Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Signs

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* TinfoilHat: Becoming paranoid, the family starts to wear aluminum foil clothing to try and protect themselves.

Added: 4

Changed: 1

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The pig-like chirping squeal noise Graham hears briefly when he's searching through his cornfield and [[spoiler: suddenly the alien's leg moves.]]

to:

** The pig-like chirping squeal noise Graham hears briefly when he's searching through his cornfield and [[spoiler: suddenly [[spoiler:suddenly the alien's leg moves.]]



* WreckedWeapon: [[spoiler:When Merrill lands his finishing blow on the alien to knock it into the water glasses, he ends up hitting it so hard that it breaks the bat in half.]]

to:

* WreckedWeapon: [[spoiler:When Merrill lands his finishing blow on the alien to knock it into the water glasses, he ends up hitting it so hard that it breaks the bat in half.]]]]
----

Added: 232

Changed: 122

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* {{Chiaroscuro}}

to:

* {{Chiaroscuro}}{{Chiaroscuro}}: The scenes which take place in the basement, lit only by flashlights. Until, of course, they find a pack of lightbulbs.



* CrisisOfFaith: Graham is a priest who lost his wife, which killed his faith in God. [[spoiler: It's restored by the end of the invasion.]]

to:

* CrisisOfFaith: Graham is a priest who lost his wife, which killed his faith in God. [[spoiler: It's [[spoiler:It's restored by the end of the invasion.]]


Added DiffLines:

** Early on in the film, Bo is watching ''WesternAnimation/DextersLaboratory'', and in the episode she's watching, Dexter can be seen getting dunked into a fish tank. [[spoiler:Water does indeed come in handy later on in the film]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''Signs'' is notable for being the last of Shyamalan's films to have a generally positive reception before his reputation as a filmmaker began to decline following the release of his next film, ''Film/TheVillage''. The film can also be interpreted as something of a spiritual successor to his previous efforts ''Film/TheSixthSense'' and ''Film/{{Unbreakable}}'', being a similarly dark and introspective family drama that presents an unconventional take on a popular genre of speculative fiction by largely eschewing flashy action in favor of thematic exploration and character studies. After putting a new spin on [[GhostStory ghost stories]] and {{superhero}}es, ''Signs'' completes the trifecta by tackling [[AlienInvasion alien invasions]].

to:

''Signs'' is notable for being the last of Shyamalan's films following ''Film/TheSixthSense'' to have a generally positive reception before his reputation as a filmmaker began to decline following the release of his next film, ''Film/TheVillage''. The film can also be interpreted as something of a spiritual successor to his ''The Sixth Sense'' and another previous efforts ''Film/TheSixthSense'' and effort of his, ''Film/{{Unbreakable}}'', being a similarly dark and introspective family drama that presents an unconventional take on a popular genre of speculative fiction by largely eschewing flashy action in favor of thematic exploration and character studies. After putting a new spin on [[GhostStory ghost stories]] and {{superhero}}es, ''Signs'' completes the trifecta by tackling [[AlienInvasion alien invasions]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In a unique spin on this premise, however, the events that follow are told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Instead of prioritizing action set-pieces, ''Signs'' mainly focuses on the sheer terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. This suspense is aided by Shyamalan's direction embracing a [[NothingIsScarier "less is more"]] approach in its depiction of the aliens, keeping details about their appearance and background minimal (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen) and never showing them using any sort of advanced technology apart from their spaceships[[note]]which are permanently [[StealthInSpace rendered invisible with cloaking devices]][[/note]], making them come across more like ''monsters'' than traditional alien invaders. At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

to:

In a unique spin on this premise, however, the events that follow are told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Instead of prioritizing action set-pieces, ''Signs'' mainly focuses on the sheer terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. This suspense is aided by Shyamalan's direction embracing a [[NothingIsScarier "less is more"]] approach in its depiction of the aliens, keeping details about their appearance and background minimal (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen) and never showing them using any sort of advanced technology apart from their spaceships[[note]]which are permanently [[StealthInSpace rendered invisible with cloaking devices]][[/note]], making them come across more like ''monsters'' than traditional alien invaders. At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

Added: 252

Changed: 3203

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


[[caption-width-right:300:[[{{Tagline}} It's happening]]. ...no, not ''that'' [[Film/TheHappening Happening]].]]

