Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Main / AbsurdlyPowerfulStudentCouncil

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/BenFortune'', when Ben is accused of illicit drug use after supposedly failing his athletics-mandated drug test, he is brought before the disciplinary committee, a student run judicial council to decide if he should be expelled from school. Student advocates from the school's debate team serve as prosecutor and defense and present a vigorous defense using things like Ben's attendance records and doctor's notes submitted to the school (records that can only be viewed by appropriate school administrators per federal law). Later, when it is revealed that Lena Montgomery and her father conspired to fake evidence of Ben's drug use in hopes of getting him expelled, Lena's case is brought before the same disciplinary committee and she is expelled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''Literature/BenFortune'', when Ben is accused of illicit drug use after supposedly failing his athletics-mandated drug test, he is brought before the disciplinary committee, a student run judicial council to decide if he should be expelled from school. Student advocates from the school's debate team serve as prosecutor and defense and present a vigorous defense using things like Ben's attendance records and doctor's notes submitted to the school (records that can only be viewed by appropriate school administrators per federal law). Later, when it is revealed that Lena Montgomery and her father conspired to fake evidence of Ben's drug use in hopes of getting him expelled, Lena's case is brought before the same disciplinary committee and she is expelled.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** The Utena UsefulNotes/SegaSaturn game pumps up the absurdity, by revealing that the only reason the council members have their places at all is that they're the most popular and "prince-like" students in the school. Their jobs on the council are arbitrarily assigned based on their age. Mikki is genuinely shocked at the revelation; Juri just gets pissed.
** Anthy is treated as a honorary member due her role as the Rose Bride and the Councilmembers being the candidates to get engaged to her. As an extension, Utena in the manga is treated as another honorary member due having won the engagement.

to:

*** The Utena UsefulNotes/SegaSaturn game pumps up the absurdity, by revealing that the only reason the council members have their places at all is that they're the most popular and "prince-like" students in the school. Their jobs on the council are arbitrarily assigned based on their age. Mikki Miki is genuinely shocked at the revelation; Juri just gets pissed.
** Anthy is treated as a honorary member due her role as the Rose Bride and the Councilmembers councilmembers being the candidates to get engaged to her. As an extension, Utena in the manga is treated as another honorary member due having won the engagement.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Forgot the second markup oops.


%Please do not wick the following work as its page was removed for violating The Content Policy. Thank you.

to:

%Please %%Please do not wick the following work as its page was removed for violating The Content Policy. Thank you.

Added: 274

Changed: 307

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Taken to its logical extreme in ''BigBangAge''. The Student Union rules not a school but the ''entire country'', enforcing order on the super-powered teenagers of Japan. Its the weakening of their authority that sets the stage for the main plot as factions start infighting.

to:

%Please do not wick the following work as its page was removed for violating The Content Policy. Thank you.
* Taken to its logical extreme in ''BigBangAge''.Big Bang Age. The Student Union rules not a school but the ''entire country'', enforcing order on the super-powered teenagers of Japan. Its the weakening of their authority that sets the stage for the main plot as factions start infighting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
ZCE


* In ''Series/KidNation'', the entire city was run by children. Some of the children acted in accordance with this trope.

to:

* %%* In ''Series/KidNation'', the entire city was run by children. Some of the children acted in accordance with this trope. <-- Zero Content: exactly HOW do they do so?
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* In ''VideoGame/WintermoorTacticsClub'', members of the Student Council are allowed to carry swords and appear to be omniscient. In particular, Alicia is terrified of their leader, who has her own unique theme, and she will refuse to approach her- which can interfere with some Quests, since she has a habit of hanging out in plot-relevant areas.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ3X4PxU8nA this]] ''Creator/ProZD'' video, he compares and contrasts student councils in anime vs the real world. In the first, the student council representative is extorting President Biden for funding and has several students and their families put to death because [[FelonyMisdemeanor the students were tardy]]. In the second, the council representative meekly tries asking the others if they want to do a fundraiser.

to:

* In [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ3X4PxU8nA this]] ''Creator/ProZD'' ''WebVideo/ProZD'' video, he compares and contrasts student councils in anime vs the real world. In the first, the student council representative is extorting President Biden for funding and has several students and their families put to death because [[FelonyMisdemeanor the students were tardy]]. In the second, the council representative meekly tries asking the others if they want to do a fundraiser.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''VideoGame/TwistedWonderland'': The headmaster and faculty of Noble Bell College are never seen. Its only authority figure seen is its student council, with its StudentCouncilPresident Rollo Flamme acting as the ''de facto'' face of the school.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also played straight in the episode in which Kevin finds himself elected to the student council: he was in the bathroom, and his classmates took advantage of his absence to elect him. It was one vote for Mr. Ed, two for Ringo Starr, and the rest for Kevin. He then gets mixed up in calls for a walkout to protest the war in Vietnam, with the realistic result that the principal threatens all concerned with suspension and a mark on their permanent record.

