Follow TV Tropes

Following

History Fanfic / WhiteMagnoliaPinkChrysanthemum

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Need more context.


* DudeLooksLikeALady: Ping.

to:

* %%* DudeLooksLikeALady: Ping.



* JerkAss: Chi-Fu, as usual.

to:

* %%* JerkAss: Chi-Fu, as usual.



* TitleDrop

to:

* %%* TitleDrop
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being so close to Ping. That is because Fang is a fan of Ping's his opera performances.

to:

* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being so close to Ping. That is because Fang is a fan of Ping's his opera performances.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping. When actually, Fang was praising him for his opera performances.

to:

* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with so close to Ping. When actually, That is because Fang was praising him for is a fan of Ping's his opera performances.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* DeathByChildbirth: [[spoiler:Quinmei falls ill during her pregnancy, leading to her death after giving birth to Shang's twins.]]


Added DiffLines:

** [[spoiler:Quinmei.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* OutlivingOnesOffspring: [[spoiler: Zhou and Zanjun were devastated when they got news that Minling was killed in battle. So they assume the same with Ping, until he returned home.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Dewicked trope


* AdultFear: [[spoiler: Zhou and Zanjun were devastated when they got news that Minling was killed in battle. So they assume the worst with Ping, until he returned home.]]

Added: 27

Removed: 27

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* DudeLooksLikeALady: Ping.



* LadyLooksLikeADude: Ping.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, "Mushu" was the name of Grandmother's husband. Ling is the one who the apple in the arrow as a prank to get Ping in trouble with Shang.

to:

** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, "Mushu" was the name of Grandmother's husband. Ling is the one who put the apple in the arrow as a prank to get Ping in trouble with Shang.



** Ping has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]] Although some versions of Mulan tale mentions her having a little brother, while others mention a sister; so Minling could be a nod to the protagonist having a sibling.

to:

** Ping has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]] Although some versions of Mulan Mulan's tale mentions her having a little brother, while others mention a sister; so Minling could be a nod to the protagonist having a sibling.



* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels that he's let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

to:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels that he's let he disappointed his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

Added: 62

Changed: 44

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AllGaysArePromiscuous: Shang and Ping enjoy each other's company.

to:

* AllGaysArePromiscuous: Shang and Ping enjoy each other's company.company, and can never get enough.



* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping. When actually Fang was praising him for his opera performances.

to:

* CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping. When actually actually, Fang was praising him for his opera performances.



* LadyLooksLikeADude: Ping.
* LongHairedPrettyBoy: Ping, again.



* MythologyGag: The name "Mulan" is heard throughout the fanfic. It was the name Ping was intended to be called when his parents thought their second child would be a girl. At one point, Ping wished he was a woman but realize he'd be lousy, basically describing Mulan in the film. [[spoiler:Ping named one of Shang and Quinmei's twins Mulan.]]

to:

* MythologyGag: The name "Mulan" is heard throughout the fanfic. It was the name Ping was intended to be called when his parents thought their second child would be a girl. At one point, Ping wished he was a woman but realize he'd be lousy, basically describing Mulan in at the start of the film. [[spoiler:Ping named one of Shang and Quinmei's twins Mulan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* ClingyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping.

to:

* ClingyJealousGuy: CrazyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping.Ping. When actually Fang was praising him for his opera performances.

Added: 552

Changed: 296

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, "Mushu" was the name of Grandmother's husband.

to:

** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, "Mushu" was the name of Grandmother's husband. Ling is the one who the apple in the arrow as a prank to get Ping in trouble with Shang.



* ClingyJealousGuy: Shang, when he noticed his second-lieutenant Fang being all chummy with Ping.



* DemotedToExtra: Shan-Yu and the Huns. Due to the fanfic focusing more on Ping and Shane’s growing relationship.

to:

* DemotedToExtra: Shan-Yu and the Huns. Due to the fanfic focusing more on Ping and Shane’s Shang's growing relationship.



* OriginalCharacter: Ping has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]]

to:

* OriginalCharacter: OriginalCharacter:
**
Ping has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]]]] Although some versions of Mulan tale mentions her having a little brother, while others mention a sister; so Minling could be a nod to the protagonist having a sibling.
** Fang, second lieutenant in the army, who's a big fan of Ping's performances.



* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels that he’s let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

to:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels that he’s he's let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

Added: 266

Changed: 93

Removed: 161

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationRelationshipOverhaul: Fa Zhou and General Li are close friends here, while they presumably never met in person in canon.
* AdaptationalNiceGuy: Yao, Ling, and Chien Po were much nicer to Ping upon their introductions. Though Yao and Ling still tease Ping and play pranks upon him.

to:

* AdaptationRelationshipOverhaul: Fa Zhou and General Li are close friends here, while they presumably never met in person in canon.
canon. Which results in Ping meeting Shang sooner than Mulan would in the film.
* AdaptationalNiceGuy: Yao, Ling, and Chien Po were much nicer to Ping upon their introductions. Though Yao and Ling still tease Ping and play pranks upon on him.



