Follow TV Tropes

Following

History AssholeVictim / ASongOfIceAndFire

Go To

OR

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Similar to the Mountain's Men, the Brave Companions, a [[PsychoForHire particularly vile sellsword company]], nicknamed the [[MonsterClown Bloody Mummers]], where every member shows themselves to be utterly evil, however they are getting picked off as they are hunted down for their war crimes. Their leader Vargo Hoat is an AxeCrazy {{Sadist}} who enjoys cutting off limbs, and [[DeathByIrony ends up having pieces cut off over days]] by the Mountain. One of the nastiest appears to be Rorge, a pedophile rapist who takes part in [[RapePillageAndBurn the Sack of Saltpans]], where a town's population is massacred and raped by a group of the Mummers. He ends up being killed by Brienne when he threatens a group of war orphans, ironic for a HeManWomanHater.

to:

* Similar to the Mountain's Men, the Brave Companions, a [[PsychoForHire particularly vile sellsword company]], nicknamed the [[MonsterClown Bloody Mummers]], where every member shows themselves to be utterly evil, however they are getting picked off as they are hunted down for their war crimes. Their leader Vargo Hoat is an AxeCrazy AxCrazy {{Sadist}} who enjoys cutting off limbs, and [[DeathByIrony ends up having pieces cut off over days]] by the Mountain. One of the nastiest appears to be Rorge, a pedophile rapist who takes part in [[RapePillageAndBurn the Sack of Saltpans]], where a town's population is massacred and raped by a group of the Mummers. He ends up being killed by Brienne when he threatens a group of war orphans, ironic for a HeManWomanHater.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'',Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and then serving your own dad as pretty much a galley slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy and "we don't want to know" if a girl...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'',Falia ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, afterwards she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, And for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and then serving your own dad as pretty much a galley slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy and "we don't want to know" if a girl...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
Cinderella Circumstances has become a disambig


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and then serving your own dad as pretty much a galley slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy and "we don't want to know" if a girl...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'',Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and then serving your own dad as pretty much a galley slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy and "we don't want to know" if a girl...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] or assholes being assholes to other assholes thus creating bigger or more broken assholes... means that it is somewhat inevitable[[note]]For victims from the TV Series, [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones go here.]][[/note]]:

to:

Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is very fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] or assholes being assholes to other assholes thus creating bigger or more broken assholes... means that it is somewhat inevitable[[note]]For victims from the TV Series, [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones go here.]][[/note]]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Most of the Freys who wind up dead in the story (with the exception of the decent Ser Stevron Frey and his disabled son Aegon "Jinglebell" Frey), especially after the [[DisproportionateRetribution Red]] [[DiabolusExMachina Wedding.]]

to:

* Most of the Freys who wind up dead in the story (with the exception exceptions of the decent Ser Stevron Frey and his disabled son Aegon "Jinglebell" Frey), Frey, [[JustAKid Tion Frey]], and the young Frey children killed by the Brotherhood on Lady Stoneheart’s order), especially after the [[DisproportionateRetribution Red]] [[DiabolusExMachina Wedding.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Balon Greyjoy, the brutal ruler of the Iron Islands who have a culture of cruel piracy, attacks the North when its ruler Robb Stark offers an alliance with him and sends back his only surviving son Theon. Balon shows no affection to the son who he hadn't seen in nine years and acts horribly towards him, thinking him too weak to inherit rule. Balon ends up falling from a bridge during a storm, though it is widely believed the nastiest of the Greyjoy brothers [[EvilOverlord Euron]] [[EvilVsEvil may have been]] [[CainAndAbel responsible]].

to:

* Balon Greyjoy, the brutal ruler of the Iron Islands who have a culture of cruel piracy, attacks the North when its ruler Robb Stark offers an alliance with him and sends back his only surviving son Theon. Balon shows no affection to the son who he hadn't seen in nine years and acts horribly towards him, thinking him too weak to inherit rule. Balon ends up falling from a bridge during a storm, though it is widely believed the nastiest of the Greyjoy brothers [[EvilOverlord Euron]] [[EvilVsEvil [[EvilVersusEvil may have been]] [[CainAndAbel responsible]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


