I heartily agree. Though there are exceptions (e.g. the evil shrew and good rat in other books) this one really hammers down the idea of entire species being good or bad in the worst possible way. Even as a kid still unaware of many issues this came off very wrong to me, and still does. A terrible message to send, and the author really went out of his way in saying that too.
Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away.-Philip K. DickMan, past me did such a good job compressing all that down. Look, he even left the thematic stuff to the end so you were waiting for it the whole time; I still do that today.
Only thing I probably also would\'ve covered now is a bit of aesthetic stuff and honestly I don\'t think I remember the writing itself well enough...
I read Outcast after a lot of the others, and I was already experiencing Redwall fatigue (just how many invading hordes of rats are there?), and yes, as a kid I recognised the message of certain animals being inherently, incurably evil was a bad one! I didn\'t go through them in any order, but I believe that was the last of the series I ever read.
Book me today! I also review weddings, funerals and bar mitzvahs.Leave a Comment:
Outcast of Redwall: Probably the Worst in the Series
I will admit, I haven't read *every* Redwall book, just the ones up to Rakkety Tam. But I sincerely doubt any of them will top Outcast for sheer lack of quality. It has three major problems, and I'll tackle them in order:
In summary, avoid. There's nothing here that can't be found better elsewhere in the series.