYouJustPunchOutCthulhu he actually ''killed'' the closest thing they had to a God]]. Sort of. ''[[{{Prequel}} Rose]]'' implies that the God figure was responsible for her own death, not the Satan figure. Either way, she's dead for the majority of the story.

Added: 522

Changed: 6

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** There's also that little detail that if you look at the extended backstory brought on by FFXII, the Ivalice gods are monstrous jerks of the highest caliber (really, the Greek gods would be proud) and the Lucavi actually come across as sympathetic. It's more a case of bad God, good Devil here. Also, Altima/Ultima IS NOT a Lucavi - she's a head Angel who used to be under the Gods' direct service, but more or less told them to go to hell after realizing just how badly they treated the Lucavi and took up their cause.



* [[http://bogleech.com/mortasheen.htm Mortasheen]], as it usually does, does this in a weird way. There are no gods (unless you count [[OlympusMons The Ultimates]]), mainly because the creator, [[WordOfGod who said it himself]] is an "agnostic science nut". However, there are [[OurDemonsAreDifferent the equivalents to demons]] The Devilbirds, birds charged in the egg with negative psychic energy to cause and feed off of negative emotions, usually in a HighOctaneNightmareFuel manner. But, there are no angel equivalents. There [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=Necromon&order=9&offset=48#/d4p0bm were]] [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?qh=&section=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh once]] when Mortasheen was still called Necromon, but the creator couldn't come up with any re-designs for them that he liked, so he scrapped them. AndThatsTerrible.



to:

* [[http://bogleech.com/mortasheen.htm Mortasheen]], as it usually does, does this in a weird way. There are no gods (unless you count [[OlympusMons The Ultimates]]), mainly because the creator, [[WordOfGod who said it himself]] is an "agnostic science nut". However, there are [[OurDemonsAreDifferent the equivalents to demons]] The Devilbirds, birds charged in the egg with negative psychic energy to cause and feed off of negative emotions, usually in a HighOctaneNightmareFuel manner. But, there are no angel equivalents. There [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=Necromon&order=9&offset=48#/d4p0bm were]] [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?qh=&section=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh com/?qh=§ion=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh once]] when Mortasheen was still called Necromon, but the creator couldn't come up with any re-designs for them that he liked, so he scrapped them. AndThatsTerrible.


Added: 360

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Subverted in ''{{Mistborn}}''. [[BigBad Ruin]] is the only actual deity acting in the setting (and actually refers to himself as [[GodIsEvil God]] on occasion) and it gradually becomes apparent that Ruin's counterpart Preservation is dead. [[spoiler: Then it turns out that Preservation's XanatosGambit was still playing out, and at the climax the heroine is elevated to take His place]].

to:

* Subverted in ''{{Mistborn}}''. [[BigBad Ruin]] is the only actual deity acting in the setting (and actually refers to himself as [[GodIsEvil God]] on occasion) and it gradually becomes apparent that Ruin's counterpart Preservation is dead. [[spoiler: Then it turns out that Preservation's XanatosGambit was still playing out, and at the climax the heroine is elevated to take His place]]. place]].
** The Way of Kings has [[spoiler: several shards (i.e. specialized gods) involved at some point, but by the end of the book, it is quite clear that the ones most invested in saving Roshar from destruction are dead, while the most definitely evil shard who killed them is apparently returning to finish the job. Or something; it's hard to say. Still, Ouch.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
a case exlusive to fanfiction should not be classified as fanfiction because it constitutes "epileptic trees"


* In one {{Persona 3}} [[http://www.fanfiction.net/s/4324241/1/Shin_Megami_Tensei_Persona_3_RES fanfiction]] Mitsuru ponders why there are ultimate evils (Lucifer, Satan) but no ultimate goods. Turns out [[spoiler: God had sacrificed himself to give humans the ability to save themselves and to seal The Reaper away. His knowledge and powers were spread all along the Multi-verse, completely averting GodIsEvil.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** Silly to begin with if you assume they bought the idea that god, Jesus and archangels happen to be omnipotent, omniscient and omnipresent; by having stats with finite numbers they actually denied such to be the case, before speaking like a fundie remember your milleage may vary.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** As for God, you get the season 5 finale, where it's very strongly implied that [[spoiler: Chuck is God. Admittedly, all he does is vanish into thin air, but since all angels and demons thus far had thought he was just a prophet and otherwise ordinary human, there aren't many alternatives. After all, angels and demons can detect each other. Plus, with his monologue/narration...he's God.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