*** [[DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale Lysa had also raped Petyr at least once]] (he was drunk after being rejected by Catelyn, and even [[WrongNameOutburst called Lysa "Cat" while they were having sex]]), and possibly twice (after Petyr had been [[DudeShesLikeInAComa gravely wounded]], possibly [[QuestionableConsent compromising his ability to knowingly consent]]), making her even more unlikeable.

to:

*** ** [[DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale Lysa had also raped Petyr at least once]] (he was drunk after being rejected by Catelyn, and even [[WrongNameOutburst called Lysa "Cat" while they were having sex]]), and possibly twice (after Petyr had been [[DudeShesLikeInAComa gravely wounded]], possibly [[QuestionableConsent compromising his ability to knowingly consent]]), making her even more unlikeable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon ''did'' a lot of awful stuff upon taking Winterfell. Including allowing two children to be killed to both try to cover his own ass and intimidate everybody into backing down when the Stark children actually escaped. Worse, these weren't two random boys; he actually knew them, because he regularly *cough* visited *cough* their mother at their home, and he knew they were about the right ages to pass. Do some mathematics.

to:

* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon ''did'' a lot of awful stuff upon taking Winterfell. Including (but not restricted to) allowing two children to be killed to both try to cover his own ass and intimidate everybody into backing down when the Stark children actually escaped. Worse, these weren't two random boys; he actually knew them, them both, because he regularly *cough* visited *cough* their mother at their home, and he knew they were about the right ages to pass. [[MamasBabyPapasMaybe Do some mathematics.of the mathematics that Theon shys away from thinking about]], particularly for the younger one...
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon ''did'' a lot of awful stuff upon taking Winterfell. Including allowing two children to be killed to both try to cover his own ass and intimidate everybody into backing down when the Stark children actually escaped. Worse, these weten't two random boys; he actually knew them, because he regularly *cough* visited *cough* their mother at their home, and he knew they were about the right ages to pass. Do some mathematics.

to:

* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon ''did'' a lot of awful stuff upon taking Winterfell. Including allowing two children to be killed to both try to cover his own ass and intimidate everybody into backing down when the Stark children actually escaped. Worse, these weten't weren't two random boys; he actually knew them, because he regularly *cough* visited *cough* their mother at their home, and he knew they were about the right ages to pass. Do some mathematics.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Almost every Frey killed that we've seen has been an asshole in some way. Little Walder bullied Bran and Rickon, and was later killed by someone during ''Dance''; Petyr and Merrett Frey, who participated in the Red Wedding, are captured and hung by Lady Stoneheart and the Brotherhood Without Banners at the end of ''Storm''; Rhaegar, Jared, and Symond Frey belittle Davos Seaworth and feed the lie about how the Starks were all shapeshifting wargs and the Red Wedding was all a misunderstanding, and they are killed and cooked into meat pies that Lord Wyman Manderly feeds to the guests of Ramsay Bolton's and "Arya Stark"'s wedding in ''Dance''; and Aenys Frey, who is no shortage of abusive to everyone who looks down on them for the Red Wedding, is caught in a trap by Mors Umber and is slain in a POV preview chapter from ''Winds''.

to:

* Almost every Frey killed that we've seen has been an asshole in some way. Little Walder bullied Bran and Rickon, and was later killed by someone during ''Dance''; ''Dance'' (possibly by his cousin Big Walder, who is actually one of the most likeable Freys); Petyr and Merrett Frey, who participated in the Red Wedding, are captured and hung by Lady Stoneheart and the Brotherhood Without Banners at the end of ''Storm''; Rhaegar, Jared, and Symond Frey belittle Davos Seaworth and feed the lie about how the Starks were all shapeshifting wargs and the Red Wedding was all a misunderstanding, and they are killed and cooked into meat pies that Lord Wyman Manderly feeds to the guests of Ramsay Bolton's and "Arya Stark"'s wedding in ''Dance''; and Aenys Frey, who is no shortage of abusive to everyone who looks down on them for the Red Wedding, is caught in a trap by Mors Umber and is slain in a POV preview chapter from ''Winds''.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Most of the Freys who winds up dead in the story (with the exception of the decent Ser Stevron Frey and his disabled son Aegon "Jinglebell" Frey), especially after the [[DisproportionateRetribution Red]] [[DiabolusExMachina Wedding.]]

to:

* Most of the Freys who winds wind up dead in the story (with the exception of the decent Ser Stevron Frey and his disabled son Aegon "Jinglebell" Frey), especially after the [[DisproportionateRetribution Red]] [[DiabolusExMachina Wedding.]]
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tyrion Lannister killing his father Tywin at the end of ''Literature/AStormOfSwords''. Tywin kinda had it coming in general. The ''specific'' thing that sent Tyrion after him? Orchestrating the gang-rape of Tyrion's first wife, just because she was a commoner.

to:

* Tyrion Lannister killing his father Tywin at the end of ''Literature/AStormOfSwords''. Tywin kinda had it coming in general. The ''specific'' thing that sent Tyrion after him? Orchestrating the gang-rape of Tyrion's first wife, just because she was a commoner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Renly Baratheon, who gives off the image of TheGoodKing, but seems a {{Deconstruction}} of it, showing himself to be more TheEvilPrince, being vain, mockingly unpleasant to unattractive people such as the [[UndyingLoyalty loyal]] but unattractive woman Brienne of Tarth and his disfigured niece Shireen Baratheon, and trying to usurp the Iron Throne after his eldest brother's death basically just because he is arrogant and can put on a [[VillainWithGoodPublicity good image]]. It's even implied Renly may be aware of the illegitimacy of the Queen's children, meaning he knows his brother Stannis is the rightful heir. When Stannis offers to make an alliance with him, saying he'll make him his heir until he has a son (which is unlikely meaning Renly will probably become King anyway), along with letting him keep his positions as Lord of Storm's End and Master of Laws on the Small Council, Renly sneeringly mocks Stannis for not being as charismatic and insults Stannis' daughter because of her unattractive appearance, basically saying he'll take the throne as [[MightMakesRight he has the bigger army]], talking of [[CainAndAbel killing Stannis while showing little remorse]]. He ends up getting murdered the night before the battle by a shadow assassin birthed by his brother's sorceress Melisandre.

to:

* Renly Baratheon, who gives off the image of TheGoodKing, but seems a {{Deconstruction}} of it, showing himself to be more TheEvilPrince, being vain, vain and mockingly unpleasant to unattractive people such as the [[UndyingLoyalty loyal]] but unattractive woman Brienne of Tarth and his disfigured niece Shireen Baratheon, and trying to usurp the Iron Throne after his eldest brother's death basically just because he is arrogant and can put on a [[VillainWithGoodPublicity good image]]. It's even implied Renly may be aware of the illegitimacy of the Queen's children, meaning he knows his brother Stannis is the rightful heir. When Stannis offers to make an alliance with him, saying he'll make him his heir until he has a son (which is unlikely meaning Renly will probably become King anyway), along with letting him keep his positions as Lord of Storm's End and Master of Laws on the Small Council, Renly sneeringly mocks Stannis for not being as charismatic and insults Stannis' daughter because of her unattractive appearance, basically saying he'll take the throne as [[MightMakesRight he has the bigger army]], talking of [[CainAndAbel killing Stannis while showing little remorse]]. He ends up getting murdered the night before the battle by a shadow assassin birthed by his brother's sorceress Melisandre.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Similar to the Mountain's Men, the Brave Companions, a [[PsychoForHire particularly vile sellsword company]], nicknamed the [[MonsterClown Bloody Mummers]], where every member shows themselves to be utterly evil, however they are getting picked off as they are hunted down for their war crimes. Their leader Vargo Hoat, is an AxeCrazy {{Sadist}} who enjoys cutting off limbs, and [[DeathByIrony ends up having pieces cut off over days]] by the Mountain. One of the nastiest appears to be Rorge, a pedophile rapist who takes part in [[RapePillageAndBurn the Sack of Saltpans]], where a town's population is massacred and raped by a group of the Mummers. He ends up being killed by Brienne when he threatens a group of war orphans, ironic for a HeManWomanHater.
* Balon Greyjoy, the brutal ruler of the Iron Islands who have a culture of cruel piracy and attacks the North when its ruler Robb Stark offers an alliance with him and sends back his only surviving son Theon. Balon shows no affection to the son who he hadn't seen in nine years and acts horribly towards him, thinking him too weak to inherit rule. Balon ends up falling from a bridge during a storm, though it is widely believed the nastiest of the Greyjoy brothers [[EvilOverlord Euron]] [[EvilVsEvil may have been]] [[CainAndAbel responsible]].

