Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Literature / HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* WhamLine: Tom Riddle's [[TheReveal reveal]]. He uses Harry's wand to write his full name ("Tom Marvolo Riddle"), then [[SignificantAnagram rearranges the letters]] to spell...

to:

* WhamLine: Tom Riddle's [[TheReveal reveal]]. He uses Harry's wand to write Turns out his full name ("Tom Marvolo Riddle"), then [[SignificantAnagram rearranges the letters]] can be rearranged]] to spell...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In retrospect, Ron trying to comfort Ginny after the attack on Mrs. Norris by telling her that "they'll catch the nutter who did it and have him out of here in no time." Assuming Ginny had begun to suspect herself at that point, this might also count as ObliviousGuiltSlinging. After all, at the end of the book, she ''was'' [[FridgeBrilliance convinced that she was going to be expelled]]. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Way to go, Ron.]]

to:

** In retrospect, Ron trying to comfort Ginny after the attack on Mrs. Norris by telling her that "they'll catch the nutter who did it and have him out of here in no time." Assuming [[spoiler: Ginny had begun to suspect herself at that point, this might also count as ObliviousGuiltSlinging. After all, at the end of the book, she ''was'' [[FridgeBrilliance convinced that she was going to be expelled]]. [[NiceJobBreakingItHero Way to go, Ron.]]]]]]

Changed: 28

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Now discontinued


** Invoked with [[WordOfGod Ginny's]] valentine to Harry. Fred and George continually tease him with it and Peeves [[StupidStatementDanceMix adds a dance routine]].

to:

** Invoked with [[WordOfGod Ginny's]] valentine to Harry. Fred and George continually tease him with it and Peeves [[StupidStatementDanceMix adds a dance routine]].routine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removal of What An Idiot potholes per Wick Cleaning Projects


* BreakTheHaughty: [[spoiler:Lucius avoids prison time but suffers several blows to his ego. A twelve-year-old both stops his plan and tricks him into freeing Dobby, who takes the first opportunity to pay Lucius back for years of abuse by ''effortlessly'' blasting him down a flight of stairs.]] And Lucius also loses his position on Hogwarts' board of governors, which he could have avoided had he not [[invoked]][[WhatAnIdiot threatened the other governors' families]].

to:

* BreakTheHaughty: [[spoiler:Lucius avoids prison time but suffers several blows to his ego. A twelve-year-old both stops his plan and tricks him into freeing Dobby, who takes the first opportunity to pay Lucius back for years of abuse by ''effortlessly'' blasting him down a flight of stairs.]] And Lucius also loses his position on Hogwarts' board of governors, which he could have avoided had he not [[invoked]][[WhatAnIdiot not threatened the other governors' families]].families.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Ron and Percy get into an argument and Percy uses his prefect authority to deduct five points from Gryffindor. This kind of thing never happens again and it's later established that prefects ''can't'' give or take house points.

to:

** Ron and Percy get into an argument and Percy uses his prefect authority to deduct five points from Gryffindor. This kind of thing never happens again and it's later established established, or at east insinuated, in ''Order of the Phoenix'' that prefects ''can't'' give or take house points.points. (WordOfGod ''does'' say that prefects have the authority to do so, but it still never happens again in the text itself.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TwistedEchoCut: When Harry, Ron and Hermione decide to make Polyjuice Potion, they need a signed note from a teacher to obtain the book they need from the library. At the end of the chapter, Ron says that no teacher will be thick enough to give them one; and at the beginning of the next chapter, the inept Professor Lockhart is mentioned, who is indeed the teacher they ask for this.
--> '''Ron:''' Oh come on, no teacher is going to fall for that, they'd have to be really thick...
--> (In the next chapter) Since the disastrous episode of the Cornish Pixies, Professor Lockhart had not brought any live creatures to the class.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ChoresWithoutPowers: When Harry and Ron get detention for crashing the Weasley family's car into the Whomping Willow, Harry has to help Lockhart answer his fan mail, while Ron has to polish the silver in the Hogwarts trophy room using elbow grease. Harry comments that he'd gladly switch, as he's had lots of practice cleaning while living with the Dursleys.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The true identity of the monster lurking in the Chamber of Secrets is supposed to be a mystery until the latter part of the book -- which did not stop multiple editions from spoiling it by heavily featuring snakes and snake imagery on their covers. The cover featured on this very page has the FinalBattle between Harry and Basilisk in plain view, thereby leaving nothing at all to the imagination.

