Follow TV Tropes

Following

History HarryPotter / TropesJToR

Go To

OR

Added: 320

Changed: 11

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** From the books alone, Voldemort's curse on the role of Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher may or may not actually ''be'' a magical curse (although [[WordOfGod Rowling]] confirmed a jinx on the position), and some of it is down to a self-fulfilling prophecy because of the very rumour that it is cursed (Gilderoy Lockhart was the only applicant for that role during Harry's second year). All of the teachers meet their end in very different circumstances, only one directly influenced by Voldemort.

to:

** From [[invoked]]From the books alone, Voldemort's curse on the role of Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher may or may not actually ''be'' a magical curse (although [[WordOfGod Rowling]] confirmed a jinx on the position), and some of it is down to a self-fulfilling prophecy because of the very rumour that it is cursed (Gilderoy Lockhart was the only applicant for that role during Harry's second year). All of the teachers meet their end in very different circumstances, only one directly influenced by Voldemort.


Added DiffLines:

** Whenever Harry talks to his reflection, it is left ambiguous whether he is being self-deprecating (because it's always snarky), imagining a response (because he always does it when exhausted) or if his reflection is actually an independent magical being during those interactions (because it can be very on-the-nose).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PunnyName:
** Placenames! Knockturn Alley ("nocturnally"), the street that deals in Dark magic; Grimmauld Place ("grim old place"), where an ancestral home of dark wizards is; Privet Drive, where wizards are not welcome. Also Diagon Alley ("diagonally").
** Several of the characters' names are puns, usually an obvious reference to their personality or another trait. Dolores Umbridge, who deliberately makes classes boring and pointless, and who is easily offended (takes umbrage). Bellatrix Lestrange, who is generally agreed to be beautiful, but has gone quite strange in the head after her years in Azkaban prison.
** Newt Scamander wrote ''Literature/FantasticBeastsAndWhereToFindThem''. His name refers to the index of his book.
** Fleur Delacour, the French champion in the Triwizard Tournament, combines this with BilingualBonus, having a name which is a pun in French. ''Fleur de la cour'' means "flower of the court", meaning "noblewoman".
** And of course, Remus Lupin. Remus, one of two founders of Rome who was raised by WOLVES. Lupin. Lupine. Lupus. Wolf. [[Creator/CleolindaJones WOLVES. WOLVES. WOLVES.]] The best part? Almost nobody caught on until it was outright said. Extended further by WordOfGod, which reveals that Remus's father was named Lyall (which also means "wolf") and his mother's maiden name was Howell ("howl").
** In the same strain, Sirius Black turns into a great BLACK dog. Sirius is the DOG star (aka Alpha Canis Majoris, part of the constellation of the Great Dog). Also, the Muggle Prime Minister once mistook Sirius' name as "Serious" Black. Several {{fanfic}}tions portray Sirius as enjoying the pun and other characters as unwittingly TemptingFate by using the word "serious" in front of him. Some of them also give some sort of HypocriticalHumor by making Sirius hate it when others make the pun.
** Dumbledore means Bumblebee in Old English. Dumbledore walks up and down the halls, humming to himself like a bee. Truthfully, it would be easier to name what character isn't this, especially the teachers. Binns: A bin is a trash can where you put rubbish. Most people see Binns' class as rubbish, since he just monotonously drones on about goblin rebellions year after year. Filius ''Flitwick'', as in "swish and flick" to levitate an object. Another blatantly obvious one is Pomona SPROUT. Three guesses what she teaches. Slughorn: students have used stewed Horned Slugs in their potions class. Severus Snape, the harsh and demanding Potions teacher: "Severus" means grave, serious, or stern, while "snape" is a recognised variant of "sneap", with meanings related to rebuking, pinching, or offending.
** The name of the puppet Minister for Magic in the final book, Pius Thicknesse, is almost too obvious to count as a pun.
** The Knight Bus, after London's well-known "Night buses".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Because of Harry being given multiple detentions by Professor Umbridge, he misses Ron's tryout for the Quidditch team, to the anger of Angelina, the team captain. When he is later banned from playing Quidditch at all, he and Hermione get ready to suffer through Ron's utter humiliation of being the Keeping in the final, when Hagrid shows up to ask them to follow him. They do, discovering that he has a (literal) giant half-brother. When they get back, they hear the crowd chanting a mocking song the Slytherins came up with, and realize the lyrics are now celebrating Ron, and sung by Gryffindors. It turns out Ron started blocking goals like a champ after they left, and while initially put off that they missed the whole thing, Hagrid's problem is enough to make him forgive them.