->''"So what you have to ask yourself is what kind of person are you. Are you the kind that sees signs, sees miracles? Or do you believe that people just get lucky? Or, look at the question this way. Is it possible that there are no coincidences?"''

to:

[[caption-width-right:300:[[{{Tagline}} It's happening]]. ...\\
...
no, not ''that'' [[Film/TheHappening Happening]].happening]].]]

->''"So what you have to ask yourself is is, what kind of person are you. you? Are you the kind that sees signs, sees miracles? Or do you believe that people just get lucky? Or, look at the question this way. Is way -- is it possible that there are no coincidences?"''



A 2002 film, written and directed by Creator/MNightShyamalan, starring Creator/MelGibson and Creator/JoaquinPhoenix.

The story focuses on the Hess family: faithless former preacher Graham (Gibson), his asthmatic son Morgan (Rory Culkin), his ostensibly autistic daughter Bo (Creator/AbigailBreslin), and his ne'er-do-well younger brother Merrill (Phoenix), a former baseball player. A few short months after the accidental death of his wife, a newly widowed Graham struggles to raise his children with Merrill's help, while also grappling with his newly shaken faith in {{God}}. Having abandoned the priesthood following his wife's death, Graham now lives as a simple farmer in rural Pennsylvania. One day, however, the Hess family's quiet life is shattered by news of a bizarre series of events: crop circles are appearing around the world, radios are picking up strange signals from space, and multiple witnesses report sightings of unearthly creatures. In the ensuing weeks, the people of the world gradually realize that Earth has been targeted by invaders from another world, and advance agents are stealthily infiltrating human civilization as a precursor to all-out invasion.

In a unique twist, however, the ensuing AlienInvasion story is told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Apart from a single fight scene, there's virtually no action, with the story instead focusing on the sheer panic and terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. To make the story as tense and suspenseful as possible, Shyamalan's direction proudly embraces NothingIsScarier: we only get a few brief glimpses of the aliens, we learn virtually nothing about them (or their motivations), and most of the information about the invasion is relayed via brief snippets of news broadcasts from the Hesses' television (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen).

In another departure from conventional alien invasion narratives: the aliens are never shown to use any sort of advanced technology apart from their spaceships (which are permanently [[StealthInSpace rendered invisible with cloaking devices]]), making them come across more like ''monsters'' than traditional alien invaders. At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

Notable for being the last of M. Night Shyamalan's films to receive widespread critical acclaim before his reputation as a filmmaker began to decline following the release of ''Film/TheVillage'', it's something of a spiritual successor to his previous efforts ''Film/TheSixthSense'' and ''Film/{{Unbreakable}}'', being a similarly dark and introspective family drama that presents a uniquely unconventional take on a popular genre of speculative fiction. After putting a new spin on [[GhostStory ghost stories]] and {{superhero}}es, ''Signs'' completes the trifecta by tackling [[AlienInvasion alien invasions]]. Like its two predecessors, the film largely eschews flashy action and {{spectacle}} in favor of using the premise as a vehicle for thematic exploration and character studies.

to:

A ''Signs'' is a 2002 film, SciFiHorror film written and directed by Creator/MNightShyamalan, starring Creator/MelGibson Creator/MelGibson, Creator/JoaquinPhoenix, Rory Culkin and Creator/JoaquinPhoenix.

Creator/AbigailBreslin.

The story film focuses on the Hess family: faithless former preacher Graham (Gibson), his asthmatic son Morgan (Rory Culkin), (Culkin), his ostensibly autistic daughter Bo (Creator/AbigailBreslin), (Breslin), and his ne'er-do-well younger brother Merrill (Phoenix), a former baseball player. A few short months after the accidental death of his wife, a newly widowed Graham struggles to raise his children with Merrill's help, while also grappling with his newly shaken faith in {{God}}. Having abandoned the priesthood following his wife's death, Graham now lives as a simple farmer in rural Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania.

