Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / TheRiseAndFallOfTheThirdReich

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AmbitiousButLazy: Hitler has ''big'' dreams, but dreaming is all he does. When it comes to pursuing his dreams, he expects others to do the work for him, or get what he wants handed to him just because he exists.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have, as Shirer predicted, been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly impressed with it. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.

to:

This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have, as Shirer predicted, been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly impressed with it.it as a serious work of historiography. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* FreudianExcuse: [[DeconstructedTrope Deconstructed.]] Hitler's younger years were certainly full of problems, but they were self-inflicted ones. His father was violent and domineering, but Adolf kept provoking him by deliberately doing poorly in school and being a lazy layabout; his failure to get into the Vienna Arts Academy was due to laziness, and he dithered over attending the equally prestigious Architecture Academy until his chances disappeared; and his "gutter life" in Vienna was brought about solely by his stubborn refusal to seek regular employment out of (again) laziness and pride.
** Possibly played straight in that his mother's incessant pampering and indulgence played a prominent role in Adolf becoming a lazy narcissist in the first place.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IRejectYourReality: Hitler spends his entire life lost in the clouds, with it becoming more obvious to everyone around him as the war he started turns sour.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HypocrisyNod: Shirer spends some time in Chapter 2 critiquing Protestantism--and then admits to being a Protestant himself in a footnote.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: As the Third Reich crumbles, many Nazis try to make a break for it, [[Hypocrite while also ordering the executions of soldiers and civilians for trying to do the same.]]

to:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: As the Third Reich crumbles, many Nazis try to make a break for it, [[Hypocrite [[{{Hypocrite}} while also ordering the executions of soldiers and civilians for trying to do the same.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterDevelopment: [[DefiedTrope Defied.]] Hitler learns ''nothing'' from his experiences and clings to his insane beliefs to the end, with his last will and testament simply being a rehash of his typical rants.


Added DiffLines:

* DefiantToTheEnd: Hitler believes right up to the end that he can still win the war. It's not until 8 days before his suicide that he realizes he has lost, but he still refuses to surrender out of pride and insists on taking as many people down with him as he can.


Added DiffLines:

* ScrewThisImOuttaHere: As the Third Reich crumbles, many Nazis try to make a break for it, [[Hypocrite while also ordering the executions of soldiers and civilians for trying to do the same.]]
Tabs MOD

Removed: 214

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Kill Em All was renamed Everybody Dies Ending due to misuse. Dewicking


* KillEmAll: Hitler tries to do this to all "inferior races", a list that eventually includes the German people themselves for "failing" him. In the latter case, several of his top cronies refuse to do his bidding.

Added: 4

Changed: -2

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Hitler tended to do this to underlings. If you incurred the Fuhrer's disfavor, you were lucky to be fired (like Werner von Blomberg or Hjalmar Schacht) or ReassignedToAntarctica (Franz von Papen). Being imprisoned or even murdered, like Ernst Röhm (whose SA became an embarrassment to Hitler upon taking power) or Gregor Strasser (Hitler's biggest rival within the Nazi Party), was not uncommon.

to:

* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Hitler tended to do this to underlings. If you incurred the Fuhrer's disfavor, you were lucky to be fired (like Werner von Blomberg or Hjalmar Schacht) or ReassignedToAntarctica (Franz von Papen). Being imprisoned or even murdered, like Ernst Röhm (whose SA became an embarrassment to Hitler upon taking power) or Gregor Strasser (Hitler's biggest rival within the Nazi Party), was not uncommon.uncommon.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IntimateHealing: Shirer describes Sigmund Rascher's experiments who induced hypothermia in concentration camp prisoners, then put them into bed with one or two naked women. He came to the conclusion that hot baths are more effective.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HistoricalVillainUpgrade: Downplayed with Charles Lindbergh. While he ''did'' show pro-Nazi sympathies and was a stubborn isolationist, for which Shirer rightly condemns him, the book neglects to mention that, after the United States was dragged into the war anyway, Lindbergh ate his words without hesitation and contributed to the war effort--on the Pacific Front, as the federal government did not trust him to go all-out against the Nazis--by training American pilots and conducting dangerous aerial operations, for which he won distinction and the personal admiration of General [=MacArthur=]. He also visited the sites of the Nazi death camps after the war, and was reportedly [[EveryoneHasStandards horrified]] by what he saw.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
grammar


