Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / MenAtArms

Go To

OR



* BelatedBackstory: This is the book where we first learn that Vimes is the descendant of the man who killed the last king of Ankh-Morpork.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ShoutOutToShakespeare: The scene with [[NoIndoorVoice SILAS! MARNER!]] the town crier being recruited for Carrot's militia is ''quite'' similar to a gag in ''Theatre/HenryIVPart2'' where a former herald with NoIndoorVoice is being drafted into the king's army.

to:

* ShoutOutToShakespeare: The scene with [[NoIndoorVoice SILAS! MARNER!]] CUMBERBATCH!]] the town crier being recruited for Carrot's militia is ''quite'' similar to a gag in ''Theatre/HenryIVPart2'' where a former herald with NoIndoorVoice is being drafted into the king's army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImplausibleDeniability: When the situation in the city is getting beyond bad, one passer-by tries claiming the Patrician's palace has been set ablaze. Carrot then looks at the palace, which is in full view and very resolutely ''not'' on fire in any way. Shortly thereafter, Throat Dibbler claims the Bronze Bridge has been burnt down. This would be the very bridge he's just come running over.

to:

* ImplausibleDeniability: When the situation in the city is getting beyond bad, one passer-by tries claiming the Patrician's palace has been set ablaze. Carrot then looks at the palace, which is in full view and very resolutely ''not'' on fire in any way. Shortly thereafter, Throat Dibbler claims the Bronze Brass Bridge has been burnt down. This would be the very bridge he's just come running over.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AutomaticCrossbows: Frequently averted. On several occasions, the plot revolves around the fact that the crossbow has either just fired or will leave the wielder unarmed for a time if it is fired. What makes the gonne dangerous is that it lacks that disadvantage on top of being longer range and almost always lethal.

to:

* AutomaticCrossbows: Frequently averted. On several occasions, the plot revolves around the fact that the crossbow has either just fired been shot or will leave the wielder unarmed for a time if it is fired.shot. What makes the gonne dangerous is that it lacks that disadvantage on top of being longer range and almost always lethal.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** The dogs are shown to be able to discuss with each other on relatively complex subjects (though this could be interpreted as TranslationConvention) and have a lot of human-like behaviours, such as raptly listening to [[ANaziByAnyOtherName their leader giving speeches on the superiority of the Canine Race]]. In ''Literature/MovingPictures'' it was a plot point that normal, non-magically enhanced dogs were mostly concerned with eating, sleeping, and mating, while ''Literature/WitchesAbroad'' showed that the results of forcing human thoughts on a wolf was [[DrivenToMadness not pretty]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Not So Different has been renamed, and it needs to be dewicked/moved


* FromTheLatinIntroDucere: Carrot points out that, as a policeman -- from ''polis'', city -- he is a man of the city. Later, [[NotSoDifferent Vetinari points out "politician" comes from the same root]].

to:

* FromTheLatinIntroDucere: Carrot points out that, as a policeman -- from ''polis'', city -- he is a man of the city. Later, [[NotSoDifferent [[NotSoDifferentRemark Vetinari points out "politician" comes from the same root]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Detritus recruits two trolls named Flint and Moraine to the Watch. Could be the same two from ''Moving Pictures'', though "Flint" changed his name a couple of times in that book.

to:

** Detritus recruits two trolls named Flint and Moraine to the Watch. Could be the same two from ''Moving Pictures'', ''Literature/MovingPictures'', though "Flint" changed his name a couple of times in that book.



* CharacterDevelopment: Compare Vimes and Carrot here to how they appear in ''Guards! Guards!'' Right from his first moments in the book, Carrot has significantly more depth than he did in his first appearance.

to:

* CharacterDevelopment: Compare Vimes and Carrot here to how they appear in ''Guards! Guards!'' Right ''Literature/GuardsGuards'' -- right from his first moments in the book, Carrot has significantly more depth than he did in his first appearance.



* DoesntLikeGuns: Assuming this applies to the Assassins is why they got the Gonne to guard. It actually ''does'' apply to most Assassins, as their reaction to similar weapons in later books demonstrates, but unfortunately Edward D'Eath is rather unhinged and doesn't hate the gonne too much to steal it. [[spoiler: Dr. Cruces also can't resist it when Edward tries to dump it.]]

to:

* DoesntLikeGuns: Assuming this applies to the Assassins is why they got the Gonne to guard. It actually ''does'' apply to most Assassins, as their reaction to similar weapons in later books demonstrates, but unfortunately Edward D'Eath is rather unhinged and doesn't hate the gonne too much to steal it. [[spoiler: Dr.[[spoiler:Dr. Cruces also can't resist it when Edward tries to dump it.]]



