Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / CreatorProvincialism

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The couch gag of "Them, Robot" shows The Simpsons hanging up a poster in 1989 with the text: "America, the most powerful country in the world". Then the years pass by and in 2012 (the year of broadcast) they pull the old text down to replace it with a new one: "America, too big to fail (we hope)". While well-intentioned -- it's clearly aimed as a spark of hope to the American viewers in light of people suffering under the economic crisis -- the recession was nevertheless a universal problem, not one America alone was facing.

to:

** The couch gag of "Them, Robot" shows The Simpsons hanging up a poster in 1989 with the text: "America, the most powerful country in the world". Then the years pass by and in 2012 (the year of broadcast) they pull the old text down to replace it with a new one: "America, too big to fail (we hope)". While well-intentioned -- it's clearly aimed as a spark of hope to the American viewers in light of people suffering under the economic crisis -- the recession was nevertheless a universal problem, not one America alone was facing.a uniquely American one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
This bit just reads as "other countries had it worse so Americans have no right to be upset that their country is in an economic slump" to me


** The couch gag of "Them, Robot" shows The Simpsons hanging up a poster in 1989 with the text: "America, the most powerful country in the world". Then the years pass by and in 2012 (the year of broadcast) they pull the old text down to replace it with a new one: "America, too big to fail (we hope)". This is clearly aimed as a spark of hope to the American viewers in light of people suffering under the economic crisis, which nevertheless is a universal problem, not just of America alone. Furthermore, even though the creators try to put in a little MyCountryTisOfTheeThatISting humor it still comes across as if the rest of the world should solely pity the poor Americans, while other countries like Greece or Iceland were hit far more seriously by the economic crisis than the USA.

to:

** The couch gag of "Them, Robot" shows The Simpsons hanging up a poster in 1989 with the text: "America, the most powerful country in the world". Then the years pass by and in 2012 (the year of broadcast) they pull the old text down to replace it with a new one: "America, too big to fail (we hope)". This is While well-intentioned -- it's clearly aimed as a spark of hope to the American viewers in light of people suffering under the economic crisis, which crisis -- the recession was nevertheless is a universal problem, not just of one America alone. Furthermore, even though the creators try to put in a little MyCountryTisOfTheeThatISting humor it still comes across as if the rest of the world should solely pity the poor Americans, while other countries like Greece or Iceland were hit far more seriously by the economic crisis than the USA. alone was facing.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/SnackShack'': The film takes place in Nebraska City, where writer/director Adam Rehmeier grew up and did many of the things that AJ and Moose do. The film was shot on location in Nebraska City.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling/grammar fix(es)


* Fanfic/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationality: subverted and lampshaded. Although the action takes place mostly in Britain, many heroes have non-British ancestry, or have immigrated. British wizards think of themselves as of "the greatest magic nation in the world", but it is implied on multiple occasions that other regions of the world, from Asia to North America, have their own well-developed wizard communities and rich history, which is only tangentially related to the history of Magic Britain. When [[spoiler: on the Hermione's trial Harry scares a dementor]], this makes news all over English-speaking wizarding world, except for the United States. "The American Wizard" is more concerned with wirewolves supposedly being the first historical population of Wyoming.

to:

* Fanfic/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationality: ''Fanfic/HarryPotterAndTheMethodsOfRationality'': subverted and lampshaded. Although the action takes place mostly in Britain, many heroes have non-British ancestry, or have immigrated. British wizards think of themselves as of "the greatest magic nation in the world", but it is implied on multiple occasions that other regions of the world, from Asia to North America, have their own well-developed wizard communities and rich history, which is only tangentially related to the history of Magic Britain. When [[spoiler: on the Hermione's trial Harry scares a dementor]], this makes news all over the English-speaking wizarding world, except for the United States. "The ''The American Wizard" Wizard'' is more concerned with wirewolves supposedly being the first historical population of Wyoming.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Creator/RobertJSawyer has set many of his books in or around Toronto where he has spent most of his life (he's from Ottawa). Others are nearby and still in Ontario.

to:

* Creator/RobertJSawyer has set many of his books in or around Toronto where he has he's spent most of his life (he's (Sawyer's from Ottawa). Others are nearby and still in Ontario.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)

Added DiffLines:

* Creator/RobertJSawyer has set many of his books in or around Toronto where he has spent most of his life (he's from Ottawa). Others are nearby and still in Ontario.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Anime/LauraThePrairieGirl'' is a Japanese anime adapting an American novel about American Midwestern life. That being said, the original novel is quite popular there

to:

** ''Anime/LauraThePrairieGirl'' is a Japanese anime adapting an American novel about American Midwestern life. That being said, the original novel is quite popular therethere.



** ''Anime/TheSecretGarden'' takes place in India, and then England. The staff behind it is fully Japanese, however it takes clues from [[Literature/TheSecretGarden the novel it's based on]], which was written by an [[Creator/FrancesHodgsonBurnett English woman]].

to:

** ''Anime/TheSecretGarden'' takes place in India, and then England. The staff behind it is fully Japanese, however Japanese; however, it takes clues from [[Literature/TheSecretGarden the novel it's based on]], which was written by an [[Creator/FrancesHodgsonBurnett English woman]].