Added: 309

Removed: 300

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
fix wick + alphabetisation


* In ''KakumeikiValvrave'', after cutting themselves off from the rest of JIOR in the most literal way ever depicted in anime, the Student Council becomes the defacto '''government of an independent nation'''. Eventually, that independent nation goes on to becoming known as the Third Galactic Reich.


Added DiffLines:

* In ''Anime/ValvraveTheLiberator'', after cutting themselves off from the rest of JIOR in the most literal way ever depicted in anime, the Student Council becomes the defacto '''government of an independent nation'''. Eventually, that independent nation goes on to becoming known as the Third Galactic Reich.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* The Yearbook Committee variation is subverted in ''Series/TheWonderYears'', in which Kevin, giving into peer pressure, puts a disparaging quote by the picture of a likable but overweight friend. He agonizes over the effect this will have on his friend, only to find that [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome reality ensues]] when the school administration, learning of the quote, has it removed and tells off Kevin.

to:

* The Yearbook Committee variation is subverted in ''Series/TheWonderYears'', in which Kevin, giving into peer pressure, puts a disparaging quote by the picture of a likable but overweight friend. He agonizes over the effect this will have on his friend, only to find that [[SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome reality ensues]] when the school administration, learning of the quote, has it removed and tells off Kevin.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Sekolah Menengah Cipta Wiyata in ''VideoGame/{{Troublemaker}}'' is a Jakarta high school whose student council somehow has ''higher'' authority than the principal and faculty, with their chairman, Ricco, leading his cronies in pummeling the snot out of any students who crosses them the wrong way. Somehow they're powerful enough to have all reports of school violence buried.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Downplayed in ''Literature/TheNaughtiestGirl'', in that there are student "meetings" every week, in which all the pupils hand in their money, and it is given out according to if the needs are considered worthy enough by the meeting; and punishments for erring students are decided.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The King of the Playground seems like a mere ceremonial position for popular kids at times, but King Bob has the authority to have kids get swirlies or locked in a box, hold trials,, have the name of any newly transfered student be legally changed to "New Kid", and build structures. He also mentions his predecessors doing things like writing a code of laws and successfully lobbying to the city council for more recess.

to:

** The King of the Playground seems like a mere ceremonial position for popular kids at times, but King Bob has the authority to have kids get swirlies or locked in a box, hold trials,, trials, have the name of any newly transfered student be legally changed to "New Kid", and build structures. He also mentions his predecessors doing things like writing a code of laws and successfully lobbying to the city council for more recess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** {{Justified}}. The Supreme Five Swords (how the students' council is called at the Private Aiichi Symbiosis Academy) have a lot of power, including the right to carry ''swords'' on campus... Because the ''headmistress is under orders to allow it'', as the owner finds it convenient for reasons so far unknown. It's shown that while the normal teachers don't dare to interfere with their antics the Supreme Five Swords know who is actually in charge, as the one time the headmistress decides to punish their president and another one they just take the punishment. In a variation, it's stated early on they're actually supposed to be the ''Disciplinary Committee'', that after Aiichi became co-ed ended up taking up the students' council's duties alongside rule enforcement... Meaning that there may be an actual yet powerless students' council somewhere.

to:

** {{Justified}}.{{Justified|Trope}}. The Supreme Five Swords (how the students' council is called at the Private Aiichi Symbiosis Academy) have a lot of power, including the right to carry ''swords'' on campus... Because the ''headmistress is under orders to allow it'', as the owner finds it convenient for reasons so far unknown. It's shown that while the normal teachers don't dare to interfere with their antics the Supreme Five Swords know who is actually in charge, as the one time the headmistress decides to punish their president and another one they just take the punishment. In a variation, it's stated early on they're actually supposed to be the ''Disciplinary Committee'', that after Aiichi became co-ed ended up taking up the students' council's duties alongside rule enforcement... Meaning that there may be an actual yet powerless students' council somewhere.