to:

* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The true identity of the monster lurking in the Chamber of Secrets is supposed to be a mystery until the latter part last third of the book -- which did not stop multiple editions from spoiling it by heavily featuring snakes and snake imagery on their covers. The cover featured on this very page has the FinalBattle between Harry and Basilisk in plain view, thereby leaving nothing at all to the imagination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Ron and Percy get into an argument and Percy uses his prefect authority to deduct five points from Gryffindor. This kind of thing never happens again and it's later established that prefects ''can't'' give or take house points.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: The kids are shown going to classes on Valentine's Day but in reality, Valentine's Day 1993 was a Sunday.

Added: 181

Changed: 5

Removed: 179

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
page split


* IdiotBall: Hermione mistaking a cat hair for human hair leading to her unfortunate Polyjuice Potion accident which is something she shouldn't have failed to do with how smart she is which is what progresses the plot.

to:

* IdiotBall: Hermione mistaking a cat hair for human hair leading to her unfortunate Polyjuice Potion accident accident, which is something she shouldn't have failed to do with how smart she is is, which is what progresses the plot.



* IllTimedSneeze: Inverted. When Harry and Ron sneak out of bed, Ron stubs his toe near Professor Snape. Snape happens to sneeze just as Ron swears in pain, so they avoid detection.



* SmallNameBigEgo: Gilderoy Lockhart.
* SneezeOfDoom: Inverted. When Harry and Ron sneak out of bed, Ron stubs his toe near Professor Snape. Snape happens to sneeze just as Ron swears in pain, so they avoid detection.

to:

* %%* SmallNameBigEgo: Gilderoy Lockhart.
* SneezeOfDoom: Inverted. When Harry and Ron sneak out of bed, Ron stubs his toe near Professor Snape. Snape happens to sneeze just as Ron swears in pain, so they avoid detection.
Lockhart.



** [[spoiler: Tom Riddle, fifty years prior to the events of the story. He used the Basilisk to murder a student, then framed Hagrid, took credit for catching him, and received a Special Award for Services to the School.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: Tom [[spoiler:Tom Riddle, fifty years prior to the events of the story. He used the Basilisk to murder a student, then framed Hagrid, took credit for catching him, and received a Special Award for Services to the School.]]

Changed: 1000

Removed: 270

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeadlyGaze: The Basilisk has one but doesn't kill anybody with it, either because they didn't technically look it in the eye or because it was blinded.

to:

* DeadlyGaze: The Basilisk has one but can kill people who see its eyes. However, it doesn't kill anybody with it, it over the course of the novel, either because they didn't technically look it in the eye or because it was blinded.



** Harry and Ron when they steal Mr. Weasley's FlyingCar. [[JustifiedTrope Granted]], they're twelve years old at the time. {{Lampshade|Hanging}}d by [=McGonagall=] when she points out other, more reasonable, things they could have done to get to Hogwarts, and Harry reluctantly admits to himself that stealing a car was pretty stupid.
** Also, over the month they spent brewing the Polyjuice Potion to sneak into the Slytherin dorms, not one of the trio realized they have no idea where those dorms ''are''.

to:

** Harry and Ron when they steal Mr. Weasley's FlyingCar. [[JustifiedTrope Granted]], they're twelve years old FlyingCar to get to Hogwarts after they find themselves barred from Platform 9 3/4. This results in Mr. Weasley facing an inquiry at work because some Muggles spotted his car, while the time.car itself crashes into a tree on the school's grounds and drives off into the Forbidden Forest. {{Lampshade|Hanging}}d by [=McGonagall=] when she points out other, more reasonable, things they could have done to get to Hogwarts, and Harry reluctantly admits to himself that stealing a car was pretty stupid.
** Also, over Despite the trio spending a month they spent brewing the Polyjuice Potion to sneak into the Slytherin dorms, not one none of the trio realized they have no idea them attempt to figure out where those dorms ''are''.''are'' until they've already taken the potion and have to find the dorms before it wears off.



