Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / TheBounty

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyCallMeMisterTibbs: The voyage starts off with Christian being on a FirstNameBasis with Bligh, calling him "William" in private. However as relations become strained later in the voyage, Bligh objects to Christian calling him by his first name in private:

to:

* TheyCallMeMisterTibbs: The voyage starts off with Christian being on a FirstNameBasis with Bligh, calling him "William" in private. However as relations become strained later in the voyage, Bligh objects to Christian calling him by his first name in private:private. To be fair, Christian has become quite unprofessional and insubordinate by this point so Bligh feels that he needs to reassert naval discipline.

Added: 80

Changed: 149

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AntiVillain: Christian is portrayed as such. He's not ''evil'', he's sincerely concerned with his crew's welfare and tries to rein in the mutineers's worst impulses/ However, he's ultimately irresponsible and immature despite his charm, and rebels mostly because he's sick of the work his job requires and to see his girlfriend again, rather than anything noble. And he strands Bligh and his loyalists at sea with only a slim chance of survival.

to:

* AntiVillain: Christian is portrayed as such. He's not ''evil'', he's sincerely concerned with his crew's welfare and tries to rein in the mutineers's worst impulses/ impulses. However, he's ultimately irresponsible and immature despite his charm, and rebels mostly because he's sick of the work his job requires and to see his girlfriend again, rather than anything noble. And he for any nobler reasons. He also strands Bligh and his loyalists at sea with only a slim chance of survival.survival rather than putting them ashore somewhere.



* BlindMusician: A blind guy is part of the crew for the sole purpose of playing violin and singing for the sailors.

to:

* BlindMusician: A blind guy near-blind fiddler is part of the crew for the sole purpose of playing violin and singing for the sailors.sailors. TruthInTelevision as Bligh did bring him along in real life.


Added DiffLines:

** Bligh really did add a near-blind violinist to the crew, for morale purposes.

Added: 1193

Changed: 274

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added example(s)


* AntiVillain: Christian is portrayed as such. He's not ''evil'', he's sincerely concerned with his crew's welfare and tries to rein in the mutineers's worst impulses/ However, he's ultimately irresponsible and immature despite his charm, and rebels mostly because he's sick of the work his job requires and to see his girlfriend again, rather than anything noble. And he strands Bligh and his loyalists at sea with only a slim chance of survival.



* DownerEnding: While Bligh [[spoiler:is exonerated when the court of inquiry rules in his favor]], the damage done by the mutiny haunts both Bligh and Christian for the rest of their lives. [[spoiler:Especially in RealLife when the bloody fate of the mutineers is discovered years later.]]

to:

* DownerEnding: While Bligh [[spoiler:is exonerated when the court of inquiry rules in his favor]], the damage done by the mutiny haunts both Bligh and Christian for the rest of their lives.lives, and the ending crawl reveals [[spoiler:most of the mutineers - including Fletcher - all likely died]]. [[spoiler:Especially in RealLife when the bloody fate of the mutineers is discovered years later.]]



* AFatherToHisMen: Christian--too much, as this causes him to lead the mutiny against Bligh.

to:

* AFatherToHisMen: Christian--too much, as this causes him to lead the mutiny against Bligh. It's also deconstructed, as it's shown to be a mark of his irresponsibility and how he and the sailors view the natives as an "exotic" alternative to their grueling work.
* FreudianExcuse: Bligh comes from poverty, which fuels his dedication to his job. He desperately wants to advance beyond his station, and thus wants his crew to perform to their peak efficiency, which alienates them.


Added DiffLines:

* TheNeidermeyer: Bligh deconstructs this. He's overbearing and irritable to be sure, and has occasional flashes of incompetence, but ultimately his worst moments are brought about because most of his crew is legitimately insubordinate, unprofessional, and lazy. His worst crime is that he's a {{Jerkass}}, and even then he's quite lenient by the standards of his time. His crew rebels simply because they've grown accustomed to slacking off after the ship was forced to stay in Tahiti, and won't tolerate any kind of discipline.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''The Bounty'' is a 1984 film directed by Roger Donaldson.

to:

''The Bounty'' is a 1984 film directed by Roger Donaldson.
Creator/RogerDonaldson.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Bligh's discipline can seem very harsh to modern eyes, but he was fairly lenient by the standards of the time. Bligh was noted as someone who would yell at crewmen in situations where other Captains would have flogged them, and flogged crew members other Captains would've hanged. Indeed, Bligh's biggest problem was that he was ''too nice a guy'' to be the captain of a ship in those days. He let discipline go to hell during the months on Tahiti, and when he finally did try to crack down, it was too little, too late.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Bligh's discipline can seem very harsh to modern eyes, but he was fairly lenient by the standards of the time. Bligh was noted as someone who would yell at crewmen in situations where other Captains would have flogged them, and flogged crew members other Captains would've hanged. Indeed, Bligh's biggest problem was that he was ''too nice a guy'' (relatively speaking) to be the captain of a ship in those days. He let discipline go to hell during the months on Tahiti, and when he finally did try to crack down, it was too little, too late.



** When the remaining core group of mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people willingly choose to accompany them, including Mauatua; in real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, most of the Tahitians were tricked into coming aboard the ship for a party and were kidnapped.

to:

** When the remaining core group of mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people willingly choose to accompany them, including Mauatua; in Mauatua. In real life, while the latter was probably possibly willing to accompany Christian, most of the Tahitians who ended up on Pitcairn were tricked into coming aboard the ship ''Bounty'' for a party and were kidnapped. kidnapped; the mutineers even made sure to abduct as many women as possible, and put six elderly women whom they had no use for ashore on nearby Moʻorea.

Added: 459

Changed: 456

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Hypocrite}}: The crew mutinies against Bligh for supposedly being an iron-fisted tyrant. This overlooks the ''months'' on Tahiti he let them do essentially whatever the hell they wanted as long as they did their jobs competently enough. They just got used to the good life and resented Bligh's attempts to start treating them like the Royal Navy crew that they are. (Although admittedly, Bligh's vindictiveness and inability to read the atmosphere didn't help him out).

to:

* {{Hypocrite}}: {{Hypocrite}}:
**
The crew mutinies against Bligh for supposedly being an iron-fisted tyrant. This overlooks the ''months'' on Tahiti he let them do essentially whatever the hell they wanted as long as they did their jobs competently enough. They just got used to the good life and resented Bligh's attempts to start treating them like the Royal Navy crew that they are. (Although admittedly, Bligh's vindictiveness and inability to read the atmosphere didn't help him out).

Added: 485

Changed: 482

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseHistory: While this film is much more accurate than other versions and largely avoids HistoricalVillainUpgrade, presenting Bligh as a man with human flaws but one who didn't really deserve to be mutinied against, it does indulge in this trope when it shows Bligh planning to make another attempt at Cape Horn. This is depicted as the breaking point that triggers the mutiny. In RealLife this did not happen, as the ''Bounty'' was sailing west for the Cape of Good Hope when the men mutinied.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseHistory: ArtisticLicenseHistory:
**
While this film is much more accurate than other versions and largely avoids HistoricalVillainUpgrade, presenting Bligh as a man with human flaws but one who didn't really deserve to be mutinied against, it does indulge in this trope when it shows Bligh planning to make another attempt at Cape Horn. This is depicted as the breaking point that triggers the mutiny. In RealLife this did not happen, as the ''Bounty'' was sailing west for the Cape of Good Hope when the men mutinied.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Christian did not order the burning of the Bounty as depicted in the film. In fact, while they debated whether to burn the ship or not, one of the mutineers, Matthew Quintal (known as a violent and insubordinate bully) took matters into his own hands and burned the ship on his own.

Removed: 120

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
TRS cleanup: no usable context


* ManOnFire: This happens early in the film to Lamb, a sailor, as the ''Bounty'' struggles to make it through Cape Horn.

Added: 164

Changed: 162

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImAHumanitarian: Briefly discussed and averted when Mr. Nelson offers his flesh to save the weakened people on the boat, but Lieutenant Bligh defies this with the following quote:

to:

* ImAHumanitarian: Briefly ImAHumanitarian:
**Briefly
discussed and averted when Mr. Nelson offers his flesh to save the weakened people on the boat, but Lieutenant Bligh defies this with the following quote:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The crew almost mutiny against Fletcher when he fails to find an island far from Tahiti (so the Navy can't find them); also, in RealLife, Fletcher and most of his fellow mutineers were ultimately killed by the Tahitians because they treated the Tahitians horribly, up to and including enslaving them, meaning they treated the locals even worse than Bligh treated them.