** Downplayed with Italian Foreign Minister Count Galeazzo Ciano whom, while not a great diplomat, is still ''a lot more'' down-to-earth than the Nazis, and even his own boss.

to:

** Downplayed with Italian Foreign Minister Count Galeazzo Ciano whom, who, while not a great diplomat, is still ''a lot more'' down-to-earth than the Nazis, and even his own boss.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have, as Shirer predicted, been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly ambivalent towards it. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.

to:

This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have, as Shirer predicted, been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly ambivalent towards impressed with it. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.

Added: 593

Changed: 184

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DirtyCoward: Even when it's clear that the war is lost, Hitler and his lackeys force the German people to keep fighting because they ''know'' they can't expect any undeserved mercy from the Allies.

to:

* DirtyCoward: DirtyCoward:
**
Even when it's clear that the war is lost, Hitler and his lackeys force the German people to keep fighting because they ''know'' they can't expect any undeserved mercy from the Allies.Allies.
** Shirer regards the German military, particularly the officer caste, as this following the 20 July Plot. He ruthlessly pours scorn upon them for throwing the conspirators under the bus while simultaneously groveling before Hitler, even though they ''knew'' that the war was lost and that Hitler's continued existence would lead to the destruction of Germany and foreign occupation for God knows how long.

Added: 620

Changed: 55

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* UnreliableNarrator: Shirer spends a lot of the book citing the memoirs or trial testimony of various Nazi officials while also noting that they weren't exactly reliable in their recollections. He's particularly critical of Franz von Papen, who tried distancing himself from the Nazis despite, and Hjalmar Schacht, who played a peripheral role in the German economy in the early days of the Third Reich until he was replaced by Walther Funk.

to:

* UnreliableNarrator: Shirer spends a lot of the book citing the memoirs or trial testimony of various Nazi officials while also noting that they weren't exactly reliable in their recollections. He's particularly critical of Franz von Papen, who tried distancing himself from the Nazis despite, despite arranging Hitler's appointment to the chancellorship; and Hjalmar Schacht, who played a peripheral role in the German economy in the early days of the Third Reich until he was replaced by Walther Funk.Funk.
* VillainBall: When Germany invades the Soviet Union, a number of its westernmost provinces throw their doors open for the invaders and welcome them as liberators because they're sick of Stalin's rule. A number of the more pragmatic Nazis suggest playing along with this notion in order to get more manpower and, hopefully, cause the Soviet government to implode; but the top Nazis in general, and Hitler in particular, are so fanatically anti-Soviet that they refuse to even pretend to do this and try to exterminate the Soviet people down to the last child, motivating them to stick with Stalin and fight to the death.

Added: 832

Removed: 832

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllGermansAreNazis: Discussed. Shirer makes the highly contentious argument that the German people consider, in his words, "blind obedience to temporal rulers the highest virtue of Germanic man and put a premium on servility." This was a variant on the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderweg Sonderweg]] theory prevalent at the time, attempting to explain Hitler's rise as the natural outcome of German history and culture. Needless to say, this interpretation was already ''highly'' contentious at the time the book came out and is almost universally discredited today. That said, Shirer ''does'' devote considerable space to [[LaResistance the German Resistance]] and notes that during his own time in Germany, he met a lot of ordinary Germans who privately disliked Hitler's regime, however they might have acted in public.



* AllGermansAreNazis: Discussed. Shirer makes the highly contentious argument that the German people consider, in his words, "blind obedience to temporal rulers the highest virtue of Germanic man and put a premium on servility." This was a variant on the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderweg Sonderweg]] theory prevalent at the time, attempting to explain Hitler's rise as the natural outcome of German history and culture. Needless to say, this interpretation was already ''highly'' contentious at the time the book came out and is almost universally discredited today. That said, Shirer ''does'' devote considerable space to [[LaResistance the German Resistance]] and notes that during his own time in Germany, he met a lot of ordinary Germans who privately disliked Hitler's regime, however they might have acted in public.