** This book implies (through Lockhart stealing real people's accomplishments and not just making them up) that there is a charm that can cure lycanthropy. This is definitely not the case in latter books.

to:

** This book implies (through Lockhart stealing real people's accomplishments and not just making them up) that there is a charm that can cure lycanthropy. This Later books state that lycanthropy is definitely not incurable; at best, it can only be managed so the case in latter books.werewolf isn't a danger to others.



* MissedTheBus:
** [[spoiler:Dobby]] blocks Harry's access to Platform 9¾, causing him and Ron to miss the Hogwarts Express and take alternative transport. HilarityEnsues.
** Lampshaded when [=McGonagall=] asks why Harry didn't just [[BoringButPractical send a message to ask for help]].

to:

* MissedTheBus:
**
MissedTheBus: [[spoiler:Dobby]] blocks Harry's access to Platform 9¾, causing him and Ron to miss the Hogwarts Express and take alternative transport. HilarityEnsues.
** Lampshaded when
Once the two get to school (causing trouble for themselves and others along the way), [=McGonagall=] asks why Harry didn't just [[BoringButPractical send a message to ask for help]].



** Ron again on the first day of term when he receives a Howler from Mrs Weasley.

to:

** Ron again panics on the first day of term when he receives a Howler from Mrs Weasley.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BizarreBelching: Ron finds himself exhibiting this after his wand backfires on him during a confrontation with Malfoy; until the curse wears off, Ron is left repeatedly burping loudly and puking up slugs.

to:

* BizarreBelching: Ron finds himself exhibiting this after After his wand backfires on him during a confrontation with Malfoy; until the curse wears off, Malfoy, Ron is left repeatedly burping loudly and puking up slugs.slugs until the curse wears off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking

Added DiffLines:

* AngerBornOfWorry: Mrs. Weasley's reaction to her children and Harry arriving at the Burrow is "Beds empty! No note! Car gone--could have crashed--out of my mind with worry--did you care?" (She then makes a point of telling Harry that it's not ''his'' fault.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SecretPetPlot: During Hagrid's time at Hogwarts, he had a secret pet acromantula (giant spider creature), Aragog. Unforutnately, this happened to be the same time the Chamber of Secrets first opened; with the Beast of Slytherin's attacks threatening the future of Hogwarts, Tom Riddle turned Hagrid and Aragog in. Aragog was forced to flee into the Forbidden Forest and Hagrid was expelled.

Added: 266

Changed: 531

Removed: 201

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AlliterativeTitle:[[invoked]] Most of Lockhart's books have them. Assigned to Hogwarts' students this year are ''Break with a Banshee'', ''Gadding with Ghouls'', ''Holidays with Hags'', ''Travels with Trolls'', ''Voyages with Vampires'', ''Wanderings with Werewolves'', and ''Year with the Yeti''. He also wrote the [[BasedOnAGreatBigLie "autobiography"]] ''Magical Me''.

to:

* AlliterativeTitle:[[invoked]] AlliterativeTitle: Most of Lockhart's books have them. Assigned to Hogwarts' students this year are ''Break with a Banshee'', ''Gadding with Ghouls'', ''Holidays with Hags'', ''Travels with Trolls'', ''Voyages with Vampires'', ''Wanderings with Werewolves'', and ''Year with the Yeti''. He also wrote the [[BasedOnAGreatBigLie "autobiography"]] ''Magical Me''.



* CopycatMockery: Malfoy does a "cruel but accurate" impression of Hero-Worshipper Colin Creevey, a Gryffindor first-year who won't stop taking pictures of Harry and doesn't realize how annoying he is.

to:

* CopycatMockery: Malfoy does a "cruel but accurate" impression of Hero-Worshipper HeroWorshipper Colin Creevey, a Gryffindor first-year who won't stop taking pictures of Harry and doesn't realize how annoying he is.