to:

** The crew almost mutiny against Fletcher when he fails to find an island far from Tahiti (so the Navy can't find them); also, in RealLife, Fletcher and most many of his fellow mutineers were ultimately killed by the Tahitians because they treated the Tahitians horribly, up to and including enslaving them, meaning they treated the locals even worse than Bligh treated them.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh is legally and probably ethically in the right throughout the film - he's correct that the men are neglecting their duties as sailors and that the junior officers are setting a bad example. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh is legally and probably ethically in the right throughout the film - he's correct that the men are neglecting their duties as sailors and that the junior officers are setting a bad example.example, and much of his discipline is aimed at ensuring the crew are fit and healthy because he is haunted by his experience on previous voyages of losing men to sickness. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''

Added: 371

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Hypocrite}}: The crew mutinies against Bligh for supposedly being an iron-fisted tyrant. This overlooks the ''months'' on Tahiti he let them do essentially whatever the hell they wanted as long as they did their jobs competently enough. They just got used to the good life and resented Bligh's attempts to start treating them like the Royal Navy crew that they are. (Although admittedly, Bligh's vindictiveness and inability to read the atmosphere didn't help him out)

to:

* {{Hypocrite}}: The crew mutinies against Bligh for supposedly being an iron-fisted tyrant. This overlooks the ''months'' on Tahiti he let them do essentially whatever the hell they wanted as long as they did their jobs competently enough. They just got used to the good life and resented Bligh's attempts to start treating them like the Royal Navy crew that they are. (Although admittedly, Bligh's vindictiveness and inability to read the atmosphere didn't help him out)out).
** The crew almost mutiny against Fletcher when he fails to find an island far from Tahiti (so the Navy can't find them); also, in RealLife, Fletcher and most of his fellow mutineers were ultimately killed by the Tahitians because they treated the Tahitians horribly, up to and including enslaving them, meaning they treated the locals even worse than Bligh treated them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Bligh's discipline can seem very harsh to modern eyes, but he was fairly lenient by the standards of the time. Indeed, Bligh's biggest problem was that he was ''too nice a guy'' to be the captain of a ship in those days. He let discipline go to hell during the months on Tahiti, and when he finally did try to crack down, it was too little, too late.

to:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Bligh's discipline can seem very harsh to modern eyes, but he was fairly lenient by the standards of the time. Bligh was noted as someone who would yell at crewmen in situations where other Captains would have flogged them, and flogged crew members other Captains would've hanged. Indeed, Bligh's biggest problem was that he was ''too nice a guy'' to be the captain of a ship in those days. He let discipline go to hell during the months on Tahiti, and when he finally did try to crack down, it was too little, too late.

Added: 171

Changed: 14

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ImAHumanitarian: Briefly Discussed when Mr. Nelson offers his flesh to save the weakened people on the boat, but Lieutenant Bligh defies this with the following quote:

to:

* ImAHumanitarian: Briefly Discussed discussed and averted when Mr. Nelson offers his flesh to save the weakened people on the boat, but Lieutenant Bligh defies this with the following quote:


Added DiffLines:

** Bligh states his reasons for not making a stop for provisions in Fiji and the surrounding islands where the local population has "perfected cannibalism into a science."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeliberateValuesDissonance: Bligh's discipline can seem very harsh to modern eyes, but he was fairly lenient by the standards of the time. Indeed, Bligh's biggest problem was that he was ''too nice a guy'' to be the captain of a ship in those days. He let discipline go to hell during the months on Tahiti, and when he finally did try to crack down, it was too little, too late.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* NationalGeographicNudity: The film has only a PG-rating despite the countless scenes of topless women and even a simulated sex scene during a fertility ritual. Because the individuals involved were Polynesians (for whom near-nudity was the norm), the scenes didn't get the censorship or R-rating that a similar showing of western people would have had.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CharacterDevelopment: Bligh initially shows disregard for the safety of his sailors in trying to cross Cape Horn (the mere mention of making a second attempt triggers the mutiny). By the time he and his loyalists are floating on their small lifeboat int he middle of the ocean, he gives his food ration to one of the hungry men.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times throughout the film - he's correct that the men are neglecting their duties as sailors and that the junior officers are setting a bad example. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''
** Bligh isn't altogether wrong in his assessment of many of the men's character. Given our introduction to the thuggish Churchill, his remarks fit:

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times is legally and probably ethically in the right throughout the film - he's correct that the men are neglecting their duties as sailors and that the junior officers are setting a bad example. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''
** Bligh isn't altogether wrong in his assessment of many of the men's character. characters. Given our introduction to the thuggish Churchill, his remarks fit:Bligh's remark is on the mark:

Added: 201

Changed: 32

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Bligh isn't altogether wrong in his assessment of many of the men's character. Given our introduction to the thuggish Churchill, his remarks fit:
--->'''Bligh''': You're a mindless animal, Churchill.