* DumbMuscle: Detritus had previously appeared in ''Guards! Guards!'' and ''Moving Pictures'', but it's here that we start to get particularly acquainted with him and his... difficulties. Poor thing can't even read, and knocks himself out trying to salute. [[spoiler:Subverted in that when locked in a freezer, his silicon-based brain becomes a superconductor and he reaches near-godlike levels of intelligence.]]

to:

* DumbMuscle: Detritus had previously appeared in ''Guards! Guards!'' ''Literature/GuardsGuards'' and ''Moving Pictures'', ''Literature/MovingPictures'', but it's here that we start to get particularly acquainted with him and his... difficulties. Poor thing can't even read, and knocks himself out trying to salute. [[spoiler:Subverted in that when locked in a freezer, his silicon-based brain becomes a superconductor and he reaches near-godlike levels of intelligence.]]



* KeepTheReward: The reward scene seems to be repeating the scene in ''Guards! Guards!'', until it turns out Carrot is just warming up. The new dartboard is just the first and cheapest of Carrot's long list of requests, but [[KingIncognito he knows that Vetinari will grant them]].

to:

* KeepTheReward: The reward scene seems to be repeating the scene in ''Guards! Guards!'', ''Literature/GuardsGuards'', until it turns out Carrot is just warming up. The new dartboard is just the first and cheapest of Carrot's long list of requests, but [[KingIncognito he knows that Vetinari will grant them]].



** When Detritus recovers from his HeroicBSOD, he gets up and proceeds to the Assassin's Guild with bloody murder in mind. It is then we learn that some of the best trained killers in Anhk-Morpork have absolutely no way of dealing with a Troll... and ''they'' learn it too. Specifically, they have no way to fight a troll head-on. An assassin in ''Literature/SoulMusic'' was confident he could kill a troll by surprise if he hit the right spot in the back of its neck. (In a display of possible continuity, ''Soul Music'' happens after the events of ''Men at Arms'', when the assassins probably figured out the back-of-the-neck thing because the Detritus made them realise how helpless they were against Trolls.)

to:

** When Detritus recovers from his HeroicBSOD, he gets up and proceeds to the Assassin's Guild with bloody murder in mind. It is then we learn that some of the best trained killers in Anhk-Morpork have absolutely no way of dealing with a Troll... and ''they'' learn it too. Specifically, they have no way to fight a troll head-on. An assassin in ''Literature/SoulMusic'' was confident he could kill a troll by surprise if he hit the right spot in the back of its neck. (In a display of possible continuity, ''Soul Music'' happens after the events of ''Men at Arms'', ''Literature/MenAtArms'', when the assassins probably figured out the back-of-the-neck thing because the Detritus made them realise how helpless they were against Trolls.)

Added: 1114

Changed: 267

Removed: 591

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FirearmsAreRevolutionary: It's revealed that the Disc's greatest inventor came up with a revolver rifle, which briefly terrorizes Ankh-Morpork when it's stolen by an unhinged assassin. Something about the "gonne"'s singular nature and sheer killing power turned it into an EvilWeapon capable of possessing its wielders, and it actively enforces FantasyGunControl by killing an artisan that was trying to duplicate it. When the thing is finally defeated, it's buried forever with a fallen guardsman so that he can have a peerless weapon in the afterlife.



** After Colon and Nobby (while playing cards) have discussed the Arthurian pull-a-sword-from-a-stone legend and considered it insufficient to become king -
---> '''Colon''': A man who could shove a sword ''into'' a stone, though, ''he's'' a king.
---> '''Nobby''': A man like that'd be an [[TheAce ace]].
** Also from the conversation above, a hint at what reward a certain KingIncognito will arrange for Vimes, through negotiations with Vetinari:
---> '''Nobby''': That's what a king does if you're useful. [[spoiler: He makes you a knight.]]
** Minor example from early in the book. Angua is incredulous at Carrot's claim to likes long walks. Later on we find that it probably wasn't because she's a w[[spoiler: -oman]] but a w[[spoiler: -erewolf]].

to:

** After Colon and Nobby (while playing cards) have discussed the Arthurian pull-a-sword-from-a-stone legend and considered it insufficient to become king -
---> '''Colon''':
A man who could shove a sword ''into'' a stone, though, ''he's'' a king.
---> '''Nobby''': A man like that'd be an [[TheAce ace]].
** Also from the conversation above, a hint at what reward a certain KingIncognito will arrange for Vimes, through negotiations with Vetinari:
---> '''Nobby''': That's what a king does if you're useful. [[spoiler: He makes you a knight.]]
** Minor
minor example from early in the book. Angua is incredulous at Carrot's claim to likes long walks. Later on we find that it probably wasn't because she's a w[[spoiler: -oman]] but a w[[spoiler: -erewolf]].