One day, however, the Hess family's quiet life is shattered by news of a bizarre series of events: crop circles are appearing around the world, radios are picking up strange signals from space, and multiple witnesses report sightings of unearthly creatures. In the ensuing weeks, the people of the world gradually realize that Earth has been targeted by invaders from another world, and advance agents are stealthily infiltrating human civilization as a precursor to [[AlienInvasion all-out invasion.

invasion]].

In a unique twist, spin on this premise, however, the ensuing AlienInvasion story is events that follow are told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Apart from a single fight scene, there's virtually no action, with the story instead focusing Instead of prioritizing action set-pieces, ''Signs'' mainly focuses on the sheer panic and terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. To make the story as tense and suspenseful as possible, This suspense is aided by Shyamalan's direction proudly embraces NothingIsScarier: we only get embracing a few brief glimpses [[NothingIsScarier "less is more"]] approach in its depiction of the aliens, we learn virtually nothing keeping details about them (or their motivations), appearance and most of the information about the invasion is relayed via brief snippets of news broadcasts from the Hesses' television background minimal (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen).

In another departure from conventional alien invasion narratives: the aliens are
unseen) and never shown to use showing them using any sort of advanced technology apart from their spaceships (which spaceships[[note]]which are permanently [[StealthInSpace rendered invisible with cloaking devices]]), devices]][[/note]], making them come across more like ''monsters'' than traditional alien invaders. At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

Notable ''Signs'' is notable for being the last of M. Night Shyamalan's films to receive widespread critical acclaim have a generally positive reception before his reputation as a filmmaker began to decline following the release of ''Film/TheVillage'', it's his next film, ''Film/TheVillage''. The film can also be interpreted as something of a spiritual successor to his previous efforts ''Film/TheSixthSense'' and ''Film/{{Unbreakable}}'', being a similarly dark and introspective family drama that presents a uniquely an unconventional take on a popular genre of speculative fiction. fiction by largely eschewing flashy action in favor of thematic exploration and character studies. After putting a new spin on [[GhostStory ghost stories]] and {{superhero}}es, ''Signs'' completes the trifecta by tackling [[AlienInvasion alien invasions]]. Like its two predecessors, the film largely eschews flashy action and {{spectacle}} in favor of using the premise as a vehicle for thematic exploration and character studies.
invasions]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** They also came to Earth with only their [[CoolStarship Spacecrafts]] that have built-in [[InvisibilityCloak Cloaking Tech]], but not have the wherewithal to keep their starships up in orbit or at a higher altitude than where Birds tend to fly so they don't get found out by their prey when a Bird-Strike happens on their ships [[SoMuchForStealth which reveals its' exact location.]]
** And while we're on the subject of technology, and to quote [[WebSeries/NostalgiaCritic Doug Walker]]:
-->''These technologically-advanced Aliens; these creatures that we are supposed to be afraid of... [[InsurmountableWaistHeightFence CANNOT get through Pantry Doors!]]''

Added: 567

Changed: 243

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


In a unique twist, however, the ensuing AlienInvasion story is told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Apart from a single fight scene, there's virtually no action, with the story instead focusing on the sheer panic and terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. To make the story as tense and suspenseful as possible, Shyamalan's direction proudly embraces NothingIsScarier: we only get a few brief glimpses of the aliens, we learn virtually nothing about them (or their motivations), and most of the information about the invasion is relayed via brief snippets of news broadcasts from the Hesses' television (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen). At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

to:

In a unique twist, however, the ensuing AlienInvasion story is told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Apart from a single fight scene, there's virtually no action, with the story instead focusing on the sheer panic and terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. To make the story as tense and suspenseful as possible, Shyamalan's direction proudly embraces NothingIsScarier: we only get a few brief glimpses of the aliens, we learn virtually nothing about them (or their motivations), and most of the information about the invasion is relayed via brief snippets of news broadcasts from the Hesses' television (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen).unseen).