to:

* Similar to the Mountain's Men, the Brave Companions, a [[PsychoForHire particularly vile sellsword company]], nicknamed the [[MonsterClown Bloody Mummers]], where every member shows themselves to be utterly evil, however they are getting picked off as they are hunted down for their war crimes. Their leader Vargo Hoat, Hoat is an AxeCrazy {{Sadist}} who enjoys cutting off limbs, and [[DeathByIrony ends up having pieces cut off over days]] by the Mountain. One of the nastiest appears to be Rorge, a pedophile rapist who takes part in [[RapePillageAndBurn the Sack of Saltpans]], where a town's population is massacred and raped by a group of the Mummers. He ends up being killed by Brienne when he threatens a group of war orphans, ironic for a HeManWomanHater.
* Balon Greyjoy, the brutal ruler of the Iron Islands who have a culture of cruel piracy and piracy, attacks the North when its ruler Robb Stark offers an alliance with him and sends back his only surviving son Theon. Balon shows no affection to the son who he hadn't seen in nine years and acts horribly towards him, thinking him too weak to inherit rule. Balon ends up falling from a bridge during a storm, though it is widely believed the nastiest of the Greyjoy brothers [[EvilOverlord Euron]] [[EvilVsEvil may have been]] [[CainAndAbel responsible]].
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon did allow two children to be killed try and cover his own ass when the Stark children escaped.

to:

* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon did allow ''did'' a lot of awful stuff upon taking Winterfell. Including allowing two children to be killed to both try and to cover his own ass and intimidate everybody into backing down when the Stark children escaped.actually escaped. Worse, these weten't two random boys; he actually knew them, because he regularly *cough* visited *cough* their mother at their home, and he knew they were about the right ages to pass. Do some mathematics.

Added: 399

Changed: 34

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* In ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'' Sansa and Littlefinger frame the singer Marillion for a murder Littlefinger committed. It's hard for the reader to feel too bad since Marillion previously tried to rape Sansa. Said murder victim also helped Littlefinger poison her husband and manipulate her sister, eventually starting a war, and was threatening to kill a young girl, [[EvilAunt her niece]], whom she thought was seducing her husband, so she counts as well.

to:

* In ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'' Sansa and Littlefinger frame the singer Marillion for a murder Littlefinger committed. It's hard for the reader to feel too bad since Marillion previously tried to rape Sansa. Said murder victim also helped Littlefinger poison her husband and manipulate her sister, eventually starting a war, and was threatening to kill a young girl, [[EvilAunt her niece]], whom she thought was seducing her husband, so she counts she's pretty hard to sympathize with as well.well.
*** [[DoubleStandardRapeFemaleOnMale Lysa had also raped Petyr at least once]] (he was drunk after being rejected by Catelyn, and even [[WrongNameOutburst called Lysa "Cat" while they were having sex]]), and possibly twice (after Petyr had been [[DudeShesLikeInAComa gravely wounded]], possibly [[QuestionableConsent compromising his ability to knowingly consent]]), making her even more unlikeable.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable[[note]]For victims from the TV Series, [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones go here.]][[/note]]:

to:

Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] or assholes being assholes to other assholes thus creating bigger or more broken assholes... means that it is somewhat inevitable[[note]]For victims from the TV Series, [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones go here.]][[/note]]:



* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and serving your own dad as pretty a slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and then serving your own dad as pretty much a galley slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy...boy and "we don't want to know" if a girl...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable:

to:

Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable:
inevitable[[note]]For victims from the TV Series, [[AssholeVictim/GameOfThrones go here.]][[/note]]:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Tyrion Lannister killing his father Tywin at the end of ''Literature/AStormOfSwords''. Tywin kinda had it coming.

to:

* Tyrion Lannister killing his father Tywin at the end of ''Literature/AStormOfSwords''. Tywin kinda had it coming.coming in general. The ''specific'' thing that sent Tyrion after him? Orchestrating the gang-rape of Tyrion's first wife, just because she was a commoner.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost. Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost.lost (except for her unborn child: mind you, with the likely alternative of "getting born, getting your tongue ripped out and serving your own dad as pretty a slave for the rest of your tortured life" on the cards if born a boy...). Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "So Not Prince Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon did double-cross the Starks and attacked Winterfell, where at one point he killed two children to try and cover his own ass when the Stark children escaped.

to:

* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon did double-cross the Starks and attacked Winterfell, where at one point he killed allow two children to be killed try and cover his own ass when the Stark children escaped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* Viserys Targaryen spent much of his backstory psychologically (and it's implied, physically) abusing his sister Daenerys during their exile. When Dany marries Drogo and journies with him to the Dothraki Sea, Viserys spends all of his time complaining and making threats against everyone for not getting what he wanted immediately, eventually being humiliated by Drogo in front of his ''khalasar''. This led to him getting himself drunk and [[BullyingADragon threatening Daenerys' unborn child in front of Drogo]] as yet another threat to do what he wanted. Drogo responded by dumping a pot of molten gold on him, and it is described in all of its grisly glory.

to:

* Viserys Targaryen spent much of his backstory psychologically (and it's implied, physically) abusing his sister Daenerys during their exile. When Dany marries Khal Drogo and journies journeys with him to the Dothraki Sea, Viserys spends all of his time complaining and making threats against everyone for not getting what he wanted immediately, eventually being humiliated by Drogo in front of his ''khalasar''. This led to him getting himself drunk and [[BullyingADragon threatening Daenerys' unborn child in front of Drogo]] as yet another threat to do what he wanted. Drogo responded by dumping a pot of molten gold on him, and it is described in all of its grisly glory.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Viserys Targaryen spent much of his backstory psychologically (and it's implied, physically) abusing his sister Daenerys during their exile. When Dany marries Drogo and journies with him to the Dothraki Sea, Viserys spends all of his time complaining and making threats against everyone for not getting what he wanted immediately, eventually being humiliated by Drogo in front of his ''khalasar''. This led to him getting himself drunk and [[BullyingADragon threatening Daenerys' unborn child in front of Drogo]] as yet another threat to do what he wanted. Drogo responded by dumping a pot of molten gold on him, and it is described in all of its grisly glory.