* {{Justified}} in ''Webcomic/MobPsycho100'', in that their president Kamuro actually ''tricks'' the faculty into giving them this kind of power by engineering a situation they don't really want to deal with and "offering" to do it in their stead, and by the point the faculty realizes what's happening they can't take it back without losing face.

to:

* {{Justified}} {{Justified|Trope}} in ''Webcomic/MobPsycho100'', in that their president Kamuro actually ''tricks'' the faculty into giving them this kind of power by engineering a situation they don't really want to deal with and "offering" to do it in their stead, and by the point the faculty realizes what's happening they can't take it back without losing face.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The King of the Playground seems like a mere ceremonial position for popular kids at times, but King Bob has the authority to have kids get swirlies or locked in a box, hold trials, and build structures. He also mentions his predecessors doing things like writing a code of laws and successfully lobbying to the city council for more recess.

to:

** The King of the Playground seems like a mere ceremonial position for popular kids at times, but King Bob has the authority to have kids get swirlies or locked in a box, hold trials, trials,, have the name of any newly transfered student be legally changed to "New Kid", and build structures. He also mentions his predecessors doing things like writing a code of laws and successfully lobbying to the city council for more recess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'': At the dark magic school Myth/TheScholomance, the top four students are known as the 'elites' and, as a group / council, decide which students are given which class rank. That rank in turn determines everything from the quality of food and equipment other students get to which missions they're assigned. As such, even though the elites are just students, they still control almost every aspect of the other students' lives and can make their lives at the Scholomance easier... or much, much harder. (And shorter).

to:

* ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'': At the dark magic school Myth/TheScholomance, ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'' is set at an evil WizardingSchool where the top four students are known as the 'elites' and, as a group / council, decide which students are given which class rank. That rank in turn determines everything from the quality of food and equipment other students get to which missions they're assigned. As such, even though the elites are just students, they still control almost every aspect of the other students' lives and can make their lives at the Scholomance easier... or much, much harder. (And shorter).

Added: 672

Changed: 38

Removed: 657

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Subverted in ''Anime/KnightHunters: Weiß Kreuz [[OddlyNamedSequel2ElectricBoogaloo Gluhen]]'': Koua Academy seems to have an Absurdly Powerful Student Council in the form of "S Class," an elite group of students who, led by EnfantTerrible Toudou, get away with murder and at one point openly declare their control over the school. They get a rude awakening 6 or 7 episodes in when [[spoiler:Toudou discovers he is the TomatoInTheMirror, has a FreakOut, and is murdered by his creator]], after which the protagonists get down to the business of ferreting out TheManBehindTheMan and The Man ''Behind'' TheManBehindTheMan from among the faculty and founders of the academy.



* Subverted in ''Anime/WeissKreuz [[OddlyNamedSequel2ElectricBoogaloo Gluhen]]'': Koua Academy seems to have an Absurdly Powerful Student Council in the form of "S Class," an elite group of students who, led by EnfantTerrible Toudou, get away with murder and at one point openly declare their control over the school. They get a rude awakening 6 or 7 episodes in when [[spoiler:Toudou discovers he is the TomatoInTheMirror, has a FreakOut, and is murdered by his creator]], after which the protagonists get down to the business of ferreting out TheManBehindTheMan and The Man ''Behind'' TheManBehindTheMan from among the faculty and founders of the academy.



* In ''LightNovel/AsuraCryin'', the student council can give the authorization to kill. Can't get much more powerful than that.

to:

* In ''LightNovel/AsuraCryin'', ''Literature/AsuraCryin'', the student council can give the authorization to kill. Can't get much more powerful than that.



* ''LightNovel/ChromeShelledRegios'': The StudentCouncilPresident is explicitly in charge of the city. Considering that includes its military for fighting giant monsters as well as other cities, that's a pretty big responsibility. He can effectively force students to change their majors if he decides it's in the city's best interest.

to:

* ''LightNovel/ChromeShelledRegios'': ''Literature/ChromeShelledRegios'': The StudentCouncilPresident is explicitly in charge of the city. Considering that includes its military for fighting giant monsters as well as other cities, that's a pretty big responsibility. He can effectively force students to change their majors if he decides it's in the city's best interest.