** Hermione has one when she realises what the monster of Slytherin is, but doesn't get to tell anyone else. Harry gets the moment secondhand when he reads her note later.

to:

** Hermione has one when she realises what the monster of Slytherin is, but doesn't get to tell anyone else.other than Penelope Clearwater. Harry gets the moment secondhand when he reads her note later.



* INeedToGoIronMyDog:
** Ron uses this to get away from Malfoy when the Polyjuice Potion starts wearing off, citing he needs medicine for a stomach ache which he had cited earlier in the scene to explain away an angry look.

to:

* INeedToGoIronMyDog:
**
INeedToGoIronMyDog: Ron uses this to get away from Malfoy when the Polyjuice Potion starts wearing off, citing he needs medicine for a stomach ache which he had cited earlier in the scene to explain away an angry look.



* IThoughtEveryoneCouldDoThat: Harry assumed that Parseltongue was just a thing wizards in general could do. It's not until after he scares everybody at the Duelling Club that he learns it's an uncommon ability associated with Slytherin and dark wizards.

to:

* IThoughtEveryoneCouldDoThat: Harry assumed that Parseltongue was just a thing wizards in general could do. It's not until after he scares everybody at the Duelling Club that he learns it's an uncommon ability associated with Salazar Slytherin and dark wizards.



* JokeAndReceive: Used as a BrickJoke. When Harry and Ron discover a trophy awarded to a Tom Riddle for undisclosed services to the school, Ron jokes that maybe Tom killed Moaning Myrtle (who is currently a ghost) because she's so annoying. [[spoiler:Much later in the book, Tom Riddle's own memory reveals that he did murder Myrtle, although that's not why he received the trophy -- more likely it was when [[FrameUp he "turned in" Hagrid for his misdeeds]].]]

to:

* JokeAndReceive: Used as a BrickJoke. When Harry and Ron discover a trophy awarded to a Tom Riddle for undisclosed services to the school, Ron jokes that maybe Tom killed Moaning Myrtle (who is currently a ghost) because she's so annoying. [[spoiler:Much later in the book, Tom Riddle's own memory reveals that he did murder Myrtle, cause Myrtle's murder, although that's not why he received the trophy -- more likely it was for when [[FrameUp he "turned in" Hagrid for his misdeeds]].]]



* NotSoAboveItAll: Hermione, "The Brightest Witch of Her Age", who normally plays the OnlySaneMan of the main trio, is completely taken in by Lockhart's charms, while Harry and Ron see him for the narcissistic buffoon he really is immediately and are baffled by her falling for him.

to:

* NotSoAboveItAll: NotSoAboveItAll:
**
Hermione, "The Brightest Witch of Her Age", who normally plays the OnlySaneMan of the main trio, is completely taken in by Lockhart's charms, while Harry and Ron see him for the narcissistic buffoon he really is immediately and are baffled by her falling for him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ExactWords: At the beginning of the book, Dobby says [[spoiler:that "He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named" is not involved in the plot he's trying to warn Harry about]]. At the end of the book, Harry asks why he said that when [[spoiler:the whole thing revolved around one of Voldemort's [[SoulJar Horcruxes]]]], which Dobby explains as [[spoiler:actually intended to be a clue -- the Horcrux in question was made when he was still Tom Riddle, and so "could be freely named", meaning that ''at the time'' he wasn't "He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named" yet]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Snape has a couple moments. During the Dueling Club, he quickly intervenes when Draco and Harry jinx each other and dispels Draco's snake when it goes for Justin. He also seems just as distraught as the other teachers when they learn that[[spoiler: Ginny was taken into the Chamber of Secrets]].

to:

** Snape has a couple moments. During the Dueling Club, he quickly intervenes when Draco and Harry jinx each other and dispels Draco's snake when it goes for Justin. He also seems just as distraught as the other teachers when they learn that[[spoiler: Ginny that [[spoiler:Ginny was taken into the Chamber of Secrets]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Snape didn't say that Harry might've been in the wrong place out of concern, he meant it sarcastically and immediately afterward tries to take Harry's broomstick away just for SUSPECTING that Harry isn't telling them the truth, when as far as he knows, Harry has nothing to do with any of this, and taking that away will accomplish nothing but make Harry miserable.