Added DiffLines:

* Almost every Frey killed that we've seen has been an asshole in some way. Little Walder bullied Bran and Rickon, and was later killed by someone during ''Dance''; Petyr and Merrett Frey, who participated in the Red Wedding, are captured and hung by Lady Stoneheart and the Brotherhood Without Banners at the end of ''Storm''; Rhaegar, Jared, and Symond Frey belittle Davos Seaworth and feed the lie about how the Starks were all shapeshifting wargs and the Red Wedding was all a misunderstanding, and they are killed and cooked into meat pies that Lord Wyman Manderly feeds to the guests of Ramsay Bolton's and "Arya Stark"'s wedding in ''Dance''; and Aenys Frey, who is no shortage of abusive to everyone who looks down on them for the Red Wedding, is caught in a trap by Mors Umber and is slain in a POV preview chapter from ''Winds''.

Changed: 20

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost. Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "[[CompleteMonster So Not Prince Charming]]" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost. Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "[[CompleteMonster So "So Not Prince Charming]]" Charming" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And nothing of value was lost.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', [[CinderellaCircumstances Falia Flowers Flowers]] laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped.raped in front of their parents. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And And, for most people, nothing much of value was lost.lost. Sure, you can feel a little sorry for the shit her father and [[WickedStepmother stepmother]] pulled on her that [[BrokenBird allowed her to become easily groomed]] by [[EvilIsSexy Euron]] "[[CompleteMonster So Not Prince Charming]]" [[DevilInPlainSight Greyjoy]] into considering the horribly squicky retribution something that became a possibility, but... still. DisproportionateRetribution is disproportionate, broken and groomed... or not.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:


'''All spoilers are unmarked.'''

Added: 174

Removed: 174

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable:



Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable:
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

* Ramsay brutally tortures Theon, turning him into TheWoobie. Regardless, Theon did double-cross the Starks and attacked Winterfell, where at one point he killed two children to try and cover his own ass when the Stark children escaped.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None


* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle, Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And nothing of value was lost.

to:

* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle, castle of House Hewett in ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'', Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And nothing of value was lost.
Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:
None

Added DiffLines:

----
Creator/GeorgeRRMartin is fond of [[AssholeVictim this trope]], [[CrapsackWorld although the sheer number of both victims and assholes]] means that it is somewhat inevitable:

* In ''Literature/AStormOfSwords'', Craster is killed in a mutiny when the starving men of the Night's Watch believe he's hoarding food and not sharing enough with them. Whether or not that's true or a sufficient reason to kill him, readers aren't likely to care, given Craster's penchant for raping his daughters and killing his infant sons.
* After spending several books of being an asshat of a king, Joffrey is soon poisoned in the Purple Wedding. Needless to say, not many people mourn him, even though he was only a teenager, as he was one of the most hated characters in the series.
* Tyrion Lannister killing his father Tywin at the end of ''Literature/AStormOfSwords''. Tywin kinda had it coming.
* The Brotherhood without Banners' victims were generally this, the Brotherhood having their mission to protect the smallfolk who were being worst hit by the war and punish those who oppressed them. However, after their original leader Beric Dondarrion dies, they are taken over by Lady Stoneheart, and though their victims generally have it coming, their attempt to hang the honorable and kind-hearted Brienne shows their changing motivations...
* Most of the Freys who winds up dead in the story (with the exception of the decent Ser Stevron Frey and his disabled son Aegon "Jinglebell" Frey), especially after the [[DisproportionateRetribution Red]] [[DiabolusExMachina Wedding.]]
* In ''Literature/AFeastForCrows'' Sansa and Littlefinger frame the singer Marillion for a murder Littlefinger committed. It's hard for the reader to feel too bad since Marillion previously tried to rape Sansa. Said murder victim also helped Littlefinger poison her husband and manipulate her sister, eventually starting a war, and was threatening to kill a young girl, [[EvilAunt her niece]], whom she thought was seducing her husband, so she counts as well.
* The fate of Ser Gregor Clegane, a.k.a. [[NamesToRunAwayFromReallyFast The Mountain that Rides]], at the hands of Oberyn Martell is absolutely horrific, with his agony lasting for weeks. It is also an extremely fitting one for a mass-murdering rapist and monster who did nothing in his life but spread untold cruelty, misery and death, including raping and murdering Oberyn Martell's sister. [[BackFromTheDead Or is he dead...]]
* [[SociopathicSoldier The Mountain's Men]], such as [[TortureTechnician the Tickler]], [[EvilOldFolks Chiswyck]], who laughingly talks of how he, some of the other men, and the Mountain gang raped a girl, and [[{{Sadist}} Raff]] [[FauxAffablyEvil the Sweetling]].
* Another of the Lannisters Knights Ser Amory Lorch, basically a miniature Mountain who also engages in RapePillageAndBurn across the Riverlands, even attacking a group of the [[TeamSwitzerland Night's Watch]], who are sworn to take no part in the conflicts of the realm, as well as having stabbed the four-year old Princess Rhaenys dead in a manner [[EvenEvilHasStandards even Tywin found unnecessarily brutal]]. He ends up getting [[ExitPursuedByABear thrown to a bear]] by the Brave Companions.
* Similar to the Mountain's Men, the Brave Companions, a [[PsychoForHire particularly vile sellsword company]], nicknamed the [[MonsterClown Bloody Mummers]], where every member shows themselves to be utterly evil, however they are getting picked off as they are hunted down for their war crimes. Their leader Vargo Hoat, is an AxeCrazy {{Sadist}} who enjoys cutting off limbs, and [[DeathByIrony ends up having pieces cut off over days]] by the Mountain. One of the nastiest appears to be Rorge, a pedophile rapist who takes part in [[RapePillageAndBurn the Sack of Saltpans]], where a town's population is massacred and raped by a group of the Mummers. He ends up being killed by Brienne when he threatens a group of war orphans, ironic for a HeManWomanHater.
* Balon Greyjoy, the brutal ruler of the Iron Islands who have a culture of cruel piracy and attacks the North when its ruler Robb Stark offers an alliance with him and sends back his only surviving son Theon. Balon shows no affection to the son who he hadn't seen in nine years and acts horribly towards him, thinking him too weak to inherit rule. Balon ends up falling from a bridge during a storm, though it is widely believed the nastiest of the Greyjoy brothers [[EvilOverlord Euron]] [[EvilVsEvil may have been]] [[CainAndAbel responsible]].
* Renly Baratheon, who gives off the image of TheGoodKing, but seems a {{Deconstruction}} of it, showing himself to be more TheEvilPrince, being vain, mockingly unpleasant to unattractive people such as the [[UndyingLoyalty loyal]] but unattractive woman Brienne of Tarth and his disfigured niece Shireen Baratheon, and trying to usurp the Iron Throne after his eldest brother's death basically just because he is arrogant and can put on a [[VillainWithGoodPublicity good image]]. It's even implied Renly may be aware of the illegitimacy of the Queen's children, meaning he knows his brother Stannis is the rightful heir. When Stannis offers to make an alliance with him, saying he'll make him his heir until he has a son (which is unlikely meaning Renly will probably become King anyway), along with letting him keep his positions as Lord of Storm's End and Master of Laws on the Small Council, Renly sneeringly mocks Stannis for not being as charismatic and insults Stannis' daughter because of her unattractive appearance, basically saying he'll take the throne as [[MightMakesRight he has the bigger army]], talking of [[CainAndAbel killing Stannis while showing little remorse]]. He ends up getting murdered the night before the battle by a shadow assassin birthed by his brother's sorceress Melisandre.
* Rattleshirt, a particularly unpleasant Wildling raider and rapist, ends up getting burnt by Melisandre while wearing a glamour that makes it look like Mance Rayder was burnt.
* After Euron Greyjoy conquers the castle, Falia Flowers laughs to see her trueborn half-sisters degraded and raped. Not too long afterwards, she herself is the victim of Euron's cruelty: she has her tongue cut out and is stripped naked and strapped to the figurehead of the Silence, and left to die of exposure and starvation. And nothing of value was lost.
----

Top