Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Film / Greenland

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* GoodIsNotNice: The US Government knows well ahead of time what is going to happen and stay quiet and even during the crisis there is little sign they are providing words of comfort or hope to the hundreds of millions who are going to die (while NASA gives a formal report to the public near the end there is no indication the president ever does.) However while certainly cold and brusque they (and it is implied other governments) are doing absolutely everything in their power to preserve humanity and they are doing what they have to do stop the evacuation of as many as possible being overwhelmed by mass panic.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Added Shown Their Work entry

Added DiffLines:

* ShownTheirWork: Although it may seem implausible that everyone would feel the impact foreshock long enough before the arrival of the shockwave to let John get outside and take a look, it's actually accurate. Seismic wave propagation through limestone is about 6,000 meters per second[[note]] most of Florida sits on limestone; harder rock like granite is a little slower, but still propagates at about 5,000 m/s[[/note]] while the shockwave would be traveling at the speed of sound, roughly 350 m/s.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** The ending sequence shows that the comet itself slams somewhere into Western Europe (the British Isles from the looks of it), sending a gigantic shockwave rushing across the continent and towards Greenland, yet the aftermath shows Paris destroyed, but still recognizable; in reality, Paris - along with great swathes of Europe - would have quite literally been wiped off the map, leaving nothing but dust and hunks of scattered molten metal and rock.

to:

** The ending sequence shows that the comet itself slams somewhere into Western Europe (the British Isles from the looks of it), Europe, sending a gigantic shockwave rushing across the continent and towards Greenland, yet the aftermath shows Paris destroyed, but still recognizable; in reality, Paris - along with great swathes of Europe - would have quite literally been wiped off the map, leaving nothing but dust and hunks of scattered molten metal and rock.

Added: 4

Removed: 128

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Moving to YMMV.


* RecycledInSpace:
** It's ''Film/TwentyTwelve''... WITH METEORS!
** Also ''Film/DeepImpact'' without the meteor destroying plot.



* ZergRush: The rioters who break through the airbase perimeter and storm the planes use their sheer numbers to counter the military's firepower.

to:

* ZergRush: The rioters who break through the airbase perimeter and storm the planes use their sheer numbers to counter the military's firepower.firepower.
----
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OffscreenKarma: Although Ralph and Judy Vento are never seen again after the military arrests them for abducting Nathan, the script allegedly contains a deleted scene where they are both executed by the military for their crimes.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Also ''Film/{{DeepImpact}}'' without the meteor destroying plot.

to:

** Also ''Film/{{DeepImpact}}'' ''Film/DeepImpact'' without the meteor destroying plot.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Correct misquote


--> '''John:''' How would you feel if this was your family?
--> '''Officer:''' My family wasn't chosen.

to:

--> '''John:''' How would you feel '''Allison:''' What if this was your family?
--> '''Officer:''' My family wasn't chosen.selected, ma'am.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DidntSeeThatComing: Crossing with ArtisticLicenseAstronomy, Clarke is only discovered as a cluster of objects about to impact Earth right as it's arriving in the orbit and one of its pieces (the size of a stadium, mind you) obliterates Florida. Apparently nobody knew this was going to happen, including all of NASA and the people literally watching it, until it landed. The call for evacuees from Homeland Security coming immediately after this disaster is televised provides a subtle hint that the government did indeed see this coming, and was preparing. The public is caught completely by surprise, however.

to:

* DidntSeeThatComing: Crossing with ArtisticLicenseAstronomy, Clarke is only discovered as a cluster of objects about to impact Earth right as it's arriving in the orbit and one of its pieces (the size of a stadium, mind you) obliterates Florida. Apparently nobody knew this was going to happen, including all of NASA and the people literally watching it, until it landed. The call for evacuees from Homeland Security coming immediately after this disaster is televised provides a subtle hint that the government did indeed see this coming, and was preparing. The public is caught completely by surprise, however.

Added: 360

Changed: 157

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* SmallRoleBigImpact: Many characters with important roles in the movie are only onscreen briefly, including another passenger on John's plane who has barely thirty seconds of screen time. He tells John that his nephew got turned away for having a health condition, causing John to realize his family isn't being evacuated and leave the plane to look for them. If not for that other passenger, John would have unknowingly left without them or died during the rioting at the airport.
* StuffBlowingUp: When rocks are falling from space and burning up in the atmosphere, ''and'' they are large enough to reach the ground, this tends to happen.

to:

* SmallRoleBigImpact: Many characters with important roles in the movie are only onscreen briefly, including another passenger on John's plane who has barely thirty seconds of screen time. He tells John that his nephew got turned away for having a health condition, causing John to realize his family isn't being evacuated and leave the plane to look for them. If not for that other passenger, John would have unknowingly left without them or died during the rioting at the airport.airbase.
* StuffBlowingUp: StuffBlowingUp:
**
When rocks are falling from space and burning up in the atmosphere, ''and'' they are large enough to reach the ground, this tends to happen.happen.
** Also happens during the riot at the airbase when stray gunfire ignites a pool of spilled aviation fuel, causing a spectacular chain-reaction of explosions that destroy several transport planes parked on the tarmac.