** Snape has a few moments. He defends Harry on Halloween when the kid is found with Ron and Hermione near Mrs. Norris's petrified body, saying that Mr. Potter was probably in the wrong place at the wrong time because only someone that excels in Dark Magic would be able to do such a thing. During the Dueling Club, he quickly intervenes when Draco and Harry jinx each other and dispels Draco's snake when it goes for Justin. He also seems just as distraught as the other teachers when they learn that[[spoiler: Ginny was taken into the Chamber of Secrets]].

to:

** Snape has a few moments. He defends Harry on Halloween when the kid is found with Ron and Hermione near Mrs. Norris's petrified body, saying that Mr. Potter was probably in the wrong place at the wrong time because only someone that excels in Dark Magic would be able to do such a thing.couple moments. During the Dueling Club, he quickly intervenes when Draco and Harry jinx each other and dispels Draco's snake when it goes for Justin. He also seems just as distraught as the other teachers when they learn that[[spoiler: Ginny was taken into the Chamber of Secrets]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ARottenTimeToRevert: Harry and Ron attempt to uncover information about the Heir of Slytherin by using Polyjuice Potion to transform into [[DumbMuscle Crabbe and Goyle]] so they can spy on the Slytherins up close. Unfortunately, the potion starts to wear off while they're questioning Draco Malfoy in the Slytherin common room, forcing them to make excuses about needing medicine for a stomachache and leave as quickly as possible before the reversion becomes noticeable.

Changed: 1

Removed: 412

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Too fantastical.


* SpinningOutOfHere: Travel by Floo sends the traveller spinning to his/her destination.

to:

* SpinningOutOfHere: Travel by Floo sends the traveller traveler spinning to his/her destination.



* SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome: Harry and Ron fly Arthur Weasley's car to school when they can't get on the train, foreseeing a triumphant arrival ... and end up pulling a CaptainCrash and are ''very'' lucky to get away with a detention each for having violated the International Statute of Secrecy. Meanwhile, Arthur is facing an inquiry at work for enchanting a Muggle object, and ends up getting a hefty fine.

Added: 1194

Changed: 1004

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AbortedArc: Ron learns that the Malfoys have a secret room in their mansion where they keep most of their more illegal dark weapons. He writes to his father and informs him, but we never hear if anything comes from it. Nothing in Draco or Lucius's later behavior suggests that he got in trouble for this, nor is it mentioned again. Knowing Lucius he probably bribed, blackmailed, or threatened his way out of legal action, assuming the secret room was discovered in the first place.



* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Harry actually enjoys Fred and George's mockery about the whole "Heir of Slytherin" business because it assures him that they don't actually believe any of it, feeling it's ridiculous and ''should'' be mocked.

to:

* ActuallyPrettyFunny: Harry actually enjoys Fred and George's mockery about the whole "Heir of Slytherin" business because it assures him that they don't actually believe any of it, feeling it's ridiculous and ''should'' be mocked. It helps that both Ernie Macmillan (the most vocal accuser) and Malfoy show obvious irritation towards them whenever the twins do it in front of them.



** All the victims of the Basilisk happen to see it indirectly, except for the last two victims who knew what the monster was and were deliberately looking around corners with a mirror.

to:

** All the victims of the Basilisk happen to see it indirectly, except for the last two victims who knew what the monster was and were deliberately looking around corners with a mirror. According to Tom Riddle it was the same way when the Chamber was opened in the 1940s, [[spoiler:other than Moaning Myrtle that is]].



* EveryoneHasStandards:
** Cornelius Fudge usually is easily swayed by Lucius Malfoy, however he quite vocally argues against him when he learns that Dumbledore is being dismissed from Hogwarts at the worst possible time.
** Gilderoy Lockhart thinks and acts as though he's magically superior than everyone else, but he never once claims or pretends to be more powerful than Dumbledore. He also shamelessly refuses to say Voldemort's name, even though it would make him appear even more impressive, implying that he fears the dark wizard and is unwilling to even pretend otherwise.