to:

** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Because of Harry being given multiple detentions by Professor Umbridge, he misses Ron's tryout for the Quidditch team, to the anger of Angelina, the team captain. When he is later banned from playing Quidditch at all, he and Hermione get ready to suffer through Ron's utter humiliation of being the Keeping Keeper in the final, when Hagrid shows up to ask them to follow him. They do, discovering that he has a (literal) giant half-brother. When they get back, they hear the crowd chanting a mocking song the Slytherins came up with, and realize the lyrics are now celebrating Ron, and sung by Gryffindors. It turns out Ron started blocking goals like a champ after they left, and while initially put off that they missed the whole thing, Hagrid's problem is enough to make him forgive them.

Added: 1873

Changed: 175

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MindYourStep: The staircases at Hogwarts have several stairs that your foot will sink through.

to:

* MindYourStep: The staircases at Hogwarts have several stairs that your foot will sink through. In ''Goblet of Fire'', Harry gets caught out by one of these, and ends up very stuck in his Invisibility Cloak, while Filch and Snape are around him, unaware of his presence.


Added DiffLines:

* MissingTheGoodStuff: This is almost a recurring theme, often involving the main characters missing Quidditch, or the Sorting Ceremony.
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets'': When Harry and Ron are sent to Professor [=McGonagall's=] office instead of attending the feast at the start of term, Ron is disappointed to have missed seeing Ginny being Sorted, but is relieved to learn she is in Gryffindor.
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban'': Harry and Hermione are summoned to Professor [=McGonagall's=] office at the very beginning of the year (for minor reasons), and are slightly disappointed to miss the Sorting ceremony.
** In the same book, Harry has to miss out on the first visit to Hogsmeade, because the Dursleys refused to sign his permission form. Later, Fred and George show him how to get there by stealth.
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheOrderOfThePhoenix'': Because of Harry being given multiple detentions by Professor Umbridge, he misses Ron's tryout for the Quidditch team, to the anger of Angelina, the team captain. When he is later banned from playing Quidditch at all, he and Hermione get ready to suffer through Ron's utter humiliation of being the Keeping in the final, when Hagrid shows up to ask them to follow him. They do, discovering that he has a (literal) giant half-brother. When they get back, they hear the crowd chanting a mocking song the Slytherins came up with, and realize the lyrics are now celebrating Ron, and sung by Gryffindors. It turns out Ron started blocking goals like a champ after they left, and while initially put off that they missed the whole thing, Hagrid's problem is enough to make him forgive them.
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince'': When Harry has been given detention by Snape, he misses playing in the Quidditch final, and has to ask Ginny to take his place as Seeker.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Crosswicking new trope.

Added DiffLines:

* LivingPhoto: Photographs developed in a special potion are able to move, and are common in the Wizarding World. However, they cannot speak or interact. Painted portraits, on the other hand, have more interactivity and retain the personality of their subjects, though the level of depth captured depends on the power and impression of the painter. The portraits of deceased Hogwarts headmasters are especially lifelike, according to WordOfGod, because the painting's subjects will impart knowledge to their painted selves while they are still alive. Acting headmasters and others will take advantage of this to seek advice from leaders past.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RedheadsAreRavishing: Ginny and Lily (and also Ron and Bill, if you argue that Heroines, or known beauties at least, want them as well). JKR confirmed that she really likes red hair, so she stuck an entire extended family of them into her series and made one her hero's best friend and the other [[spoiler:his (eventual) love interest]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MultipleChoiceChosen: Trelawny's prophecy about TheChosenOne to defeat Lord Voldemort could applied to both Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom at the time that she said it, but Voldemort himself chose Harry when he tried to kill him, which applied the final part of the prophecy to Harry only.

to:

* MultipleChoiceChosen: Trelawny's prophecy about TheChosenOne to defeat Lord Voldemort could applied apply to both Harry Potter and Neville Longbottom at the time that she said it, but Voldemort himself chose Harry when he tried to kill him, which applied the final part of the prophecy to Harry only.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* OurZombiesAreDifferent: The Inferi (singular: "Inferius") are slaves to a master, much like classic zombies, and unlike the Creator/GeorgeRomero flesh-eating version. The word's root is "''inferus'''", which means "below" in latin (it shares its root with "'''Inferni'''", the latin name for the Underworld in Classical Mythology).

