Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / CanonFodder

Go To

OR

Willbyr MOD

Changed: 1751

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Given the fact that much of its fluff is delivered through half-seen and heavily classified reports, ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'' does this a lot. One is "The Gates of C'Tan", which were mentioned in a 2nd edition race book and then later used as the name of an ancient star god two editions on.
** In every Space Marine codex there's a list of the original twenty Space Marine legions, nine of which remained loyal during the HorusHeresy, and nine which turned traitor. But for legions II and XI, there is no information about their names or primarchs or homeworlds, only "[[{{Unperson}} All records expunged from library - order origination unknown]]" -- they are even known, in-verse, as "The Lost Legions". GamesWorkshop has said that they never intend to outright explain the mystery of the lost legions, since it gives fans something to work with. Indeed, even stories set during the HorusHeresy will only hint at the legions' fate in the vaguest terms, though there are some pretty strong hints that they either turned traitor, suffered unacceptable mutations, or both.
*** We do get a few hints about them in official sources, though. Apparently some of the surviving members of one or both Lost Legions were rolled into the Ultramarines (a nod to how in 1st edition the Rainbow Warriors and Valedictors were the 2nd and 11th legions but were later retconned into Ultramarine successors). It's also suggested (perhaps tongue in cheek) that the reason one of the Lost Legions can't be found is because they possess a special mutation that makes them invisible and simply don't ''want'' to be found.

to:

* Given the fact that much of its fluff is delivered through half-seen and heavily classified reports, ''TabletopGame/{{Warhammer 40000}}'' does this a lot. lot.
**
One is "The Gates of C'Tan", which were mentioned in a 2nd edition race book and then later used as the name of an ancient star god two editions on.
** In every Space Marine codex there's a list of the original twenty Space Marine legions, nine of which remained loyal during the HorusHeresy, Literature/HorusHeresy, and nine which turned traitor. But for legions II and XI, there is no information about their names or primarchs names, primarchs, or homeworlds, only "[[{{Unperson}} All records expunged from library - order origination unknown]]" -- they are even known, in-verse, as "The Lost Legions". GamesWorkshop Creator/GamesWorkshop has said that they never intend to outright explain the mystery of the lost legions, since it gives fans something to work with. Indeed, even stories set during the HorusHeresy Horus Heresy will only hint at the legions' fate in the vaguest terms, though there are some pretty strong hints that they either turned traitor, suffered unacceptable mutations, or both.
*** We
both. Official sources do get give a few hints about them in official sources, though.hints. Apparently some of the surviving members of one or both Lost Legions were rolled into the Ultramarines (a nod to how in 1st edition the Rainbow Warriors and Valedictors were the 2nd and 11th legions but were later retconned into Ultramarine successors). It's also suggested (perhaps tongue in cheek) that the reason one of the Lost Legions can't be found is because they possess a special mutation that makes them invisible and simply don't ''want'' to be found.

Added: 378

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''{{Series/Supernatural}}'', the origins of the demon-killing knife introduced in season 3 have never been explained and, [[WordOfGod according to series creator Eric Kripke]], probably never will be.

to:

* In ''{{Series/Supernatural}}'', the origins of the demon-killing knife introduced in season 3 have never been explained and, [[WordOfGod according to series creator Eric Kripke]], probably never will be. be.
* ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'': First introduced in the episode "Inquisition", [[NoSuchAgency Section 31]] and its stated 200 year history opened up plenty of opportunities for novels and spinoffs to feature "[[IWasNeverHere classified]]" examples of its involvement in the earlier franchises, particularly in ''Series/StarTrekEnterprise'' and ''Film/StarTrekIntoDarkness''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
bypassing redirect


If the creators of an active work [[{{Jossed}} take a piece of Canon Fodder and develop it contrary]] to how most of the {{Fanon}} based off that piece is going, FanDumb and related swearing at the creator can easily result. If the creators go a step further and actually use the {{Fanon}}'s answer for Canon Fodder, it's SureWhyNot.

to:

If the creators of an active work [[{{Jossed}} take a piece of Canon Fodder and develop it contrary]] to how most of the {{Fanon}} based off that piece is going, FanDumb and related swearing at the creator can easily result. If the creators go a step further and actually use the {{Fanon}}'s answer for Canon Fodder, it's SureWhyNot.
AscendedFanon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

*** We do get a few hints about them in official sources, though. Apparently some of the surviving members of one or both Lost Legions were rolled into the Ultramarines (a nod to how in 1st edition the Rainbow Warriors and Valedictors were the 2nd and 11th legions but were later retconned into Ultramarine successors). It's also suggested (perhaps tongue in cheek) that the reason one of the Lost Legions can't be found is because they possess a special mutation that makes them invisible and simply don't ''want'' to be found.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''KillBill'': Will Nikki Green get her own revenge on the Bride for her mother's death? Tarantino himself said that she deserves her revenge just as much as the Bride did.

to:

* ''KillBill'': ''Film/KillBill'': Will Nikki Green get her own revenge on the Bride for her mother's death? Tarantino himself said that she deserves her revenge just as much as the Bride did.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ''VideoGame/{{Portal}}'' series (and its interquel comic ''Lab Rat'') has several areas often used as launching points, including life at Aperture and the events leading up to [=GLaDOS=]'s takeover, the exact significance of 'Bring Your Daughter/Cat To Work Day', and the backstories behind several characters, including Doug Rattmann, Chell, Cave Johnson, and Caroline. And, of course, Chell's escape from Aperture at the end of Portal 1/2 (depending on [[{{Jossed}} when the fic was written]].)

to:

** The ''VideoGame/{{Portal}}'' series (and its interquel comic ''Lab Rat'') has several areas often used as launching points, including life at Aperture and the events leading up to [=GLaDOS=]'s takeover, the exact significance of 'Bring Your Daughter/Cat To Work Day', and the backstories behind several characters, including Doug Rattmann, Chell, Cave Johnson, and Caroline. And, of course, Chell's escape from Aperture at the end of Portal 1/2 ''Portal 1''/''2'' (depending on [[{{Jossed}} when the fic was written]].)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''GeneWolfe'''s BookOfTheNewSun intentionally made this into a major part of enjoying the book. He lays it all out in this quote: "My definition of good literature is that which can be read by an educated reader, and reread with increased pleasure."

to:

* ''GeneWolfe'''s ''Creator/GeneWolfe'''s BookOfTheNewSun intentionally made this into a major part of enjoying the book. He lays it all out in this quote: "My definition of good literature is that which can be read by an educated reader, and reread with increased pleasure."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** However, it may be a bit of a stretch to call it "fodder" at this point, because the fans will speculate on ''anything'', whether they're meant to or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''CodenameKidsNextDoor'' has its fair share. Usually either about [[spoiler: the Galactic KND and other related parts of the GrandFinale]] or whatever the incident that lead to [[EvilCounterpart the Delightful Children]] making Numbuh 1 bald and [[MyGreatestFailure the reason Numbuh 5 refuses to lead the team]] was.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** TheAmericanCivilWar, and, by extension, any civil wars. Was there a Confederacy-tan, and if so, what happened to him/her? Or did Alfred develop a split personality?

to:

** TheAmericanCivilWar, UsefulNotes/TheAmericanCivilWar, and, by extension, any civil wars. Was there a Confederacy-tan, and if so, what happened to him/her? Or did Alfred develop a split personality?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** What happened to Zuko's mother?

to:

** What happened to Zuko's mother?mother? [[spoiler:This is answered in ''ComicBook/AvatarTheLastAirbenderTheSearch''.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Presumably, this is also what ChrisClaremont was up to all those years on the ''Comicbook/{{X-Men}}'', too.

to:

** Presumably, this is also what ChrisClaremont Creator/ChrisClaremont was up to all those years on the ''Comicbook/{{X-Men}}'', too.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JimButcher is a master of this: ''TheDresdenFiles'' has things brought up in book ''14'' that were initially introduced in book ''3'', and ''still'' leaves them incompletely resolved.

to:

* JimButcher is a master of this: ''TheDresdenFiles'' ''Literature/TheDresdenFiles'' has things brought up in book ''14'' that were initially introduced in book ''3'', and ''still'' leaves them incompletely resolved.

