Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Series / KamenRiderExAid

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
DragonRanger Since: Dec, 2009
Dec 18th 2016 at 4:04:40 PM •••

Regarding recent changes to the Gashat list under Transformation Trinket:

  • I don't think Ex-Aid's final form should be split in a separate entry from Level 99. They both use the same Maximum Mighty Gashat, so they should be listed together. The point to the split is that we don't know that one's an enhancement of the other, like Level 1 to Level 2, but I think it's reasonable considering they use the same Gashat and they look like a Level 1 and 2. Even if they aren't, I stand by the point of same Gashat, same entry.
  • I object to some of the genre reclassifications. I'll readily accept Girigiri Chambara as a Hack and Slash and admit that we don't really know Maximum Mighty's genre yet, but I have trouble accepting Maximum Mighty as a Mecha game and Gekitotsu Robots as a Fighter. Paradox's "Knockout Fighter" Gashat is the Fighting game; if Toei were to make a second Gashat in a genre it'd go to the same Rider that holds the genre's first Gashat, like with the Mighty or Taddle series. I also have trouble accepting that they would make it so that the resident Mecha game is not the one with "Robots" right in the title.

Hide / Show Replies
sasagane_alan Since: Oct, 2014
Dec 18th 2016 at 10:26:26 PM •••

description for Gekitotsu Robots game: "Gekitotsu Robots is a sci-fi fighting game, where robots punch the lights out of each other! " http://kamenrider.wikia.com/wiki/Gekitotsu_Robots

Asuna herself describes Gekitotsu Robots as a robot boxing game where the player must beat up the opposing robot until they are defeated.

Honestly, I don't know whether it should be considered mecha game or fight game, since the description seems to overlap with both. That's why I added the note. You're welcome to change it if you want.

While it seems to use to the same Gashat, the final form also uses and add on and there's no official announcement about it being an enhancement from level 99.

Especially considering it's a final form, I hardly think even if it also uses the Maximum Mighty X Gashat, it will be just an enchancement like how Level 2 is to Level 1.

IMO, it's going to be like Gaim, which also uses the Kachidoki Lockseed combine with an add on, the kiwami lockseed. In Ex-Aid's case, the add on will just be as important as the Gashat and that's why I think it should be separate.

I decide to made the add on a sub point of the Maximum Might X Gashat. What do you think?

Maximum Mighty summons a gigantic armor that looks a gigantic mecha, that's why I think it's more appropriate. The Kamen Rider wiki also said it's a mecha game. Looking back, I think we should just left it as unknown for now. Nothing official yet indicates that it will be platformer as well

Edited by sasagane_alan
DragonRanger Since: Dec, 2009
Dec 19th 2016 at 9:51:00 AM •••

I agree with leaving Maximum Mighty's genre blank until we get further information. As for the sub-bullet for the final form; I don't know. I know we're discouraged from going four or more indents deep on these things. We'll really need to see the last form for ourselves before we can make a final call on how to list it.

Top