to:

* OurZombiesAreDifferent: The Inferi (singular: "Inferius") are slaves to a master, much like classic zombies, and unlike the Creator/GeorgeRomero flesh-eating version. The word's root is "''inferus'''", "''inferus''", which means "below" in latin (it shares its root with "'''Inferni'''", "''Inferni''", the latin name for the Underworld in Classical Mythology).
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
In latin, "Inferi" doesn't mean "dead people" (that would be "mortuus" or "cadaver").


* OurZombiesAreDifferent: {{Justified|Trope}} because Inferi is taken from the Latin word for "Dead people". Much like classic zombies they are slaves to a master, unlike the Creator/GeorgeRomero flesh-eating version.

to:

* OurZombiesAreDifferent: {{Justified|Trope}} because The Inferi is taken from the Latin word for "Dead people". Much like classic zombies they (singular: "Inferius") are slaves to a master, much like classic zombies, and unlike the Creator/GeorgeRomero flesh-eating version.version. The word's root is "''inferus'''", which means "below" in latin (it shares its root with "'''Inferni'''", the latin name for the Underworld in Classical Mythology).

Added: 732

Changed: 592

Removed: 176

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The Dursley's -- the family that raises Harry -- are a deeply unpleasant group of people who reflexively loathe anything even slightly out of the ordinary, leading them to relentlessly abuse and neglect Harry in an effort to "stamp the magic" out of him. Dudley starts out even worse than his parents, due to being heavily spoiled by every authority figure in his life, and is a gluttonous, brutish bully who is so stupid as to be barely literate.

to:

** The Dursley's Dursleys -- the family that raises Harry -- are a deeply unpleasant group of people who reflexively loathe anything even slightly out of the ordinary, leading them to relentlessly abuse and neglect Harry in an effort to "stamp the magic" out of him. Dudley starts out even worse than his parents, due to being heavily spoiled by every authority figure in his life, and is a gluttonous, brutish bully who is so stupid as to be barely literate.



** Albus Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts, believed to be the most powerful wizard to have ever lived. He's the only wizard that Voldemort, the greatest dark wizard of the age, has ever feared, and is responsible for defeating Voldemort's predecessor Gellert Grindlewald. The final book reveals that the truth is far more complicated than the legend purports, and Dumbledore himself is extremly humble because of it.

to:

** Albus Dumbledore, the headmaster of Hogwarts, believed to be the most powerful wizard to have ever lived. He's the only wizard that Voldemort, the greatest dark wizard of the age, has ever feared, and is responsible for defeating Voldemort's predecessor Gellert Grindlewald. The final book reveals that the truth is far more complicated than the legend purports, and Dumbledore himself is extremly extremely humble because of it.



** In a more mundane example than fabulous wealth or defying mortality, when Ron complains that his mother can conjure fabulous feasts out of thin air, Henrmione tells him that food is one of the five exceptions to Gamp's Law of Elemental Transfiguration (presumably, currency is another). You can summon food if you know where it is, duplicate it if you have it, or transfigure food into different food, but not spontaneous generation. Oddly, this begs the question of whether only prepared food is subject to this, as it is presumably possible to create animals (like Hermione's birds in [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince Book 6]]) or plants that are inedible unless prepared like cashew fruits (which have to be roasted extensively to get rid of the poison).

to:

** In a more mundane example than fabulous wealth or defying mortality, when Ron complains that his mother can conjure fabulous feasts out of thin air, Henrmione Hermione tells him that food is one of the five exceptions to Gamp's Law of Elemental Transfiguration (presumably, currency is another). You can summon food if you know where it is, duplicate it if you have it, or transfigure food into different food, but not spontaneous generation. Oddly, this begs the question of whether only prepared food is subject to this, as it is presumably possible to create animals (like Hermione's birds in [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince Book 6]]) or plants that are inedible unless prepared like cashew fruits (which have to be roasted extensively to get rid of the poison).