Added DiffLines:

%%** After Colon and Nobby (while playing cards) have discussed the Arthurian pull-a-sword-from-a-stone legend and considered it insufficient to become king:%%Quotes are not context.
%%--->'''Colon''': A man who could shove a sword ''into'' a stone, though, ''he's'' a king.\\
'''Nobby''': A man like that'd be an [[TheAce ace]].
%%** A hint at what reward a certain KingIncognito will arrange for Vimes, through negotiations with Vetinari.%%Quotes are not context.
%%---> '''Nobby''': That's what a king does if you're useful. [[spoiler: He makes you a knight.]]

Added: 342

Removed: 339

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None



* AccidentalMurder: Edward d'Eath needs to get Beano out of the way for a while [[spoiler:in order to steal his identity]] so he gives him a TapOnTheHead. Only instead of putting Beano out like a light for twenty minutes, d'Eath accidentally ''kills'' him. (Beano even hears a ''crunch'' just before he dies, implying d'Eath broke his skull.)



* RealityEnsues: Edward d'Eath needs to get Beano out of the way for a while [[spoiler:in order to steal his identity]] so he gives him a TapOnTheHead. Only instead of putting Beano out like a light for twenty minutes, d'Eath accidentally ''kills'' him. (Beano even hears a ''crunch'' just before he dies, implying d'Eath broke his skull.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RunningGag: Whenever someone addresses Lance-constable Detritus -- ''don't salute!''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* FantasyGunControl: Analysed. Vimes muses that gonnes would change the world because, instead of simply storing the power of your own muscles like crossbows, they 'give you power from outside' - the comparison to magic is obvious, and just as wizards try to restrict the availability of magic, assassins hate the gonne as it would make killing ''so easy''. So there are forces actively keeping gonnes from becoming available.

to:

* FantasyGunControl: Analysed. Vimes muses that gonnes would change the world because, instead of simply storing the power of your own muscles like crossbows, they 'give you power from outside' - the comparison to magic is obvious, and just as wizards try to restrict the availability of magic, assassins hate the gonne as it would make killing ''so easy''. So there are forces actively keeping gonnes from becoming available. [[spoiler: One of which is the Gonne itself, which wants to be THE Gonne. It murders the dwarf who fixed it so he couldn't make more of them.]]

Added: 230

Removed: 228

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HaHaYouSaidX: The Bursar is highly amused by Ridcully "Cleaning the organ," and furthermore, by his comment that it's a "Mighty organ." Ridcully's talking about the Great Hall's ''pipe'' organ, and orders the Bursar sent away.


Added DiffLines:

* HehHehYouSaidX: The Bursar is highly amused by Ridcully "Cleaning the organ," and furthermore, by his comment that it's a "Mighty organ." Ridcully's talking about the Great Hall's ''pipe'' organ, and orders the Bursar sent away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* HaHaYouSaidX: The Bursar is highly amused by Ridcully "Cleaning the organ," and furthermore, by his comment that it's a "Mighty organ." Ridcully's talking about the Great Hall's ''pipe'' organ, and orders the Bursar sent away.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SubParSupremacist: The main subplot involves a flatulence-prone dog named Big Fido advocating that dogs should rise up against their human masters, and makes long speeches about the nobility and savagery of wolves despite never having met one and being a tiny poodle himself. [[UsefulNotes/AdolfHitler No prizes for guessing which short, grandiloquent politician Big Fido was based on.]]