* DemotedToExtra: Shan-Yu and the Huns. Due to the fanfic focusing more on Ping and Shane’s growing relationship.



* JerkassBall: Due to the stress of training the men, Shang vents most of his frustration onto Ping, when it's clear that he's unfit to become a soldier.



** General Li appears to accept his son has feelings for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue their family lineage.
* OriginalCharacter: Ping (male Mulan) has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]]

to:

** General Li appears to accept his son has having feelings for Ping. But he also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue their family lineage.
* OriginalCharacter: Ping (male Mulan) has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]]



* TookALevelInJerkass: Due to the stress of training the men, Shang vents most of his frustration onto Ping, when it's clear that he's unfit to become a soldier.



* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels he’s let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

to:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels that he’s let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.

Added: 165

Changed: 41

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''White Magnolia, Pink Chrysanthemum'' is a ''WesternAnimation/{{Mulan}}'' AU fanfic, where Mulan is male.

to:

''White Magnolia, Pink Chrysanthemum'' is a ''WesternAnimation/{{Mulan}}'' AU fanfic, where Mulan is male.
born as a man named Ping.



** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, it was the name of Grandmother's husband.

to:

** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, it "Mushu" was the name of Grandmother's husband.



** General Li appears to accept his son has love for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue their family lineage.

to:

** General Li appears to accept his son has love feelings for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue their family lineage.


Added DiffLines:

* WellDoneSonGuy: Ping sometimes feels he’s let his parents down for not being the son they wanted. Being a famous nándàn is his way of bringing honor to his family.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* EveryoneCanSeeIt: General Li, Grandmother Fa, and all the men at the training camp can tell there's something going o between Ping and Shang.

to:

* EveryoneCanSeeIt: General Li, Grandmother Fa, and all the men at the training camp can tell there's something going o on between Ping and Shang.

Added: 761

Changed: 138

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* AdaptationalNiceGuy: Yao, Ling, and Chien Po were much nicer to Ping upon their introductions. Though Yao and Ling still tease Ping and play pranks upon him.



* AllGaysArePromiscuous: Shang and Ping enjoy each other's company.



* DeathByAdaptation: [[spoiler:Grandmother Fa passed away at the end of the fic.]]



* EveryoneCanSeeIt: General Li, Grandmother Fa, and all the men at the training camp can tell there's something going o between Ping and Shang.



* KnewItAllAlong: It's revealed that Ping's parents were told by a fortune teller that their second child would be a girl. But Grandmother Fa didn't believe in the “quack”, and guessed correctly that he'd be a boy.

to:

* KnewItAllAlong: It's revealed that Ping's parents were told by a fortune teller that their second child would be a girl. But Grandmother Fa didn't believe in the “quack”, "quack", and guessed correctly that he'd be a boy.



* MythologyGag: The name “Mulan” is heard throughout the fanfic. It was the name Ping was intended to be called when his parents thought their second child would be a girl. At one point, Ping wished he was a woman so he and Shang could marry. [[spoiler:Ping named one of Shang and Quinmei's twins Mulan.]]

to:

* MythologyGag: The name “Mulan” "Mulan" is heard throughout the fanfic. It was the name Ping was intended to be called when his parents thought their second child would be a girl. At one point, Ping wished he was a woman so he and Shang could marry.but realize he'd be lousy, basically describing Mulan in the film. [[spoiler:Ping named one of Shang and Quinmei's twins Mulan.]]



** Grandmother Fa, as she supports Ping's relationship with Shang. Though she warns Shang to treat her grandson right with a FreudianThreat.

to:

** Grandmother Fa, as she supports Ping's relationship with Shang. Though she warns Shang to treat her grandson right with or she'll return as a FreudianThreat.ghost and have her ancestors upon him.



* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Not a villain, but still a jerk. Chi-Fu is disgusted with Ping's lifestyle choice. Even calls him a "whore".

to:

* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Not a villain, but still a jerk. Chi-Fu is disgusted with Ping's lifestyle choice. Even choice, even calls him a "whore".


Added DiffLines:

* TookALevelInJerkass: Due to the stress of training the men, Shang vents most of his frustration onto Ping, when it's clear that he's unfit to become a soldier.
* UnfortunateName: Yao and Ling laugh at Ping's full name.
-->'''Ping:''' ''(after being told why it's funny)'' Oh gods! Why am I a joke to you, gods?

