Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheThreeMusketeers1973

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Madame de Chevreuse, Raoul's mother is absent from the sequel.


Added DiffLines:

* DemotedToExtra:
** The Duchess du Longueville only briefly appears in ''Return of the Musketeers'' compared to the prominent role she played in ''Twenty Years After''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* RelatedInTheAdaptation: The father of Milady's child here is Rochefort, since her marriage to Lord de Winter's brother was AdaptedOut.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% * TheAlcoholic: Athos. And he's played by Creator/OliverReed.

to:

%% * TheAlcoholic: Athos.Athos is frequently seen with a bottle in hand. And he's played by Creator/OliverReed.



%% * BittersweetEnding: Like the book.

to:

%% * BittersweetEnding: Like the book.book. The Musketeers avenge themselves on Milady and Rochefort, but Constance is dead.



%% * BookDumb: D'Artagnan.

to:

%% * BookDumb: D'Artagnan.D'Artagnan apparently never learned to read as he has to have a fellow



%% * CrashIntoHello: How D'Artagnan meets the musketeers, as in the book.

to:

%% * CrashIntoHello: How D'Artagnan meets the musketeers, as in the book.book. He accidentally rams into Athos' injured shoulder while chasing after Rochefort and gets caught in Porthos' cloak.



%% * MarkOfShame: The brand on Milady's shoulder.

to:

%% * MarkOfShame: The fleur de lis brand on Milady's shoulder.shoulder which marks her as a criminal. When her husband the Comte de la Fere discovered it he was horrified and renounced her. Milady immediately tries to kill D'Artagnan when he sees it.



* {{Retcon}}: Rochefort was explicitly killed off in the second film with Richelieu stating as much, but is revealed to have survived in ''The Return of the Musketeers''.

to:

* {{Retcon}}: Rochefort was explicitly killed off in the second film with Richelieu stating as much, but is revealed to have survived in ''The Return of the Musketeers''.Musketeers'' since he did in the original books.

Added: 539

Changed: 138

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalJerkass: The Executioner of Lille in the book, made a point to throw the money he received in the river to show he was acting to avenge his own debt against Milady. The film has him keep the money and demand extra for rowing across the river, since the film cut his history with Milady.



%% * AdaptationalVillainy: Rochefort.

to:

%% * AdaptationalVillainy: Rochefort.Rochefort, who's heavily involved with Milady's schemes and a party to the murder of Constance. In the book he had no involvement with any of it.


Added DiffLines:

** The Executioner of Lille's grudge against Milady is not mentioned.


Added DiffLines:

* {{Retcon}}: Rochefort was explicitly killed off in the second film with Richelieu stating as much, but is revealed to have survived in ''The Return of the Musketeers''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Lalo Schifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/MichaelHordern as Tréville, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.

to:

Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Lalo Schifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/MichaelHordern Creator/GeorgesWilson as Tréville, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.



** In ''The Three Musketeers'', Georges Wilson (de Treville, the commander of the musketeers) is dubbed by Michael Hordern.
** In ''The Return of the Musketeers'', Eusebio Lázaro, Jean-Pierre Cassel and Creator/PhilippeNoiret are all dubbed by British actors.

to:

** In ''The Three Musketeers'', Georges Wilson Creator/GeorgesWilson (de Treville, Tréville, the commander of the musketeers) is was dubbed by Michael Hordern.
Creator/MichaelHordern.
** In ''The Return of the Musketeers'', Eusebio Lázaro, Jean-Pierre Cassel and Creator/PhilippeNoiret are were all dubbed by British actors.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Lalo Schifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.

to:

Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Lalo Schifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/MichaelHordern as Tréville, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** In ''The Three Musketeers'', Georges Wilson (de Treville, the commander of the musketeers) is dubbed by Michael Hordern.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GenderFlip: Milday's son Mordaunt is replaced by a daughter named Justine.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtImitatesArt: The second film references the famous painting "Cardinal Richelieu at the Siege of La Rochelle" by Henri-Paul Motte. Creator/CharltonHeston is costumed in full armour like the painting.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ExactEavesdropping: Zig-zagged. One of the [[PunchClockVillain Cardinal's spies]]. is seen reporting on a panicked conversation he heard Constance and the Queen having about how to retrieve the diamonds and about the need to send a messenger. But the flashback accompanied by his voiceover then has the two of them suddenly make shushing sounds when they realize there is a spy. The spy himself continues his report to give Richelieu a TheReasonYouSuckSpeech [[MoodWhiplash by pretending that they'd kept talking]], and that it was something he'd overheard them saying.
--> ''Spy: '' That devil has spies everywhere. That evil man, dirty, filthy, evil, nasty, dirty, that evil man calling himself a priest. (Richelieu glares). [[BlatantLies Is what it says here]].