* ''Franchise/{{Gundam}}''

to:

* ''Franchise/{{Gundam}}''''Franchise/{{Gundam}}'':
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**''Anime/LauraThePrairieGirl'' is a Japanese anime adapting an American novel about American Midwestern life. That being said, the original novel is quite popular there
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Manga/TheRoseOfVersailles'' is a manga about the French Revolution written by a Japanese woman, Creator/RyokoIkeda, and there are no Japanese characters. When the anime aired in France, the French loved it, and she even received a Legion d'Honneur award!

to:

** ''Manga/TheRoseOfVersailles'' is a manga about the French Revolution written by a Japanese woman, Creator/RyokoIkeda, Creator/RiyokoIkeda, and there are no Japanese characters. When the anime aired in France, the French loved it, and she even received a Legion d'Honneur award!award!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The 1975 anime ''Anime/LaSeineNoHoshi'' is a re-telling of the French Revolution with some fictional elements here and there. The main characters are mostly French, with a Spanish side character.

to:

* ** The 1975 anime ''Anime/LaSeineNoHoshi'' is a re-telling of the French Revolution with some fictional elements here and there. The main characters are mostly French, with a Spanish side character.

Added: 831

Changed: 136

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*The 1975 anime ''Anime/LaSeineNoHoshi'' is a re-telling of the French Revolution with some fictional elements here and there. The main characters are mostly French, with a Spanish side character.



** ''Anime/HelloSandybell'' takes place in Scotland.

to:

** ''Anime/HelloSandybell'' takes place in Scotland.all over Europe, mainly Scotland, England, France and Greece. There's no mention of Japan, and the series is styled like a WesternAnimation as well.


Added DiffLines:

**''Manga/TheRoseOfVersailles'' is a manga about the French Revolution written by a Japanese woman, Creator/RyokoIkeda, and there are no Japanese characters. When the anime aired in France, the French loved it, and she even received a Legion d'Honneur award!


Added DiffLines:

*''Manga/{{Lady}}'' is about a half-Japanese girl named Lynn who lives in England. Creator/YokoHanabusa is a fully Japanese woman, but she did travel to England once to get an idea for the story[[note]]She confirms it in the author's notes of the final manga chapter[[/note]]. WordOfGod is that Lynn was made half-Japanese so Japanese readers could understand her predicament.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

**Averted in ''Manga/HonooNoAlpenRose''. Creator/MichiyoAkaishi is Japanese, but the anime takes place in Switzerland, then Austria, then Lichtenstein, and there are no Japanese characters. The only person of colour in the series is Louise, the Jewish girl who escaped the Nazis in Switzerland, but she doesn't make an appearance in the anime.

Added: 354

Changed: 307

Removed: 353

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Anime/ADogOfFlanders1975'': Averted, and that's why the setting seems so unusual. The story is set in Belgium, but since the showrunners are Japanese and have no idea how Belgium is supposed to look like. The end results come out looking like the Netherlands, with Alois wearing traditional Dutch clothing and a white sling, and Nello wearing clogs.



** ''Anime/ADogOfFlanders1975'': Averted, and that's why the setting seems so unusual. The story is set in Belgium, but since the showrunners are Japanese and have no idea how Belgium is supposed to look like. The end results come out looking like the Netherlands, with Alois wearing traditional Dutch clothing and a white sling, and Nello wearing clogs.



* ''Anime/IsabelleOfParis'' takes place in 1870s France and England and focuses on the Franco-Prussian war.
* ''Anime/WorldMasterpieceTheater'' runs on this, since it's a Japanese studio that adapts Western literature into anime.
* ''Anime/TheSecretGarden'' takes place in India and then England. The staff behind it is fully Japanese.

to:

* ** ''Anime/IsabelleOfParis'' takes place in 1870s France and England and focuses on the Franco-Prussian war.
*
war. Despite the work being from Japan, there aren't any Japanese characters and the only person of colour in the cast is Irma (who's a Romani woman).
**
''Anime/WorldMasterpieceTheater'' runs on this, since it's a Japanese studio that adapts Western literature into anime.
* ** ''Anime/TheSecretGarden'' takes place in India India, and then England. The staff behind it is fully Japanese.Japanese, however it takes clues from [[Literature/TheSecretGarden the novel it's based on]], which was written by an [[Creator/FrancesHodgsonBurnett English woman]].

Added: 525

Changed: 266

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The setting takes place in an apocalyptic version of the U.S., through there's many characters of Japanese origin, mainly The Engineer, which is based on the likeness of the mangaka Creator/JunjiIto, the Musician, based in musician Daichi Miura and the Chiral Artist, who is also of Japanese origin.

to:

*** The setting takes place in an apocalyptic version of the U.S., through there's many characters of Japanese origin, mainly The Engineer, which is based on the likeness of the mangaka Creator/JunjiIto, the Musician, based in musician Daichi Miura and Miura, the Chiral Artist, who is also of Japanese origin. origin and the Collector, based on on Hirokazu Hamamura, the editor-in-chief of the Japanese magazine Famitsu. Oddly enough, outside those characters and Charles Khan, a member of BRIDGES of Indian origin, there's ''no other'' non-Japanese Asian characters in the game.
*** The whole premise of the game, about delivering goods on foot while walking through dangerous and rough terrain seems to be heavily inspired in the whole concept of the ''bokka'', [[https://twitter.com/wrathofgnon/status/1763138299085091110 a kind of Japanese porter transporting goods on places inaccessible to other kind of vehicles, just like the main protagonist does in the game]]. In fact, the same backpack Sam use in the game is basically a futuristic version of the same backpack Japanese bokka use in real life.

Top