Added: 670

Changed: 88

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AscendedExtra: Hans Fritzsche is portrayed as this at the Nuremberg Trials. In fact, according to Shirer, he's such an extra that the judges can't think of anything to adequately convict him for and they, as a result, declare him "not guilty" and cut him loose.



* EndOfAnEra: Shirer believes that Hitler will be the last "great conqueror" and World War II the last "great war", as modern weaponry can reduce countries to ashes without any actual fighting.



* KillEmAll: Hitler tries to do this to all "inferior races", a list that eventually includes the German people themselves for "failing" him. In the latter case, several of his top cronies refuse to do his bidding.



* UnreliableNarrator: Shirer spends a lot of the book citing the memoirs or trial testimony of various Nazi officials while also noting that they weren't exactly reliable in their recollections. He's particularly critical of Franz von Papen, who tried distancing himself from the Nazis despite, and Hjalmar Schacht, who played a peripheral role in the Ge

to:

* UnreliableNarrator: Shirer spends a lot of the book citing the memoirs or trial testimony of various Nazi officials while also noting that they weren't exactly reliable in their recollections. He's particularly critical of Franz von Papen, who tried distancing himself from the Nazis despite, and Hjalmar Schacht, who played a peripheral role in the GeGerman economy in the early days of the Third Reich until he was replaced by Walther Funk.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly ambivalent towards it. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.

to:

This book is the result of years of extensive research, and yet despite this, Shirer himself bluntly states early on that he is a ''journalist'', not a historian, and thus everything he says must not be seen as absolute fact. He also warns that his personal biases may color his perception of the facts. A number of the book's claims have have, as Shirer predicted, been debunked over the years, and historians as a whole are not particularly ambivalent towards it. However, even they tend to find it a pleasant read, and many have argued that it is a good place to get general information on Nazi Germany for those who are interested.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
"Gay man sleeps in bed with other gay man" does not a Depraved Homosexual make.


* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Röhm, noting that Röhm abused his position to procure male lovers and that one of his underlings was arrested with a man in his bed.

to:

* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Röhm, noting that Röhm abused his position to procure male lovers and that one of his underlings was arrested with a man in his bed. lovers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Presumably the SA did not consist solely of gay men.


* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Röhm and the SA, noting that Röhm abused his position to procure male lovers and that one of his underlings was arrested with a man in his bed.

to:

* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Röhm and the SA, Röhm, noting that Röhm abused his position to procure male lovers and that one of his underlings was arrested with a man in his bed.

Added: 1177

Changed: 167

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%%* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Rohm and the SA, with some degree of TruthInTelevision. %% Zero Context Example

to:

%%* * DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Rohm Röhm and the SA, noting that Röhm abused his position to procure male lovers and that one of his underlings was arrested with some degree of TruthInTelevision. %% Zero Context Examplea man in his bed.



* LaResistance: The book devotes a fair amount of space to the German Resistance and the various coup and assassination plots against Hitler. Shirer shows mixed feelings about them: he doesn't deny Resistance leaders' sincerity or courage, but criticizes them (particularly Germany's military leadership) for not doing more to oppose Hitler earlier, when they stood a greater chance of success.



* UnreliableNarrator: Shirer spends a lot of the book citing the memoirs or trial testimony of various Nazi officials while also noting that they weren't exactly reliable in their recollections. He's particularly critical of Franz von Papen, who tried distancing himself from the Nazis despite, and Hjalmar Schacht, who played a peripheral role in the Ge



* YouHaveFailedMe: When it becomes clear that Germany is going to lose the war, Hitler feels that the German people are "no longer worthy of his greatness" and hopes that they will all die for not being able to conquer the world for him. He even [[KickTheDog issues a decree ordering the complete destruction of the nation's infrastructure]], though fortunately, Albert Speer sabotages it.

to:

* YouHaveFailedMe: When it becomes clear that Germany is going to lose the war, Hitler feels that the German people are "no longer worthy of his greatness" and hopes that they will all die for not being able to conquer the world for him. He even [[KickTheDog issues a decree ordering the complete destruction of the nation's infrastructure]], though fortunately, Albert Speer sabotages it.it.
* YouHaveOutlivedYourUsefulness: Hitler tended to do this to underlings. If you incurred the Fuhrer's disfavor, you were lucky to be fired (like Werner von Blomberg or Hjalmar Schacht) or ReassignedToAntarctica (Franz von Papen). Being imprisoned or even murdered, like Ernst Röhm (whose SA became an embarrassment to Hitler upon taking power) or Gregor Strasser (Hitler's biggest rival within the Nazi Party), was not uncommon.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Zero Context Example. Please provide context before uncommenting.


* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Rohm and the SA, with some degree of TruthInTelevision.

to:

* %%* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Rohm and the SA, with some degree of TruthInTelevision.TruthInTelevision. %% Zero Context Example
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DepravedHomosexual: How Shirer portrays Ernst Rohm and the SA, with some degree of TruthInTelevision.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BigBadWannabe: Franz von Papen, the conservative politician who convinces Paul von Hindenburg to [[DealWithADevil form a government]] with Hitler as Chancellor and himself as Vice Chancellor, thinking he'll be able to control the Nazis. Instead, von Papen is marginalized within Hitler's cabinet, narrowly escapes assassination during the Night of the Long Knives and spends the rest of the Third Reich [[ReassignedToAntarctica exiled to diplomatic posts]].

to:

* BigBadWannabe: Franz von Papen, the conservative politician who convinces Paul von Hindenburg to [[DealWithADevil [[DealWithTheDevil form a government]] with Hitler as Chancellor and himself as Vice Chancellor, thinking he'll be able to control the Nazis. Instead, von Papen is marginalized within Hitler's cabinet, narrowly escapes assassination during the Night of the Long Knives and spends the rest of the Third Reich [[ReassignedToAntarctica exiled to diplomatic posts]].

Added: 460

Changed: 22

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllGermansAreNazis: Discussed. Shirer makes the highly contentious argument that the German people consider in his words, "blind obedience to temporal rulers the highest virtue of Germanic man and put a premium on servility." This was a variant on the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderweg Sonderweg]] theory prevalent at the time, attempting to explain Hitler's rise as the natural outcome of German history and culture. Needless to say, this interpretation was already ''highly'' contentious at the time the book came out and is almost universally discredited today. That said, Shirer does devote considerable space to the German Resistance and notes that during his own time in Germany, he met a lot of ordinary Germans who privately disliked Hitler's regime, however they might have acted in public.

to:

* AllGermansAreNazis: Discussed. Shirer makes the highly contentious argument that the German people consider consider, in his words, "blind obedience to temporal rulers the highest virtue of Germanic man and put a premium on servility." This was a variant on the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderweg Sonderweg]] theory prevalent at the time, attempting to explain Hitler's rise as the natural outcome of German history and culture. Needless to say, this interpretation was already ''highly'' contentious at the time the book came out and is almost universally discredited today. That said, Shirer does ''does'' devote considerable space to [[LaResistance the German Resistance Resistance]] and notes that during his own time in Germany, he met a lot of ordinary Germans who privately disliked Hitler's regime, however they might have acted in public.


Added DiffLines:

* BigBadWannabe: Franz von Papen, the conservative politician who convinces Paul von Hindenburg to [[DealWithADevil form a government]] with Hitler as Chancellor and himself as Vice Chancellor, thinking he'll be able to control the Nazis. Instead, von Papen is marginalized within Hitler's cabinet, narrowly escapes assassination during the Night of the Long Knives and spends the rest of the Third Reich [[ReassignedToAntarctica exiled to diplomatic posts]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AllGermansAreNazis: Discussed. Shirer makes the highly contentious argument that the German people consider in his words, "blind obedience to temporal rulers the highest virtue of Germanic man and put a premium on servility." This was a variant on the [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonderweg Sonderweg]] theory prevalent at the time, attempting to explain Hitler's rise as the natural outcome of German history and culture. Needless to say, this interpretation was already ''highly'' contentious at the time the book came out and is almost universally discredited today. That said, Shirer does devote considerable space to the German Resistance and notes that during his own time in Germany, he met a lot of ordinary Germans who privately disliked Hitler's regime, however they might have acted in public.

Top