Added: 269

Changed: 153

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HoldYourHippogriffs: "Is the High Priest an Offlian? Does a dragon explode in the woods?" is the Discworld version of "Is the Pope a Catholic? Does a bear shit in the woods?"

to:

* HoldYourHippogriffs: HoldYourHippogriffs:
**
"Is the High Priest an Offlian? Does a dragon explode in the woods?" is the Discworld version of "Is the Pope a Catholic? Does a bear shit in the woods?"woods?"
** Colon worries that, as ranking officer once Vimes retires, he's "well and truly up the Ankh without a paddle".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Colon tells the new recruits "[[Series/HillStreetBlues Let's be careful out there]]".
** An Assassin tells Vimes "Your uniform doesn't scare me". Vimes agrees that it's not a scary uniform, and calls over Carrot and Detritus. "Now these, I think you'll agree, are scary uniforms." There's a similar exchange in ''Film/PoliceAcademy III'' between Mahoney and a cabbie, where he calls over Hightower for the same effect.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Also weirdly inverted by Carrot. This book seems to suggest he may in fact be the Discworld's counterpart of Adolf Hitler, being extremely charismatic and able to command the loyalty of the common people, despite (at the time) only holding the rank of corporal. Thankfully, he's firmly a GoodCounterpart, being painfully aware of the damage his abilities could cause if he were to misuse them and fully internalizing Vimes' beliefs about the importance of free will.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
wrong henry


* ShoutOutToShakespeare: The scene with [[NoIndoorVoice SILAS! MARNER!]] the town crier being recruited for Carrot's militia is ''quite'' similar to a gag in ''Theatre/HenryVIPart2'' where a former herald with NoIndoorVoice is being drafted into the king's army.

to:

* ShoutOutToShakespeare: The scene with [[NoIndoorVoice SILAS! MARNER!]] the town crier being recruited for Carrot's militia is ''quite'' similar to a gag in ''Theatre/HenryVIPart2'' ''Theatre/HenryIVPart2'' where a former herald with NoIndoorVoice is being drafted into the king's army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ShoutOutToShakespeare: The scene with [[NoIndoorVoice SILAS! MARNER!]] the town crier being recruited for Carrot's militia is ''quite'' similar to a gag in ''Theatre/HenryVIPart2'' where a former herald with NoIndoorVoice is being drafted into the king's army.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* IronicName: Big Fido. While Fido is, of course, a [[StockAnimalName stock dog name]], it actually means "faithful" or "loyal", something Big Fido most definitely is ''not''. [[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fido_(dog) The original Fido]] was famed for always waiting for his owner to return home from work in the evening, and [[UndyingLoyalty continuing to do so for fourteen years after said owner's death]]. Big Fido ''savaged'' his owner, and is training his "Dog Guild" to hate all humans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* KilledOffscreen: The scene with Bjorn Hammerhock turns out to be the last time we see [[spoiler:Edward d'Eath]] alive. By the time the narrative returns to the Gonne, [[spoiler:Dr. Cruces has killed him and taken over as the BigBad]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Lord Rust here is shown as one of the more cynical and intelligent of Ankh-Morpork's nobles. In ''Literature/{{Jingo}}'' by contrast he's presented as TooDumbToLive, while in ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment'' he's about halfway between the two.

to:

** Lord Rust here is shown as one of the more cynical and intelligent of Ankh-Morpork's nobles. In ''Literature/{{Jingo}}'' by contrast he's presented as TooDumbToLive, while in ''Literature/MonstrousRegiment'' he's about halfway between the two. By the time of ''Literature/{{Snuff}}'', Rust is elderly, wheelchair-bound, facing reality square on and accepting Vimes has a perfect right to arrest his son for serious crime: it could be said he gets a degree of humility in his final years.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AshesToCreashes: Beano's mortal remains are cremated and then poured down another clown's trousers.

to:

* AshesToCreashes: AshesToCrashes: Beano's mortal remains are cremated and then poured down another clown's trousers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* AshesToCreashes: Beano's mortal remains are cremated and then poured down another clown's trousers.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RealityEnsues: Edward d'Eath needs to get Beano out of the way for a while [[spoiler:in order to steal his identity]] so he gives him a TapOnTheHead. Only instead of putting Beano out like a light for twenty minutes, d'Eath accidentally ''kills'' him.

to:

* RealityEnsues: Edward d'Eath needs to get Beano out of the way for a while [[spoiler:in order to steal his identity]] so he gives him a TapOnTheHead. Only instead of putting Beano out like a light for twenty minutes, d'Eath accidentally ''kills'' him. (Beano even hears a ''crunch'' just before he dies, implying d'Eath broke his skull.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RealityEnsues: Edward d'Eath needs to get Beano out of the way for a while [[spoiler:in order to steal his identity]] so he gives him a TapOnTheHead. Only instead of putting Beano out like a light for twenty minutes, d'Eath accidentally ''kills'' him.