** Christian insists that neither Bligh nor those loyal to him are to be killed or physically harmed, and he gives Bligh just enough provisions to give him a fighting chance of survival at sea (though he assumed Bligh would just wind up stranded on a nearby island, as opposed to sailing over a thousand miles to Australia!)

to:

** Christian insists that neither Bligh nor those loyal to him are to be killed or physically harmed, and he gives Bligh just enough provisions to give him a fighting chance of survival at sea (though he assumed Bligh would just wind up stranded on a nearby island, as opposed to sailing over a thousand nearly 4000 miles to Australia!)Timor!)

Added: 1856

Changed: 1573

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* BadPeopleAbuseAnimals: Two of the mutineers amuse themselves by shooting dolphins riding a bow wave after Fletcher Christian takes the Bounty (not for meat, which would be justified given their situation, just for cruel fun). The scene followed shortly after Christian was asked if he could control a rabble of criminal sailors.



* EveryoneHasStandards: Fletcher Christian insists that neither Bligh nor any of the crew who remain loyal to him are to be killed.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times throughout the film. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: For all his overbearing manner, Bligh does love his family.

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times throughout the film.film - he's correct that the men are neglecting their duties as sailors and that the junior officers are setting a bad example. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''
* JerkWithAHeartOfGold: For all his overbearing manner, Bligh does love his family.family and cares about the welfare of the men who remained loyal to him on the launch.



* PetTheDog: On the open boat Bligh is doling out the pitiful amount of food they have (the carcass of a bird that got caught in the sails). When asked who gets each piece, he goes through the officers one by one. Purcell angrily shouts that the officers shouldn't be treated special with their limited food and some of the regular men haven't had anything in days. Bligh shows how he's grown-instead of punishing him for his outburst (as he would have before he lost the Bounty), he orders his share of the food given to Purcell, indicating that he's learned that discipline must be tempered with kindness.
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: [Overblown] instances of pettiness aside, Bligh is really quite lenient with his crew, far more than other British captains. If anything, that's (at least initially) the real problem; he lets them get away with far too much on Tahiti, and when he tries to make them shape up too quickly later on, it starts the chain of events that leads to the mutiny.

to:

* PetTheDog: Both Bligh and Christian are flawed individuals, but both have their moments of decency as well.
**
On the open boat Bligh is doling out the pitiful amount of food they have (the carcass of a bird that got caught in the sails). When asked who gets each piece, he goes through the officers one by one. Purcell angrily shouts that the officers shouldn't be treated special with their limited food and some of the regular men haven't had anything in days. Bligh shows how he's grown-instead of punishing him for his outburst (as he would have before he lost the Bounty), he orders his share of the food given to Purcell, indicating that he's learned that discipline must be tempered with kindness.
** Christian insists that neither Bligh nor those loyal to him are to be killed or physically harmed, and he gives Bligh just enough provisions to give him a fighting chance of survival at sea (though he assumed Bligh would just wind up stranded on a nearby island, as opposed to sailing over a thousand miles to Australia!)
* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: [Overblown] Several examples.
** For Bligh:[Overblown]
instances of pettiness and yelling aside, Bligh is really quite lenient with his crew, far more than other British captains. If anything, that's (at least initially) the real problem; he lets them get away with far too much on Tahiti, and when he tries to make them shape up too quickly later on, it starts the chain of events that leads to the mutiny.mutiny.
** Boatswain William Cole. It's notable that while the mutineers hate Bligh and Fryer and take pleasure in tormenting some of the junior officers like Nelson, they're matter of fact when dealing with Botswain Cole, even though he was responsible for discipline on board the ship. They probably realized that Cole was just a sailor doing his duty, as opposed to the overbearing, power-hungry Bligh or the smarmy Fryer.
** Admiral Hood. While Captain Greetham adopts a very hostile and confrontational manner when questioning Bligh, Admiral Hood is very fair and even handed, giving Bligh every opportunity to explain his own account of what happened.