In another departure from conventional alien invasion narratives: the aliens are never shown to use any sort of advanced technology apart from their spaceships (which are permanently [[StealthInSpace rendered invisible with cloaking devices]]), making them come across more like ''monsters'' than traditional alien invaders.
At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

Added: 611

Changed: 465

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ArtisticLicenseTraditionalChristianity: Graham was an Episcopal priest. It's a branch of Christianity with a lot of similarities with Catholicism, but the Confessional isn't one of them. DownPlayed, because it's not called confession, just "clearing my conscience" and Tracey may not have known the difference.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseLaw: No mention is ever made of Ray Reddy facing any legal repercussions for killing Graham's wife. While her death may have been an accident, Ray should (at the very least) have been charged with involuntary manslaughter for hitting her with his truck. In Pennsylvania, involuntary manslaughter carries a maximum sentence of five years in prison.
* ArtisticLicenseTraditionalChristianity: In one scene, a girl named Tracey insists on confessing her sins to Graham in order to clear her conscience, since she feels remorseful about a recent argument with a friend. Graham was an ''Episcopal'' priest, while Confession is primarily a ''Catholic'' tradition; the Episcopal priest. It's a branch of Christianity with a lot of Church has many similarities with Catholicism, to the Catholic Church (it's an American offshoot of Anglicanism, which is an English offshoot of Catholicism), but the Confessional isn't one of them. DownPlayed, because it's not called confession, just "clearing my conscience" and it doesn't recognize Confession as a sacrament. To be fair: Tracey may not have known that, and she doesn't actually use the difference. term "Confession".
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* CastingGag: Morgan and Bo are both played by the younger siblings of famous child actors: Morgan is played by Rory Culkin (the younger brother of Creator/MacaulayCulkin), and Bo is played by Creator/AbigailBreslin (the younger sister of Creator/SpencerBreslin). Their uncle Merrill is played by Creator/JoaquinPhoenix, who was (similarly) initially best known as the younger brother of the late Creator/RiverPhoenix, who first broke out as a teenager.

Added: 1911

Changed: 1384

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


A 2002 film, written and directed by Creator/MNightShyamalan, starring Creator/MelGibson and Creator/JoaquinPhoenix. Weird things start happening all over the globe. Strange sightings of unearthly creatures, {{crop circles}}, and other unexplained phenomena start occurring.

The story focuses on the Hess family, consisting of a faithless former preacher, Graham (Gibson), his asthmatic son, Morgan (Rory Culkin), his ostensibly autistic daughter, Bo (Creator/AbigailBreslin) and his ne'er do well younger brother, Merrill (Phoenix), who live in a podunk farmland community. Like the rest of the world, they start thinking that it's an AlienInvasion being done as a stealth infiltration. The entire story is told through this farming family in Pennsylvania as they watch the paranoia grip the world through their television set. Of course, since an off-screen repulsion isn't too dramatic, there's still a fight scene. Oh, and there's a lot of [[{{Anvilicious}} incredibly blunt]] [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic religious symbolism]], with the story serving more as a story about a man finding his faith in God again as the "signs" start to coalesce.

to:

A 2002 film, written and directed by Creator/MNightShyamalan, starring Creator/MelGibson and Creator/JoaquinPhoenix. Weird things start happening all over Creator/JoaquinPhoenix.

The story focuses on
the globe. Strange Hess family: faithless former preacher Graham (Gibson), his asthmatic son Morgan (Rory Culkin), his ostensibly autistic daughter Bo (Creator/AbigailBreslin), and his ne'er-do-well younger brother Merrill (Phoenix), a former baseball player. A few short months after the accidental death of his wife, a newly widowed Graham struggles to raise his children with Merrill's help, while also grappling with his newly shaken faith in {{God}}. Having abandoned the priesthood following his wife's death, Graham now lives as a simple farmer in rural Pennsylvania. One day, however, the Hess family's quiet life is shattered by news of a bizarre series of events: crop circles are appearing around the world, radios are picking up strange signals from space, and multiple witnesses report sightings of unearthly creatures, {{crop circles}}, creatures. In the ensuing weeks, the people of the world gradually realize that Earth has been targeted by invaders from another world, and other unexplained phenomena start occurring.advance agents are stealthily infiltrating human civilization as a precursor to all-out invasion.

