Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AgainstMyReligion

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/AreYouThereGodItsMeMargaret'': During the preparations for Margaret's class's holiday choir concert — with five Christian songs and three Hanukkah ones — Jewish classmate Alan Gordon refuses to sing Christmas songs and Christian classmate Lisa Murphy refuses to sing Hanukkah songs, both claiming it's against their religion. Mr. Benedict's appeal to reason fails. Unlike in the book, Mr. Benedict compromises by allowing both kids to remain silent during any songs that go against their beliefs.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Being tolerant of one another's religious beliefs is very important (in many 20th & 21st century cultures, at least). In works created by people from those cultures, if someone says something is against their religion, other characters think they can't make them do it. Now that person might be telling BlatantLies to get out of doing that thing, but it might be the truth. Other characters are likely not going to press that character about it.

to:

Being tolerant of one another's religious beliefs is very important (in many 20th & 21st century cultures, at least).least (and some earlier ones, but usally in a much narrower scope)). In works created by people from those cultures, if someone says something is against their religion, other characters think they can't make them do it. Now that person might be telling BlatantLies to get out of doing that thing, but it might be the truth. Other characters are likely not going to press that character about it.

Added: 386

Changed: 7

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During negotiations, the Jawas demand Din put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.

to:

** During negotiations, the Jawas demand Din Djarin put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/TheBookOfBobaFett'': When Din Djarin tries to board a commercial transport to Tatooine (his own ship having been destroyed) a security droid stops him because he's not allowed to board with weapons on his person. Din tries the "part of my religion" line [[SubvertedTrope but]] the droid isn't having it and orders him to place his weapons in a secure container for the trip.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Film/LevyAndGoliath'', the Orthodox UsefulNotes/{{Judaism}}[=-observant=] Moses has troubles just looking at other women than his wife (or tradition-observing Jewish women with covered hair), having to go through the RedLightDistrict of UsefulNotes/{{Paris}} is a nightmare for him, and ditching his visible signs of Hasidism (black clothes, [[BeardnessProtectionProgram beard, hair]]) to save his own life doesn't sit too well with him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''ComicStrip/{{Candorville}}'': Roxanne claims to follow an Aztec religion that bans the examination of DNA—ruling out a paternity test to determine whether Lionel is really Lemont's son.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Similarly in ''Film/PitchBlack'' Imam refuses to drink liquor for the same reason, even though its the only thing drinkable for the moment. This is not well researched regarding Islam. Imam's position in the film is dire. Plus, he has two children to look after. He was stuck on a desert planet with no other food or water -- in Islam, if the situation is dire enough to threaten one's life by lack of halal food and clean (no alcohol) drinks, Muslims are permitted to consume any available meat (meat of a lizard, meat of a dog or pig) or drink alcohol. Just to survive until help comes.

to:

* Similarly in ''Film/PitchBlack'' Imam refuses to drink liquor for the same reason, even though its the only thing drinkable for the moment. This is not well researched regarding Islam. Imam's position in the film is dire. Plus, he has two children to look after. He was stuck on a desert planet with no other food or water -- in Islam, if the situation is dire enough to threaten one's life by lack of halal food and clean (no alcohol) drinks, Muslims are permitted to consume any available meat (meat of a lizard, meat of a dog or pig) or drink alcohol. Just to survive until help comes.[[note]]That being said, the alcohol was high-proof liquor, so it would probably have dehydrated them even more if they'd drank it.[[/note]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The person is known as Niko Alm and this was more of a publicity stunt. He protested against the "privilege" of Religious people to get their photos taken with various forms of headgear. He got this allowed in the end because the spaghetti strainer didn't obstruct his face and not based on his belief.

to:

** The person is known as Niko Alm and this was more of a publicity stunt. He protested against the "privilege" of Religious religious people to get their photos taken with various forms of headgear. He got this allowed in the end because the spaghetti strainer didn't obstruct his face and not based on his belief.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/{{Attachment}}'': Leah initially refuses the bacon Maja cooked, as she's Jewish. Though she isn't religious, Leah says the prohibition sunk in. She caves soon though when it smells so good. Later she's chided by her mom, who's Orthodox, over traveling on Shabbos (which is also forbidden).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Keep in mind that most religions, especially the Abrahamic ones, view not doing what you can to survive as a greater sin. If it comes down to starving or eating non-kosher/halaal food for example, the religion expressly commands you survive.

to:

Keep in mind that most religions, especially the Abrahamic ones, view not doing what you can to survive as a greater sin. If it comes down to starving or eating non-kosher/halaal non-kosher/halal food for example, the religion expressly commands you survive.