* ''LightNovel/HighSchoolDxD'': Most of the school's politics seemed to be settled through negotiation between the StudentCouncilPresident Souna Sitri and the Occult Research Club President Rias Gremory. Justified, as most of the senior faculty are devils, and direly outranked by the ''de facto'' heads of two of the three great houses. In fact, since both Rias and Souna have older siblings who are Satans, the balance of power for ''the entire Devil faction'' is filtered through Kuoh Academy's school politics.

to:

* ''LightNovel/HighSchoolDxD'': ''Literature/HighSchoolDXD'': Most of the school's politics seemed to be settled through negotiation between the StudentCouncilPresident Souna Sitri and the Occult Research Club President Rias Gremory. Justified, as most of the senior faculty are devils, and direly outranked by the ''de facto'' heads of two of the three great houses. In fact, since both Rias and Souna have older siblings who are Satans, the balance of power for ''the entire Devil faction'' is filtered through Kuoh Academy's school politics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


--->'''Cecil''' (In reference to "angel" sightings): "The Council would like to remind you that you should not know anything about this. They only tell lies and they do not exist."

to:

--->'''Cecil''' -->'''Cecil''' (In reference to "angel" sightings): "The Council would like to remind you that you should not know anything about this. They only tell lies and they do not exist."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Due to student-teachers conflicts in the 1800s that led to the murder of a professor, the faculty of the University of Virginia are formally banned from punishing their students for academic misconduct. Instead, assigning guilt and punishment is entirely in the hands of a wholly student-run Honor Court (i.e. a full-blown criminal justice system, with juries, judges, and counsels for the prosecution and defense). For most of the history of the U-Va Honor Court, the only punishment available was permanent expulsion (or if the student has already graduated, the retroactive voiding of the degree awarded); serious business indeed.

to:

* Due to student-teachers conflicts in the 1800s that led to the murder of a professor, the faculty of the University of Virginia are formally banned from punishing their students for academic misconduct. Instead, assigning guilt and punishment is entirely in the hands of a wholly student-run Honor Court (i.e. a full-blown criminal justice system, with juries, judges, and counsels for the prosecution and defense). For most of the history of the U-Va Honor Court, the only punishment available was permanent expulsion (or if the student has already graduated, the retroactive voiding of the degree awarded); serious business indeed. Although, the students did vote in 2022 to considerably neuter the power of the court; as it turned out, a system that was mostly run by the scions of the Southern Aristocracy can get quite racist against black students.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'': At the dark magic school Myth/TheScholomance, the top four students are known as the 'elites' and decide which students are given which class rank. That rank in turn determines everything from the quality of food and equipment other students get to which missions they're assigned. As such, even though the elites are just students, they still control almost every aspect of the other students' lives and can make their lives at the Scholomance easier... or much, much harder. (And shorter).

to:

* ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'': At the dark magic school Myth/TheScholomance, the top four students are known as the 'elites' and and, as a group / council, decide which students are given which class rank. That rank in turn determines everything from the quality of food and equipment other students get to which missions they're assigned. As such, even though the elites are just students, they still control almost every aspect of the other students' lives and can make their lives at the Scholomance easier... or much, much harder. (And shorter).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ''Literature/TheWitchOfKnightcharm'': At the dark magic school Myth/TheScholomance, the top four students are known as the 'elites' and decide which students are given which class rank. That rank in turn determines everything from the quality of food and equipment other students get to which missions they're assigned. As such, even though the elites are just students, they still control almost every aspect of the other students' lives and can make their lives at the Scholomance easier... or much, much harder. (And shorter).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In "Links in a Chain of Honor" , the eighth grade student council President has the authority to buy truckloads of foam fingers for the school and is in charge of appointing the sixth grade student council officials rather than let them be chosen by election.

to:

** In "Links in a Chain of Honor" , the eighth grade student council President has the authority to buy truckloads of foam fingers for the school and is in charge of appointing the sixth grade student council officials rather than let them be chosen by election. The episode "A Forgetten Yesterday" also reveals that the student council can issue search warrants, while a student council president candidate in "Two Wheels, Full Throttle, No Breaks" indicates that he'd have the power to disband the safety patrol if he wins the election.

Added: 500

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ''WesternAnimation/{{Recess}}'': The Principal for a Day elections allow the winner to order all-day recess and big parties if he chooses, which the actual principal is helpless to stop.

to:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Recess}}'': ''WesternAnimation/{{Recess}}'':
**
The Principal for a Day elections allow the winner to order all-day recess and big parties if he chooses, which the actual principal is helpless to stop.stop.
** The King of the Playground seems like a mere ceremonial position for popular kids at times, but King Bob has the authority to have kids get swirlies or locked in a box, hold trials, and build structures. He also mentions his predecessors doing things like writing a code of laws and successfully lobbying to the city council for more recess.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In "Links in a Chain of Honor" , the eighth grade student council President has the authority to buy truckloads of foam fingers for the school and is in charge of appointing the sixth grade student council officials rather than let them be chosen by election.