* ZergRush: The rioters who break through the airport perimeter and storm the planes use their sheer numbers to counter the military's firepower.

to:

* ZergRush: The rioters who break through the airport airbase perimeter and storm the planes use their sheer numbers to counter the military's firepower.

Added: 626

Changed: 258

Removed: 566

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:


* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: A bigoted man and his buddy try to steal John's wristband so that he could get on a flight to Greenland. John kills him, and the asshole's buddy doesn't try to keep fighting.]]
** [[spoiler: Ralph may qualify as well, as he's last seen being arrested by the military for kidnapping a child and posing as his father just to be given a selfish chance at survival, which means he almost certainly didn't make it to a safe location in time before the comet struck the Earth. It's unfortunate that his wife, who never agreed with his plan and was forced to go along with it, ended up collateral damage.]]
* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy: Despite being one of the more grounded space-based disaster films, there are still a few awkward points to be found:

to:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: A bigoted man and his buddy try to steal John's wristband so that he could get on a flight to Greenland. John kills him, and the asshole's buddy doesn't try to keep fighting.]]
** [[spoiler: Ralph may qualify as well, as he's last seen being arrested by the military for kidnapping a child and posing as his father just to be given a selfish chance at survival, which means he almost certainly didn't make it to a safe location in time before the comet struck the Earth. It's unfortunate that his wife, who never agreed with his plan and was forced to go along with it, ended up collateral damage.]]
* ArtisticLicenseAstronomy:
ArtisticLicenseSpace: Despite being one of the more grounded space-based disaster films, there are still a few awkward points to be found:


Added DiffLines:

* AssholeVictim: [[spoiler: A bigoted man and his buddy try to steal John's wristband so that he could get on a flight to Greenland. John kills him, and the asshole's buddy doesn't try to keep fighting.]]
** [[spoiler: Ralph may qualify as well, as he's last seen being arrested by the military for kidnapping a child and posing as his father just to be given a selfish chance at survival, which means he almost certainly didn't make it to a safe location in time before the comet struck the Earth. It's unfortunate that his wife, who never agreed with his plan and was forced to go along with it, ended up collateral damage.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* TheElitesJumpShip: Referenced and downplayed. When the government selects people to be evacuated to shelters before a ColonyDrop, Ralph complains that they're probably all rich people. Actually, the government is picking people based on their skills to rebuild society (and none of them have any idea the evacuation is going on until right before the cataclysm). Still, at least some of them (such as John, a building engineer with a nice house, and Colin's mother, a doctor) have jobs with upper-class incomes, which is usually the cast for high-valued jobs such as doctors and engineers.

to:

* TheElitesJumpShip: Referenced and downplayed. When the government selects people to be evacuated to shelters before a ColonyDrop, Ralph complains that they're probably all rich people. Actually, the government is picking people based on their skills to rebuild society (and none of them have any idea the evacuation is going on until right before the cataclysm). Still, at least some of them (such as John, a building engineer with a nice house, and Colin's mother, a doctor) have jobs with upper-class incomes, which is usually the cast case for high-valued jobs such as doctors and engineers.

Added: 695

Changed: 378

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CellPhonesAreUseless: They certainly will be when the system is overwhelmed by huge numbers of users attempting to call and text each other. John even lampshades this, saying that this stuff should work in case of an emergency. It also becomes a problem when [[spoiler: Allison and Nathan are turned away from the plane and forced back to the car. Her text doesn't reach him, so she leaves him a written note]].



* TheElitesJumpShip: Referenced and downplayed. When the government selects people to be evacuated to shelters before a ColonyDrop, Ralph complains that they're probably all rich people. Actually, the government is picking people based on their skills to rebuild society (and none of them have any idea the evacuation is going on until right before the cataclysm). Still, at least some of them (such as John, a building engineer with a nice house, and Colin's mother, a doctor) have jobs with upper-class incomes.

to:

* TheElitesJumpShip: Referenced and downplayed. When the government selects people to be evacuated to shelters before a ColonyDrop, Ralph complains that they're probably all rich people. Actually, the government is picking people based on their skills to rebuild society (and none of them have any idea the evacuation is going on until right before the cataclysm). Still, at least some of them (such as John, a building engineer with a nice house, and Colin's mother, a doctor) have jobs with upper-class incomes.incomes, which is usually the cast for high-valued jobs such as doctors and engineers.



* MilitariesAreUseless: Averted. The militaries of not just the United States, but of the world do ''everything'' in their power to try and preserve humanity. They can't do anything to stop a comet cluster from striking the planet, but they [[spoiler: successfully ensure that many humans survive the calamity]].

to:

* MilitariesAreUseless: Averted.
**
The militaries of not just the United States, but of the world do ''everything'' in their power to try and preserve humanity. They can't do anything to stop a comet cluster from striking the planet, but they [[spoiler: successfully ensure that many humans survive the calamity]].



* RelationshipSalvagingDisaster: John and Allison's marriage was on the rocks due to his cheating on her. Fortunately, they reconciled shortly before leaving for Greenland.

to:

* RelationshipSalvagingDisaster: John and Allison's marriage was on the rocks and made even worse due to his cheating on her. Fortunately, they reconciled shortly before leaving for Greenland.

Top