* MagicAIsMagicA: Rules of magic that are directly stated tend to be followed in the book they first appear in at minimum, although there are some instances of previously mentioned rules being contradicted in later books. For example, it is repeatedly stated that it's impossible to teleport into or out of Hogwarts, which remains true throughout the series. Even during an Apparition test it's explicitly noted that the room they're practicing in has temporarily had the blocking field suspended, so they shouldn't try it after the lesson's over. Whenever someone wants to teleport to Hogwarts, they're instead forced to teleport nearby and travel the rest of the way though another means.

to:

* MagicAIsMagicA: Rules of magic that are directly stated tend to be followed in the book they first appear in at minimum, although there are some instances of previously mentioned rules being contradicted in later books. For example, it is repeatedly stated that it's impossible to teleport into or out of Hogwarts, which remains true throughout the series. Even during an Apparition test it's explicitly noted that the room they're practicing in has temporarily had the blocking field suspended, so they shouldn't try it after the lesson's over. Whenever someone wants to teleport to Hogwarts, they're instead forced to teleport nearby and travel the rest of the way though through another means.



** Much of this is clearly intended to reflect the cultural differences between those who live entirely in Wizarding society and those who mingle in both. For example, by the end of the series Ron, [[spoiler: who is now married to Hermione, a Muggle-born]], has gotten a driver's license. However because electronics do not work in Hogwarts, where young witches and wizards spend a large chunk of their childhoods, they naturally become distanced from technology and learn to get by using magic in their daily lives instead.

to:

** Much of this is clearly intended to reflect the cultural differences between those who live entirely in Wizarding society and those who mingle in both. For example, by the end of the series Ron, [[spoiler: who [[spoiler:who is now married to Hermione, a Muggle-born]], has gotten a driver's license. However because electronics do not work in Hogwarts, where young witches and wizards spend a large chunk of their childhoods, they naturally become distanced from technology and learn to get by using magic in their daily lives instead.



** Mrs. Weasley[[spoiler: who kills Bellatrix Lestrange, who had almost killed Ginny Weasley.]]

to:

** Mrs. Weasley[[spoiler: who Weasley [[spoiler:who kills Bellatrix Lestrange, who had almost killed Ginny Weasley.]]



* MentorOccupationalHazard: Dumbledore is often analogized to [[Franchise/StarWars Obi-Wan Kenobi]] in terms of his appearance, demeanor, and role in Harry's life, so readers naturally expected this to come to pass. [[spoiler: Sure enough, this is exactly what happens the sixth book.]]

to:

* MentorOccupationalHazard: Dumbledore is often analogized to [[Franchise/StarWars Obi-Wan Kenobi]] in terms of his appearance, demeanor, and role in Harry's life, so readers naturally expected this to come to pass. [[spoiler: Sure [[spoiler:Sure enough, this is exactly what happens the sixth book.]]



** The mental link between Harry and Voldemort potentially allows a two-way channel for either one to search the other's mind. However, whereas Harry can, if willing, look inside Voldemort's mind with relative ease and end up only a few nasty headaches worse for wear, Voldemort can't reach too deeply into Harry's mind without suffering unspeakable pain. Dumbledore theorizes that [[spoiler: Voldemort's unstable maimed soul is unable to come in contact with Harry's pure soul]].

to:

** The mental link between Harry and Voldemort potentially allows a two-way channel for either one to search the other's mind. However, whereas Harry can, if willing, look inside Voldemort's mind with relative ease and end up only a few nasty headaches worse for wear, Voldemort can't reach too deeply into Harry's mind without suffering unspeakable pain. Dumbledore theorizes that [[spoiler: Voldemort's [[spoiler:Voldemort's unstable maimed soul is unable to come in contact with Harry's pure soul]].



** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince'' sees Harry suspect Snape and Malfoy yet again, this time of hatching several failed assassination plots from within Hogwarts. By this point, Harry's friends and allies attribute his suspicion to his dislike for both people. [[spoiler: As it turns out, Harry is completely right about both, even if their situations are much more complex than Harry assumed.]]

to:

** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince'' sees Harry suspect Snape and Malfoy yet again, this time of hatching several failed assassination plots from within Hogwarts. By this point, Harry's friends and allies attribute his suspicion to his dislike for both people. [[spoiler: As [[spoiler:As it turns out, Harry is completely right about both, even if their situations are much more complex than Harry assumed.]]