Added: 519

Changed: 90

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


** Little Brother and Cri-Kee doesn't appear either.

to:

** Little Brother and Cri-Kee doesn't appear either. [[spoiler: Although Little Brother shows up as the pet of Shang and Quinmei's children.]]


Added DiffLines:

* KnewItAllAlong: It's revealed that Ping's parents were told by a fortune teller that their second child would be a girl. But Grandmother Fa didn't believe in the “quack”, and guessed correctly that he'd be a boy.


Added DiffLines:

* MythologyGag: The name “Mulan” is heard throughout the fanfic. It was the name Ping was intended to be called when his parents thought their second child would be a girl. At one point, Ping wished he was a woman so he and Shang could marry. [[spoiler:Ping named one of Shang and Quinmei's twins Mulan.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


''White Magnolia, Pink Chrysanthemum'' is a ''WesternAnimation/{{Mulan}}'' fanfic, where Mulan is male.

to:

''White Magnolia, Pink Chrysanthemum'' is a ''WesternAnimation/{{Mulan}}'' AU fanfic, where Mulan is male.



** [[spoiler: The Emperor reveals to Shang that he himself was once in love with a man (the general who trained Shang's father), but had to marry his bride to continue the lineage of the royal family.]]

to:

** [[spoiler: The Emperor reveals to Shang that he himself was once in love with a man (the (a general who trained Shang's father), but had to marry his bride to continue the lineage of the royal family.]]



** General Li appears to accept his son has love for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue the family legacy.

to:

** General Li appears to accept his son has love for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue the their family legacy.lineage.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

''White Magnolia, Pink Chrysanthemum'' is a ''WesternAnimation/{{Mulan}}'' fanfic, where Mulan is male.

Read [[https://www.fanfiction.net/s/12042041/1/White-Magnolia-Pink-Chrysanthemum here]].
----
!!This fanfiction contains examples of:
* AdaptedOut:
** Mushu doesn't appear here. Instead, it was the name of Grandmother's husband.
** Little Brother and Cri-Kee doesn't appear either.
* AdaptationRelationshipOverhaul: Fa Zhou and General Li are close friends here, while they presumably never met in person in canon.
* AdaptationalSexuality:
** Shang is gay here, and thus falls in love with Ping.
** [[spoiler: The Emperor reveals to Shang that he himself was once in love with a man (the general who trained Shang's father), but had to marry his bride to continue the lineage of the royal family.]]
* AdultFear: [[spoiler: Zhou and Zanjun were devastated when they got news that Minling was killed in battle. So they assume the worst with Ping, until he returned home.]]
* TheBeard: [[spoiler:Shang's wife Quinmei.]]
* CrosscastRole: InUniverse, Ping is a nándàn, which is a male opera actor who performs female roles.
* DoomedByCanon: [[spoiler: General Li still gets killed by the Huns.]]
* GenderFlip: Mulan is born a man, and his name is Ping.
* JerkAss: Chi-Fu, as usual.
* KissOfDistraction: [[spoiler:While disguised as one of the Emperor's concubine,]] Ping [[spoiler:kisses Shan-Yu on the lips to both stop him from trying to kill the Emperor and to allow Shang to sneak from behind.]] Shang was briefly shocked, and shuddered at the display.
* LoveAtFirstSight: Shang falls in love Ping the moment he saw him on stage, dressed as a woman and singing.
* MasculineFeminineGayCouple: Shang and Ping.
* NamedByTheAdaptation: [[spoiler: Fa Li is named Zanjun. In Chinese culture, women keep their surnames upon marriage, though Fa Li has the same surname as her husband.]]
* OpenSecret: The men at training camp become aware of Shang and Ping's relationship.
* OpenMindedParent:
** Grandmother Fa, as she supports Ping's relationship with Shang. Though she warns Shang to treat her grandson right with a FreudianThreat.
** General Li appears to accept his son has love for Ping. But also tells him that he must marry a wife to bear a son to continue the family legacy.
* OriginalCharacter: Ping (male Mulan) has an older brother named Minling. He is said to have joined the army in his wife's family's behalf, forcing Ping to join the army on his father's behalf. [[spoiler:Sadly, he was killed in battle.]]
* PoliticallyIncorrectVillain: Not a villain, but still a jerk. Chi-Fu is disgusted with Ping's lifestyle choice. Even calls him a "whore".
* RagingStiffie: We get a lot of descriptions of Shang and Ping getting hard for each other.
* ShipperOnDeck: [[spoiler: The Emperor notices the attraction between Shang and Ping, and approves of their relationship.]]
* TitleDrop
* UngratefulBastard: Like in the film, Chi-Fu doesn't thank Ping for saving China. Even accuses him of [[InsaneTrollLogic making a deliberate attempt at his life]].
----

Top