Added DiffLines:

* ''WesternAnimation/{{Recess}}'': The Principal for a Day elections allow the winner to order all-day recess and big parties if he chooses, which the actual principal is helpless to stop.

Added: 575

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* Subverted and lampshaded in ''Literature/IAmAGeniusOfUnspeakableEvilAndIWantToBeYourClassPresident''.

to:

%%* Subverted and lampshaded in ''Literature/IAmAGeniusOfUnspeakableEvilAndIWantToBeYourClassPresident''.''Literature/IAmAGeniusOfUnspeakableEvilAndIWantToBeYourClassPresident''..
* {{Downplayed}} in ''Literature/ReignOfTheSevenSpellblades''. The student council and its president do have some power, but it's mostly soft power over the school culture and whatever respect they personally have as mages: Alvin Godfrey is liked by most for running the Campus Watch which works to keep the more malevolent upperclassmen from posing a threat to new students, while his right-hand Carlos Whitrow runs a club for students with [[SexMagic gender identity- and sex-linked magical traits]]. The council is vastly outweighed in authority by Headmistress Esmeralda.

Added: 431

Changed: 1865

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Asskicking Equals Authority has been renamed. Also fixed Example Indentation.


* {{Justified}} in ''Manga/ArmedGirlsMachiavellism'': the Supreme Five Swords (how the students' council is called at the Private Aiichi Symbiosis Academy) have a lot of power, including the right to carry ''swords'' on campus... Because the ''headmistress is under orders to allow it'', as the owner finds it convenient for reasons so far unknown. It's shown that while the normal teachers don't dare to interfere with their antics the Supreme Five Swords know who is actually in charge, as the one time the headmistress decides to punish their president and another one they just take the punishment. In a variation, it's stated early on they're actually supposed to be the ''Disciplinary Committee'', that after Aiichi became co-ed ended up taking up the students' council's duties alongside rule enforcement... Meaning that there may be an actual yet powerless students' council somewhere.
** Hokkai, Aiichi's twin school, has the Six King Swords to fulfill this trope... [[AsskickingEqualsAuthority By being the best fighters in the school]] (it's possible to enter the Six Kings or even become their leader by defeating the incumbent, as the current leader Nonomura and his predecessor both did). The school's owner is the same as Aiichi (and [[spoiler:Nonomura's sword teacher]]), explaining the very similar system.

to:

* {{Justified}} in ''Manga/ArmedGirlsMachiavellism'': the ''Manga/ArmedGirlsMachiavellism'':
** {{Justified}}. The
Supreme Five Swords (how the students' council is called at the Private Aiichi Symbiosis Academy) have a lot of power, including the right to carry ''swords'' on campus... Because the ''headmistress is under orders to allow it'', as the owner finds it convenient for reasons so far unknown. It's shown that while the normal teachers don't dare to interfere with their antics the Supreme Five Swords know who is actually in charge, as the one time the headmistress decides to punish their president and another one they just take the punishment. In a variation, it's stated early on they're actually supposed to be the ''Disciplinary Committee'', that after Aiichi became co-ed ended up taking up the students' council's duties alongside rule enforcement... Meaning that there may be an actual yet powerless students' council somewhere.
** Hokkai, Aiichi's twin school, has the Six King Swords to fulfill this trope... [[AsskickingEqualsAuthority [[AsskickingLeadsToLeadership By being the best fighters in the school]] (it's possible to enter the Six Kings or even become their leader by defeating the incumbent, as the current leader Nonomura and his predecessor both did). The school's owner is the same as Aiichi (and [[spoiler:Nonomura's sword teacher]]), explaining the very similar system.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ3X4PxU8nA this]] ''Creator/ProZD'' video, he compares and contrasts student councils in anime vs the real world. In the first, the student council representative is extorting President Biden for funding and has several students and their families put to death because the students were tardy. In the second, the council representative meekly tries asking the others if they want to do a fundraiser.

to:

* In [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KQ3X4PxU8nA this]] ''Creator/ProZD'' video, he compares and contrasts student councils in anime vs the real world. In the first, the student council representative is extorting President Biden for funding and has several students and their families put to death because [[FelonyMisdemeanor the students were tardy.tardy]]. In the second, the council representative meekly tries asking the others if they want to do a fundraiser.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Anthy is treated as a honorary member due her role as the Rose Bride and the Councilmembers being the candidates to get engaged to her. As an extension, Utena in the manga is treated as another honorary member due having won the engagement.

Top