[[AC:WebOriginal]]
* [[http://bogleech.com/mortasheen.htm Mortasheen]], as it usually does, does this in a weird way. There are no gods (unless you count [[OlympusMons The Ultimates]]), mainly because the creator, [[WordOfGod who said it himself]] is an "agnostic science nut". However, there are [[OurDemonsAreDifferent the equivalents to demons]] The Devilbirds, birds charged in the egg with negative psychic energy to cause and feed off of negative emotions, usually in a HighOctaneNightmareFuel manner. But, there are no angel equivalents. There [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?q=Necromon&order=9&offset=48#/d4p0bm were]] [[http://browse.deviantart.com/?qh=&section=&q=Necromon+Celestials#/d7psvh once]] when Mortasheen was still called Necromon, but the creator couldn't come up with any re-designs for them that he liked, so he scrapped them. AndThatsTerrible.


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** [[ElderScrolls Oblivion]] and {{Morrowind}} drop huge metaphysical bombshells on this subject. As it turns out [[spoiler: the world as you know it is probably Lorkhan's daedra realm, therefore men, elves, the missing dwarves and all animals or monsters, you're probably all daedra. Daedra have unearthly and demonic connotations, but only because people are ignorant of the fact that they and the animals or monsters that live around them are likely the metaphysical equals of the 'demons' that live in other realms. Hell, there are extremely "human" daedra and the magic of men and daedra are not only equivalent but work based on the same fundamental rules. The "gods" or Aedra do exist, or at least one of them does, and the story goes that most were daedric servants who rebelled against the realm's trickster creator god.]]

Added: 176

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** While not in Oblivion, in the previous game, [[{{Elder Scrolls}} Morrowind]], you did in fact meet what is implied to be avatars of the Nine Divine (Stendarr & Mara in sidequests, Talos during the Main Quest), who reward the hero/heroine according to the action they take.

to:

** While not in Oblivion, in the previous game, [[{{Elder Scrolls}} Morrowind]], {{Morrowind}}, you did in fact meet what is implied to be avatars of the Nine Divine (Stendarr & Mara in sidequests, Talos during the Main Quest), who reward the hero/heroine according to the action they take.take.
*** There are also Vivec, Sotha Sil, and Almalexia, the Tribunal, who are a trio of supposedly good PhysicalGods. Then again, they're not ''natural'' gods, and two of them die.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Another alternate explanation is that in most cases He knows [[TheHero the hero]]es [[OmniscientMoralityLicense don't actually need His help]], so He doesn't give it. Another reason is that God might easily become the ultimate BoringInvincibleHero or DeusExMachina, so the writers need to [[DeusExitMachina get rid of him]]. Possibly [[JustifiedTrope justified]] if [[RousseauWasRight people are significantly harder to make bad than good]].

to:

Another alternate explanation is that in most cases He knows [[TheHero the hero]]es {{the hero}}es [[OmniscientMoralityLicense don't actually need His help]], so He doesn't give it. Another reason is that God might easily become the ultimate BoringInvincibleHero or DeusExMachina, so the writers need to [[DeusExitMachina get rid of him]]. Possibly [[JustifiedTrope justified]] if [[RousseauWasRight people are significantly harder to make bad than good]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



to:

*In {{kuroshitsuji}} we have lawful evil devils,shinigamis are either lawful neutral or chaotic evil but there is no benevolent supernatural being. In the anime version the {{Big Bad}} is a fallen angel, which implies there is good angels, but they never show up and a devil saves the day.

Top