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
gramar


** The Anime only arcs tend to create Canon Fodder in the form of new characters:

to:

** The Anime only Anime-only arcs tend to create Canon Fodder in the form of new characters:



*** Ashido Kano from the Forest of the Menos episodes, who is presumably still hanging living in the titular forest.

to:

*** Ashido Kano from the Forest of the Menos episodes, who is presumably still hanging living in the titular forest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The Anime only arcs tend to create Canon Fodder in the form of new characters:
*** Gou Koga, who survived the Bount arc, and was left in the Soul Society.
*** Ashido Kano from the Forest of the Menos episodes, who is presumably still hanging living in the titular forest.
*** The various nobles and their retainers from the New Captain arc, who showed up in a pair of filler episodes later.
*** Many of the Reigais sacrifice themselves at the end of the Invading Army arc, but several others were disabled at the time, and not explicitly shown to have been destroyed. Also, a few of the active Reigais are not shown dying in the mass-self-sacrifice.
*** Finally, the zanpakuto spirits from the Zanpakuto Rebellion arc are still around, inhabiting the various zanpakutos.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* JimButcher is a master of this: ''TheDresdenFiles'' has things brought up in book ''14'' that were initially introduced in book ''3'', and ''still'' leaves them incompletely resolved.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** For the longest time there were also the questions: What were the other tailed beasts[[hottip:note:Mainly the four through seven tailed beasts]] and who were their hosts? What happened on the night Naruto was born and the Nine-Tailed Demon Fox was sealed? Who was Kushina, and how did she become a Leaf ninja despite being from Whirlpool?

to:

** For the longest time there were also the questions: What were the other tailed beasts[[hottip:note:Mainly beasts[[note]]Mainly the four through seven tailed beasts]] beasts[[/note]] and who were their hosts? What happened on the night Naruto was born and the Nine-Tailed Demon Fox was sealed? Who was Kushina, and how did she become a Leaf ninja despite being from Whirlpool?



* ''VideoGame/DeadSpace3'' seemed to be wrapping up loose ends for the origins of the [[ZombieApocalypse Necromorphs]] and [[ArtifactOfDoom the Markers]], considering it takes place in an abandoned research outpost on the Marker homeworld. [[spoiler: However, it's not the case. The "homeworld" is just the planet of another alien species that succumbed to the Necromorph infestation as humanity is now, and though explanation is given to the purpose of the Markers[[hottip:+: subvert sentient minds into creating more Markers, deceptively providing an infinite source of energy, starting a Necromorph outbreak, and then acting as a homing beacon for the final stage.]] and Necromorphs[[hottip:+: to create enough dead matter for the Markers to begin a Convergence event, culminating in the birth of a [[EldritchAbomination Brethren Moon that eats the entire race that created it]], the true origin of both the Markers and the Brethren Moons that made them are still unknown]].

to:

* ''VideoGame/DeadSpace3'' seemed to be wrapping up loose ends for the origins of the [[ZombieApocalypse Necromorphs]] and [[ArtifactOfDoom the Markers]], considering it takes place in an abandoned research outpost on the Marker homeworld. [[spoiler: However, it's not the case. The "homeworld" is just the planet of another alien species that succumbed to the Necromorph infestation as humanity is now, and though explanation is given to the purpose of the Markers[[hottip:+: Markers[[note]] subvert sentient minds into creating more Markers, deceptively providing an infinite source of energy, starting a Necromorph outbreak, and then acting as a homing beacon for the final stage.]] [[/note]] and Necromorphs[[hottip:+: Necromorphs[[note]] to create enough dead matter for the Markers to begin a Convergence event, culminating in the birth of a [[EldritchAbomination Brethren Moon that eats the entire race that created it]], it]][[/note]], the true origin of both the Markers and the Brethren Moons that made them are still unknown]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''UminekoNoNakuKoroNi'', Featherine created a lot of this when she said that anyone who knows the Golden Truth can create forgeries that are just as true as the original (not that this stops anyone who ''doesn't'' know the Golden Truth.) Then there's the whole body of omake [=TIPS=] of varying canonicity...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Good thing we have ''SuperRobotWars''. Who knew the ancient Martians were related to the [[MazingerZ Mikene Empire]], the [[BlueCometSPTLayzner Gradosians]] and the [[VoltesV Boazanians]]?