In a unique twist, however, the ensuing AlienInvasion story is told entirely from the perspective of the Hesses as they attempt to survive the invasion while hiding out on their remote farm. Apart from a single fight scene, there's virtually no action, with the story instead focusing on the sheer panic and terror of an ordinary family caught in the path of an attack by bizarre creatures that they don't understand. To make the story as tense and suspenseful as possible, Shyamalan's direction proudly embraces NothingIsScarier: we only get a few brief glimpses of the aliens, we learn virtually nothing about them (or their motivations), and most of the information about the invasion is relayed via brief snippets of news broadcasts from the Hesses' television (with scenes of mass pandemonium left entirely unseen). At heart, the film is essentially a drama about a widowed father's spiritual crisis as he struggles to interpret a series of enigmatic [[TitleDrop signs]] from above, inspiring him to question whether life has an inherent meaning and purpose.

Notable for being the last of M. Night Shyamalan's films to receive widespread critical acclaim before his reputation as a filmmaker began to decline following the release of ''Film/TheVillage'', it's something of a spiritual successor to his previous efforts ''Film/TheSixthSense'' and ''Film/{{Unbreakable}}'', being a similarly dark and introspective family drama that presents a uniquely unconventional take on a popular genre of speculative fiction. After putting a new spin on [[GhostStory ghost stories]] and {{superhero}}es, ''Signs'' completes the trifecta by tackling [[AlienInvasion alien invasions]]. Like its two predecessors, the film largely eschews flashy action and {{spectacle}} in favor of using the premise as a vehicle for thematic exploration and character studies.


The story focuses on the Hess family, consisting And, of a faithless former preacher, Graham (Gibson), his asthmatic son, Morgan (Rory Culkin), his ostensibly autistic daughter, Bo (Creator/AbigailBreslin) and his ne'er do well younger brother, Merrill (Phoenix), who live in a podunk farmland community. Like the rest of the world, they start thinking that it's an AlienInvasion being done as a stealth infiltration. The entire story is told through this farming family in Pennsylvania as they watch the paranoia grip the world through their television set. Of course, since an off-screen repulsion isn't too dramatic, there's still it ''does'' have a fight scene. Oh, and there's a lot of [[{{Anvilicious}} incredibly blunt]] [[WhatDoYouMeanItsNotSymbolic religious symbolism]], with {{plot twist}} at the story serving more as a story about a man finding his faith in God again as the "signs" start to coalesce.
end.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseTraditionalChristianity: Graham was an Episcopal priest. It's a branch of Christianity with a lot of similarities with Catholicism, but the Confessional isn't one of them. DownPlayed, because it's not called confession, just "clearing my conscience" and Tracey may not have known the difference.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Removing natter


** This is actually lampshaded: when Graham announces they're going to board the windows shut, he's asked how he thinks this will work. WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic famously had a field day with this one.
---> "Because they seem to have trouble with pantry doors."
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear: there's something in Graham's farm menacing him and his family. He tries to board up all the windows and doors in his house to repel the invaders, but they find a way in through the attic. In the midst of this crisis, his son has an asthma attack and nearly suffocates until Graham can calm him down. Then when they think the coast is clear, one of the creatures - who he accidentally maimed - has his unconscious son in his arms, and is preparing to poison him.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* StupidEvil: The {{Epic Fail}}ing aliens. Despite their technological superiority - they choose to just LeeroyJenkins a planet that's KryptoniteIsEverywhere to them.

to:

* StupidEvil: The {{Epic Fail}}ing aliens. Despite their technological superiority - they choose to just LeeroyJenkins a planet that's KryptoniteIsEverywhere to them. Possibly downplayed, since it's possible the aliens are on a supply run rather than actually invading.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntThinkThisThrough: The aliens themselves. They decide to attack a planet whose surface is more than 50 percent water. [[spoiler:Guess what their weakness is?]]

to:

* DidntThinkThisThrough: The aliens themselves. They decide to attack a planet whose surface is more than 50 percent water. [[spoiler:Guess what their weakness is?]]is?]] Possibly justified, as it's not clear whether the aliens are actually invading or just doing their equivalent of a supply run.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* ArtisticLicenseGeography: Despite Shyamalan being from Philadelphia, his version of Bucks County is hilariously wrong, to the point that Bucks residents didn't even ''realize'' it was set in their county initially, let alone the ''county seat.''
** The uniforms the police wear don't look anything like what any officers in Bucks County wear or have ever worn - Sheriffs, deputies, state patrolmen, local police, or anything.
*** To wit: Officers in Bucks all wear blue uniforms, not brown. The jackets they wear are blue windbreakers, not brown with fur trim. They also don't wear wide-brimmed hats; they wear standard police hats, if any hats at all (most don't). Ultimately, the police uniforms seen in the movie look like California outfits, rather than Pennsylvania uniforms.
** There are no large farms at all within the vicinity of Doylestown, as the entire area is much too hilly for proper farming, and by now much too developed.
** There are also no large natural bodies of water within ''miles'' of Doylestown - where that lake came from is anyone's guess.
** While there ''are'' a ludicrous number of trees in Bucks County and Doylestown especially, which give a little privacy, it's also so densely populated that it's literally impossible for a farm to be secluded - there would have been at ''least'' two dozen houses within short walking distance and probably ''line of sight'' of the farmhouse.
** The setting as a whole looks nothing like Bucks County except maybe the northern-most areas; it actually bears more of a striking resemblance to the Poconos about a half-hour farther north.

Changed: 88

Removed: 321

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
not sure where the idea the aliens can't open doors is coming from; we even see them opening the door to the basement at the end; they can't get past locked or blockaded doors, yes, but that's another kettle of fish isn't it?


** The fact they can't even open a damn ''door''. Who knows, maybe they ''have'' become terribly reliant on technological, sliding doors, but all it takes is a basic understanding of levers! Especially given that a wide range of not particularly intelligent Earth animals can work out how to open doors (cats, dogs, etc.)



* InsufficientlyAdvancedAlien: See IdiotBall, also they can't open an unlocked door.

to:

* InsufficientlyAdvancedAlien: See IdiotBall, also they can't open an unlocked door.IdiotBall.



* StupidEvil: The {{Epic Fail}}ing aliens. Despite their technological superiority - they choose to just LeeroyJenkins a planet that's KryptoniteIsEverywhere to them, and they somehow can't even bypass a basic door.

to:

* StupidEvil: The {{Epic Fail}}ing aliens. Despite their technological superiority - they choose to just LeeroyJenkins a planet that's KryptoniteIsEverywhere to them, and they somehow can't even bypass a basic door.them.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* BerserkBoardBarricade: Amidst the alien invasion, Graham and Merrill board up every way to enter their house and it manages to keep the invaders out for a while.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** This is actually lampshaded: when Graham announces they're going to board the windows shut, he's asked how he thinks this will work.

to:

** This is actually lampshaded: when Graham announces they're going to board the windows shut, he's asked how he thinks this will work. WebVideo/TheNostalgiaCritic famously had a field day with this one.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CamouflageChameleon: the aliens have skin that changes patterns to mimic theur surroundings It is detailed enough that it can mimic faces of people standing in front of them on their back.

to:

* CamouflageChameleon: ChameleonCamouflage: the aliens have skin that changes patterns to mimic theur surroundings It is detailed enough that it can mimic faces of people standing in front of them on their back.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* SpitefulGluttony: During the dinner scene, everyone is too upset to eat the dinner Graham made for them all, and Graham covers up his own worries by piling food on his plate and shoveling it down. Finally he can't hide his own fear and breaks down crying with a plateful of mashed potatoes.