* OddlyCommonRarity: Hermione says there were only seven Animagi registered with the Ministry during the entire century, but the trio encounters two unregistered Animagi within two years[[note]]and learn of a third, now deceased[[/note]], and another within five years, which strongly implies that it is far more common ability than she belives, and the actual rarity is for the Animagi to be registered. Hermione is just a law-obsessed teenager and doesn't consider that others. It wouldn't be terribly surprising to find out it is the Wizarding equivalent of speeding.

to:

* ObviousCrossoverMethod: [Crossover character] raises Harry instead of the Dursleys might be the single most common crossover mechanism for Potter Fanfic.
* OddlyCommonRarity: Hermione says there were only seven Animagi registered with the Ministry during the entire century, but the trio encounters two unregistered Animagi within two years[[note]]and learn of a third, now deceased[[/note]], and another within five years, which strongly implies that it is far more common ability than she belives, believes, and the actual rarity is for the Animagi to be registered. Hermione is just a law-obsessed teenager and doesn't consider that others. It wouldn't be terribly surprising to find out it is the Wizarding equivalent of speeding.



* ThePollyanna: Luna probably suffers more at the hands of her classmates than [[{{Wangst}} Harry]] does, but never complains or shows any signs of self-pity or even annoyance.



** ''Goblet of Fire'' also doesn't explain why the whole complex plot was necesarry in the first case, since the bad guy could have just turned any object into a Portkey. Dumbledore does exactly that in Book 5 when he needs to get Harry and the Weasleys out of Hogwarts in a hurry.

to:

** ''Goblet of Fire'' also doesn't explain why the whole complex plot was necesarry necessary in the first case, since the bad guy could have just turned any object into a Portkey. Dumbledore does exactly that in Book 5 when he needs to get Harry and the Weasleys out of Hogwarts in a hurry.


Added DiffLines:

* ThePollyanna: Luna probably suffers more at the hands of her classmates than Harry does, but never complains or shows any signs of self-pity or even annoyance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** ''Deathly Hallows'' is neigh-untranslatable so most markets use some approximation of "relics of death".

to:

** ''Deathly Hallows'' is neigh-untranslatable nigh-untranslatable so most markets use some approximation of "relics of death".

Added: 440

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PaddingThePaper: The trio talk about writing an essay and Ron suggests they write in huge letters so they can fulfil the length requirement (as their papers are measure by inches of parchment, rather than something like word count). Hermione is not amused.

to:

* PaddingThePaper: The trio talk talks about writing an essay and Ron suggests they write in huge letters so they can fulfil the length requirement (as their papers are measure by inches of parchment, rather than something like word count). Hermione is not amused.amused.
* PageTurnSurprise: There is a page of stars in between every chapter, which means no matter what happens with fonts or translation you will always have to turn a page to get to the next chapter. This is sometimes used for dramatic pauses, such as in ''Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone'', when revealing who is in the room with the stone: [[spoiler:It wasn't Snape. It wasn't even Voldemort. (chapter break) It was Quirrell.]].

Added: 480

Changed: 730

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RedHerring: The first four books each have at least one:
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone Philosopher's Stone]]: [[spoiler:Snape]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets Chamber of Secrets]]: [[spoiler:Hagrid, Lucius and Draco Malfoy, Percy]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban Prisoner of Azkaban]]: [[spoiler:Sirius Black]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire Goblet of Fire]]: [[spoiler:Igor Karkaroff, Ludo Bagman, Snape (again)]]

to:

* RedHerring: The first four books each have at least one:
one related to the main plot. PlayedWith in the sixth.
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePhilosophersStone Philosopher's Stone]]: [[spoiler:Snape]]
[[spoiler:Harry believes Snape is trying to steal the Philosopher's Stone. It's actually Quirrell.]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets Chamber of Secrets]]: [[spoiler:Hagrid, [[spoiler:At different points, Harry believes that Hagrid, Lucius and Draco Malfoy, Percy]]
and Percy are all in some way connected to or responsible for opening the Chamber of Secrets. He is correct in Hagrid's and Lucius' connection, but not responsibility.]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndThePrisonerOfAzkaban Prisoner of Azkaban]]: [[spoiler:Sirius Black]]
Black is painted up to be a loyal servant to Lord Voldemort and responsible for the deaths of Harry's parents. In reality, it was Peter Pettigrew, and Sirius is trying to hunt Pettigrew down.]]
** [[Literature/HarryPotterAndTheGobletOfFire Goblet of Fire]]: [[spoiler:Igor Karkaroff, Ludo Bagman, Karkaroff has the heaviest suspicion cast on him as the one who put Harry's name in the Goblet of Fire, due to being a former Death Eater. In reality, Alastor Moody did it, though Moody is not who he appears to be.]]
** ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince'': [[spoiler:DoubleSubverted. Harry is absolutely convinced that Draco Malfoy is up to no good and refuses to see reason that it could be anyone else. Brief suspicion is cast on
Snape (again)]]as well, but is shot down by Dumbledore. However, at the end of the novel, it turns out Harry was right all along, and Draco was trying to kill Dumbledore. But when Draco isn't able to go through with it, Snape comes along to do it himself.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Masquerade Paradox example from its page

Added DiffLines:

* MasqueradeParadox: This is a textbook example; a discussion of it even provides the page quote. The stated reasons for the Masquerade are that {{Muggles}} are inclined to mistrust wizards and [[TheWorldIsNotReady not ready to learn the truth]], and Muggles would want magical solutions to all their problems. Wizards cite medieval BurnTheWitch sentiment as the reason to enact the Masquerade to begin with, but that fails to address why the Masquerade is necessary ''today''. And even then, the books point out that few witches or wizards were actually ''harmed'' by medieval witch hunts, as they could create the illusion of their suffering and death and walk away from a witch-burning unscathed (that said, [[LiteraryAgentHypothesis Dumbledore's notes]] in ''Literature/TheTalesOfBeedleTheBard'' point out that a wizard separated from his wand could easily be killed by mundane means, and magical children were [[WouldHurtAChild often targeted by Muggle persecutors]] due to PowerIncontinence and their inability to protect themselves). There's also the possibility of informational exchange, as wizards are shown to be absolutely hopeless with technology but good with healing power (and supplemental material suggests this is ''exactly'' how wizards and Muggles interacted before the witch hunts). And wizards not only have superior firepower to {{Muggles}} (the question of whether Muggle weapons could [[MugglesDoItBetter take down a wizard]] is a bit of a [[BrokenBase contentious topic in the fandom]]), but magic explicitly neutralizes technology -- so why not just take over? The Masquerade seems to hit pretty much every point of contention the Paradox raises. Perhaps the most interesting explanation is ''wizard'' prejudice -- they hate {{Muggles}} and don't want to interact with them in principle. Arthur Weasley has an interest in Muggles and likes tinkering with Muggle devices, but this gets him seen as a kook by other wizards and the entire Weasley family is disparaged by pure-bloods for ''not'' having FantasticRacism against Muggles.
** Explored in comedic fashion in [[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cbdGsQdZUVs this video]] by none other than Creator/MatthewMercer and [[WebVideo/Dimension20 Brendan Lee Mulligan]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RaisedByHumans: Hagrid tries to raise Norbert(a), a hippogriff. It doesn't work.

to:

* RaisedByHumans: Hagrid tries to raise Norbert(a), a hippogriff.dragon. It doesn't work.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheHalfBloodPrince'', Malfoy mocks this just before a Quidditch game, saying "they'll be waiting for The Boy who Scored, or whatever they call you these days".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Hurting Hero is a disambiguation


* MoeCouplet: Harry and Luna. Luna is a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} who hardly seems troubled by anything and helps her father run the magical equivalent of a tabloid magazine, whereas Harry becomes more [[HurtingHero traumatized as increasing numbers of his friends and loved ones die. Some of them right in front of him.]] Yet, Luna understands what losing a loved one feels like, enabling her to empathize with his grief over Sirius -- and Harry knows what being picked on feels like, so he naturally wants to help her out when people hide Luna's things and mock her behind her back.

to:

* MoeCouplet: Harry and Luna. Luna is a {{Cloudcuckoolander}} who hardly seems troubled by anything and helps her father run the magical equivalent of a tabloid magazine, whereas Harry becomes more [[HurtingHero traumatized as increasing numbers of his friends and loved ones die. Some of them right in front of him.]] Yet, Luna understands what losing a loved one feels like, enabling her to empathize with his grief over Sirius -- and Harry knows what being picked on feels like, so he naturally wants to help her out when people hide Luna's things and mock her behind her back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
crosswicking new trope