to:

** Good thing we have ''SuperRobotWars''.''VideoGame/SuperRobotWars''. Who knew the ancient Martians were related to the [[MazingerZ Mikene Empire]], the [[BlueCometSPTLayzner Gradosians]] and the [[VoltesV Boazanians]]?



* ''SuperRobotWars'' loves to play this trope with its ever-expanding OriginalGeneration, and not just in the [[SuperRobotWarsOriginalGeneration OG games]] themselves. Expect any given game to be littered with {{Sequel Hook}}s, prequel hooks, AlternateContinuity spinoff hooks, and many a CrypticBackgroundReference. The big one right now is the "twelve keys" plot, which isn't limited to any one continuity and seems to be setting up for a [[MassiveMultiplayerCrossover crossover]] [[UpToEleven among crossovers]].

to:

* ''SuperRobotWars'' ''VideoGame/SuperRobotWars'' loves to play this trope with its ever-expanding OriginalGeneration, and not just in the [[SuperRobotWarsOriginalGeneration [[VideoGame/SuperRobotWarsOriginalGeneration OG games]] themselves. Expect any given game to be littered with {{Sequel Hook}}s, prequel hooks, AlternateContinuity spinoff hooks, and many a CrypticBackgroundReference. The big one right now is the "twelve keys" plot, which isn't limited to any one continuity and seems to be setting up for a [[MassiveMultiplayerCrossover crossover]] [[UpToEleven among crossovers]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''DannyPhantom'' accumulated hordes of this, thanks to [[ScrewedByTheNetwork early cancellation and the head writer being replaced]]:
** The entirety of "The Ultimate Enemy", from whether the BadFuture really was altered to the nature of [[TimeMaster Clockwork]] to the prospect of [[EnsembleDarkhorse Dark Danny]] escaping.

to:

* ''DannyPhantom'' ''WesternAnimation/DannyPhantom'' accumulated hordes of this, thanks to [[ScrewedByTheNetwork early cancellation and the head writer being replaced]]:
** The entirety of "The Ultimate Enemy", "WesternAnimation/TheUltimateEnemy", from whether the BadFuture really was altered to the nature of [[TimeMaster Clockwork]] to the prospect of [[EnsembleDarkhorse Dark Danny]] escaping.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the HalfLife games, almost anything not stated in game is totally up in the air. How did Eli, Dr. Kleiner and Judith get from Black Mesa to City 17? Who and what is the G-Man, and what does he want? Does Gordon [[HeroicMime talk]]?

to:

** In the HalfLife VideoGame/HalfLife games, almost anything not stated in game is totally up in the air. How did Eli, Dr. Kleiner and Judith get from Black Mesa to City 17? Who and what is the G-Man, and what does he want? Does Gordon [[HeroicMime talk]]?
K

Changed: 570

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* There are several in ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice'', but the two primary ones right now are "What happened during the five year time skip?" and, less prominently, "who are the four missing team members?" Since each team member has a designation number, fans counted up the characters present in the second season premiere and came up with seven unknowns. Episode three revealed that one of them was Tula as Aquagirl, promotional material for the upcoming video shows that another was Garth as Tempest, and the presence of his memorial in the grotto means a third was Jason Todd as Robin, but that's still four former teammates we can't account for, with no trace of them at all in the show.

to:

* There are several in ''WesternAnimation/YoungJustice'', but the two primary ones right now are "What happened during the five year time skip?" and, less prominently, "who and "What are the four missing Light's plans with Darkseid?" There was a minor one relating to the heroes who must have been members of the team members?" Since each team member has a due to how high the designation number, fans counted up the characters present in the second season premiere and came up with seven unknowns. Episode three numbers got but were never seen, but WordOfGod revealed that one of them was Tula right before the finale, as Aquagirl, promotional material a reward for the upcoming video shows that another was Garth as Tempest, and the presence of his memorial in the grotto means a third was Jason Todd as Robin, but that's still four former teammates we can't account for, with no trace of them at all in the show. fans' patience.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''SilentHill''. Holy crap, ''SilentHill''. While it is difficult to think ill of those that latch onto the smallest of details in a series that almost prides itself on providing as little information as possible without showing a blank screen, it becomes patently ridiculous at times. It also doesn't help that it is entirely probable the ''creators themselves'' know about as much of the series as the fans do, maybe less (see SureWhyNot and ShrugOfGod).

to:

* ''SilentHill''. Holy crap, ''SilentHill''. While it is difficult to think ill of those that latch onto the smallest of details in a series that almost prides itself on providing as little information as possible without showing a blank screen, it becomes patently ridiculous at times. It also doesn't help that it is entirely probable the ''creators themselves'' know about as much of the series as the fans do, maybe less (see SureWhyNot AscendedFanon and ShrugOfGod).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Is Appa the last air bison? Heck, did Aang and Katara become the Adam and Eve for a new race of Air Nomads? Fortunately, both are answered in the sequel series ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra''.

to:

** Is Appa the last air bison? Heck, did Aang and Katara become the Adam and Eve for a new race of Air Nomads? Fortunately, both are answered in the sequel series ''WesternAnimation/TheLegendOfKorra''. [[spoiler:No, and yes.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Pick a background and/or psychological profile of [[PlayerCharacter Shepard's]] from ''MassEffect'' and chances are, someone's done a fan fic about his/her life growing up. And outside of a few small sidequests in the first game related to said backstories, the details are left fairly vague enough so that fan fiction can ''thrive'' on this trope.

to:

* Pick a background and/or psychological profile of [[PlayerCharacter Shepard's]] from ''MassEffect'' ''Franchise/MassEffect'' and chances are, someone's done a fan fic about his/her life growing up. And outside of a few small sidequests in the first game related to said backstories, the details are left fairly vague enough so that fan fiction can ''thrive'' on this trope.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Hyrule Historia ''does'' confirm that Kaepora Gaebora is a form of the sage Rauru--and then creates more questions by revealing that Rauru built and sealed the Temple of Time sometime between the events of ''VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaSkywardSword'' and ''VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaTheMinishCap'', generations before his appearance in ''VideoGame/TheLegendOfZeldaOcarinaOfTime''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In her last message to the Doctor in ''The Angels Take Manhattan'', Amy assured the Doctor that she and Rory had long happy lives together after being sent in the past by the Weeping Angel. Speculation on how their lives went have fueled more than a few fanfics.

to:

** In her last message to the Doctor in ''The Angels Take Manhattan'', Amy assured the Doctor that she and Rory had long happy lives together after being sent in the past by the Weeping Angel. Speculation on how their lives went have has fueled more than a few fanfics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In her last message to the Doctor in ''The Angels Take Manhattan'', Amy assured the Doctor that she and Rory had long happy lives together after being sent in the past by the Weeping Angel. Speculation on how their lives went have fueled more than a few fanfics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* A couple of episodes of ''TransformersGeneration1'' mentioned that many Transformers had fled Cybertron during the CivilWar. In a late episode, Cyclonus and Scourge encounter a planet of them, and the main characters of ''TransformersHeadmasters'' were all such refugees.

to:

* A couple of episodes of ''TransformersGeneration1'' ''WesternAnimation/TheTransformers'' mentioned that many Transformers had fled Cybertron during the CivilWar. In a late episode, Cyclonus and Scourge encounter a planet of them, and the main characters of ''TransformersHeadmasters'' ''Anime/TransformersHeadmasters'' were all such refugees.

Top