to:

* ExactEavesdropping: Zig-zagged. One of the [[PunchClockVillain Cardinal's spies]]. spies]] is seen reporting on a panicked conversation he heard Constance and the Queen having about how to retrieve the diamonds and about the need to send a messenger. But the flashback accompanied by his voiceover then has the two of them suddenly make shushing sounds when they realize there is a spy. The spy himself continues his report to give Richelieu a TheReasonYouSuckSpeech [[MoodWhiplash by pretending that they'd kept talking]], and that it was something he'd overheard them saying.
--> ''Spy: '' -->'''Spy:''' That devil has spies everywhere. That evil man, dirty, filthy, evil, nasty, dirty, that evil man calling himself a priest. (Richelieu glares). priest... ''[Richelieu glares]'' [[BlatantLies Is is what it says here]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Music/LaloSchifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.

to:

Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Music/LaloSchifrin Lalo Schifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Spelling


** In the book, D'Artangan intercepts and has a duel with Comte de Wardes. In the film, he fights Rochefort (who is his cousin in the book).

to:

** In the book, D'Artangan D'Artagnan intercepts and has a duel with Comte de Wardes. In the film, he fights Rochefort (who is his cousin in the book).



* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The last we see of Kitty, she's being abused by Milady after D'Artangan escapes. In the book, he has her transfered in order to escape Milady's vengeance.

to:

* WhatHappenedToTheMouse: The last we see of Kitty, she's being abused by Milady after D'Artangan D'Artagnan escapes. In the book, he has her transfered in order to escape Milady's vengeance.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% * MookLieutenant: Jussac.

to:

%% * MookLieutenant: Jussac.A senior officer of the cardinal’s guard, Jussac, often appears to interfere with the musketeers plans.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: D'Artagnan treats his servant [[ButtMonkey Planchet]] (played by frequent Lester collaborator Roy Kinnear) like dirt. This is PlayedForLaughs.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: D'Artagnan treats his servant [[ButtMonkey Planchet]] (played by frequent Lester collaborator Roy Kinnear) Creator/RoyKinnear) like dirt. This is PlayedForLaughs.



* WrittenInAbsence: Creator/RichardChamberlain quit ''The Return of the Musketeers'' because he was angry at the producers lack of reaction over the death of Roy Kinnear. This is why Chamberlain's role is so brief in the final film.

to:

* WrittenInAbsence: Creator/RichardChamberlain quit ''The Return of the Musketeers'' because he was angry at the producers lack of reaction over the death of Roy Kinnear.Creator/RoyKinnear. This is why Chamberlain's role is so brief in the final film.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


The director, the screenwriter and much of the cast reunited again for ''The Return of the Musketeers'' in 1989, which is loosely based on the novel ''Twenty Years After''.

to:

The director, the screenwriter and much of the cast reunited again for ''The Return of the Musketeers'' in 1989, which is loosely based on the {{sequel}} novel ''Twenty Years After''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Music/LaloSchifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, and Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains.

to:

Directed by Creator/RichardLester from a screenplay by Creator/GeorgeMacDonaldFraser with a soundtrack by Music/MichelLegrand (replaced by Music/LaloSchifrin on ''The Four Musketeers''), they star Creator/MichaelYork as D'Artagnan, Creator/OliverReed, Creator/RichardChamberlain, and Frank Finlay as the three Musketeers, and Creator/CharltonHeston, Creator/FayeDunaway, and Creator/ChristopherLee as the villains.villains and Creator/RaquelWelch as the LoveInterest.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS has turned Gainaxing into a definition only page. Removing examples.


* VictoriasSecretCompartment: Constance gets her hands on a key which she triumphantly dropped into her cleavage--having forgotten that her friends needed that key to unlock the chains and '''rescue''' her. And then, it being a very small key, it slipped further down and she couldn't dig it out. Eventually she tries [[{{Gainaxing}} jumping up and down]] in hopes that it would fly out.

to:

* VictoriasSecretCompartment: Constance gets her hands on a key which she triumphantly dropped into her cleavage--having forgotten that her friends needed that key to unlock the chains and '''rescue''' her. And then, it being a very small key, it slipped further down down, and she couldn't dig it out. Eventually she tries [[{{Gainaxing}} jumping up and down]] down in hopes that it would fly out.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* MasterForger: The Duke of Buckingham, having met The Three Musketeers while on a secret mission in France, discovers that two large jewels are missing from his collarpiece. These were taken by the guileful Countess de Winter to keep the Duke from spoiling her machinations. The Duke visits a decrepit-looking fellow called O'Reilly (a dual role for Frank Finlay, who also plays Porthos) who happens to have a talent for making copies, and hires him thusly:

to:

* MasterForger: The Duke of Buckingham, having met The Three Musketeers while on a secret mission in France, discovers that two large jewels are missing from his collarpiece. These were taken by the guileful Countess de Winter to keep on Richelieu's orders as evidence of Buckingham's affair with the Duke from spoiling her machinations.Queen. The Duke visits a decrepit-looking fellow called O'Reilly (a dual role for Frank Finlay, who also plays Porthos) who happens to have a talent for making copies, and hires him thusly:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* IGaveMyWord: D'artagnan is facing Cardinal Richelieu who is about to hang him for a variety of illegal acts which destroyed the Cardinal's plan. D'artagnan hands Richelieu a note which says "By my order and for the good of the state, the bearer has done what has been done", basically a "get out of jail free" card. Richelieu accepts it, says "Be careful what you write, and be careful whom you give it to" (causing D'artagnan and the audience a moment of concern, thinking he is going to rip it up), but then follows this trope straight by honoring the document he himself wrote and releasing D'artagnan, even though it was intended as a blanket pardon to excuse Milady de Winter from her acts which would have advanced the Cardinal's plan.
* ImADoctorNotAPlaceholder: Milady's executioner demands extra pay for taking her in a boat, saying that he's a headsman, not a boatsman.

to:

* IGaveMyWord: D'artagnan D'Artagnan is facing Cardinal Richelieu who is about to hang him for a variety of illegal acts which destroyed the Cardinal's plan. D'artagnan D'Artagnan hands Richelieu a note which says "By the ''carte blanche'' ("By my order and for the good of the state, the bearer has done what has been done", basically a "get out of jail free" card. done —signed Richelieu") he'd stolen from Milady, Richelieu accepts it, says "Be careful what you write, and be careful whom you give it to" before tearing it and crumpling it up (causing D'artagnan D'Artagnan and the audience a moment of concern, thinking he is going to rip it up), but concern), then follows this trope straight by honoring the document he himself wrote and releasing D'artagnan, even though it was intended as a blanket pardon to excuse Milady de Winter from her acts which would have advanced offering him an officer's commission in the Cardinal's plan.
Musketeers for his audacity.
* ImADoctorNotAPlaceholder: Milady's executioner demands extra pay for taking her in a boat, saying that he's a headsman, not a boatsman.sailor.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** In the book, d'artangan intercepts and has a duel with Comte de Wardes. In the film, he fights Rochefort (who is his cousin in the book).
** In the book, it is Rochefort who tells the friends to surrender their swords and see the cardinal. Seeing as he's dead at this point, Jussac fills this role.

to:

** In the book, d'artangan D'Artangan intercepts and has a duel with Comte de Wardes. In the film, he fights Rochefort (who is his cousin in the book).
** In the book, it is Rochefort who tells the friends to surrender their swords and see the cardinal. Seeing as he's dead ''hors de combat'' in the film at this point, Jussac fills this role.



'''D'Artagnan:''' ''I'' am only one person. That is a servant.

to:

'''D'Artagnan:''' ''I'' am I ''am'' only one person. That ''That'' is a servant.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
add internal homage trope

Added DiffLines:

* InternalHomage: The first film opens with a closeup of a sword slowly being withdrawn from a scabbard, leading into the opening duel between D'Artagnan and his father. The third film opens with a closeup of a sword slowly being withdrawn from a scabbard, but this time it's revealed to have a fork on the end of it, as Planchet uses it to surreptitiously skewer food off plates belonging to the patrons seated below his perch in the rafters.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* PullingTheRugOut: PlayedForLaughs. Near the end of the movie D'Artagnan confronts several guards inside the palace. He grabs the rug they're standing on and tries to pull it out from under them, but only succeeds in ripping off the edge of the rug. As the guards are not actually involved in the current fight they don't pursue him and just wonder aloud why a random guy tore their carpet and ran.

to:

* PullingTheRugOut: PlayedForLaughs. Near the end of the movie first movie, D'Artagnan confronts several guards inside the palace. He grabs the rug they're standing on and tries to pull it out from under them, but only succeeds in ripping off the edge fringe of the rug. As the guards are not actually involved in the current fight fight, they don't pursue him and just wonder aloud why a random guy tore their carpet and ran.ran off.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


%% * NothingPersonal: "I have no enemies. ''France'' has enemies."

to:

%% * NothingPersonal: When asked if it isn't awful to have so many enemies, Richelieu replies "I have no enemies. ''France'' has enemies."" (Evidently a real quote by the historical Richelieu, which Heston pushed to have included in the film.)

Top