* ForgottenPhlebotinum: ''Website/{{Cracked}}'' [[http://www.cracked.com/article_21025_5-reasons-harry-potter-wizards-are-huge-threat.html wondered why innocent Hagrid had to go to jail]] in a world with truth potions and mind-reading spells.

to:

* ForgottenPhlebotinum: ''Website/{{Cracked}}'' [[http://www.cracked.com/article_21025_5-reasons-harry-potter-wizards-are-huge-threat.html wondered why innocent Hagrid had to go to jail]] in a world with truth potions and mind-reading spells. Though as these methods can be resisted, the Ministry and Prof. Dippet may have assumed that the "heir of Slytherin" was powerful enough to do so.



* HandOfGlory: Draco Malfoy notices a Hand of Glory in Borgin and Burkes. [[spoiler:He [[ChekhovsGun eventually uses it]] in ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince Half-Blood Prince]]'' for his plan to let Death Eaters into the school.]]

to:

* HandOfGlory: Draco Malfoy notices a Hand of Glory in Borgin and Burkes.Burkes and takes an interest in it. [[spoiler:He [[ChekhovsGun eventually uses it]] in ''[[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince Half-Blood Prince]]'' for his plan to let Death Eaters into the school.]]



* HijackedByGanon: The book plays out like this. So a monster controlled by the Heir of Slytherin has been attacking students. At the end, we discover that [[spoiler:— surprise! — Voldemort]] was behind the entire thing. [[spoiler:Only it's not Voldemort himself, just a piece of his soul containing the memories of his sixteen-year-old self.]]

to:

* HijackedByGanon: The book plays out like this. So a monster controlled by the Heir of Slytherin has been attacking students. At the end, we discover that [[spoiler:— surprise! — Voldemort]] was behind the entire thing. [[spoiler:Only it's not Voldemort himself, just a piece of his soul containing the memories of his sixteen-year-old self.]] Riddle even makes a point to explain his actions and motivations before revealing himself to be a young Voldemort, making it seem as though he was something of a PredecessorVillain]].



** [[spoiler:Lucius Malfoy planting the diary on Ginny Weasley. As we learn in the sixth book, this set off a chain of events that destroys one of Voldemort's Horcruxes and provides Dumbledore with the first real proof that Voldemort split his soul. Good going, Lucius.]]

to:

** [[spoiler:Lucius Malfoy planting the diary on Ginny Weasley. As we learn in the sixth book, this set off a chain of events that destroys one of Voldemort's Horcruxes and Horcruxes, provides Dumbledore with the first real proof that Voldemort split his soul.soul, and alerts Dumbledore to the possibility of multiple Horcruxes (Voldemort would be unlikely to put his only Horcrux in harms way). Good going, Lucius.]]



** Also subverted. [[spoiler:The book tries to convince you that Lord Voldemort is not behind the mystery this time, with Dobby even telling Harry that "He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named" is not involved. Of course, it turns out the perpetrator is a manifestation of the young Voldemort, then known as Tom Riddle. At the end, Dobby explains that his earlier comment was a subtle clue: [[MetaphoricallyTrue "The Dark Lord, before he changed his name, could be freely named, you see?"]] Though it would have been lost on Harry at the time, not finding out until it was almost too late that Riddle and Voldemort were the same person.]]
* NotSoAboveItAll: Hermione, "The Brightest Witch of Her Age", who normally plays the OnlySaneMan of the main trio, is completely taken in by Lockhart's charms, while Harry and Ron see him for the narcissistic buffoon he really is immediately and are baffled by her falling for him.

to:

** Also subverted. [[spoiler:The book tries to convince you that Lord Voldemort is not behind the mystery this time, with time given the fact that the Chamber was originally opened almost 30 years before Voldemort rose to prominence, and Dobby even telling Harry that "He-Who-Must-Not-Be-Named" is not involved. Of course, it turns out the perpetrator is a manifestation of the young Voldemort, then known as Tom Riddle. At the end, Dobby explains that his earlier comment was a subtle clue: [[MetaphoricallyTrue "The Dark Lord, before he changed his name, could be freely named, you see?"]] Though it would have been lost on Harry at the time, not finding out until it was almost too late that Riddle and Voldemort were the same person.]]
* NotSoAboveItAll: Hermione, "The Brightest Witch of Her Age", who normally plays the OnlySaneMan of the main trio, is completely taken in by Lockhart's charms, while Harry and Ron see him for the narcissistic buffoon he really is immediately and are baffled by her falling for him. him.
** While Lockhart loves to demonstrate his bravado and claim superiority to everyone else, even he refuses to say Voldemort's name.



** Malfoy, Percy, Hagrid, and even Harry are set up as possible Heirs of Slytherin, with Malfoy being the choice that's so obvious it's stupid, and Percy and Hagrid both having Really Big Secrets that make them act suspiciously. Naturally, our heroes suspect Malfoy immediately and spend several chapters investigating him, only to find out he's not the culprit.

to:

** Malfoy, Percy, Hagrid, and even Harry are set up as possible Heirs of Slytherin, with Malfoy being the choice that's so obvious it's stupid, and Percy and Hagrid both having Really Big Secrets that make them act suspiciously. Naturally, our heroes suspect Malfoy immediately and spend several chapters investigating him, only to find out he's not the culprit. Much later, Ernie Macmillan asks Harry and Ron if it could be Malfoy, but they have long since discovered his innocence.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Baleful Polymorph was renamed per TRS


** Hermione took what she thought was Millicent Bulstrode's hair to use in the Polyjuice Potion. As she found out when she took it (and after Harry and Ron's doses had worn off), it wasn't Millicent's hair. It was cat hair. [[BalefulPolymorph Oops.]]

to:

** Hermione took what she thought was Millicent Bulstrode's hair to use in the Polyjuice Potion. As she found out when she took it (and after Harry and Ron's doses had worn off), it wasn't Millicent's hair. It was cat hair. [[BalefulPolymorph [[ForcedTransformation Oops.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The true identity of the monster lurking in the Chamber of Secrets is supposed to be a mystery until the latter part of the book -- which did not stop multiple editions from spoiling it by heavily featuring snakes and snake imagery on their covers. The cover featured on this very page abandons all pretense and just has Harry fighting the Basilisk, thereby spoiling the end of the book.

to:

* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The true identity of the monster lurking in the Chamber of Secrets is supposed to be a mystery until the latter part of the book -- which did not stop multiple editions from spoiling it by heavily featuring snakes and snake imagery on their covers. The cover featured on this very page abandons all pretense and just has the FinalBattle between Harry fighting the Basilisk, and Basilisk in plain view, thereby spoiling leaving nothing at all to the end of the book.imagination.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TrailersAlwaysSpoil: The true identity of the monster lurking in the Chamber of Secrets is supposed to be a mystery until the latter part of the book -- which did not stop multiple editions from spoiling it by heavily featuring snakes and snake imagery on their covers. The cover featured on this very page abandons all pretense and just has Harry fighting the Basilisk, thereby spoiling the end of the book.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SeriesContinuityError: Two mentions of werewolves in this book make absolutely no sense come the very next instalment: Lockhart claims he used a spell to turn a werewolf back into a man, and Riddle claims that Hagrid raised "werewolf cubs" during their school days. The former could be InUniverse CriticalResearchFailure, though it would require the wizarding public to be ignorant enough about werewolves that Lockhart's claim ''doesn't'' immediately reveal him as a charlatan. The "werewolf cubs" error was straightened out much later by WordOfGod: apparently if a male and female werewolf meet in their wolf forms, they can breed and produce a litter of "beautiful and unusually intelligent" wolves, incapable of spreading the condition. The brood raised by Hagrid is apparently still running around the Forbidden Forest.

to:

* SeriesContinuityError: Two mentions of werewolves in this book make absolutely no sense come the very next instalment: Lockhart claims he used a spell to turn a werewolf back into a man, and Riddle claims that Hagrid raised "werewolf cubs" during their school days. The former could be InUniverse CriticalResearchFailure, InUniverseFactoidFailure, though it would require the wizarding public to be ignorant enough about werewolves that Lockhart's claim ''doesn't'' immediately reveal him as a charlatan. The "werewolf cubs" error was straightened out much later by WordOfGod: apparently if a male and female werewolf meet in their wolf forms, they can breed and produce a litter of "beautiful and unusually intelligent" wolves, incapable of spreading the condition. The brood raised by Hagrid is apparently still running around the Forbidden Forest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheFriendNobodyLikes: It is very apparent that none of the other teachers likes Lockhart. Even the usually cheery Professor Sprout quickly tires of his rampant narcissism. When the Chamber of Secrets is opened, they all eagerly nominate him for the task of [[spoiler:rescuing Ginny]], seeing a chance to get rid of him.

to:

* TheFriendNobodyLikes: It is very apparent that none of the other teachers likes like Lockhart. Even the usually cheery Professor Sprout quickly tires of his rampant narcissism. When the Chamber of Secrets is opened, they all eagerly nominate him for the task of [[spoiler:rescuing Ginny]], seeing a chance to get rid of him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TheFriendNobodyLikes: It is very apparent that none of the other teachers likes Lockhart. Even the usually cheery Professor Sprout quickly tires of his rampant narcissism. When the Chamber of Secrets is opened, they all eagerly nominate him for the task of [[spoiler:rescuing Ginny]], seeing a chance to get rid of him.

Changed: 198

Removed: 722

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing the former to the YMMV page.


* TheWoobie:
** The reader is often reminded how poor the Weasley family are; Mrs Weasley cleans out their bank vault in order to afford Hogwarts supplies for five children, and even those are often second-hand; Harry, meanwhile, tries to hide his riches. Ron laments that they probably couldn't afford a replacement wand and thus is forced to use ChekhovsGun all year, and Harry is both sickened to learn that Mr Weasley has received a 50 galleon fine for enchanting a Ford Anglia, and guilty they have bought him Christmas presents.
** InUniverse: Harry feels sorry for Tom Riddle upon learning that Riddle grew up in a Muggle orphanage, and returned there every summer. That is, until [[spoiler:Riddle reveals that he is Voldemort]].

to:

* TheWoobie:
** The reader is often reminded how poor the Weasley family are; Mrs Weasley cleans out their bank vault in order to afford Hogwarts supplies for five children, and even those are often second-hand; Harry, meanwhile, tries to hide his riches. Ron laments that they probably couldn't afford a replacement wand and thus is forced to use ChekhovsGun all year, and Harry is both sickened to learn that Mr Weasley has received a 50 galleon fine for enchanting a Ford Anglia, and guilty they have bought him Christmas presents.
**
TheWoobie: InUniverse: Harry feels sorry for Tom Riddle upon learning that Riddle grew up in a Muggle orphanage, and returned there every summer. That is, until [[spoiler:Riddle reveals that he is Voldemort]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Chekov's Gun


** The reader is often reminded how poor the Weasley family are; Mrs Weasley cleans out their bank vault in order to afford Hogwarts supplies for five children, and even those are often second-hand; Harry, meanwhile, tries to hide his riches. Ron laments that they probably couldn't afford a replacement wand and thus is forced to use ChekovsGun all year, and Harry is both sickened to learn that Mr Weasley has received a 50 galleon fine for enchanting a Ford Anglia, and guilty they have bought him Christmas presents.

to:

** The reader is often reminded how poor the Weasley family are; Mrs Weasley cleans out their bank vault in order to afford Hogwarts supplies for five children, and even those are often second-hand; Harry, meanwhile, tries to hide his riches. Ron laments that they probably couldn't afford a replacement wand and thus is forced to use ChekovsGun ChekhovsGun all year, and Harry is both sickened to learn that Mr Weasley has received a 50 galleon fine for enchanting a Ford Anglia, and guilty they have bought him Christmas presents.

Top