Changed: 775

Removed: 1529

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* ArtisticLicenseBiology: The aliens are capable of mastering space travel and being undetectable until planetary approach... yet they lack the intelligence to bring equipment for their "takeover", they seem to have difficulty getting past wooden doors, AND went on a planet that is 71% coated in their number one weakness, ignoring what is present in the atmosphere. This is all important as basic problem-solving is a sign of intelligence, which the aliens SHOULD possess to traverse space but evidently lack in terms of common sense and strategy 101.
** This isn't really an issue with biology, but strategy. It also ignores that the movie states outright at the end that this wasn't an invasion, it was a mass abduction.
** For that matter... what are they bleeding when the water dissolves them? While not all liquids are H[[subscript:2]]O-based, a very large number that can viably exist in a liquid state are.

to:

* ArtisticLicenseBiology: The aliens are capable of mastering space travel and being undetectable until planetary approach... yet they lack the intelligence to bring equipment for their "takeover", they seem to have difficulty getting past wooden doors, AND went on a planet that is 71% coated in their number one weakness, ignoring what is present in the atmosphere. This is all important as basic problem-solving is a sign of intelligence, which the aliens SHOULD possess to traverse space but evidently lack in terms of common sense and strategy 101.
ArtisticLicenseBiology:
** This isn't really an issue with biology, but strategy. It also ignores that the movie states outright at the end that this wasn't an invasion, it was a mass abduction.
** For that matter... what
What are they bleeding when the water dissolves them? While not all liquids are H[[subscript:2]]O-based, a very large number that can viably exist in a liquid state are.



* ArtisticLicenseChemistry: The film reveals that the aliens can only be destroyed by water, as it seems to dissolve them. The problem is that water is NOT naturally acidic or reactive. Water is actually extremely nonreactive unless either rapidly heated, or in contact with an alkali metal: neither of these conditions are met and even if they were, it would result in a more explosive reaction... NOT AN ACIDIC ONE!
** Pure water is pH-neutral, but drinking water from a tap is anything but pure, and is generally slightly towards the acid end of the pH spectrum, as is human skin (and, really, most lifeforms on Earth). The aliens may well be from a planet where everything is shifted toward the alkaline rather than mildly acidic, and so the weak acid of tap water would react exothermically with their skin to form a salt. Though, really, that reaction would still be pretty mild and more likely to cause minor irritation than anything as severe as shown.
** Upon reflection, this trope may actually be somewhat averted as, with all of the symbolism surrounding the aliens, there is a case of AlternateCharacterInterpretation in addition to an AmbiguousSituation as to whether or not these, "aliens," are in fact just demons in disguise. Therefore, if this is indeed the case, water being used against them would make a lot more sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
If the movie isn't listed as such then it's speculation, however probable it may be.


* BasedOnATrueStory or BasedOnAGreatBigLie: While the story doesn't cite itself as such, there are a large number of similarities between ''Signs'' and the "Hopkinsville Goblins" event in 1955. It's quite possible Shyamalan drew on it for inspiration... whether it's a true story or a hoax is largely immaterial to the movie.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

** Upon reflection, this trope may actually be somewhat averted as, with all of the symbolism surrounding the aliens, there is a case of AlternateCharacterInterpretation in addition to an AmbiguousSituation as to whether or not these, "aliens," are in fact just demons in disguise. Therefore, if this is indeed the case, water being used against them would make a lot more sense.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* InfantImmortality: Morgan almost succumbs to a severe asthma attack, but survives.

to:

* InfantImmortality: ImprobableInfantSurvival: Morgan almost succumbs to a severe asthma attack, but survives.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AliensAreBastards: It is an AlienInvasion movie, after all.

to:

* AliensAreBastards: It is an AlienInvasion movie, after all. Fortunately for humanity, though, they also seem to be incredibly stupid.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added: 284

Removed: 357

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** They did a good job of making this seem more like a horror movie. The trailers and teasers almost all had no references to aliens (except for two of them) - the TV spots, moreso than the trailers, makes this seem more like a horror movie. Although this is crop circles, but going by the trailer, one can deduce that monsters with magical powers did them.


Added DiffLines:

* TheyWastedAPerfectlyGoodSandwich: The family sits down to a dinner consisting of their favorite dishes before heading down to the cellar, the idea being it could be their last. An argument breaks out and then the aliens arrive, and all that spaghetti and French toast goes uneaten.

Top