Added: 46

Changed: 330

Removed: 262

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Metaphorgotten}}: Parodied with Captain Quirke, whose nickname is 'Mayonnaise'.
--> '''Angua:''' Don't tell me. He's rich, thick and oily, right?
--> '''Colon:''' And smells faintly of eggs.

to:

* {{Metaphorgotten}}: Parodied with Captain Quirke, whose nickname is 'Mayonnaise'.
--> '''Angua:'''
"Mayonnaise".
-->'''Angua:'''
Don't tell me. He's rich, thick and oily, right?
-->
right?\\
'''Colon:''' And smells faintly of eggs.



--> Didn't you used to be the town crier?
--> THAT'S RIGHT!

to:

--> Didn't -->Didn't you used to be the town crier?
-->
crier?\\
THAT'S RIGHT!



--> You killed Bjorn Hammerhock! The boy said you fired yourself! [[TheFarmerAndTheViper And he'd repaired you!]]
--> ''You expect gratitude? [[UniquenessDecay He would have made another gonne.]]''

to:

--> You -->You killed Bjorn Hammerhock! The boy said you fired yourself! [[TheFarmerAndTheViper And he'd repaired you!]]
-->
you!]]\\
''You expect gratitude? [[UniquenessDecay He would have made another gonne.]]''



-->'''Angua''': Annabel Curry couldn't have been much good, for only two dollars.
-->'''Carrot''': I shouldn't think so. [[WhamLine She's only nine years old.]]

to:

-->'''Angua''': Annabel Curry couldn't have been much good, for only two dollars.
-->'''Carrot''':
dollars.\\
'''Carrot''':
I shouldn't think so. [[WhamLine She's only nine years old.]]



-->'There's no need,' said Vetinari, trying to [[MajorInjuryUnderreaction smile]] and [[ICanStillFight stand up]]. 'It's just a flesh-'
-->The leg collapsed under him.

to:

-->'There's -->"There's no need,' need," said Vetinari, trying to [[MajorInjuryUnderreaction smile]] smile and [[ICanStillFight stand up]]. 'It's up. "It's just a flesh-'
-->The
flesh-"\\
The
leg collapsed under him.



* OurWerewolvesAreDifferent: [[spoiler:Angua]]



* PunBasedTitle: "Men-at-arms" is a real phrase for soldiers or guards, but "arms" can also refer to weapons. So we have "men at arms" who are also men (though Angua would object) "at" (against) "arms" (the Gonne.)
** The "Men" part itself refers to a major plot thread in the book; the hiring of non-men (a dwarf, a troll and a w[[spoiler:erewolf]] in particular) into the Watch, aka the "men at arms". Making this an even more convoluted pun.

to:

* PunBasedTitle: "Men-at-arms" is a real phrase for soldiers or guards, but "arms" can also refer to weapons. So we have "men at arms" who are also men (though Angua would object) "at" (against) "arms" (the Gonne.)
**
Gonne). The "Men" part itself refers to a major plot thread in the book; the hiring of non-men (a dwarf, a troll and a w[[spoiler:erewolf]] in particular) into the Watch, aka the "men at arms". Making this an even more convoluted pun.



--->'''Vimes''': That's not how you spell "gone".
--->'''Carrot''': Yes it is, sir.
--->'''Vimes''': I mean, it's not how "gone" is ''normally'' spelled.

to:

--->'''Vimes''': That's not how you spell "gone".
--->'''Carrot''':
"gone".\\
'''Carrot''':
Yes it is, sir.
--->'''Vimes''':
sir.\\
'''Vimes''':
I mean, it's not how "gone" is ''normally'' spelled.



* {{Werewolf}}: [[spoiler:Angua]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeathGlare: Mr Cheese the bartender insists that a drunken Vimes has to pay his bar bill. Angua and Carrot merely *look* at Cheese and he immediately changes his mind.

to:

* DeathGlare: Mr Cheese the bartender insists that a drunken Vimes has to pay his bar bill. Angua and Carrot merely *look* ''look'' at Cheese and he immediately changes his mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathGlare: Mr Cheese the bartender insists that a drunken Vimes has to pay his bar bill. Angua and Carrot merely *look* at Cheese and he immediately changes his mind.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CompellingVoice: Because everyone knows dogs can't speak human, almost nobody can understand Gaspode, but they still ''hear'' him subconsciously when he talks to them, letting him make suggestions to them from the harmless (getting them to give him a treat) to the irritating (convincing Captain Quirk he has an itchy bum). [[spoiler:The reverse is also true, since his ability to speak in human to dogs makes them react to declarations like "SIT!" and "BAD DOG!" [[BehavioralConditioning the way that humans have conditioned them to]].]]

Top