* In ""Film/TheThirteenthWarrior'' Ahmed explains to the Viking Herger that he can't drink alcohol whether made from "grape or grain". Herger laughs and explains mead is made from honey. Cue next morning shot of Ahmed holding head and moaning.

to:

* In ""Film/TheThirteenthWarrior'' ''Film/TheThirteenthWarrior'' Ahmed explains to the Viking Herger that he can't drink alcohol whether made from "grape or grain". Herger laughs and explains mead is made from honey. Cue next morning shot of Ahmed holding head and moaning.

Added: 307

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** During negotiations, the Jawas demand the Mandalorian put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.

to:

** During negotiations, the Jawas demand the Mandalorian Din put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.


Added DiffLines:

** In season 3, Din and Bo-Katan find themselves on a peaceful planet facing a violent problem. Their planetary charter forbids weapons in the city limits, but cultural allowances are made; everyone knows weapons are part of Mandalorian culture. Hence, they can hire the Mandalorians to solve the problem.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* An ''Series/UnsolvedMysteries'' segment about the still-unsolved 1986 [[https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Chaim_Weiss murder of Chaim Weiss]], a yeshiva student, found the detectives running into this problem. Aside from the staff and students at the school being forbidden to write because it was the Sabbath, Jewish law prevents speaking ill of someone unless you have specific knowledge of their wrongdoing. Which means that to this day, even if someone has suspicions about who his killer might be, they can't or won't say anything without knowing for certain.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/TheHolyOffice'': The Carvajales in the dungeon refuse to eat the pork they're served because they're Jews. Fray Hernando also refuses since he ends up converting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The "Sacrum Profanum" gig from ''VideoGame/{{Cyberpunk 2077}}'' has you dealing with a pair of Buddhist-style monks who were kidnapped by Maelstrom, a vicious gang of cyberpsychos who among other things love to forcibly cybernize people. Cybernetic implantation is against the religion that these monks practice, but unfortunately for them, not only do Maelstrom not give a damn about that, they find it ''funny''. And then you're tasked with rescuing the monk's non-modified brother. [[PacifistRun Without killing anyone]].

to:

* The "Sacrum Profanum" gig from ''VideoGame/{{Cyberpunk 2077}}'' has you dealing with a pair of Buddhist-style monks who were kidnapped by Maelstrom, a vicious gang of cyberpsychos who among other things love to forcibly cybernize people. Cybernetic implantation is against the religion that these monks practice, but unfortunately for them, not only do Maelstrom not give a damn about that, they find it ''funny''. And then you're tasked with rescuing the monk's non-modified brother.brother before they cybernize him like they did to the monk himself. [[PacifistRun Without killing anyone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* The "Sacrum Profanum" gig from ''VideoGame/{{Cyberpunk 2077}}'' has you dealing with a pair of Buddhist-style monks who were kidnapped by Maelstrom, a vicious gang of cyberpsychos who among other things love to forcibly cybernize people. Cybernetic implantation is against the religion that these monks practice, but unfortunately for them, not only do Maelstrom not give a damn about that, they find it ''funny''. And then you're tasked with rescuing the monk's non-modified brother. [[PacifistRun Without killing anyone]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Bo Katan is not a reliable source about what is or isn’t a cult


** Similarly, he absolutely refuses to take off his helmet, and would rather die than show his face in front of others. Since he was raised by a cult of zealots who strictly adhered to "The Way," he considers those who wear the armor who are not of Mandalore, or those who are of Mandalore but take off their helmets to be a disgrace to their creed.

to:

** Similarly, he absolutely refuses to take off his helmet, and would rather die than show his face in front of others. Since he was raised by a cult particularly strict sect of zealots Mandalorians who strictly adhered to "The Way," he considers those who wear the armor who are not of Mandalore, or those who are of Mandalore but take off their helmets to be a disgrace to their creed.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* In the 2009 Christmas Special of ''Machinima/RedVsBlue'', Grif claims to have joined every single religion in the world. That way, he can refuse to do anything, since, according to him, every day of the week is at least one religion's holy day of rest (except for Monday, curiously).

to:

* In the 2009 Christmas Special of ''Machinima/RedVsBlue'', ''WebAnimation/RedVsBlue'', Grif claims to have joined every single religion in the world. That way, he can refuse to do anything, since, according to him, every day of the week is at least one religion's holy day of rest (except for Monday, curiously).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taken to the extreme: the entire point of the [=MtoP=] (Motohiro to People) parody religion started in 2018 by Japanese Motohiro Hisano is to bestow its followers with the power of "religious reasons" to invoke to refuse things like working overtime.

to:

* Taken to the extreme: the entire point of the [=MtoP=] (Motohiro to People) parody religion started in 2018 by Japanese Motohiro Hisano is to bestow its followers with the power of "religious reasons" to invoke to refuse things like working overtime. That being said, working overtime is a massive issue in Japan's office culture (as well as in other Asian countries), to the point where they have to have a word for overwork death, "karoshi". It is most commonly caused by heart attacks and strokes due to stress and a starvation diet, but also by suicide.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Film/YoungAndWild'': Daniela's parents and Evangelicals generally oppose her libertine ways because of their strict religious beliefs that all extramarital sex is wrong.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Parodied in ''[[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8059366/6/Objective-Emiya Objective: Emiya]]'', where after seeing Illya "help" Rin get over Shirou (who is dating Ayaka Sajyou) by setting her on a date with Berseker, Saber quickly claims that she's gay and that match-making her is offensive to the gay community. Illya buys this, and again when Sakura claims so, despite the fact that the two were in love with Shirou.
-->'''Illya''': ...how is that...\\
'''Saber''': IT JUST IS! DO NOT QUESTION MY RELIGION!
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/ResidentAlien'': Sahar doesn't look at Max's bare back, saying as a Muslim it's forbidden since he's not her husband (it's somewhat amusing as they're both kids, but Sahar's [[TheComicallySerious perfectly serious]] in saying this).

to:

* ''Series/ResidentAlien'': Sahar doesn't look at Max's bare back, saying as a Muslim it's forbidden since he's not her husband (it's somewhat amusing as they're both kids, but Sahar's [[TheComicallySerious perfectly serious]] in saying this). Later she tells Harry that divorce is against her religion unless it's initiated by the husband and therefore she's never getting married.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


Comes up a lot with someone RaisedCatholic, GoodGirlsAvoidAbortion in particular. Of course, in RealLife, many practices considered common by the majority may be expressly forbidden to people of a particular religious group. A common loophole use of this in real life is that some religions believe people have intellect, guardian angels, or a conscious that enables them to judge things as wrong that are not explicitly banned by their religion, and then requires they do what they think/feel/believe/know is right. Therefore, they are able to attribute their personal judgment as religious mandates.

to:

Comes up a lot with someone RaisedCatholic, raised Catholic, GoodGirlsAvoidAbortion in particular. Of course, in RealLife, many practices considered common by the majority may be expressly forbidden to people of a particular religious group. A common loophole use of this in real life is that some religions believe people have intellect, guardian angels, or a conscious that enables them to judge things as wrong that are not explicitly banned by their religion, and then requires they do what they think/feel/believe/know is right. Therefore, they are able to attribute their personal judgment as religious mandates.



* In ''Webcomic/SomethingPositive,'' Mike [[RaisedCatholic cites this]] as his reason for him and Tamara having sex without birth control ([[LawOfInverseFertility resulting in her pregnancy]]). Given that he follows few if any other Catholic practices, [=PeeJee=] immediately [[http://www.somethingpositive.net/sp03032006.shtml calls him out on this]]:

to:

* In ''Webcomic/SomethingPositive,'' Mike [[RaisedCatholic cites this]] this as his reason for him and Tamara having sex without birth control ([[LawOfInverseFertility resulting in her pregnancy]]). Given that he follows few if any other Catholic practices, [=PeeJee=] immediately [[http://www.somethingpositive.net/sp03032006.shtml calls him out on this]]:

Added: 701

Changed: 455

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Series/TheMandalorian'': During negotiations, the Jawas demand the Mandalorian put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.

to:

* ''Series/TheMandalorian'': ''Series/TheMandalorian'':
**
During negotiations, the Jawas demand the Mandalorian put down his weapons. He claims that his weapons are a part of his religion; he grudgingly relents but is soon revealed to have kept his wrist-mounted flamethrower. Even better, since Mandalorians are a ProudWarriorRace, it is quite possible that he was being perfectly honest. His armor is ''definitely'' part of his religion, and when the Jawas try to buy it off him this deal is dismissed outright.


Added DiffLines:

* ''Series/ResidentAlien'': Sahar doesn't look at Max's bare back, saying as a Muslim it's forbidden since he's not her husband (it's somewhat amusing as they're both kids, but Sahar's [[TheComicallySerious perfectly serious]] in saying this).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheLoveAndLiesOfRukhsanaAli'': Rukhsana's parents have a hard time accepting her as a lesbian as they're Muslims, with homosexuality traditionally being forbidden. On the same note, they're afraid that their family and friends will react poorly to her lesbianism too as a result.
Tabs MOD

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''[[DescribeTopicHere Describe Against My Religion Here, unless describing tropes is forbidden by your creed.]]''

to:

''[[DescribeTopicHere ''[[JustForFun/DescribeTopicHere Describe Against My Religion Here, unless describing tropes is forbidden by your creed.]]''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Taken to the extreme: the entire point of the [=MtoP=] (Motohiro to People) parody religion started in 2018 by Japanese Motohiro Hisano is to bestow its followers with the power of "religious reasons" to invoke to refuse things like working overtime.

Added: 137

Changed: 141

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* One ''ComicStrip/CalvinAndHobbes'' strip has Calvin jotting down in his quiz that he couldn't answer a question because it's against his religion (see the page pic).

to:

* ''ComicStrip/CalvinAndHobbes'':
**
One ''ComicStrip/CalvinAndHobbes'' strip has Calvin jotting down in his quiz that he couldn't answer a question because it's against his religion (see the page pic).



* ''Film/ANewYorkChristmasWedding'': Father Kelly at first gently refusing to wed Gabby and Jenni as Catholic doctrine doesn't recognize same-sex marriage. However, he later relents on this and does it anyway.

to:

* ''Film/ANewYorkChristmasWedding'': Father Kelly at first gently refusing refuses to wed Gabby and Jenni as Catholic doctrine doesn't recognize same-sex marriage. However, he later relents on this and does it anyway.

Added: 11

Changed: 220

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ""Film/TheThirteenthWarrior'' Ahmed explains to the Viking Herger that he can't drink alcohol whether made from "grape or grain". Herger laughs and explains mead is made from honey. Cue next morning shot of Ahmed holding head and moaning.[[/folder]]

to:

* In ""Film/TheThirteenthWarrior'' Ahmed explains to the Viking Herger that he can't drink alcohol whether made from "grape or grain". Herger laughs and explains mead is made from honey. Cue next morning shot of Ahmed holding head and moaning.moaning.
* ''Film/ANewYorkChristmasWedding'': Father Kelly at first gently refusing to wed Gabby and Jenni as Catholic doctrine doesn't recognize same-sex marriage. However, he later relents on this and does it anyway.
[[/folder]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** A variant appears in ''Series/LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit''. A suspect in a number of rape/murders claims he's a Jehovah's Witness, and so the court cannot compel him to give blood for a DNA sample. This is circumvented when a brother of one of the victims attacks him, and he bites the brother during the fight. The saliva on the bite was "given voluntarily", so it can be legally used for the sample.

to:

** A variant appears in ''Series/LawAndOrderSpecialVictimsUnit''. A suspect in a number of rape/murders claims he's a he is one of Jehovah's Witness, Witnesses, and so the court cannot compel him to give blood for a DNA sample. This is circumvented when a brother of one of the victims attacks him, and he bites the brother during the fight. The saliva on the bite was "given voluntarily", so it can be legally used for the sample.

Top