Follow TV Tropes

Following

Discussion Main / PureIsNotGood

Go To

You will be notified by PM when someone responds to your discussion
Type the word in the image. This goes away if you get known.
If you can't read this one, hit reload for the page.
The next one might be easier to see.
harharhar Since: Oct, 2010
May 27th 2014 at 12:14:04 AM •••

So, I just read that this page falls under No Real Life Examples Please category. Although I understand the underlying reason, I wonder if we can include somewhere that in Real Life nature, several elements/components can be very dangerous to life when pure.

Maybe the best example is water: Mandatory for life, and yet if overly distilled to its purest state, can rid our body of useful trace minerals by way of osmosis, eventually causing health problems.

Oxygen is a borderline case also; many organism, and practically all multicellular organisms, breathe oxyegn to live, and yet if breathed in in higher than normal concentration can prove fatal.

Besides, Bright Is Not Good has a Real Life section, which has a disclaimer that it should include scientific examples only. I wonder if we can include the same thing here.

What's your thought on this?

EDIT:

  • sigh* Where's that Delete button when I need it? Anyway, After some time I realize the folly of this post; This trope is more about moral purity, so whatever babbling I made up there is all invalid. Basically I got my own answer, so thanks for reading :)

Edited by harharhar
Stoogebie Since: Apr, 2011
Dec 9th 2011 at 6:27:48 PM •••

Would a more downplayed instance count if the character is Incorruptible Pure Pureness*

, but as a result, has a hard time connecting with others and is even a little bit unstable? Granted, s/he isn't outright evil, but not exactly an ideal model hero either.

Edited by Stoogebie
urutapu Since: Jan, 2001
Jun 19th 2011 at 11:15:04 PM •••

Would a more, er, physical example count? In Parks And Recreation, Chris Traeger's top physical form is played as a weakness fairly often; his purity of health makes him very susceptible to both contraction and the effects of contagious disease, for example.

Haven {{Planescape}} Hijack Since: Jan, 2001
{{Planescape}} Hijack
Dec 7th 2010 at 4:10:47 PM •••

I'm pretty sure this isn't an example, since Scooby is still a good guy. Also, "what you're looking for is the word sapient" is pretty much the embodiment of natter.

Film

  • In the live action Scooby Doo film, it is discovered that the Big Bad needs to consume a pure soul before he can become all-powerful. Turns out the pure soul he's after belongs to the cowardly, food-obsessed Scooby. Don't ask me how that works.
    • He's a DOG. How the hell can he be tempted by evil? Also, he is loyal, giving and never lets down his friend. Not to mention being basically sentient. I don't see how the last part would help him be pure but it's impressive.
      • All dogs (and other animals, at that) are sentient; the word you're looking for is sapient.

Productivity is for people without internet connections. -Count Dorku
ued199 Emperor of Acheron Since: Oct, 2009
Emperor of Acheron
Oct 25th 2010 at 3:23:51 AM •••

Would real life examples be counted as well?

Not all dreams are meant to come true, otherwise there would be a lot of dead people.
Madrugada MOD Zzzzzzzzzz Since: Jan, 2001
Zzzzzzzzzz
Jul 17th 2010 at 1:16:02 PM •••

Moving this here. Example plus Justifying edit, plus counter-edit, plus counter-counter edit means it needs to be sorted out here,not on the main page.

  • The Imperium and Eldar of Warhammer 40000 embody this trope. Of course, impurity is no better in the universe.
    • To be fair, even a slight mutation like a funny eye colour is actually evidence of possession by the great old ones, demonic gods.
    • It actually isn't. Just a genetic quirk most of the time, and even the more twisted mutations are a result of the Imperial policy on pollution - there isn't one. Real Chaos mutations are a league apart.
    • Of course, that won't save you from being condemned to a brutal death as a mutant for evincing even said slight mutation. Assuming you haven't been killed by something else first. [[Blackand Grey Morality It's that kind of universe.]

...if you don’t love you’re dead, and if you do, they’ll kill you for it.
Top