Added: 595

Changed: 517

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The film leaves out the mutineers' disastrous attempt to settle on Tubuai, which resulted in the deaths of many of the island's inhabitants when the mutineers' attempted to steal supplies and force women to be 'wives'. When the mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people willingly choose to accompany them, including Mauatua; in real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, most of the Tahitians were tricked into coming aboard the boat for a party and were kidnapped.

to:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: HistoricalHeroUpgrade:
**
The film leaves out the mutineers' disastrous attempt to settle on Tubuai, the island of Tubuai before they returned to Tahiti, which resulted in the deaths of many of the island's inhabitants when the mutineers' mutineers attempted to steal supplies and force women to be 'wives'. their 'wives'.
**
When the remaining core group of mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people willingly choose to accompany them, including Mauatua; in real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, most of the Tahitians were tricked into coming aboard the boat ship for a party and were kidnapped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Bligh is exonerated and praised for saving the lives of his loyal crew, but some years later as Governor of New South Wales he faced another revolt in the form of the Rum Rebellion and was deposed, arrested and replaced, was court-martialled twice more though acquitted both times, and after that never held an important command again.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The film ends with the mutineers landing on Pitcairn Island and burning the ''Bounty''. It's rather melancholy, as they realize they are stuck there forever, but they have their home and their women. An on-screen text then alludes to, but does not directly mention, the violence and murder that led the mutineers and the Tahitian men that accompanied them to kill each other, leaving only one mutineer alive (along with a bunch of women and children) when an American ship found them on Pitcairn Island in 1818. (Descendants of the mutineers still live there today.)

to:

** The film ends with the mutineers landing on Pitcairn Island and burning the ''Bounty''. It's rather melancholy, as they realize they are stuck there forever, but they have their home and their women. An on-screen text then alludes to, but does not directly mention, the violence violence, enslavement and murder that led the mutineers and the Tahitian men that accompanied them to kill each other, leaving only one mutineer alive (along with a bunch of women and children) when an American ship found them on Pitcairn Island in 1818. (Descendants of the mutineers still live there today.)
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: When the mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people choose to accompany them, including Mauatua. In real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, the 'brides' of many of the mutineers were essentially tricked into coming aboard the boat for a party and were kidnapped.

to:

* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: The film leaves out the mutineers' disastrous attempt to settle on Tubuai, which resulted in the deaths of many of the island's inhabitants when the mutineers' attempted to steal supplies and force women to be 'wives'. When the mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people willingly choose to accompany them, including Mauatua. In Mauatua; in real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, the 'brides' of many most of the mutineers Tahitians were essentially tricked into coming aboard the boat for a party and were kidnapped.

Added: 341

Changed: 10

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* HistoricalHeroUpgrade: When the mutineers set off for Pitcairn Island, several Tahitian people choose to accompany them, including Mauatua. In real life, while the latter was probably willing to accompany Christian, the 'brides' of many of the mutineers were essentially tricked into coming aboard the boat for a party and were kidnapped.



* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times throughout the film, at least. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''

to:

* JerkassHasAPoint: Bligh does, anyways, several times throughout the film, at least.film. It's not his logic that turns everyone against him, it's his ''manner.''
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheyCallMeMisterTibbs: The voyage starts off with Christian being on a FirstNameBasis with Bligh, calling him "William." However as relations become strained later in the voyage, Bligh objects to Christian calling him by his first name:

to:

* TheyCallMeMisterTibbs: The voyage starts off with Christian being on a FirstNameBasis with Bligh, calling him "William." "William" in private. However as relations become strained later in the voyage, Bligh objects to Christian calling him by his first name:name in private:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: [Overblown] instances of pettiness aside, Bligh is really quite lenient with his crew, far more than other British captains.

to:

* ReasonableAuthorityFigure: [Overblown] instances of pettiness aside, Bligh is really quite lenient with his crew, far more than other British captains. If anything, that's (at least initially) the real problem; he lets them get away with far too much on Tahiti, and when he tries to make them shape up too quickly later on, it starts the chain of events that leads to the mutiny.

Top