Added DiffLines:

* PictorialLetterSubstitution: The American editions of the novels feature a lightning bolt as the left half of the letter "P" in the series word font logo. The same logo would later be used for the film adaptations.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RidiculouslyLonglivedFamilyName: While many old wizarding families in Britain did experience name changes through the centuries [[spoiler:(i.e. the Gaunts were direct descendants of Salazar Slytherin but did not carry the Slytherin name)]], some can trace their surnames back over a thousand years. Justified, since wizards tend to live longer and thus are better able to pass on their family names, and certain wizarding families (usually those associated with Slytherin House) became obsessed with proving their blood purity, so kept strong records.

to:

* RidiculouslyLonglivedFamilyName: While many old wizarding families in Britain did experience name changes through the centuries [[spoiler:(i.e.[[spoiler:(e.g. the Gaunts were direct descendants of Salazar Slytherin but did not carry the Slytherin name)]], some can trace their surnames back over a thousand years. Justified, since wizards tend to live longer and thus are better able to pass on their family names, and certain wizarding families (usually those associated with Slytherin House) became obsessed with proving their blood purity, so kept strong records.

Added: 1214

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* RaisedByHumans: Hagrid tries to raise Norbert(a). It doesn't work.

to:

* RaisedByHumans: Hagrid tries to raise Norbert(a).Norbert(a), a hippogriff. It doesn't work.


Added DiffLines:

* RidiculouslyLonglivedFamilyName: While many old wizarding families in Britain did experience name changes through the centuries [[spoiler:(i.e. the Gaunts were direct descendants of Salazar Slytherin but did not carry the Slytherin name)]], some can trace their surnames back over a thousand years. Justified, since wizards tend to live longer and thus are better able to pass on their family names, and certain wizarding families (usually those associated with Slytherin House) became obsessed with proving their blood purity, so kept strong records.
** Sirius Black states that the House of Black could trace their name back to the Middle Ages, and many members intermarried to "keep the line pure", not something he was particularly proud of. [[spoiler: With his death, the Black family name died out, though their blood lives on in the Tonks and Malfoy families.]]
** Armand Malfoy arrived in Britain with William the Conqueror as part of the invading Norman army. The Malfoy Family has since lived on the same plot of land for ten consecutive centuries.
** The Potter name traces back to the 12th Century, when Linfred of Stinchcombe became known as "The Potterer", passing his name to his son, Hardwin Potter.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* PerverseSexualLust: Aberforth apparently has a thing for goats.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Harry (and the narration) freely mock Dudley's weight issues, but when Draco makes fun of Mrs. Weasley's weight, it's treated as crossing some kind of line. However, this is understandable, Dudley is a spoiled fat bully who Harry understandably hates, and the reader is supposed to hate him for his appalling behavior; also, Dudley's known to be the size of a small well because of his spoiled overeating. While Mrs. Weasley has been shown to be a good parent and person despite her flaws and being overbearing, her weight is because of her having multiple children.

to:

** Harry (and the narration) freely mock Dudley's weight issues, but when Draco makes fun of Mrs. Weasley's weight, it's treated as crossing some kind of line. However, this is understandable, Dudley is a spoiled fat bully who Harry understandably hates, and the reader is supposed to hate him for his appalling behavior; also, Dudley's known to be the size of a small well whale because of his spoiled overeating. While Mrs. Weasley has been shown to be a good parent and person despite her flaws and being overbearing, her weight is because of her having multiple children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Harry (and the narration) freely mock Dudley's weight issues, but when Draco makes fun of Mrs. Weasley's weight it's treated as crossing some kind of line.

to:

** Harry (and the narration) freely mock Dudley's weight issues, but when Draco makes fun of Mrs. Weasley's weight weight, it's treated as crossing some kind of line.line. However, this is understandable, Dudley is a spoiled fat bully who Harry understandably hates, and the reader is supposed to hate him for his appalling behavior; also, Dudley's known to be the size of a small well because of his spoiled overeating. While Mrs. Weasley has been shown to be a good parent and person despite her flaws and being overbearing, her weight is because of her having multiple children.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* PerverseSexualLust: Aberforth apparently has a thing for goats.

Top